Rob St. Amant

Rob St. Amant
Birthday
December 31
Bio
My roots are in San Francisco and later Baltimore, where I went to high school and college. I stayed on the move, living for a while in Texas, several years in a small town in Germany, and then several more in Massachusetts, working on a Ph.D. in computer science. I'm now a professor at North Carolina State University, in Raleigh. My book, Computing for Ordinary Mortals, will appear this fall. www.amazon.com/author/robertstamant

MY RECENT POSTS

AUGUST 19, 2010 11:17PM

Open Call: Stop word stories

Rate: 5 Flag

Here's the challenge: Write a story using only words from this list.

Here's the backstory: One area of computer science, information retrieval, deals with the comparison of documents, especially the identification of documents that are similar to each other. Imagine typing a query into a search engine, for example: conceptually (and approximately) you've created a tiny document containing the string of words you've typed, and you're asking for other documents on the Web that are most similar to yours. How should we measure similarity? One way is is to count the words that two documents have in common (along with other stuff I won't get into). But there are a lot of words that don't really contribute to similarity in a useful way. They're too common: words like "the" and "was" and "about" and "go" and so forth. These are called stop words. Many information retrieval systems filter out stop words before they make their comparisons between documents, to concentrate on the more meaningful similarities.

A couple of weeks ago I was involved in a Master's Examination in the area of information retrieval. During her presentation, the student showed us the list of stop words she'd used in her work. A friend (one of a few I wouldn't hesitate to call a genius) suggested that it would be interesting to write a story using only words from such a list. This was clever and funny--you could write a story and put it online, but trying to find it might be difficult if a search engine, by default, is ignoring all the words in the story.

If I had more creativity, energy, and time, I'd give you an example of such a story, but instead I'll punt and only offer the challenge.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
cool! It will be interesting to see what people come up with.
Damn Rob. Do we have to do all the heavy lifting around here?



(I'm buying time)
LOL yeah right. Although this is OS and you will get some stories! I'd suggest you offer this to all of our college English profs as an exercise for thier unsuspecting students :-)
I am thinking of a few students I have known who would have loved playing with something like this.
Thanks for the comments! I actually didn't realize, until a few of you mentioned it, that this sounds more like puzzle solving than story writing.
Ok, so people type a word, look it up on the list, type another word, look it up...it doesn't sound very practical.
Maybe not. I was thinking that people would read the list of words to get a feel for what's in it, write a little story, and then massage the wording until it all worked.
I think it has potential as long as one is patient and truly creative.
Poems are easier than prose-
here's mine:

as for herself
she was used to wanting that
small pointed state
the one where problems presented thought
but then worked out
parting
opening like numbers
between each other
making an ordered room
largely full of kind facts
Hey, I'm impressed, Julie! It's more evocative than I would have expected, given the vocabulary you're limited to.
it was fun to try! :D
So where is your piece?
I'll give it a shot... though it'll take time. It's harder than I thought.