The District Dispatch

News from DC

Rob Crotty

Rob Crotty
Location
Washington, District of Columbia,
Birthday
January 01
Bio
America, you're doing okay.

FEBRUARY 17, 2010 10:21AM

War on Terror using Cold War playbook

Rate: 1 Flag


Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy


The list of assassinations has crept up over the past month, and they all seem to have one thing in common: Israel. While plausible deniability remains the country's best defense, it appears that the Global War on Terror is taking lessons out of the Cold War's playbook.

Authorities in Dubai recently announced the January 20th death of a Hamas leader in one of their luxury hotels that smacks of 007-hijinks: eleven suspected assassins flew into the Emirate on separate flights, dressed up in disguises ranging from wigs to tennis wear, followed a Hamas terrorist to his room, suffocated him, and then departed the country within 19 hours of arriving. The Hamas man, Mahmoud al-Mabhouh, was recently fingered for the death of two Israeli soldiers in 1989.

Linking the assassins back to nearly anywhere is tough, as all used fake passports from European countries. The only positive ID of the killers comes from Dubai's elaborate security camera system, which at one point caught the killers and the victim riding the same elevator to the man's hotel room. Said a former high-ranking Mossad (Israeli Intelligence) expert, it "doesn't look like an Israeli operation" because its members were caught on security cameras, an apparent amateur move.

However, there are links to Israel. First, the victim was a Hamas leader. Second, many of the passports used, while British in origin, have ties back to Israel: one of the actual passport holders is an American-Israeli and another had used his passport to work on an Israeli farm.

As an added twist, Dubai recently arrested two Palestinian Authority citizens, muddying the waters all the more.

Still, the Dubai assassination isn't the only peculiar death in the Middle East in recent months. Iranian nuclear physicist Masoud Alimohammadi was recently killed in Tehran when his motorcycle was blown up by remote detonation, according to the Economist. While more speculation circulates around what Alimohammadi's role was in potentially weaponizing Iranian uranium for the Ministry of Defense, just as much ambiguity revolves around who killed him.

In both cases, there are multiple parties who benefited from the individual's deaths. As for Mahmoud al-Mahoub, Israel clearly wanted revenge, but his death also benefited the Fatah party, and even some within Hamas. As for the Iranian physicist, he had family ties to the recent opposition in Iran, and so Iran's own government may have sought to make an example of him.

However, it's an apt time for Israel to shift to covert tactics, and certainly Israel is the most likely culprit in both cases. The overt Israel-Hezbollah conflict ruined Israel's reputation without accomplishing much. With conventional methods currently taboo, a rising Iranian nuclear power, and a militant wing of Hamas to keep in check, covert is the perfect way for Israel to tell its foes that it isn't out of the fight, its just changed tactics.

Planting circumstantial evidence--the surveillance videos, the use passports that loosely tie back to Israel--is a brilliant way to warn enemies to keep themselves in check without allowing for outright retaliation or international condemnation in the minefield that is Middle Eastern politics. In the Cold War similar tactics were used to eliminate threats without inducing an international incident, and now, it seems, the Middle East is taking note.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Interesting post, Rob. I have not seen discussion of this elsewhere.
Could be, one thing Israel does not do is let acts against its country go unchecked. Some in this country my criticize, but we have not had suicide bombers blowing up shopping malls or schools.

On one hand the move is more just than bombing a village or blowing up something equal in size. Instead Israel goes after the leader who gave the order. Since they are at war regular justice channels do not apply. Beginning with the tracking down and execution of those responsible for killing Jewish athletes in Munich, Israel has a long standing policy of killing those responsible for acts of terror or violence against its people.

If we would have adopted the same policy back at the beginning of the Afghan war we could have taken out most of the Taliban and a-Qaeda leadership with a predator drone, but since it violated our standing order of not assassinating leaders they escaped to Pakistan. So 8 years later and thousands of deaths later we still have the same problem along with a billion dollar war.