Robert J. Elisberg

Tidbit Bay

Robert J. Elisberg

Robert J. Elisberg
Location
Los Angeles, California,
Bio
Robert J. Elisberg has been a regular contributor to the Huffington Post since 2006. His writing has appeared in such publications as the Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles Daily News, and Los Angeles Magazine, and served on the editorial board for the Writers Guild of America. He has contributed political writing to the anthology, "Clued in on Politics," 3rd edition (CQ Press). Born in Chicago, he attended Northwestern University and received his MFA from UCLA, where he was twice awarded the Lucille Ball Award for comedy screenwriting. Most recently, he wrote the comedy-adventure screenplay, “The Wild Roses,” for Callahan Filmworks.

MY RECENT POSTS

Robert J. Elisberg's Links

New list
No links in this category.
Editor’s Pick
MAY 13, 2010 11:09AM

An Illegal Immigration Bill We All Can Love

Rate: 13 Flag

Last week, Minnesota Republicans announced they wanted to introduce an anti-immigration bill, similar to that passed by Arizona.

"We have an illegal immigration problem here in Minnesota," the bill's sponsor Steve Drazkowski (R-Mazeppa) explained to Politics in Minnesota.  "We've had it for years."

Finally.  Unlike with Arizona, this bill is something I can fully applaud.  There are an estimated 100,000 illegal immigrants in Minnesota, at least according to crack Republican estimators.  And like Arizona, Minnesota has illegal immigrants pouring into the state because it also shares borders with another country.  Unlike Arizona, however,  that country is Canada.

Illegal Canadians have long been a cause of mine.  It's an issue of national importance overlooked by the all-too easy shadow of Mexico.  Back when vigilantes started patrolling the U.S.-Mexican border and demanded a giant wall be built, I wrote about the dangers of Canadians sneaking in, too, and the need for a wall on America's northern border.

"If you were honestly concerned about keeping illegal aliens out of the United States," I noted in May, 2006, "you'd want to keep them all out.  Right?"  Of course some people dismiss this, insisting there are no 'criminal cartels' of Canadians trying to slip in illegally.  But then, how do you explain William Shatner?  And Howie Mandel?

It turns out I was years ahead of my time.

Oh, sure, it's unlikely that many illegal Canadians would be interested in picking vegetables or doing grunt menial labor, howver none of those jobs are taking work that anyone else wants.  But illegal Canadians - ah, those are people who can blend right in and take your job.  Some cushy position as a secretary or in upper-management.  Or selling double-lattes.  Or one of those temp holiday jobs when department stores need to add extra staff.  The next time some salesperson asks, "May I help you?" and they're just a little too polite - guess what, they're probably an illegal Canadian.

If you don't think there are illegal Canadians in the United States, you're hurting America.  When the government instituted a practice called "expedited removal" along our northern border back in 2006, officials claimed that up to 500 illegal Canadians would be deported each year.  At that rate, it would take 200 years to get rid of them all in Minnesota.

Illegal immigration from Canada is as big a problem as Mexico.  Just look at a map.  We share 5,000 miles of border with Canada, the longest in the world - but a paltry 1,900 miles with our neighbors to the south.  Yet Mexico gets all the attention, all the armed militia, all the wall-building material.  Is this fair?  Is this safe??!!

Some unpatriotic deniers would insist it's not the same problem as with Mexico.  After all, why would Canadians want to illegally sneak across the border to live in America?  Have you ever spent a winter in Manitoba?  Have you ever spent a day in New Brunswick?  Have you ever tried speaking two legally-mandated languages?  They speak French there, you know.

The problem of illegal Canadians is far more insidious than you think.  I've spent time in Minnesota, and can tell you that it's really hard to distinguish a Canadian from the locals.  They blend in really easily.  Especially in Minnesota.  For starters, Canadians look just like you and me.  (Unless you're black or Hispanic, but you get my point.)  They speak perfect English.  And they wear nice shoes.

So, it's about time that we have an anti-immigration bill in Minnesota to deal with illegal Canadians.  But once we have the bill, our problems don't stop there.  

How does it get enforced?  What is it about an illegal Canadian that would make them "reasonably suspicious" to be stopped und show zer papers?  It's so much more difficult than with illegal Mexicans.  For one thing, they're not Mexican.  You can't just stop and question someone simply because they look…well, very white.

True, there's their tell-tale dialect.  But a person can just avoid saying things like, "I'm going ootside."  And of course legal Canadians say "oot," so that's not suspicious, just silly.  Moreover, Minnesotans have their own strange dialect, so everyone blends together.  See how difficult it is?  

There are two ways to detect an illegal Canadian:

One is excessive politeness.  Normal politeness, of course, is not suspicious, because they could be a perfectly legal Canadian.  But someone illegal will try at all costs to avoid confrontation.  If that happens - if someone is so polite your teeth ached, bam, you've got reasonable cause.  

The other way is if the person is using phrases to avoid words that would otherwise have an "oot" in them.  Like "I'm leaving the house and going through the front door so that I'll be away from the inside and in open air."  That, my friend, is the language of an illegal Canadian.

Difficult as this problem is, though, don't despair.  Because there's one thing about illegal Canadians that, once you've established "reasonable suspicion," makes proof and deportation drop-dead easy.  Indeed, it's the greatest gift ever to law enforcement:  if you ask an illegal Canadian if they are illegal - they will tell you the truth.

So, hat's off to Minnesota.  It's about time someone shined a light on the illegal immigration problem with our neighbors to the north.  

Now, if only we could start building that 5,000 mile wall, we'll finally be on our way.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha. Now, down to brass tacks.

"Oot?" What in gods name are you babbling about? You appear to be confusing us with Scots. We say owt, we say garaaaage, and we keep the jack and the jumper cables in the trunk, not the boot. (or the bowt.) I suspect Americans of widespread hearing impediments when I hear these specious claims abowt are pronunciations.

As you can see, we aren't all polite. But your border patrol could catch a lot of us by simply bumping into people on the street or in the supermarket, and busting anyone who responded "I'm sorry."

Not me though. I'm a delivery guy. We do "excuse me", but not "sorry".

Now, look, New Brunswick is the best part of Canada. Only not in the winter. I've been to Minnesota. The only temperatures I've experienced there (I'll use Fahrenheit so you understand) are 105 and minus 30. I'm pretty sure it's the only state with a worse climate than Canada. I quite liked all the inside walkways connecting downtown Minneapolis, but they have them in Calgary too. Admittedly, Calgary isn't exactly in Canada, it's in Alberta.

Oh yes, "I'm leaving the house and going through the front door so that I'll be away from the inside and in open air." I have actually known some people who were pompous enough to say this. However, there are Canadian teenagers, so just put a listening device on every teenager in Minnesota, and you will find that they only ever have one destination beyond their house. "Owt." Whether they are Canadian, American, Mexican, or, probably, Scottish.
Maybe we can get our beloved Senator Al Franken to introduce federal legislation, eh? Seriously, though, I think it is the reverse border crossing that's a problem: Those buses senior citizens charter to buy their medications in Winnipeg. The jobs that haven't disappeared on the other side. Sneaking into a clinic for urgent care, if you are uninsured here. And as you just indicated, we Minnesotans can fit in: we can talk about the hockey play-offs, how the walleye are biting, and will barely notice the temperature difference, eh?
You laugh, but maybe it's time for the re-post this Janet Napoletano piece I wrote almost a year ago. The former governor of Arizona has been itching for a more draconian U.S. Canada border for a while now.
Geesh, I liked this! And if illegal Canadians are stopped at the border, my alma mater (the University of North Dakota) would no longer be able to get those Canadian hockey players (you know, the 24 year old freshman from Flin Flon they always seem to have) and would have to compete with UMD and UM for "Rangers".
And the U.S./Canadian border fence can do double duty. It will also keep Americans from slipping over into Canada for health care which is both available and affordable there. (I remember reading stories about U. S. Border Patrol families who moved to Sioux St. Marie for the health care--a sorry commentary).
I totally agree!! I grew up on the Detroit-Windsor border (well, there is a lot of river water to cross) and I can tell you stories of illegal Candians sneaking into Detroit. Now you know someone is really desperate when they sneak INTO Detroit. I hope that Michigan watches the Minnesota bill and gets on the bandwagon here.

The thing about Canadians that gives them away and is so irritating is that when you order a regular coffee in Canada you get coffee with cream in it. What's REGULAR about that? These Canucks are dangerous. And they talk funny, eh?

And Guy Lombardo was a Canadian. A subversive I suspect.
For the record, Minnesota's climate beats Labrador's (nearly) any day of the week. Oh wait...Labrador, that's a separate country isn't it?
I remember many years ago on TV Nation, Michael Moore had a bunch of people dress as hockey players and mooses (meese?) and hop back & forth from Canada to the U.S. Then he set up a big cardboard box labeled, "Free Guns For Canadians," right next to a security checkpoint. Brilliant stuff.
The "oot" is a dead giveaway. Excessive politeness - not so easy, since Minnesota folks seem to suffer from the same disease. I'm surprised you didn't mention the comedy jobs the Canadians take away from Americans, especially in Hollywood -- shameful!
Well said, eh?

When I sneak over the border I will bring maple syrup and beaver tails.
i used to think there were not enough canadians to civilize [read: invade] america, but of course it doesn't have to be smart bombs and tanks. it can be done with tourism and politeness. those clever, bi-lingual, canadians!

what a shame the department of defense doesn't realize this.
Whatever, Bill's dubious. Maybe it isn't your accent, but I grew up in Montreal, and actually it isn't just "oot" for me, it's most any "oo." House, for instance, so the cited phrase would be a dead giveaway for me too.
I don't care where you are from there is a correct way to come to this country.

As for the fence in AZ. Phoenix is the number 2 place in the WORLD for kidnapping. What place was the twin cities? Maybe we should worry about the fence down south first since we can't do both at the same time.
Long oo's, that's Minnesooota. And, anyone who pokes fun at our dialect is a raaacist (so watch yourselves).
Arizona has a bunch of illegal Canadians too... maybe they like the sunshine like the Minnesotans here do. I imagine that they would be pretty easily picked out. They probably don't run red lights, enunciate their English and don't carry guns. The extreme politeness is almost embarrassing after a couple beers- and they keep outing themselves with their gentlemanly manners. The accent is pretty obvious too.....
Well said, sueinaz. :)

I mean, because ooooooooobviously we talk in funny accents, end every sentence with "eh" -- or something in regards to maple syrup and beavers -- and harvest a desire to be American. Oh, and don't forget, we ride polar bears to school! (PS. The Arctic doesn't belong to us either!) Surely, the Vancouver 2010 Olympics proved all that, if not more?

I hear from many Americans that it's quite enjoyable to be living in McDonalds all the time (aside from the obesity part, but if everyone's fat then it doesn't matter!). And I suppose bringing guns to school must be like, the American equivalence of bringing textbooks to school, eh? And we can't forget about the excellent healthcare! (Oh wait-)

At least "illegal Canadians" will make it seem as though Americans aren't all that obese (or bad-mannered for that matter)! Not to mention it might make it seem like the students actually give a damn about studying. (Since, you know, the Canadians will probably be the only ones bringing a REAL textbook to school.)

Hope I'm not stereotyping or anything here.
(I wouldn't know, really.)

Robert J. Elisberg's Favorites

  1. facewall Joan Walsh

view all

Updates

  1. Joan Walsh

    Me on Open Salon