Rob Crotty

Rob Crotty
Location
Washington, District of Columbia,
Bio
I've always been interested in the fringe story ... you know those Mexican fishermen that were lost at sea for 270 days? It's likely they were muling drugs and their ship was scuttled by a worried druglord ... Stories like that ... or the one about the world's deadliest geyser ... or the 10 billion rabbits in Australia. That's what the Fourth Corner is about. Went to Iraq, worked on Afghanistan, got out, road tripped, traveled around the world(ish), wrote a few books, working on a few others. I believe country is just another word for rock and roll, that North Dakota is better than South Dakota, and that America is an alright place, but certainly not the only place.

Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 15, 2009 8:09AM

Saw VI: Jigsaw is a Metaphor for Osama Bin Laden

Rate: 3 Flag

Stephen King once noted that good horror reacts to the common fears of the people.  In the nuclear 1950s, the films were about attacks of the fifty foot ant, crab, or spider or woman because most Americans were afraid of the unknown future of the atom. 

From there, with increased space exploration, we looked toward the skies to scare us.  2001.  The Alien series. Close Encounters of the Third Kind. 

Terminator was something of a hybrid.  Technology and the notion of Big Brother has always gripped our hearts, and a hybrid piece of machine-gun totting technology that spits out led justice at someone else's command, well, there you have it.  You can see it in theMatrix, too.  Our fear that we the masters of technology have now become its servant. 

But lately, it's Saw.  Jigsaw and his gore fest have captivated America and the formula fits.  As a former intelligence analyst, I can say with confidence that a man who kidnaps strangers off the street, subjects them to torture to suit his own malformed ideology, and uses that subsequent fear to advance his own cause is a textbook terrorist (also known as a whacko, or nutjob).

The parallels don't end there, either.  Jigsaw died in Saw V, yet the folks in Hollywood keep making Saw movies without their main antagonist.  Just like we'd like to think the Saw franchise would die with its star actor, we'd also like to think that knocking out Osama Bin Laden would put an end to Al Qaeda.  Tragically, such is not the fate of radical ideology, but that's exactly what we're afraid of.  The only thing more terrifying than a man willing to dismember others for an obscure purpose is that killing him won't stop him.  In fact, his death, his martyrdom that is, only seems to elevate the cause (it's little surprise that Saw VI's tagline is "Trust In Him", a clear association to Jigsaw's elevation to a godlike status following his death.)

It will be interesting to see how the Saw franchise comes to a close.  While a tactical strike from a predator drone may end a movie, it won't prevent a sequel from happening.  Maybe in Saw VI the good guy will sit down with Jigsaw's female protege and have a heartfelt discussion over the clash of civilizations and the marrying of ideological causes with resource competition.   Or maybe he'll just blow her head off.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I wondered about this genre, just seeing the advertisement here and there made me want to not see the films. Now I know. Great analysis of the genre.
He's not Bin Laden. He's Dick Cheney. Isn't that obvious?
I wondered how the heck you were going to tie the two together... that's actually a pretty brilliant comparison.
Come on. "Saw" and nearly all Hollywood horror these days is just torture porn. It doesn't say anything about bin Laden. It says that Americans are sick fucks. You think we're denying health care to the sick and dying and poor because we're cheap? We want our own people to die. We just wish we could put the dying on TV.
I think your analysis of Jigsaw and Osama is perfect. I also disagree with those who put their noses up at horror or sci-fi films. They are a genre unto themselves, indeed not to everyone's taste - but the good ones have their own message. Sometimes, if you can take some fake gore, they can be just fun. Indeed we can kill off Osama, but as in Saw, he still has at least one acolyte. And even one is enough to wreak havoc. Rated.
@madcelt. I'm with you. Horror is just one narrative we all follow to test our fears and reactions. I think it's one of the main reasons story telling endures.

I can't stand the Saw movies though. I side with Tomreedtoon on the torture porn, but I think it's an interesting topic too. I mean, where is this obsession with gore coming from? Porn itself too. I'd argue the more online we get, the more visceral things we'll watch to have the most base of human interactions. The less violent we are, the more we look for outlets for the violence inherent within us. Voila. Gory movies.
Apologies for my rudeness, but have you actually watched the Saw films? I ask only because the series hasn't had a 'good guy' at its core in any of its films. Yes, there have been cops who tried to stop the killings, but they were flawed, damaged, and often ill-tempered or naive. There really are no heroes in the Saw world. Saying that John Kramer is Bin Laden purely because he's (theoretically) cheated death is silly, since every single horror film baddie of note (Freddy, Jason, Michael, etc) has risen from the grave countless times. It's a horror staple. Besides Kramer isn't a terrorist in that he's not out to influence large swaths of people. He targets specific people for specific reasons and he couldn't care less if anyone else knew of his existence. I hesitate to condemn so forcefully, but this feels like an analysis based on cursory knowledge of the series at best, something scribbled down after glancing a couple previews or a few DVD boxes.
@scottmendelson: Unfortunately I have seen all the SAWs up until number VI, but I think the points you raise only confirm my suspicions. So the "heroine" is inherently flawed and acting out of selfish reasons, usually of self-preservation. Comparisons to America's wars in Iraq and Afghanistan reflect that. As does Kramers specific targeting of specific individuals. Bin Laden didn't attack Canada, he attacked America, who did some nastiness in the eyes of extremist Muslims, and he thought we deserved a lesson.

For me, I think your points drive home the comparison, though I'd love to continue the debate!