Stringing Pearls

Reflections on Qi
MAY 15, 2009 2:09AM

The Thirteen Movements

Rate: 9 Flag

 Tai Chi Ch’uan means “Supreme Ultimate Fist.”

While there’s some disagreement as to whether the double modifier refers to the supremacy of the fighting system, the philosophy that spawned it, or the dynamic, primordial harmony of yin and yang that brought the universe into existence, both the translation and martial connotation are beyond dispute.

Formerly and colloquially, Tai Chi Ch’uan was called Chang Ch’uan, “Long Fist,” a descriptive reference to the sweeping, spacious physicality of this style of boxing.  Formerly and formally, it was called Shi San Tse, “The Thirteen Movements,” a reference to the art’s metaphysical origins; “thirteen” being the sum of the Five Elements (Wu Shing) plus the Eight Trigrams (Ba Gua) of Taoism’s oracular Book of Changes, the I Ching (Yi Jing).

The Elements correspond to the body’s possible positions of orientation relative to the earth’s surface (forward, back, left, right, centered), and the Trigrams to the directional orientation of bodies in space (the cardinal and intermediate points of the compass).  Positional orientation is expressed through the feet:  advance (Metal), retreat (Wood), shift left (Water), shift right (Fire), equilibrium (Earth).  The spatial correspondences are realized in the eight hand/ upper body moves used for sparring:
 
   - ward off – Ch’ien/ Heaven
   - pull back – K’un/ Earth
   - press – K’an/ Water (Moon)
   - push – Li/ Fire (Sun)
   - pull down – Sun/ Wind
   - bend backward – Chen/ Thunder
   - elbow strike – Tai/ Valley (Marsh)
   - shoulder strike – Ken/ Mountain

In concert and in various combinations, the hand and foot motions form the kinesthetic basis of Tai Chi Ch’uan.  They also beg the question, is “The Thirteen Movements” a titular tally of the form’s original thirteen moves, or an allusion to its thirteen distinct methods of movement?  I’m solidly in the 13-methods camp, but I see no reason it couldn’t be both.  Thirteen is a terrifically powerful number – sacred, in fact, to those of us who celebrate the silver cycles of the moon.

Young witches have it easy these days – young witches in my neck of the woods, anyway.  Here in Northern California, the paths that lead to the remaining and reinvented old religions are wide and well marked.  Seasonal celebrations and lunar rituals are performed openly.  Goddess shops sell their Goddess wares from prime retail locations on Main Street.  Seekers freely sample from an array of clearly defined neo-pagan belief systems and philosophies or boldly embark on the non-Judeo/ Christian/ Muslim spiritual journey of their choice through an assortment of continuing and easy-to-access classes, programs, retreats, apprenticeships, events, workshops, institutions and tours.  Magic abounds.

Back when I was a seeker, the few paths that weren’t buried under the asphalt of progress were overgrown by brambled centuries of persecution and secrecy.  About the time I started studying Tai Chi Ch’uan with Sifu Kuo, I also started realizing that my love of nature was religious passion, that my belief in magic was justified, and that the faint, sweet music tugging on my soul was the Mother’s voice, calling my Name.  On my own and unguided, I’d begun to discover the hidden, moon-lit tracks to the Goddess’s ancient groves twining through the myths and forgotten tales, the folk songs and fairy stories.  I was nowhere near recognizing that the old ways and the Tao shared common ground.  I simply recognized that in Tai Chi Ch’uan I’d found a martial art that sated my inner warrior without compromising my anti-war sensibilities.  For me, it was all about the moves, and only marginally about the philosophical underpinnings of the movements.

Every morning before practice, Sifu Kuo would stand in front of a calligraphy he had hanging from the Tai Chi Academy’s wall and recite what was written there – a 144-character mnemonic poem of the Thirteen Movements.

 

13

 

 My respect for his daily ritual was unrelated to the Chinese/ Taoist or lunar/Pagan significance of the numeric; both contexts were beyond my ken.  I simply felt the ritual expressed an admirable dedication to the art, and was inspired to adopt it.

Once in possession of the English version of the mnemonic, inspiration faltered.  I was a theatre major at the time, and a quick study, but this “poem” defied memorization.  I expect it’s a lovely rhyme in Mandarin, easy to con, easy to conjure, easy on the tongue.  The English translation is beautiful in its intention and its sincere adherence to structure and the meaning of the words, but it doesn’t scan, it doesn’t flow, and it doesn’t sing.

    Let no one esteem lightly the Thirteen Movements,
    But bear in mind that your consciousness of them commences in the waist.
    In performance, care must be exercised regarding your transposition from one stance to another, the twists and turns in each movement, and the distribution of blanks and substantives in a given movement,
    While keeping the chi freely circulating throughout your whole body.
    All changes and motions are conceived and touched off in the stillness of absolute quietude,
    Hence motion and action are kindred to rest and inaction, in other words, ultimately indistinguishable from each other.
    Likewise, the mystery of Tai Chi Ch’uan is that
    It is your opponent’s movements that condition your own as adapted by nature to his own undoing.
    Remember to be mindful of every single move by trying to feel its meaning,
    And you will eventually come into possession of the art’s secrets without conscious effort.
    Rivet your attention, without even a moment’s interruption, onto the waist interval, and
    Keep your abdomen free from tension due to food or impurities, so that
    Your vitality flux (chi) may, as it were, boil and rise like steam.
    Keep the lowest segments of your vertebrae central in relation to gravitation all the while, when
    Your limbs and body are gyrating with effortless nimbleness, and your head is held up buoyant as if suspended from above.
    Carefully observe and investigate and convince yourself that
    Your way of bending or straightening, your closing-in or throwing-open should never be as you will them to be, but as Nature wills.
    A novice will require verbal instruction during the initial stages,
    But practice will steer its own course and bring about its own perfection.
    As to the theory and practice, i.e., the constituents and functioning of Tai Chi Ch’uan,
    The spirit is sovereign and the body its servant,
    The end purpose of these exercises is to prolong life and endow it with the youth of eternal spring.
    Oh, sing!  Oh, sing! sing this short song of 144 Chinese characters;
    Commit every single word of it to memory without exception.
    Enquiries and researches that deviate from this approach
    Only waste time and leave behind regrets and sighings.


Reminiscent of the Wilhelm version of the I Ching, I'd say.  Impressively thorough, unerringly precise, linguistically stilted and appallingly verbose.  (Give me the Blofeld every time.)  I learned the gist of the mnemonic and could recite pithy bits of it, but never got the whole thing committed to memory, and never missed it.  Never till now.

Now my Wiccan-esque world-view and kung fu universe are perfectly, inextricably entwined.  Sifu (my beloved teacher, Master Donald Rubbo) purports to be instructing me in martial arts and QiGong, but he knows full-well he’s giving me lessons in practical magic, and delights in doing so.  It’s one world, after all, spinning under a solitary silver moon and a single golden star.  Whether you prefer your circle of life cross-quartered or with a pentacle inside it, whether you perceive it as a six-direction Medicine Wheel or an eight-trigram Ba Gua, we’re all dancing the ring.

When Sifu re-introduced me to the mnemonic verse, its numeric title thundered in my consciousness, echoing with contexts and connotations.  The true name of the physical-spiritual path I’d chosen was The Thirteen Movements?  Somewhere between “Well, duh!” and “Hallelujah!” and “Ah, I should have known!” the old desire to emblazon the poem's wisdom on my heart-mind woke in me again… but still the unwieldy words resisted my best efforts.

Older now, and maybe a little wiser, it occurred to me I was perenially failing because memorization wasn't actually my opponent.  Perhaps I’d do better to focus my efforts on the unwieldy words.

My inner warrior smiles, accepting the challenge.  Finger-strikes on the keyboard; I deliver the first draft.

    Honor the Thirteen Movements.
    Awareness begins in the lower dan-tien;
    Pay attention to the weight shifts, the twists and turns, and the dynamic balance of emptiness and fullness in each stance and transition
    And let the chi flow.
    Every movement is born from stillness;
    Motion and rest, action and inaction are one and the same.
    This is the mystery of Tai Chi Ch’uan:
    Your opponent’s actions and the laws of Nature determine your movements and will encompass his defeat.
    Focus on the meaning of each movement,
    And the secrets of the art will be revealed.
    Never let your attention stray from the lower dan-tien, even for a moment.
    Your belly must be empty,
    So your chi can boil and rise like steam.
    Let gravity straighten your lower spine,
    Let your upper body dance and  your head float as if it was dangling from the sky.
    Break it down, test it out, examine each movement until you realize
    That to do it right, you must do it as Nature intends it.
    Beginners need to be told what to do,
    But practice is the best master and will lead to perfection.
    The essence of the art is that
    The spirit is sovereign and the body its servant;
    Its essential purpose, a long life blessed with spring’s eternal youth.
    Oh, sing!  Oh, sing! sing this song of the Thirteen Movements!
    Sear every syllable into your memory!
    This is the way.  All others
    Are a waste of time, and will bring you nothing but grief and regret.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Risa this is wonderful. I'm going to post it over my computer.

There are a couple of things, however, that I prefer in the original.

"Your way of bending or straightening, your closing-in or throwing-open should never be as you will them to be, but as Nature wills.

A novice will require verbal instruction during the initial stages,
But practice will steer its own course and bring about its own perfection."

I'm not sure if your version really captures the moment when you the chi really starts charting its own course like a muse that you must surrender to. Nature's "intention" doesn't quite do it for me, as well as nature's "will". And practice isn't the master. Nature is the master. Practice only opens you up to being guided. Practice is more like the rudder. It steers you, but it should never entirely control you...I think.
Every time I read one of your Tai Chi Ch'uan posts I am more drawn to the idea of exploring it for myself. This one may have sealed the deal. I really enjoyed sharing in your thought process and the connections you made to the natural world.
Well done Risa!!! I love your ability to translate these concepts so clearly into words. Your translation or interpretation of the original rings true for me in every sense. Strangely enough, I've never seen the original, but I've heard/I hear the principles and the teachings in every class. I remember well that feeling of being disjointed as a beginner...may body moving in 1o different directions at once. The difference once your body moves as one is so powerful, but it is always sad to see students who give up before they get to this stage, or even worse, the students who just don't/can't get it. I have a couple of classmates who have been with us for 10 or more years, and for whatever reason, they cannot hear what is being told to them, they cannot focus outward from the dan-tien and let it flow.

I laughed as I read this also. Last night while in my meditation class, I once again thought about all the "ah ha" moments I've had over the years. Ah ha moments for me are when I finally hear or realize what my teacher has been telling me for YEARS!!
As an example, for several years, my teacher kept at me for disconnecting my rear heel during the long form.

Me: "what...my heel is down, what is she talking about?" (a thousand times we did this dance it seemed)

Then one day I connected my heel. The difference was imperceptible to the untrained eye. But, the change to the king fu in my stance and the strength in my quas was immediate and my mind said "AH HA!" Suddenly her words rung true and I had to laugh at myself again for not hearing this for so long. She laughed at me too and we used it as a teaching moment for others.
So, last night I was thinking that I hadn't had an ah ha moment for awhile. Until reading this this morning. We do the short form, which is a distilled version of the 108 move set. We always talk about it as having 13 movements. (Can you see where I am going with this?) Well, I’ve never asked, but I’ve often wondered about this because I can’t count 13 moves. It is mostly Grasp Bird’s Tail and Single Whip, repeated as you circle in one direction and then in reverse as you return to the starting position…with a few transitional moves in between. I love this set because you can teach it in a 12 week session and practice it in your living room…alone. As soon as I got to your 3rd paragraph, the ah ha was ringing in my head. Ta Da!!!! Question answered. I will show this to my teacher, and we will laugh together. She is of German origin, so some things are lost as she translates what is already translated from Chinese from German into English.

I love this post. And the interconnectivity of all the ancient teachings…absolutely.

Of course, I could go on and on, but I will not. You continue to challenge me to return to my classes after taking such a long break, and for that I thank you.
Fascinating. I am printing this for further study. My own belief system, such as it is, encompasses the inter-relatedness of all things. This is beautiful and meditative, and worthy. Thank you.
Thanks for posting this. I will keep it in mind when I do my warmups :)
you never cease to amaze me
Juliet - Thanks so much for your feedback on the translation! The "couple" things you mention were two of the phrases I went up and back on a gazillion times. Adding your much-valued opinion to the balance, I'm inclined to return to a fuller version of the "bending/ straightening" line. "Your way of bending or straightening, opening or closing" might do; "throwing-open" seems to me to focus too intently on one particular aspect of that energetic expression of chi, and "closing-IN" seems redundant. And while "require verbal instruction" is a bit formal, I totally agree about "steer." Maybe, "At first, beginners need verbal instruction/ But practice steers its own course and brings about its own perfection."
To my mind, the real problem comes down to the relative linguistic strengths of English and Chinese. The former is unmatched in vocabulary (so many glorious words from which to choose the one that exactly suits the purpose), while the latter is conceptually brilliant (a single symbol, even a single sound evokes countless associations). In the original tongue, the mnemonic is short, aurally sweet (the syllables frolic, as when English words rhyme or alliterate) and musical (intonation is part of the language, and the poem structurally designed to create an easy-to-remember melodic pattern). It's closer to the "A-B-C Song" than to the "Diserderata," I'm saying; less an inspirational prose poem and more like our times-tables. Neither the established translation nor my first stab at an alternate capture the concise, eloquent charm of the original. If you post it for yourself, I hope you do your own edits and translating -- and share it with us. :)

mamoore - ooh, I hope my posts ARE enticing you to gambol in the Sea of Chi! Come on, in -- the water's fine! ;) And thanks for coming by and reading.

JK - I had to sigh a little at the thought of diligent 10-year students who just don't "get it." Then again, traditionally, Tai Chi Ch'uan was an advanced art only taught to specific, gifted students who were already accomplished martial artists. I think everybody gains benefits from the practice -- improved balance and posture, healthier organs, better concentration, etc. But I wonder if some can't get to the truly magical stuff because they didn't have the physical training or experiences early on that would lay a solid foundation for Qi-arts later on. Too much like going from zero to sixty, if you know what I mean.
I'm totally with you on the Ah-HAs! (My "heel" story is a "hip" story, but otherwise your tale's twin.) Your teacher is originally from Germany -- how fascinating! Bet she's got some keen insight into this whole 13-Movements thing... do let us know :)

Owl - It's so satisfying to know that my sense of the underlying one-ness of our myriad disparate paths came through -- and means as much to you as to me. :)

Bryn - you always seem to have it in mind; stretching, dancing, and especially singing :)

Roy - nice to know I can still surprise you, now and again. ;)
Risa -- this is inspiring! It makes me want to learn tai chi, except I know I'd be dismal at it. My husband is into martial arts & we take my grandson twice a week to Tae Kwon Do and he's learning very quickly. The teacher asked if we'd be interested in taking Tai Chi & I thought about how I love the way it looks & how taking it might be calming & keep me from breaking a hip ten years down the line. But I don't take instruction well -- when they say left, I go right -- I've flunked baton twirling, swimming, drivers ed, sewing and P.E. But I love the THOUGHT of it, and I love what you've written here. (By the way, April's Moon still graces my refrigerator)
Suzie -- Hi! And thanks! Naturally, you've got to follow your heart when deciding to Tai Chi or not to Tai Chi... and it certainly isn't everybody's cup of tea. But why not check out the class? If the instructor is a traditionalist, the students will be getting lots of individual instruction and progressing through the form at their own, unique speeds. Traditional classes mean no group pressure to
"get" specific moves within a specific period of time, no comparing yourself to other students, and lots of playing with the energies of the universe. (That's why we're called "players," not "fighters" or "warriors." That's why practice is called, "playing Tai Chi.")