Rick Spilman

Rick Spilman
Location
Jersey City, New Jersey, USA
Birthday
March 25
Bio
I am the author of a nautical thriller set in the last days of sail, Hell Around the Horn. I also the host of the Old Salt Blog. I have a background in ship operations, banking and corporate communications. I am an avid sailor and kayaker.

JANUARY 23, 2012 10:24AM

Costa Concordia ‚Äď the Inchino, Costa Management & the Web

Rate: 2 Flag

L'inchino al Faraglioni di Capri, an unidentified cruise ship "bowing" to the Faraglioni rocks

The dangerous practice of the “inchino,”¬†Italian for “bow” and often translated as “salute,” ¬†appears to be widespread and not limited to Costa.¬†¬†The “inchino” is performed by¬†sailing¬†a ship close to an island or port and blowing the ship’s horn, figuratively bowing or saluting the port. It now appears that such a “bow”¬†resulted in the grounding and sinking of the Costa Concordia off Giglio. While the practice may not be limited to Costa, the suggestion that Costa was not aware of the practice and did not approve of it, seems unlikely.

Italian news site, Napoli de Vivere, has featured a photograph of an unidentified cruise ship (not a Costa Crociere ship) passing between the famous famous cliffs of the Isle of Capri, the Faraglioni, from a video shot on September 24, 2006.  Navi da crociera: inchino anche ai faraglioni di Capri  They comment:  Apparently, the passage of the cruise ship Costa Concordia, near the coast of the island of Giglio was not an isolated case. Captains like to greet the coast, close to the mainland, attracting the attention of the people and astound the passengers, but the danger of certain maneuvers is not worth a salute, and tragically, we realized these days that can never be too cautious.

A week ago,¬†Costa Crociere¬†chairman and CEO Pier Luigi Foschi blamed the grounding of the Costa Concordia on an¬†‚ÄĚinexplicable‚ÄĚ error by the captain. ¬†Mr. Foschi said: ‚ÄúThis route was put in correctly. The fact that it left from this course is due solely to a manoeuvre by the commander that was unapproved, unauthorised and unknown to Costa.‚ÄĚ ¬†He went on to say that¬†the captain had sailed close to land to ‚Äúshow the ship to the port‚ÄĚ and to ‚Äúmake a salute‚Äú. ¬†Captain¬†Francesco Schettino, on the other hand, said he was ordered to carry out the manoeuvre by Costa Crociere.

There is a heated argument on the internet over what the Costa management knew and¬†whether¬†it approved¬†of the “inchino.” ¬†¬†We have¬†previously¬†posted that¬†the mayor of Giglio, referred to the “bow” or “salute” as a “nice tradition.”¬† ¬†Residents of the island have been quoted saying that the “inchino” was performed frequently by cruise ships off the island. Neverthess, Mr. Foschi asserts that the¬†”inchino,” at least as performed on the night of Friday, January 13th, 2012 was¬†”unapproved, unauthorised and unknown to Costa.”

Many Italian news sites and bloggers disagree strongly with¬†Mr. Foschi. ¬†The BlogDellaVella notes that the bow”¬†though dangerous and absolutely forbidden by the regulations, was tacitly tolerated by the supervisory bodies and the same shipping company, Costa Cruises, which even makes a point of pride in Blog.”¬† They are referring to a¬†blog post from Costa itself described how the “Costa Concordia celebrated in front of Procida.” ¬†While the Costa blog does not use the word “inchino” the “celebration” they ¬†describe is effectively a “bow.”

Why would Costa allow the “bow”? ¬†GQ Italia suggests that it was part of Costa’s advertizing -¬†BOWS FOR ADVERTISING ENCOURAGED BY COSTA AND THE CHALLENGES OF THE COMMANDERS

Cruise passengers have also been posting videos of¬†the “inchino” from several Costa ships as well as cruise ships operated by other companies on Youtube. ¬†A few examples:

Gae1606 posted¬†Costa Concordia che passa vicino dall’isola del Giglio, commenting: “passage of the Concorida close to the Giglio .. This ‘bow ie the so-called’ salute to the islanders Gigliesi.”

Leopoldoeva2 posted¬†Costa Concordia and ‘bow to Procida August 30, 2010, who comments in part:¬†The greeting in Procida in August 2010, however, is special. In that case the festive atmosphere for the close encounter is told with great enthusiasm, even on the official blog of Costa Cruises. The company in recent days have distanced themselves from Schettino, who has declared his maneuver Lily “unauthorized” and that, following the disaster, it is considered “injured party”. “The Costa Concordia [...] August 30, 2010 in Naples before arrival, expected around 13:00, he honored with his greeting, and his brief stop in the harbor of Corricella, the island of Procida.

Sebastian1969 posted¬†”Costa Serena e l’”inchino” all’isola di Ischia” with the comment: ¬†”End of June 2011 … The ship Costa Serena is the ‘”bow” to the island of Ischia, passing a few hundred meters from the coast, before disappearing behind the Aragonese Castle and head over Procida.

Priscillav79 posted Costa Crociere l’inchino andato bene a Sorrento¬†with the comment:¬†Majestic!¬†It¬†’was great to¬†see it¬†close,¬†when you do not¬†know¬†what could happen¬†…

Costa’s ships are not the only ones bowing to islands along their routes. Marra72 posted “Inchino MSC crociera a Stromboli” and comments “Here is the¬†proof that¬†the ritual¬†of bowing¬†brushing¬†the coasts¬†of the islands is¬†customary¬†…¬†Here the¬†MSC¬†touches¬†the island¬†of Stromboli¬†less than¬†100m¬†from the coast!”

Another bow by also posted by Marra72 - Inchino MSC crociera allo stretto di Messina, commenting: Specifically, the town that you see in the video is Scilla (RC). Usually ships pass by Scylla, perform the bow and then veer left to head towards the Aeolian Islands.

The majority of sites that I have quoted were in Italian. As a non-Italian speaker, I relied on Google to translate. My apologies for any and all mistakes in the translations.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Rick, thanks for this latest information that sheds more light on what happened!
not a carnival fan...cut corners and screw passengers - from day one.