Send

a butch soul's guide to the universe

Robin Sneed

Robin Sneed
Location
USA,
Birthday
October 28
Company
Always Welcome
Bio
We loved with a love that was more than love. ~Edgar Allan Poe ++++++++++++++++++++++++++ I wrote a book-Flowergirls, A Mirroir. I'm working on a second one- The American Daughter. +++++++++++++++++++++ Banner image: From Here to Eternity, Deborah Kerr, Burt Lancaster

Robin Sneed's Links

yielding click
JUNE 29, 2009 5:58PM

Transgressing the Strap-On

Rate: 45 Flag

 

 This is not what I' m talking about

While visiting my friend in Boulder, we got talking about Frequently Asked Questions. The most common question he gets is...do you really take copious amounts of LSD, while dancing around a bonfire with naked women? The answer is no, Rageboy hasn't had a drink or drug in over 25 years, isn't much for dancing, but naked women are always welcome. Bonfires optional

My FAQ is: Well, if you're like the 'guy' (and shuffle shuffle shuffling of feet, that has to involve some kind of equipment) why wouldn't the woman just be with an 'actual' guy?

The answer to that is a resounding: I don't know.

I found this from a poet named Chris, and she seems to know....

It's in the way they swagger into a room, sure of themselves,
that makes me stop mid-sentence
It's in the way they move through space, sure footing,
tilt of the head, maybe a smirk, that makes me look twice
It's in the way they look--strong, bold and fierce,
that makes me swoon
It's in the way they wear their jeans, their suits,
their ties that makes me stutter a step
It's in the way that they posture, rough house and
out butch each other, that makes me giggle
It's in the way that they are rough and sweet,
that makes me smile
It's in the way that they are both gallant...and in
private moments raunchy, sexy and hot, that makes me shudder
It's the Butch Mystique, which I would never pretend
to know, but that I understand and love.

You see, she doesnt know either, she understands. And I guess that's why a woman who doesn't identify as lesbian, or gay, or bisexual, might be attracted to me. They seem to understand something...and typically they get it immediately.

There's another question that some finally get around to asking...I know they're going to ask...so, I lead, "Just say. Just what?"

"Well," the reply slowly comes, "I don't mean to insult you, but how can you satisfy a woman, if you're the man?" Then they say something like..."I've seen porns with two women...," but...they want to say, "You're different."

You're not like this:

Lesbians.jpg Lesbians image by coreymlogan

Apparently, what I represent doesn't fit much into the heterosexual porn scene. At any rate, I have affected a little shrug, like the answer is the most obvious thing in the world, and say, "Strap-on." Is that mean? That usually ends the question and answer period. "Oh!" Ahem ahem ahem. "Oooh......sorry I was just wondering."

Well, now ya know!

What I don't say to the curious set, is that strap-ons are still considered transgressive, even to a degree, in gay culture. That is why I almost never say that a strap-on is not a sex toy to me, it's an extension of my maleness. Only with the boldest of inquiries do I say I don't  (I really don't, which some find odd) want a woman to 'perform' cunnilingus on me. Oral sex with a strap-on is amazing, but I have zero desire for oral stimulation without one. Giving it...well yesssssss.

I have been asked many times (small town), about penetration. I say, "Oh yes!" But they mean me. No, no no, nooo, I do not want to be penetrated. Not at all. Straight men are fascinated by this. When I ask them if they would like to be penetrated by a man, the response is always, "Bleehhh, noooo!" Yeah, well, me neither. Or by a woman with a strap-on. Unless it was Rebecca, when she wanted to know 'what it was like.' Other than that, no. That would be gay. Gay man gay, and as I've said before, I'm simply not a gay man. I have only been asked once, "Well, how do you 'get off'?

As any guy knows...some things take care of themselves.

As I undressed her, she kept looking at me and saying, "I can’t believe this is happening." I said, "You’re not the only one." Then I said it for the first time, "My sweetheart." She got into the tub, saying she hadn’t taken a bubble bath in forever…then she pulled herself up and whispered in my ear, "Are you a girl or a boy?" I whispered, "A boy." My heart was beating so fast, and I said, "I am so hard for you." She let out a little cry and I felt like I had never told the truth in my whole life until that moment. My mind was sort of racing because she saw my insides and she wanted me and she understood.

Robin Sneed, Flowergirls, A Mirroir

For Owl..You're in the arms of the angels.....

 

 

 

 

 



 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Rated for capturing it perfectly... and the "Bleehhh, noooo!" *giggles*
Heeeehe, Webbigail! xox
*loud cheering*
Interesting take from your perspective. And yes, I've definitely been attracted to butch women before; they are, in many ways, more beautiful than men!
This promises to be a fascinating discussion. I'm almost afraid to comment further on the grounds that I may incriminate myself (or others)!

I will say this, mostly for those who might read what you've said and apply it too generally to the butch-femme dynamic: how we "do it," and with what apparatus, and for what reasons, and with whom . . . soooooooo individual. There's no general rule, as far as I know - which is part of what makes sexuality so fascinating and sensual, I think.

It's a pity that a strap-on is considered a transgression - but there are far too many stigmas, even within the GLBTQI community.

I may have a drink and see if I return with more, uh, courage!
dicea-hehehee! xox
Perfect. Like yourself.
I've got a few questions...

back later
Rilllly...Ash....xox
Owl...oh yes...this is certainly meant to be entirely individual...do come back and tell! Courage! xox
The love doctor is in, Ablonde! Ha!
Excellent.

(thumbified because it doesn't matter how you do it, only that you do it well.)
Oh this is great.

Sometimes the most satisfying thing is giving another pleasure, watching their response, listening and just taking it all in. That, to me is one of the most beautiful things about sex.

Damn, this makes me want to go write some more.

RATED!
Hey Jodi..I tryyyy....xox
I'll be over Lady Miko to see what you write! You are amazing....
Robin, thanks for answering some questions I would never have had the nerve to ask (or possibly the rudeness). I never understood lesbians using strap-ons until I read your post. Thank you for the artistic and beautiful way you describe yourself.
@Robin - I knew you'd say that! I've clearly been living in the wilderness for too long, if it takes me a drink to talk about sex.

My answer to "I don't mean to insult you, but how can you satisfy a woman, if you're the man?" typically involves what is probably a similar shrug, looking directly into the questioner's eyes, and with a slight almost wink: "I'm sure you'd love to know. But a gentleman never tells."

The company I work for does construction, so there's a lot of what my Grandmother would have called "rough talk." I hold my own among the construction workers - always with a superior smile. After all, I will NEVER suffer ED, and premature ejaculation NEVER compromises my performance!
Any time, Mary! And thank you for bringing truth and reason to the purity ring situation....
Owl! Now see, I thought you were going to come back and say that you're butch in the streets, femme in the sheets! Ha! There are numerous questions I don't answer...but sometimes...I'm just in the educatin' mood....
Rock on JODI!!!!!!
Wow... I've got to stop reading these blogs!!!! Rated
And Owl...I think maybe only butch women have the inside inside on how much size matters....and yeah, no EPD...kinda no issues along any of those line...
Is there a crush we don't know about going on between Lady and Jodi?...

Ralph...you are a good sport....xox
My, my, my you certainly know how to start answer a question. Except now I seem to even have more! I swear sometimes I wish there was an instruction manual but then again, what would be the fun of that?
rated for keeping the mystery alive ; )
Now that would be some gossip!
If everyone went around doing it the same way, well how much fun would that be? Rated. Enthusiastically.
@ Robin - LOL - Where's the creativity in that? So true about the inside inside: I just realized that you so out-butched me with this post (and your amazing style), I completely abdicated (no pun intended)!
Thanks for putting it out there. Some people have no imagination when it comes to sex.
Huh, interesting. It has not been my experience that the strap on is considered transgressive. But then again I live in SF.
(drinking with owl for a minute)
Brava.

I won't pretend to be an A student here but I think I get at least some of what you're saying. I went to a woman's college and - even being a "straight" female, will honestly admit that there was something very exciting about the more butch students on campus. At the same time, there were women who weren't butch but definitely had..... something...... I found intriguing. I haven't been able to explain it then or since and yet I won't deny whatever feelings I was having.

Thank you for writing this.
@ Ren Lady

I've noticed sometimes that a butch woman is sometimes far more female than a more effeminate woman. There is a lot about femaleness that goes beyond effeminacy. And there is definitely something something unutterably sexy about confidence, competence, and that slow look that a sweet butch offers up to a girl who blushes at the right moment...

um, I'm just gonna go get a glass of cold cold ice tea... y'all carry on, now.
ok, deep breath: no, still can't tell the story, but it's a good one.

back to drinking (metaphorically :) with owl!
@ dicea,

I think you're absolutely right. There's also still, something more that I can't quite explain or even really understand.

I do appreciate the education. Maybe it's time now for a bubble bath and something sparkling?
I get very bashful around good looking butch women, and when a beautiful lesbian flirts with me I totally get why men act the fool for beautiful women. But I'm not wired for being a lesbian, or bi. Kinda wish I was, sometimes. Still, all is good, b/c strap ons are for boys too! I am quite surprised in my life, how hetero boys are into this if you approach it the right way. The kind of hetero boys that turn my rank anyway - which is, super masculine and super smart.
@bahHMMblog - By all means, feel free to join me.

@dicea - Damn, girl!

@RenLady - But of course!

@Sandra - You never cease to amaze! And if it's any consolation, I get all schoolboyish around gorgeous, smart women. Just ask my wife!

@Robin - It's your party, I'm just playing wingman!
I am attracted to more butch lesbian women too...something that didn't start for me until five or so years ago. Traditionally attractive, feminine women don't do much for me.

And strap-ons...I have Blowfish bookmarked and someday will be purchasing said device.
@ Ren Lady,

Yeah, there is that... something more... that's why you go ahead and start talking with them. You may never find out what that something is, but it sure is fun to keep looking.

@ Owl,

Uh-huh, and if I ever end up somewhere at an OS party with you and Robin in the same place, Imma bring a can of pink spray paint and sit in the corner pretending to be Freaky Troll.
Ladyfarmer...well...ask away...it was one of those days at work....xox There are manuals....
Yes, it would Owl....
Ann...right...do feel free to share about anything that's on your mind....!
Owl...abdicated, you? Right. Keeping in mind, I'm single...and...well...
coffeegyrl...I felt someone had to on this issue!
lorelie...that's interesting...it has always been my experience...and I come from L.A. Especially with lesbians...some kind of purism?
Renaissance Lady...um...are you still having those feelings? xox
@Robin - just trying to keep the ladies entertained while you were away - I'm a good wingman, in part because I'm NOT single. (But hoping you find a love connection. Or lust. Either way.)
dicea! well...well.....xox
bahhm...okay...get back to me...xox
Owl...it seems you are making the rounds...huh? Okay, then!

Sandra...yeah, I'd get pretty bashful around you too. For a minute. Then...become a little more direct....
cruelwench...for what purpose would you be purchasing said item?
Dicea, there is only one darling Freaky. But you on the other hand...what are you wearing?
This was very...Open, like minds should be. Bravo!

Rated for all sorts of reasons.
Um, Owl...thank you! I still have one more phone call to make about the &&**!!)) grant. Today was a screamer, literally. The bad kind. But then...that whole is she 'a....(fill in the blank) always made me bristle.

Anyway...we all know where this has led me...
Hey, Buffy...thank you....would you like to share those reasons?
xox
"cruelwench...for what purpose would you be purchasing said item?"

It's complicated but I have wanted one for several years...perhaps I would have no use for it. I'm just not sure.
cruelwench...just wondering. It's fun to be the asker of questions....
Hey...I've got .87 cents in my google account! This is a great time to get in on my bottom floor...got nowhere to go but up!
Sure Robin!

Because you are very open.

You are very attractive.

You are loving.

You are kind.

You write beautifully.

Need more?
Lady Miko wrote me a poem....

!!!!!!

http://open.salon.com/blog/ladymiko/2009/06/29/pleasure_of_a_thousand_faces
I read for the pics and also, ain't nothing with a strapon.....

That's what my boyfriend tells me. What?

;D

Rated.
scuffs feet
looks up
looks down
smiles
blushes
@Robin,

Alright, I won't try to pass as Freaky, I'm not sure I could stay that excited about cake for that long anyhow.

At present I'm wearing an old pair of sweat pants and a baseball cap that has two little LEDs in the front of the brim.

*facepalm* right, this is why I was turned down for that phone sex job.
Oh, and while I'm not single, our family always has room for one more.
@Robin . . . uh . . . looks like you've got a few fans!

@Ladies - let me tell you. Although you've not met her, Robin's Scorpio-ness is at least as bold and smooth as her writing. Scorps are extremely, uh, sensual, to say the least.
No, Buffy...my ego is kind puffy now! Thank you...xox
Dicea...you surprise me! How long have you been together? Who's the lucky woman? etc etc
Owl! OMG! Owl wants me to go on a date now that I have almost a dollar from google...
May I get you something to drink, Sandra?
Tink, my dear, we know. Coming out is painful....we're here for you.xox
Enlightening. Thank you for the perspective.
@Robin - Shiiit - you don't EVEN need a dollar to go on a date. Have you read Sandra's comment? ;~)
Trudgeh, I'm always up for a good spiritual awakening when you need one...ha!
*laughs*

Two ladies, actually. We've been together 10-ish years. Neither is on OS, or I'd've made sure to refer to them as "two insanely beautiful and brilliant ladies". Between the three of us we've got two houses, four lawns, two dogs, and five cats.

Honey, we're always in the market for someone else to help us pick up poop and get the groceries into the houses.

I've been pretty shy about posting about my family here on OS, but you and Owl and a few others have given me a good idea that the boring daily mechanics of some stranger's life can be compelling and interesting without being threatening. Someday, maybe I'll hike up the writing skills and the courage to talk about our little family and the greater weirder family of which we are only a small part.

Egads, that totally made me sound like some strange cultist. I swear, whatever you think, it's way more boring and far more fulfilling than that.
No Owl...I really don't. But maybe Sandra would like a nice cold beer...as I recall...that's her post run pleasure...
Dicea....I happen to be a true monogamist...so...I was just playing with you! But, I would love to read about your family, your life...these things are compelling and we gain insight into the way different things work for people...no right way...only the right to live as we choose.
Robin, honey, that's okay.... you can still come help pick up poop.

We have two plumbing projects in the near future, how are you with a wrench? We pay in cookies and puppy and kitty snuggles.

On a more serious note, I'll start thinking about how to describe our family. What we have we've built from the ground up and by doing everything the hard slow way. Honestly, knowing that you won't laugh or shun is a big bolster to putting out some actual personal thinky essay. Thank you.
Owl, my friend, I envy you...you've got a sweet wife at home..lucky boy.
@Robin - I know how lucky I am - I ain't no playa! (And you aren't either.) I truly wish the best for you. In love, in lust, in life.
Dicea...I'm good with a wrench actually, and someone told me I look good holding one...so there's that. xox
Miss 13...I'm not perfect...I'm a human girl with a boy inside...just that. Like lots of humans, I have a great capacity for love, joy, sadness, lust, all kinds of stuff. I'm just this.
I appreciate the tone of your piece as well as its content. It is without condescension, but more of an "in case you were wondering" vibe. For a guy like me, how would I possibly understand? Unless a girl like you told me.
I know you aren't Owl...you deserve the life you have....and thank you.
Oh, thank you, Jimmy....I'm glad I don't have a looking down vibe...and glad to fill you in!
always a fascinating read.

You help me to understand more - each time.

Thank you. I yearn to understand.
Right on, Robin,

We've got a new garbage disposal to install and a leaky tub drain to fix. I'm not pleased about having to learn another chapter in the book of "basic home maintenance" , but I don't suppose anyone ever is.

I won't ask for your help in the plumbing projects, but I am curious: what does the xox at the end of some of your comments mean, and how can I best respond to it in a way that most reflects your intent?
I love to learn from someone who knows how to teach. A guide who has self-respect, self-awareness and self-worth makes it even better.

Like Sandra, I'm not wired lesbian, but I am wired curious and hedonist and open. (It's partly a Boomer thing, I think. And partly an upbringing that encouraged intellectual and physical exploration and acceptance of self).

That poem spoke to me. With strength, authority and tender regard. And, of course, heat.
I'm not the least bit butch, but I got my strap-on when everybody was getting one and damned if it didn't feel like it was sensitive. Not sure how that works but it seems to.
I need to get my eyes checked. I thought this was about "Clap on".
I always found it most amusing how many straights who think they are so smart continuously confuse porn with the real world. Even straight porn is bullshit.

Thanks very much for an educational piece, Robin. You are an amazing advocate and you seem to have this ability to verbalize concepts so that people get it without "dumbing down" what you're talking about. One your many stellar qualities. :-D

Thumbed (of course).
1. i believe dialogue is one of our most important tools in the ongoing process of acceptance, understanding, ultimately the fight for equality. thank you Robin for the post, and the conversation it has sparked here. and for being willing to have the conversations in "real life." it is brave of you, and brave of those willing to ask the questions.
2. i'm extremely happy to be on the 'inside' of this, to already be in the know about what is being discussed, instead of trying to learn and understand. there are a LOT of things this girl doesn't understand, but what Robin speaks of, these things i get.
3. in my first post on OS i wrote about my confusion as an insider on this subject: "i dream of sexy butch women and wonder if i want to BE them, or just be RAVAGED by them." Robin (and Chris the poet) explain amazingly well why i will probably ultimately always turn to the option of being RAVAGED by these sexy butch creatures...with their sure footing, and their smirks, their roughness but sweetness....mmm....now i miss my ex.

thank you for writing this Robin. thank you for being this Robin.
rated for bravery, dialogue, progress, honesty.
treasured for accuracy.
ps - when i witness women react in the bashful, blushing manner Sandra describes, THAT'S the staggering, blinding, crippling power of femmes that sometimes draws me to the other side.
Duane, glad I could be of assistance...if a man has a butch friend, we can come in handy...not to put too much swagger on it...but...we spend a lot of time listening to women, it seems....
dicea, the xox is a kiss and a hug! friendly...loving. xox...swack!
Um...Sally...the professor is IN.....xox
Hey, Bill...I hope people will see us as more human...just as human and confused at times, as anyone else....xox
Half of 42...that's very kind of you...and I thank you for your understanding...the woman who has that inside on the butch are rare and beautiful creatures. Even in gay culture, we went through a period of being less than popular...I think because lesbianism got wrapped up in feminism, and we came to represent the 'enemy.' That's changing...thank god. xox
Half of 42...femmes...they don't have any idea in some ways...the power they have with that vulnerability. There's something about this dynamic that makes both parties...real.
Sirenita...in my experience it does work like that...it's very sensitive...I don't know if it's a heart thing that makes it so...but it feels real. xox
Send? Respectfully, to Robin Sneed. etc.,
I'm here for a bite to eat. You are a joy to read.
If... itchy?
Maybe I'll New Post a generic antidote for silly itches.
There were so many people You do enjoy on the Feed.
Arthur...itching?
Let's go to Cappy's for a Spam Sandwich
All American
God and Country
Do I have a place here
in your heart?
Why is it anybody else's business what (pick any number) consenting adults choose to do to give and receive pleasure? Being a dishonest, "God fearing" politician with your spouse/mate is far more egregious than anything one could strap on.
Cartouche...the people who ask me this stuff seem genuinely curious. What's it their business? I dunno...but...anything I can do to help people to see that gays are individuals, and we have that thing: natural selection. Unless we've got some other issues going on, we don't 'sleep with just anyone.'
Sally...here's the thing of it....you would be the professor! Women are individual (!) and I have had vast experience with one woman...there is no one size fits all...so you show me.
ooh...i forgot one more thing:
4. Robin have you ever seen or heard of The Crash Pad? or it's director Shine 'Shiner' Houston? Or of Erocktavision, or Dana Dane? contemporary queer porn (yes, porn. beg pardon if that's not yer thang) with real lesbian and/or genderqueer women, by women for women. i only know of it through a dvd i snagged on netflix "Lesbian Sex and Sexuality" but it looks like good genuine stuff. i'm thinking it could probably answer a few people's FAQs :)
"Even straight porn is bullshit."

Amen to that, thank you Bill!
I re-read this today during a quiet space. As always, you hit it on the head, articulating some things I might not have known how to say, but are nonetheless true.

The poem . . . makes me weak in the knees - when a woman understands the vibe, and dances to it . . . it is the hottest thing.
Half of 42...I gotta say...no. I have never been much into porn...the every day world is such a visual pleasuredome. Or maybe, I have a thing about not wanting to lose sensitivity...I like being this susceptible.

Owl, how about you...ever heard of this?
Owl...isn't it though? When she gets your insides...that connection is truly outrageous...I added a piece of my novel to the end...
Lady...I get a bajillion times more insight into the heterosexual exploration from what you write than any heterosexual porn I have ever seen. xox
Nah - I hadn't heard of that either. Porn is generally so fake, it's hard to even enjoy it. Occasionally a movie will really get it right though - did you see Frida? The scene when Frida out-drinks the guys for a chance to dance with the hostess? Damn.

Outstanding addition . . . gorgeous . . . "I felt like I had never told the truth in my whole life until that moment" . . . exactly.

BTW - When are you going to publish that thing and quit teasing us all with these snippets?
Owl, I know...I'm surprised any woman would want to watch such a fake representation of women as is seen in porn.

But, Frida....WOW. That scene...I wanted to be her. All for a dance with a beautiful woman. That's it...that's the thing.

Getting my novel published...um..okay...I actually will start working on that. I didn't want to let go of it...not the whole thing..you know...it's like letting go of her....
umm, well, that's kind of the point of this stuff. that it's made FOR women, BY women, queer women, and from the mouths of the directors 'contains real orgasms.'

not that i'm trying to sell it. i just discovered it this week, and it seemed connected here. henceforth i shall keep my porn insight to myself ;)
I hear you. When you are ready, then. That makes a lot of sense . . . especially because, properly marketed, that book could hit big, which means a LOT of talking about it. Your heart will know.
Interesting, Half of 42...real orgasms...I guess I prefer for that to take place over me and under me with real skin and real voice and...as Owl pointed out, I'm a Scorpio. If it ain't real, we don't go in for it much...but as always around here...whatever anyone is into is great to me.

Of course, if I was with a woman who wanted to watch porn, I would go there with her...
Owl...I had someone else say that...that my book could hit big...and it kinda scared me.
one more, then i'm done.
fake o's
grr..that didn't work.
i'm done.
thanks again for writing on this xo
Gosh. I just do not have enough lesbians in my life. Well, I have none. I always seemed to have gay male friends etc., but not one gay female. I feel like I've been living in the dark. This is very enlightening Robin. Thank you for answering questions I likely never would have asked. As some have already said, sex is personal. No one seems to question what straight couples do in the bedroom or anywhere else, but it seems okay somehow to ask gay people to explain themselves. What counts is that you and your lover find what works. This all makes perfect sense the way you write it. I'll be back in time for the next lesson. ;)
Stone butches and trans men... Sigh. You're gorgeous in your writing. (On a side note, hope you don't mind my adding that being sucked when I am wearing a strap-on - for me, that is wonderfully, erotically "trans" gressive -from a queer grrl with more than a little bit of the gay boy in her.)
halfof42...what are fake'os? or whatever...
JK...that's it exactly. But maybe people don't ask so much about straight sex is because it's everywhere...it's pretty much on t.v., radio, internet, and magazines 24/7. I think by talking about it, it becomes like saying spoon a hundred times...it just won't matter anymore. xox
Oh, JK...I forgot...you made me think of something that is really weird when you're a gay woman. And it is heterosexual porn. There's a lot of 'lesbian action' featured and I guess there are quite a few straights who find that stimulating. But here's the thing...sometimes...you know someone is straight and you know they're thinking about that when they look at you. You just know it. And even weirder: okay, I never think about straights having sex. My fantasies run along my own lines...you know?
Shivaun...rillllly.....wonderful! xox
Robin, I keep coming back and reading both your posts and the comment conversation and I must tell you both how fascinating and stimulating this is and how much I feel like a lurker. %;-(
But never mind that, I'm very happy to be included in the dialogue.
What Coyote said?

Me too *smiles* Very... *searches for phrase* thought provoking.

Thank you.
Wow, do you identify as a stone butch, or how do you identify? However you identify, this is the first time I've met this perspective other than at b-f sites, and I am absolutely thrilled! You go, bro (or what you'd say here)! I love that there is such a range to butchness, and it really is hard for people to get.

I'm not stone (though I totally understand your love of blow jobs, oooohh yeessssss!), or necessarily attached to one cock (though I have my faves), so when I get asked the how do you satisfy/equipment question, I'm like, What's not to love about having every size a woman wants, duh? She can either try my assortment, or if she already knows her ring size, she can pick out her very own brand new one (or two or three since she might like variety)! And of course that's just one option. I mean, do you want the entire list of how I satisfy? (And do you have enough money for several pitchers since this may take a while?)

Fab post! Loved the Lesbians poster. Too funny! And, yes, it's startling sometimes how many people think these are the only lesbians. But then, again, I have not run across many other butchies writing in (mainstream?) public forums, so it makes sense that people are tentative in their questions. Looks like Owl and I are up for helping you educate! Well done, and make sure you tell us when we can buy that novel! Hot DAMN, America is looking better all the time, indeed! (Now tell us something seXXXy, Owl!)
Dang, guys this thread is getting HOT. Gotta write some more!
Thank you so much or writing this. I always have questions that never seem appropriate but you answered so many with such confidence. I'm in your debt and a little under your spell.
"But maybe people don't ask so much about straight sex is because it's everywhere."

so here's the thing...in my humble opinion. We don't ask or talk about it because we "assume" it is all the same. As in...oh you are straight so I guess you do it like me. duh.. But, when you add in a new flavour (sexual persuasion), all bets are off and suddenly we are all...oh...erm...how do you do that? But it is not all the same in the same sex world. I can honestly say that each relationship is totally unique. Sure the basic mechanics are the same, but the rest is all up for grabs.

"you know someone is straight and you know they're thinking about that when they look at you. You just know it. And even weirder: okay, I never think about straights having sex. My fantasies run along my own lines...you know?"

so I never think about straights having sex either...except with me. ooops. ;) And I don't think I go far down the path of imagining how gays have sex because, well, that's their sex. not mine. Does that make sense?

still, robin, a great post. I think that when people stop wondering about gay sex and realize that sex is sex to a certain degree, then maybe...just maybe, we will get over some of this crap.
Coyote...you're no lurker, you're family! And I'm glad you like this one...xox
Webbigail....glad you're back! You know...even in 2009...OS is one of the few places where I can be just who I am. Thank you. Sincerely.
Athena...coming from you, that's quite a compliment... xox
@Robin - I predict the novel will hit big time, and you need to be thinking about screen rights.

And Reddit too.
Butchy...why thank you! I do identify as stone...although in the world I'm seen as soft. And that's true, too. Even Leslie Feinberg is identified as soft...I think that has something to do with sensibilities...sensitivities.

It is pretty amazing to be writing about this in a mainstream forum...I decided to just do it! It's my way of fighting the fight....and I'm glad you're up for educating, because we need more more more of it.

As for something sexy how about: Coyote's erotica?
JK...well exactly. It's all individual...and one of the reasons I wrote this is to begin a conversation about just that. The societal belief that gays just run around having sex with anyone and everyone is a complete lie. And that what's presented in porns involving two women is hugely homogenized and tailored to some perception of a 'straight' fantasy. At any rate...I'm glad you liked it. And I'm thankful that you're so accepting...xox
Behind Blue Eyes: Thank you, thank you, thank you.xox
Owl, if that turns out to be true, then I hope you're available to consult.xox
"It is pretty amazing to be writing about this in a mainstream forum...I decided to just do it! It's my way of fighting the fight..."

Thank you for that.
@JK Brady - Happy Canada Day! And this:

"I think that when people stop wondering about gay sex and realize that sex is sex to a certain degree, then maybe...just maybe, we will get over some of this crap."

I wholeheartedly agree! There are far too many labels, including within the gay community, regarding who is doing what to whom using what apparatus. For example, for what it's worth, I have slept with men and had a nice time. And for me it was very "that was fun - oh you're staying? I'll be sleeping on the couch." It was a great way to pass some time.

It wasn't personal, but certain friction on certain parts will produce a physiological reaction which can be pleasurable.

When I kissed Raven . . . the earth moved, and I suddenly understood why poetry and song claimed people would die for love. The planets came into alignment. Even though I couldn't be sure we would be together for any length of time.

As Robin stated so eloquently above, "I felt like I had never told the truth in my whole life until that moment."

JK- you are way ahead of the curve! Namaste.
"the societal belief that gays just run around having sex with anyone and everyone is a complete lie. "

shit, shit, shit. Really????!!! shit well shit. damn robin, you ruined EVERYTHING.

crap. ~~sigh~~ back to regular fantasies then. ~~sigh~~

;)
Dicea, you're very interesting...I look forward to reading more from you. I haven't been able to read much today due to the phone ringing! But, tomorrow....it's read read read.xox
Owl...you little vixen, using men for pleasure then dismissing them to their own beds! : ) In my case....see how individual....I sincerely don't want any friction from a dude against any of my parts. I think I have that reaction even the most open and accepting straight man can have at the thought of having sex with a man. I'm actually revolted. And I like men, relate to them very well...as I've said, I am one...but...you're definitely...I dunno...it's all very compelling.
Damn Robin, I must have that book as soon as possible. And once I heal up, I may need to come back to Loveland. Your writing rocks my world. I am breathless awaiting your next post. Rated and loved for every word, every comma, and every fantastic metaphor and simile.
Robin, I have some posts for you to read, subtle soft hetero (or not) porn-wise. We'll commune.
Elena...that is the most wonderful compliment to receive...coming for you, who dreamed so big, and risked so much to live truthfully. And I'm blushing. xox
Sally...I love bedtime stories...and I'm wondering if you've ever...I'll PM you....xox
"Owl...you little vixen, using men for pleasure then dismissing them to their own bed"

Oh shit...in the straight world we call that marriage. ::gah:: apparently, I am getting this all wrong...so very very wrong.

Now I am beginning to believe the myth that all gays have great sex all the time. Tell me there is such a thing as bad sex in the gay world? go ahead, burst my bubble.

Keep posting Robin. I am sure I will get it right soon enough.
:)
And Elena...if you come to Loveland..be gentle with me!
JK...um...is there such a thing as bad sex? A teenager once told me that sex is like pizza...even when it's not that great, it's good. But...um..seriously...Owl...I don't know what JK is talking about here...help me.
Ok, JK...now we're going to have to define bad sex...meaning? Oh wow. And I have to get some work done tonight...or I don't get tomorrow off. So...I'm gonna go finish this stuff...and I'll see you later....xox
@JK (Per Robin's request): "Owl...you little vixen, using men for pleasure then dismissing them to their own bed" / Oh shit...in the straight world we call that marriage. ::gah:: apparently, I am getting this all wrong...so very very wrong.

JK - Are you telling me that "using men for pleasure than dismissing them to their own beds" is how straight marriage works? 'Cuz if that's the case, I would have thought (stereotypically, mind you) men would be on their knees all the time, begging to get married!

Of course, it's possible that you ARE the vixen . . . in which case, that might have been your experience. ;~)
Um...I know, Owl...damn...you'd think men would be lining up, taking out ads just to get married, instead of divorcing. Huh. Good point.
ah robin...sex as pizza ... now that's an analogy. At the risk of outing myself among the hoards of OSers who have never had anything but hot great sex (and it seems they all do)...I have to say that yes...there is a thing as bad sex. (it usually goes with bad, tired, trapped relationships) Maybe it is easier to have bad sex in the straight world, ...erm, see~~ I was going to make a sweeping generalization there. Now, I have to assume, in thinking that we are all equal, that gays have bad sex too. And crap relationships and all the same shit we deal with. If not, move over sweetie, I'm jumping the fence. (kidding of course, to say that would be crass and trivializing to gay relationships)

you got me all confused when you introduced pizza into the mix. Next week, let's talk about sex among foodies. :) Did I tell you I had chicken mole on Sunday. Was like sex on a plate. mmmmm
"JK - Are you telling me that "using men for pleasure than dismissing them to their own beds" is how straight marriage works? 'Cuz if that's the case, I would have thought (stereotypically, mind you) men would be on their knees all the time, begging to get married!

Of course, it's possible that you ARE the vixen . . . in which case, that might have been your experience. ;~)"

Ah Owl, you and Robin have got me in a tizzy now. Actually, and I may be generalizing, but using men for pleasure (theirs and yours) and then giving them space to sleep alone or whatever ... it actually seems to work for many men. Kinda like giving them their own TV room. In fact, my husband has his own home and me mine. (men don't always realize how good this works up front, and even then, they are a little uncomfortable with the freedom it gives the woman...shhh, don't tell them)

I don't know about them being on their knees for marriage...but I get the being on their knees part though... ;)

ok...I am now off to bed. you' two are getting me into trouble.
*sigh* It's good to be part of the family. Thank you! And I hope my erotica appeals to a diverse audience. I know it makes me happy. In so many ways . ..
@Robin et al - to clarify my, uh, position/identification/and such:

My "having sex with a man" phase was primarily during my "trying to be a girl" phase, which may well have been a function of my "trying not to go to hell" phase of "trying to be normal." Due to the severity of hell, I tried it with several partners (one at a time - sheesh) of various ages/skill levels - almost scientifically. I also almost married a very sweet male friend of mine who turned out to be gay - I know - what a surprise!

As such, it was a little like using a vibrator - yeah, the orgasm was an orgasm (when one could be had - how do straight women do that with a man? I understand the fantasy aspect, as well as the faking it, but really? On a regular basis?) but it wasn't exactly chemistry-related. (Not to denigrate vibes or men - just that it wasn't chemistry, it was friction.)

When I kissed a girl, my world made sense - the rest of the world no longer did. I finally got to be the boy I'd always been - thank god/dess!
"And Elena...if you come to Loveland..be gentle with me!"

Oh Robin darling, please do NOT be gentle with me!
You are truly an intruiging person, Robin. I love your writing, I love you and I admire your incredible honest, openness.

I am oh so honored to consider you a friend.
I just keep coming back to this conversation over and over, because there is always something new,sexy, and thoughtful to find. Lovely beyond words.

Bad sex - bad sex is any sexually associated contact that reduces intimacy between individuals.

I feel so lucky to have stumbled across such a great forum of thinkers and lovers.
Robin - fake O's are the orgasms women have in straight porn. real O's (in videos) are the orgasms women have in the new queer porn. real O's (in real life) are clearly the best kind, as you point out.

What's wrong with "(not really even that) butch in the streets, femme in the sheets"?? ;)

"Of course, if I was with a woman who wanted to watch porn, I would go there with her..." - is there anything a butch wouldn't do for her girl? love it.
Robin, I gotta say it takes some courage for me to just access your blog sometimes. It took me a long time to look at this one. I probably saw the headline almost immediately and avoided it.

I'm never sorry for reading you, and that's a hell of a statement given your subject matter. Integrity, sensitivity, and courage.

Thanks for opening my mind a bit.
Of course gays get themselves into trapped, bored relationships, JK...however lots of gays know how lucky they are to find love...and maybe that helps.
Coyote...I have rarely read such good erotica...I think you might consider submitting to Playboy...Hugh needs a bailout....xox
Owl...yours is an important revelation to the woman who wants to come out...many gay women go through the 'i'm going to hell, so I better make this work somehow' thing...and it's scary, and often times painful. But that's it...chemistry. I kissed a girl for the first time when I was in junior high...and I already knew what was up with me anyway...and that kiss opened my own door. With undying gratitude for Christy. But, at that age I was on pure instinct...and I knew it was right...kissing a boy...it was all the rage...I played spin the bottle at a junior high party once...and GOD. A kid named Clay spun to me...and he looked at me...and shook his head, 'no.' And he smiled...he knew, he got it...and they other guys were laughing at him saying, "Hey, what's wrong with you?!" He just spun again...by undying gratitude to Clay.
Okay, Elena! Then...start....runnning...because I will chase you all the way down the hall and take you....xox
Bob...you are a just a good soul...that time on the road as a trucker...you were paying attention...you learned something about people. xox
Dicea...that's it! Bad sex...is when intimacy is reduced due to bad behaviour...NO is the answer when one is not in a good frame for sex...physically, mentally...no is okay...AND good sex happens when I am in the frame of giving someone a good experience...listening to what they want.

Around here, I think we're all Accidental Tourists...
half of 42...there's nothing wrong with 'butch in the streets, femme in the sheets' but I had to tease Owl...butch her down a little...

And there's very little a butch won't do for a femme...but I do have a couple of NO's: rough is beautiful, but no asking me to actually hit, and no cutting play.
@Robin - Thanks for noting "'i'm going to hell, so I better make this work somehow' thing...and it's scary, and often times painful" as a common theme among many GLBTQ folk (and also among straight folk who make unconventional choices). One of the funniest things, when I came out, was that EVERYBODY but me knew before I did, with the exception of the churchies and my parents.

The term I've used to describe myself (as coined by one of my best friends) is "chude" - chick on the outside, dude on the inside. The inside wins, when it comes to energy.
Leslie...I appreciate that a lot...I guess I'm not for the faint of heart...but I'm happy to have opened your mind a little...I know that sometimes lesbians...well, I'll just say it...sometimes I get a feeling of female 'purity' in that sense...and that's okay with me, but even in gay culture butch women are sometimes pushed away...and...it hurts...
Hey Owl...yes...I have a bunch to say about coming out...OHHHH! It's so many things...good lord. And typically others do know first...Christy...she knew...I did too...but I never told her...and we were in the swimming pool and instinct told me she wanted to me to kiss her..and those experiences are often overlooked in gay culture...gay is ADULT...but it isn't...that kiss was as innocent as anyone elses in junior high...sex didn't get adult until I met Beck...
rough IS beautiful. hitting is not.

spanking is fine?
I was ten years old before it really dawned on me that I was going to grow up to be a woman. I remember the exact moment, looking into a full-length mirror behind my parents' bedroom door. I had been playing some sort of role-playing game with the kids my mom babysat and, as usual, I was the "leading man".

I KNEW I was a girl but the thought of growing up to be like my mom was so disappointing. I still have some trouble feeling like a girl and even more trouble feeling like a "woman". I love men, though, and have never felt an emotional love-like connection with a woman, even though I have close female friends.
You know, I don't know either. But I understand. I think it has something to do with chemicals.

Yours is a great, dark, full heart, Robin Sneed.
sigh, I miss all the good conversations...
half of 42, spanking is great, especially when it is deserved. Errant behavior is always easily corrected over my knee.

There's a film...Unfaithful...Richard Gere and Diane Lane...where she is having an affair with a french guy...and she becomes angry with herself for what she's doing and in a very hot film scene, she starts slapping his chest...but still pulling him closer...I've had that happen. With my wife...and wow. But, no hitting back. That's just...unacceptable in every way I can imagine...
"Bad sex - bad sex is any sexually associated contact that reduces intimacy between individuals."
Dicea, god that is such a truthful and sussinct way to put it

"sometimes I get a feeling of female 'purity' in that sense" It's funny Robin, but I've only ever been with Karen as far as women go, and yes, it's something about purity. I'm sure that's a large part of the unhealthy side of our relationship. The part that keeps us from having sex anymore. I read s&m to get off, but I put Karen no where near that content in my mind, she does not belong there, she is untouchable in that aspect. (although I do spank her as much as I can get away with) I don't want her to be that way, I think if she did all of a sudden get all sexual on me, a quiet part of me would be fundamentally appalled.

I think that's been the first thing I've written on OS that hasn't been said to Karen first.
cruelwench...i'm gonna say it...I know someone who describes their journey on the planet very much the way you do...and she discovered she was actually a gay man inside. Yes. She was relating to men as a gay man. She had a sex change operation and has been living real ever since. xox Thank you for feeling free to share who you are here...and always feel even freer to tell me if I make you uncomfortable.
oh crap- forgot to run that through spell checker *blushes* oh well, now you all know how I feel sexually and how much I cannot for the life of me spell ;)
Hey Lonnie...um...you got me. Dark. Yes. Very at times.
Robin, in my small circle there's an ongoing joke about which of us is "most butch." It's a contest of sorts. You know, the meaning of "butch" has changed so much over the years that I don't really know how to define it any longer. I think that's why it's a joke. I love the growing diversity of the community. It's a fascinating world out there.

I'm working on a post about gender roles in a few lesbian relationships I know well. How times have changed!
Julie...do you have any idea how brilliant you are? Seriously. You just described where you are with such clarity...and as always...this time is heartbreaking.

And I have to ask, why would you be appalled? What fundamentally about that...gives you pause? Juliieeeee....are you a repressed butch s and m person? The unexpressed male...thinking he should somehow protect that purity...? Wow. You rock.
This is the most interesting post on OS,and I've been following it with interest, especially dicea and Coyote and Julie and Owl's comments. Dicea, perfect definition of bad sex.
love you Robin- thanks for having such a big heart- I'm going to go off and cry now ((Robin))
Leslie...I'll be over to read it! Butch has changed dramatically over the years...Ellen is butch, but most viewers of her t.v. show...probably don't even know it. Being with Portia probably sent the radar up for some...

In my case, I am a tie wearer for instance. I love ties. There are butch women who don't. Anyway...just small stuff like that...
Julie, that's a powerful thing you said. I'll be thinking about it a lot today, as there is something universal in the tensions you describe, something that I've had experience with as well.
Julie...I love you...coming out all the way is hard to do.....
Robin wrote: "those experiences are often overlooked in gay culture...gay is ADULT...but it isn't...that kiss was as innocent as anyone elses in junior high..."

This! I can't tell you how many of my "homosexual" experiences have involved the most innocent, peaceful, intimate, quiet company with another female. Sometimes sensual, hair-brushing or holding hands, but hardly anything to get excited about in terms of taboo. And yet, even as sweet and harmless as those moments are, my partner or an observer at the moment might consider that to be inherently kinky or wrong.

Then again, when I've shared similar quiet intimate moments with a male, I've always felt a little perverse and wicked inside. Maybe it is daring to share a sweetness with another human being of our own choosing that makes that sharing so very sweet.

Thank you for keeping me thinking.
Julie, thanks for your honesty. This is such a supportive community, and you and Robin have expressed something here that I have yet to confront but most definitely feel and worry about. It's not discussed much anywhere that I've seen, and until we share these stories, isolation is probably the rule.

This is, to me, the funniest thing about the perception of us as purely and overtly sexual beings. How little they know!
Thank you, Sandra, you're very kind.

Julie, when you go to cry just remember one thing: Each of us, however tough or clever or well written we might seem, has been sitting and crying and utterly heart broken at one time or another. When you're feeling most alone and sad and broken up inside, we're right there with you. Fighting over the last kleenex in the box.

It's funny, isn't it? We toss around our observations and lessons learned here almost easily, but every lesson we've learned has been learned the hard way, with pain and tears and suffering. Thank goodness we can gather here and share.
Where I am...is I am single and all the lights are back on. When I started this blog, the lights were flickering...I found myself noticing women again, and that would bring on tears and depression. Now, all systems are up and running. And no tears, (over that) no depression. Thank you, OS! In fact...I am in a coffee place here right now...and there's this woman who works here...she's soooo smart...Mexican...her Spanish...yummm...and if I'm not mistaken...she just flirted with me...um...
Dicea...that's it. Your insight and ability to express that is remarkable. I have cried...I didn't know a human could cry that much. When my wife died, I died. I felt like the world stopped. And the isolation...yes, I had gay friends, of course, who understood the depth of the relationship, but I was, and am, still walking around in a world that doesn't give these relationships any weight.
Ummm...I don't know if that clears anything up for me, Robin. I'm pretty sure I don't want a sex change, and since I can't even spring for a pap smear or a mammogram -- or the lap band all my friends have gotten lately, that is kind of out of the question anyway.

Man, do lessons ever come at a cost!
cruelwench...oh! I didn't mean to imply that you would even want a sex change operation...that was one person's experience...you just made me think of it.

And yes, I agree, Life is a serious of the most luxurious high end lessons...
series...Harvard is less expensive than the every day thing...
The reason I was able to write the book I did about my wife was that she didn't want any protection of purity...I have been asked why, how, whatever...could I write in such sexual terms about Rebecca...and the reason is: Rebecca. She wanted that...she wanted the doors to be flung open....
Dicea and Robin - aren't we just like women, starting out talking about sex and ending up talking about love (smile). A broken heart is the one thing I have never been able to write about. Even the memory of how bad my heart got broken is too overwhelming to even attempt it - despite the fact that I'm in a great place now, the power of *then* is still dark.
Robin, I think Hef needs more help than I can give him.
%;-)
Sandra, you're soooo right. I have a friend who once said that the worst part of lesbian sex is the hours spent talking about our feeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeelings.

I grin when I try to reconcile the twin images of queers as sex-fiends and queers as eternal emotion debaters.

And yet, I wouldn't have it any other way.

Thank you for your good humor and your perseverance.
Sandra...yes....I walk around in a woman's body, a woman in the world...and...as much as I am given (lately) to purely sexual outcomes in terms of what I'm thinking...I want to fall in love again. Sex and love, are for me, pretty much inseparable in how I approach this in real life...
Coyote...I think you're just the kind of help he needs...seriously.
Now, Dicea...I wanna hear all about the feeeellliiingssss....but as a butch in good standing...mine will rarely be discussed. Except for my feeling that this woman who works at the coffee place is HOT. Sandy brown hair, green eyes...damn. wow.
Robin,

I often wonder if anyone can actually understand and appreciate the depth of emotion or pain happening within another human.

Our Family lost one of our most uniting members this past autumn. I don't have the words to describe what this loss has meant or what I really feel about it. However painful it is for me, I cannot compare that pain to what is felt by another. Pain is not quantitative. It is absolute. It is a purely individual experience that nobody else can judge, take away, or cure.

I am so very proud, and selfishly pleased that you have been able to write and put your words out here. I'm tickled and giggling imagining you flirting with the coffee lady. I am happy that you are alive and here in this life.
Oh, Robin,

A butch's feeeeeeeeeelings are never discussed, but they are always accepted, listened to, respected, and considered... then it's usually time for me to make her breakfast.
Yeah - Robin out-butched me, at least for a minute! I'll be honest - this discussion has totally knocked me in the head. I hadn't realized how much I missed being around other butches, in all our boyishness, until I hit OS. I live far from anything like gay "community."

Wheras my wife can be close friends with straight women, and even pass for straight without even trying, I miss talking about real life with people that "get it." I try not to be threatening to straight women who are insecure about EVERYTHING, or to straight men who are threatened by my energy.

It takes a toll, toning it down.

This post, in particular, has punched some holes in my armor, in ways I wouldn't have expected. So thanks, all, for that.
"as a butch in good standing...{my feeeeeeeeeeeeelings} will rarely be discussed"

One of my best friends and I periodically had what Raven called "chude chat." She could only stand listening to it for so long because it's so indirect (according to her). My friend lost a dear pet, who had finished it's time on earth. She came over to drink beer and smoke cigars.

Every time Raven walked in to join us for awhile, we were talking about mismatched socks, the weather, who was hot, whatever. My friend would say a few words about the cat, then we'd gravitate towards the other meaningless subjects.

Raven was so pissed at me for not making my friend talk about the cat, until I explain that we HAD talked about the cat. In little pieces, all night. Raven missed the subtext - with butches, it's in there.
Owl...I think some of the women around here have pulled on our ties a bit...and I know what you mean...straight women...INSECURE...oh wow...there's something about us that inherently threatens some of them...the friends I have here who are straight women are members of a very confident ilk...and the straight men who are my friends are of the liberal university kind...who feel duty bound to accept and are just slightly curious about the whole thing.

And it sure does take a toll, toning it down...
Okay - next question - this is getting too feeeeeeeeeeling:

Proviso: don't answer if you don't want to - I ask because I've been asked, often, and I'm curious about how other butches might answer.

If one could wave a magic wand, and give you the body of a man, would you want to be a man, and why?


My answer is no, I wouldn't - and believe me I've thought about it. It would be so much easier for my family of choice if I just transitioned. Theoretically, I could move more easily in the world. But I wouldn't do it because I like being a butch. I like who I am. When I realized that, about 7 years ago, it was a happy day.
Exactttllly...Owl...for the chude conversation...feelings can only be briefly touched on...then we have to shake it off...it's our way. For a butch to really break down, it would take more than a cat, however beloved it may have been, or our cards would be revoked.
I'm sorry to hear of your loss, Dicea. And again...with that keen insight...pain is absolute. It is not quantitative...when I lost Rebecca, I wanted to die, tried to die. It didn't work. I'm here, and today I'm happy. In 2001, I wouldn't have believed anyone if they'd told me that could be true. And yet...I just offered to bring the coffee girl...some Borges...she was very impressed that I know Spanish and Portuguese are different things...that I know where Mexico and Portugual are...
Oh, Owl! Thank you for give me the name for it!

I love Chude Chat! It's like a plant orbiting around a sun, it comes back to the same place over and over again, but maybe in a slightly different plane. It talks all around an issue before dealing with the issue. It handles all of the conditions and relations from a bit of a distance and maybe gets to the root of the issue most firmly.

And darn your sweet feathery hide for bringing up a full blog essay question like that! If I had a bucket of bourbon and ten hours to write, I'd do my best to answer your question in full.

In short, my answer would be Yes, in a heart beat... if, and only if, I could keep my teats and my voice as they are now.
Owl...the answer is no, I wouldn't transition, although I still fantasize about it. It would be easier to move around in the world, yes, but I, too, love being butch. I am this. If I could be a man for a day...yes, I would.
Thank you, Robin, you are very kind.

Now, you gotta sneak a picture of the coffee lady for us!

(never underestimate how sexy a good understanding of geography, language, anthropology, and culture can be.)
Wow...Dicea...see...I'm not attached to my breasts the way women are...my wife died of breast cancer, and I was strikingly aware of her attachment to her breasts...I was attached to them...but I don't feel that way about them...and my voice...I wish it was deeper.
I want a picture of her...wow...
Robin.... "Butch has changed dramatically over the years...Ellen is butch, but most viewers of her t.v. show...probably don't even know it. Being with Portia probably sent the radar up for some..."

*puzzled cackle* how on earth can people not know Ellen is butch?

Or is it a "Butches recognise other butches"

Cos they don'y always *cackles again*

Webbi xox *smiles*
My amended answer, given the additional input: I'd totally do it for a day. I wouldn't miss my breasts, really. And my voice is naturally fairly deep, such that when I answered the phone at my folks house, they assumed they were talking to my dad (the callers were invariably embarrassed, but I was a bit complimented and amused.).
Hmmmmm, now I know that I've got lousy gaydar (they had a recall from the factory for my year).

I have trouble seeing Ellen as a "Butch". She's dykey, she's a bit androgynous, she's been through some phases that are more butch than others. And she's never gone really Femme.

A Butch makes me want to melt against her, a Femme makes me want to be big and protective and courteous, an androgen makes me want to break out my David Bowie LPs.
Webbi...heheeee! I seriously think that the every day viewer of Ellen stops at lesbian...she's a lesbian! She walks that line very well...the quintessential soft butch...she's careful with feelings...but has that sexual energy...she just gets close enough to objectification without ever going over the line.

Webb....are you butch? xox
Owl...my voice has a depth...but it's soft...I guess...that's what I'm told...
One day I had to page over the loudspeaker for someone to pick up the phone in the other building. I delibrately softened up my voice just a little . . . "Line 1 for Bob Smith . . . Bob Smith, please pick up line 1."

I could hear the intake of breath from across the street. Sure enough, the guys at the warehouse, one by one, ended up having to come over here and tell me how shocked they were that I, uh, got their attention in such a way. As in "have you ever worked for a 1-900 service?"

I just said, "you're welcome." Talk about making the boys sweat bullets!
Dicea..rillllyyy? Funny about the David Bowie LP's...! A femme makes me want to...um...definitely show some manners...but then not so much in other ways...I want to muss the coffee girl up!
Robin - will you ask the girl out before closing, please? Just don't ask her to go out for a cup of coffee ;~)
Heheheeee Owl! I'm going to practice a voice like that...calling Bob Smith...line 1...
It freaked them the hell out! I'm still laughing about that (they are too, actually).
Oh yes, the sexah contralto voice on the radio. it wins every time. Go Owl!

Yes, Robin, it is the drive to show manners and by showing proper manners offering behavior that is not mannerly at all, at a specific request and with conscious attention and vigor.

Ask her out. Do it. The worst that can happen is that she's impressed by your bravery. The best that can happen... honey, I'll just leave that to your imagination (and the imaginations of everyone else who is following this comment thread).

Ask her.
You can show her this blog . . . and if she reads to the end, you will have to explain almost nothing.
Owl...I'm scared to ask her out! Omg...seriously...kinda scared. Okay, I'll do it...
It's in the way they wear their jeans,


It's that, for me, every single fucking time. Those damn jeans. I melt. And then I flirt. I then I am a mess.
@wakingupslowly - Bless you. If it's any comfort, we are a mess too - but we aren't allowed to let it show.
Owl, really? You all always come across as very assured... but I know... it's that sexy vulnerability underneath that's so hot.

Shit. I better shut up.
WOW Robin. You started one hell of a conversation here. Now I know why I haven't seen you around much lately.

Very fine post and conversation kiddo. I dare say I've read plenty to learn from too.
Waking up Slowly, exactly what Owl said. No matter what side I'm feeling on at the moment, I end up a mess. It's all about the "you hit me in my goo spot" and the willingness to just give up and say, "I like what you've got. May I get to know you better, please?"

Reading this, Robin?
@wakingupslowly - So cool to hear a woman say that besides my wife. It blesses my heart - makes me feel like a boy again!
@Bill "Even straight porn is bullshit" Dude! So that's how I fucked up my back! D'oh!
Robin, Owl, et al, thank you for letting me participate in and eavesdrop on this conversation. I have learned so much. I am humbled by your honesty. (Julie-H, wow) It will take me a long time to digest this all, because there is a universality to it that extends to all of us. "we are all the same" just keeps ringing out from this post and from the comments. It is so much more than sex.

I am kind of choking up here. This is so powerful.

namaste to all.
@JK - Namaste to you (and all others as well) for sharing so honestly as well. This has been an amazing exchange - rather groundbreaking, in my limited experience. Truly, the divinity . . .
Bob...what can I say...it's part of being butch. We start the conversation...then we listen...you know I love you....
Owl. I'm. Scared. She. Said. Yes.
JK...you are such a lady...a woman...a soul. Converse, singular. Namaste. xox
halfof42:

:D Rough is awesome, spanking is double fun and BITING is yummy too (nothing that breaks skin of course) Meow! Anyone here ever been nibbled on at the height of orgasm?

Hmmmm.
I wondered, after the loooooong pause.

You're going to be fine. You are the courtly friend first . . . start there.
Truly . . . you don't even have to kiss the girl on the first date . . . first things first - she said yes. Of course - if you WANT to kiss the girl . . . let the night take its course.
Of course she said yes. The tough part is over now, it's just a matter of being yourself.
LadyMiko: goodness...biting. i had buried that pleasure after leaving one too many bruises and feeling just a little too guilty. i can't speak from the receiving end, but i do like to bite. thanks for reminding me :)
"Butches are steel on the outside, but velvet on the inside; Femmes are velvet on the outside, but steel on the inside."

just stumbled upon this out there on the interwebs. to me it speaks to that power each has over the other, strong but equal, in my experience.
halfof42: I'm the opposite, I LOVE being nibbled, lol ;)
Yes, Lady Miko...I have...and being nibbled. My my. If anyone wonders about how to drive a butch woman wild with passion, here's one way: kiss her neck. Nibble her neck. Give her a hickie even!
Halfof42...I would describe a femme thus: She laughs with me, at me, ut only because I can take it...because I forgot the word for marriage in Spanish...she holds my hand as we walk around in the rain in Loveland (it actually rained last night). She says when I ask her why she's doing this: "Your heart. Your mouth. And Your mouth again." And she detests the patriarchy, and never wants any part of it. She kinda doesn't believe in feminine 'dominance,' but rather, feminine expression and honour. She asks if I will honour her for one night. Yes. For all nights. That's a femme, one woman, in Loveland.
not the obvious word in Spanish for marriage...there are other linguistic concepts...I could think of one!
nuttin but happy for you Robin :)

and maybe jealous. of the femme.

enjoy these first moments!
and femmes like hickeys too...
Webb....are you butch? xox

Led to a lot of soul searching, that question.

Robin.... I *look* femme (long hair, but that's it), but I've had more people tell me I'm butch than tongue could tell.

I don't quite know *how* I classify, but I do know I'm not comfortable being female usually. Pregnancy is the only exception to this, then I'm happy being female.

Owl.... "If one could wave a magic wand, and give you the body of a man, would you want to be a man, and why?"

Just for one day? Yes. In a heartbeat. I'm not particularly comfortable being in a female body, and I wonder if I'd feel better or worse in a male body.

xox
Thank you, halfof42...xox
Webbigail...we gotta have a drag king night around here! I'd like to see you try male on....in the visual societal sense....
So . . . last night went well?
halfof42 made me think ofsomething...'enjoy these first moments...' and how...(and this has nothing to do with halfof42 or her sensibilities) there's something about those words that are ominous. People seem to think...I dunno...there's an unfortunate opinion that romance, the early days are the best...but...not in my experience. With Beck, they were heady, first time, and life changing...and as we got older, it got deeper, richer...with this...there is no first time, because I've already had a first time. This is...now.
What I'm thinking is that I'm bringing 20 years of love with me here...to this person.
Well said. It is my prayer that she (whoever she is, or may be in the future) will "get" that, and value it. As you say . . . this is now.
"there's an unfortunate opinion that romance, the early days are the best...but...not in my experience"

I agree - the early days were . . . what they were . . . absolutely shook the building down to the bare earth, and had to reset the foundation. Maturity in love brings a whole new enjoyment of the experience - and each moment. Blessings, Robin . . . Namaste.
Owl? She isn't a citizen here. And the remarkable thing is...she lives by the heart. Many people...in her situation would, and I hope everyone knows I say this without judgment, seek legal marriage. Instead, she's wandering around with me in the rain at one in the morning.
I seem to remember a post some time ago, in which rain was a prominent image . . .

My heart is full on your behalf - y por ella tambien.
Wow, Robin! Don't know how I missed this one. Both incredible and enlightening. Beautifully written on top of all that.
Robin... I'm usually in men's clothes *cackles* I can femme up though, but I feel insecure when I do.

Now *smiles* I'm happy your date went so well. Enjoy the now, as halfof said, as a good beginning to something that could (and hopefully will) keep getting better. xox
Owl...

...she walks in beauty like the night...

I thought to myself, she's being born in this very moment....

Why is the universe doing this to me?
@Webbi - "I can femme up though, but I feel insecure when I do."

Perhaps you need the right butch to stand next to . . . hand in the small of your back . . .
Why? 'Cuz we can't sleep in our armor all the time. And we can only take it off when it's safe.
And this: Once you have loved, You will always love. For
what's in your mind may escape, but what's in
your heart will remain forever. There is no
instinct like that of the heart....Lord Byron.
Owl! What are you doing to Webbi?!
"Why? 'Cuz we can't sleep in our armor all the time. And we can only take it off when it's safe."

True for all of us...I think. But even when you think it's safe, beware the hidden dagger.
May I just point out that anyone who thinks the way you do about love is bound to find it? And the object of your love . . . a very fortunate soul.


Oh yeah - that was the other very hot main stream movie - "Bound" - I've been searching for that title for the last 3 days!
the make-up, the finery, the luxe of the femme...is armory...different kind.
((((((Robin)))))))

you sound like you are floating. so glad to hear your evening was charmed.

Namaste.
Sad . . . I wasn't offering to BE that butch - just suggesting that sometimes, with the right person, the balance is achieved!

::blushing at my accidental, uh, whatever::

Here is what I mean by that - when Raven and I got together, it allowed my energy to flow the way it was meant to. I was finally (mostly) comfortable with my boy-ness. Part of it was simply her acceptance - she saw me for who I was - and it was conveyed through the simplest of gestures.

After almost 14 years, I often feel most myself when I'm in her presence.

The whole first part of this comment is precisely why I'm a doofus.
::Laughing at myself::

Apologies, all, for any misunderstanding.
What a spirited group of people. Love and admiration to all. Robin, you look great in happiness.

I would not have reassignment surgery. I like being an underdog and a rebel, and I don't want to lose that. It is a big part of my identity. My partner probably would do the surgery if she could, and I don't know if I could handle that. Good thing it's not an option right now. How could I love this person so deeply and not be able to support her fully in such an effort? I have never thought about that before.

I'm really getting a much better understanding of transgender issues. I was never against it; I just didn't know anyone who had openly done it so I could learn by asking those most basic questions. (Thank you, Elena!) I think I get it now, or at least far more than I did, but in my world, I'd like to think I'd be devoted regardless of the sex of the person I love. Not so. I feel two dimensional and strangely guilty.

My self perception is changing, and that's a bit scary. Growing and learning again. I would still love the person who is my closest, dearest friend, but I don't think I could stay. Wow.

In another odd little twist, the penetration issue was raised. I do not like it at all but Angela does, very much.

We are such a complicated, diverse, and vibrant lot. Be courageous, Leslie, write, ask questions, and learn.
*cackles* Owl, no need to apologise to me. I didn't think you meant it like that, but when Robin asked what you were doing to me, I thought I'd hang around and find out *grins* conversations over the internet can be... fuzzy.

*takes a breath*

Robin...never thought of femme... *waves hand* ... style as armour.. not for myself, certainly.

Karma... you're getting back what you put out... and quoting Byron wholesale has to be a winner in anyone's book *trans: keep talkin'*
Owl...I have the terrible Freudian plague....
Leslie...someone has been bringing me to tears on this post at least once a day...today, it's you....xox
Webbi...Owl is very sexy and she doesn't know it. Not entirely, anyway. The simplest little move and whaaatttt????
@ Leslie..."I would not have reassignment surgery. I like being an underdog and a rebel, and I don't want to lose that. It is a big part of my identity. "...

If there's one thing I've learnt through *my* interaction with transitioning TS' , is that... being the underdog and rebel *becomes* your entire existence, according to people who don't/can't/won't "get" how important a process it is to the person transitioning.

To me... you are who you are, and extra/fewer appendages simply means that *now* you're truly happy within yourself, outside of familial/social pressures.

If that makes sense.
Oh, cruelwench...I wish I could sing you to sleep...give you songs of loving princes and Romeo's youth...where daggers are slips of tongue, soon to be healed by pleasure. xox
JK...she is extraordinary.xox
Freudian plague?

Robin, if you re-phrase the question, I'll try to answer.

I'm still processing the idea that I'm sexy. I mean, Raven seems to think so, but she could be awfully biased . . . but it's not like she hasn't had other offers - a lot of other offers - and yet, she chooses me, so there's that.
Well, Owl...those who have Freudian Plague...may be given to seeing sexual subtletly where there is none...OR...we just might be perceptive.

Face it, Owl. You're too sexy for your pants! Raven could have chosen others...she didn't...Beck didn't...there's a reason....
Robin - remember when I was talking about the constant toning down taking a toll? I just realized where I've been paying the heaviest. The realization fell on me like ton of bricks . . . damn . . . gotta take a minute to breathe it out . . .

::pointing:: Oh look over there, a house on fire!
damn, damn, damn...leave the party for a day and look what happens!

julie spanks AND knits
hopeless mute crush on robin grows and grows like on that perfect annie lenox look girl at the club in the eighties who would never say a word to me, but always kissed my hand most gallantly.
dicea???!!!???
sandra is flirting in the nicest, most hetero way possible.

(gonna melt into the office chair any second)

owl - any drinks left? :)
Owl...with Raven...being the Freudian word has it's benefits...did you think I didn't know.....? (((((((((hugs)))))))))
bah...I'm glad you're here...I think Owl might need some refreshment...Owl? Cold beer? No absinthe now...not good.
Thanks, Robin - a cold beer sounds great about now. And thanks for the hug. I, uh, needed that.

Yeah - I'm better now, almost.

And welcome back, bah!
Owl...stay with me here...you are loved
Owl...don't...are you gonna do that butch thing? May I be so bold to say...that...your relationship needs you.
I'm not goin' anywhere - yeah - here's what I realized: It's really hard to feel like a sexy being when all day, every day, I've got to tone it down to a neutral. Even on a date with my wife, we have to be pretty quiet, and pretty sedate. But yeah - there's a little more to it.
Owl? What would Gary Justis do? He's gotta be one of the most well ordered dudes around....
Bring it, Owl. Let's solve this....
Nah - see, I figure the bravest thing anyone - including and especially a butch - can do is face life with honesty. So even when I have that running instinct, I don't. In fact, that's when I stand still and turn around, and try to face it.
(And honestly, I have no idea what Gary would do - though it makes me want to read everything he's written to see what he might do ;~)
Owl...tone it down for who? Now, you know me a little bit enough here...even in fuggin Loveland-fuck them! I was holding hands with a woman last night (name only withheld because I haven't asked her if it's okay) walking around town...did we get a few looks even at fuggin midnight? Yep. So?
Okay - and thanks - if you've got a few minutes - I'm up for it.

As with all things, if I solve the inner puzzle, the outer will be more clear.
I can only say Gary is so well wired that he was on his knees, kissing a life size dolly at a young age...and it goes from there...meaning...he's way okay with his sexuality.
Owl, what's going on with you....
It's a good point, but you're still in a fairly suburban area, there's a certain amount of anonymity afforded, simply because there's a fair likelihood that you'll never see those people again. That is emphatically not the case where we live. In fact, you are practically guaranteed to see "those people" again.

Plus, the Giant. I know he can take care of himself, but still . . .

(Good point about Gary, by the way. I really dig that guy. Great role model.)
The church influence in the area is strong enough that they boycotted the mini-mart where Raven was assistant manager - she reads tarot (though doesn't advertise), wears dark lipstick (obviously a devil-worshipper), and is a lesbian. I am not exagerating. (and I know that's spelled wrong, but bear with me - I'm trying to keep my head from exploding)
That's not why Raven walked out of there, mind you, but it's part of why the job won't reappear, in spite of her outstanding performance, and a good relationship with the manager.

Of course, that's not the question is it?

(Drilling down to where it hurts to find the motherfucking goddamn answers.)
You dears sure know how to make me feel glad to be home. Even if I don't have the energy I'd like to respond properly.

BahMMMblog, that's a lot of punctuation to stick next to one's name. What's the drahmah?

Owl, you're sexy. Trust me on this. That's no burden on you, but an observation and a statement of perception from a healthy perspective.

Robin, you so totally rock. Proud, dear, proud!
Dicea...drahma...bahhh...um...I'll PM you...the insight you have is outrageous.
Owl...okay...I have had death threats here....seriously. This is a town of around 65,000 people...and I live downtown...those threats? When I worked for Housing Authority...

Here's the thing...I experienced that single...this isn't your fault...
I know you're right. And honestly, if I were single, I absolutely would not give a shit. I die, I die - since I was a kid, I have always had nightmares where there's a hail of bullets, explosions, and/or concentration camps. So that idea - for some ideal - not at all foreign, and well within my nature to deal with.
We haven't received threats. Everyone loves Raven and the Giant. Anyone who has gotten to know me ends up loving me.

Here's the kicker. You know the concept of going where you're called? I know we are where we're supposed to be. 'Cuz we've met some people who need us to be there - pouring light into dark cups. We've just started meeting a few GLB folks . . .

We, at least, know there's a whole wide world out there, they don't.

As a kid, I thought I was called to be a missionary. When I came out, my mom was upset that I would never answer that call. I laughed and said that maybe I'd become a gay missionary.

It ain't the jungle, but our people die for lack of vision.

We are either very right, or very crazy/masochistic/delusional. Maybe even all of the above.
(Jesus, Owl, enough with the avoidance already - the question was simple - "what's going on with you?")

Not much - how's everyone else in the room? ::leaning back against the wall, trying to look all casual::
Owl...no human truly has the capacity to deal with bombs, guns, explosions, and concentration camps. We do deal with it some how...and we are damaged by it. It's traumatic...I've got to wonder...have you been beaten for being gay at some point in your life...or as a child...was there violence? Lest I seem textbook...well..I am...first questions first.

And there is trauma in being the one to pour that light into dark cups....
And Owl...I wanted to be a Rabbi growing up...many many gays have such a calling...interesting, no? As you know...we can be very moral...gays can be....we have a sense of fairness few know....
I was spanked as a kid - that's about it for personal trauma. If I have any form of PTSD, it came from preparing at a constant for the apocolypse.

I can't believe I'm saying this out loud, but I participated in an excorcism of the spirit of homosexuality from a friend of mine. There was no violence in it, except to the spirit, I think now. No holding her down, but still . . .
what kinda g-damn town you people live in...in my town
the sexually experimental are sort of...given a special place
of honor as the leaders toward a new understanding of the sex-
ual nature of the human ...

they are sort of textbooks of what is possible...for all of the boring
straight laced types too timid to experiment but secvretly wishing to...they lead the way by example...

for it is the philosphy of our town that sexual enjoument
is the spiritual path to better days for the whole town,
in that it...loosens the psychosomatic organism up.
allows him/her to get all the bugaboos in their makeup all
ironed out with the satisfaction of fulfilling fantsies
of many different hues
til the right way of life is
found for each of our citizenss, according to his/her
individual karmic configurations...i.e. tastes...

i would advise immigration from that awful town forthwith
especially if it has such odd
chursches...inour town thats where we have sexual artfestivals...

hm

oh...what metaphorically is penetration d'you tink?
jim
I don't think you're going to be able to convince us we shouldn't like you or trust you, Owl. But you can try.

Who in this room has not made a few, sometimes many disturbing mistakes? I'm curious about that exorcism experience, frankly. Want to tell?
wow...this has become one of the most powerful posts I've read and participated in on OS. Robin, you've created a coffee house environment where everyone seems to feel comfortable sharing very personal stuff. This could be the basis of a study. I hate the thought of people I respect here on OS walking through life feeling the need to hold back love and their sense of self. It is awful to read about and worse to imagine. Sure straights feel constrained from public displays of affection based on upbringing and societal expectations, but when we do, we don't have to feel fear or expect violence. Wow...I just keep saying wow, which isn't particularly articulate, but wow. things really have to change so all people can be themselves and not live in fear of hatred and ignorance. What a world that would be. Did you hear the announcement from India today? One more brick in the wall dismantled.
I am just awed by your courage.

Namaste ladies, you are all lovely and loveable.
Owl...what you describe is like murder...in Judaism...Thou Shalt Not Kill...is interpreted to mean not only the body, but the spirit...

This is a very traumatic experience...I'm horrified reading about you experiencing it...you must have felt like you were dying too...
And Robin - I hope you realize that you are very much a Rabbi, a teacher. So you have answered your calling, just differently than expected.

@Leslie - I do, but the setup for it would be too long. In context, it made sense at the time, even though it's a whacked out way of thinking to most people. Without the context (and in retrospect), it is incredibly heartbreaking to me. I want to write about it at some point, but haven't found the words/time/je ne se qua. I wrote a series of posts awhile ago which kind of explains the general context of where I came from religiously - "Hook, Line, and Sinker" - in 3 parts, of course. I hope to edit them someday into something shorter or longer - we'll have to see which!
Yes, Leslie...if there is someone here who hasn't made a mistake, please identify yourself so we can make you leave!
JK...wow...huh? Who knew? Actually...I'm pretty teary right now...I love you...and I'm glad to know you...you have no idea....someone once told me...I'd never have love or much of anything...and here I am...
I absolutely did - but had no idea why. I just knew -deep inside - how incredibly wrong it was. She was a friend of mine, more or less, we grew up in the same neighborhood and played ball together. She was younger than me - a total butch if ever there was one. Tough as fuck. She trusted me, in spite of the Christianity, and I can't remember why she had started coming to our church.

I'm pretty sure I didn't invite her, because by that time in my life (mid college?) I didn't witness to anyone unless they asked me about what I believed. I figured I could save more souls by not letting them know about Christ, that way they have to be let into heaven, since they didn't know (like babies, so to speak).

That was risking their blood on my hands, spiritually, but hey - at least they wouldn't have the nightmares and guilt.
@JK, Leslie, et al - Thanks for being part of this. Part of the reason I'm breaking a fundamental butch principle (don't melt down in public) is as a public service. We don't know who needs to know. There's a reason I write from behind an avatar - there are a lot of people who could be hurt by my stories - and I have no desire to do that to them. But I have to have my voice back. And someone, running across this, may realize that they're not alone, or may recognize their loved one, or neighbor, and say namaste.
Owler...I had to have a smoke on that one...and I've decided to dangle myelf out on a limb because someone did that for me:

You are justifying a horrible experience by trying to couch it within context.

When a therapist said that to me I wanted to slap him across the face. I told him so.

He told me that was unacceptable behaviour related to unimaginable behaviour.

He was correct...and I had to sit back and face it.

What's going on here? Is the pain about not saving her?

Dangling on the limb here....because I love you...
Owl...was the young woman your first love...ideally, or metaphorically?
Robin - I wouldn't leave you hanging. I trust your heart as my brother. And I thank you for being willing to take the risk - that's way to much to ask (for me), but you offered so:

Yes - but that's not even remotely the half of it, in terms of the pain related to the whole church thing. That exact experience though - which it figures that I haven't thought about it in years - I not only couldn't save her, I ultimately couldn't save myself.
(Wait - you smoke?)
And Owl...to quote a song:

...she asked me are you a Christian child? And I said, Ma'am I am tonight...

This is communion to me Owl. Thank you. You have fulfilled your calling.
Yes, Church Lady...are you gonna spank me? Putting up a vid for you...hold up....
Nah - she wasn't a love interest - that would be like, ugh, no. Loved her as a friend. She was younger than me, and I felt like her older sister. Especially when other people picked on her - just thought that was wrong.

I already hate myself for saying this but:

If anything, she may have gotten off easy (specifically in regards to God-guilt/trauma - nothing else - that's a whole 'nother story too).

She didn't grow up with the escape-proof guilt and condemnation. Her family wasn't part of the church, and so she didn't lose her family by leaving it.

(I haven't lost my family, entirely - but I thought I would - a whole 'nother story)

I know it had to have sickeningly wrong and traumatic for her - and I regret all participation with it - I was such a brain-washed idiot, for awhile.

But I bet she doesn't have dreams featuring all the shit that periodically characterizes mine. And if she connects to the divine (and I pray that she does) I hope that it can be the most sustaining, real part of her life. I hope she finds peace - 'cuz fuck, man - I don't know how to do that.

I get little glimmers, now and again. I know how wrong the shit I was taught is - and I know damn good and well that it was HOW IT WAS TAUGHT - not how it was intended by God.

But . . . how do you undo the crazy?

(Wouldn't dare spank you - you might like it, and then what would the coffee girl do?)
"someone once told me...I'd never have love or much of anything...and here I am..."

YES!! here you are in all your wonderfulness!! I which I could meet that person and give them a piece of my mind.

also...
http://open.salon.com/blog/kalpanam/2009/07/02/gay_times_in_india

Times are changing everywhere. Just not fast enough.

...i better go before I start to gush and be all girlie. ;)
JK...I think tonight is gonna be a gusher...so ladies...women...the souls that haven't let us die...are home here...
Owl...so metaphorically she was very like your first love...YOU. And did she 'get off easy' or do you feel you did?
Robin - it is communion to me as well. I can only hope that I can/do fulfill my calling.

This is why I said that it is well within my nature to deal with the threat of death, it is at least somewhat true - I spent ages 7 to whenever training to die at a moments notice. But back in the day, I knew I'd be a martyr. Now . . . can't even be sure I won't burn.

Obviously I'm still working through a few things regarding god. But seriously - when Raven and I got together, and I realized it was serious, and that I was serious, I knew that I would go to hell for it.

Okay - I'm heading to the video room now.
And Owl...have you considered the Episcopal Church? Perhaps starting as a lay minister...they are ordaining openly gay priests.

And, I would not like you to spank me!! Get Elena....only Elena can spank me!
Owl, G-d made you. Just as you are, in infinite pleasure, with Her hands, She formed you, your very mind, heart, and soul, that only She has true communion with. Made in Her image, at Her delight.
Owl... this is only my view but.... and not trying to be direspectful at all.... going to hell because you love and are loved? because you have a good kid?

Nope, don't see it.

Any of the elders in your church have a direct line to god? nope.

It's *their* construct...and if you *are* going to go to hell (which I seriously doubt) make it worth it... love your fullest, and enjoy your life and relationships.

You are an incredible woman... don't lose sight of that.
Awesome song - you know how to pick 'em, and I look forward to the story someday.

The metaphorical thing makes sense - I've never thought of it that way.

I don't think there's any legitimate way to know who got off easier. How could anyone know? Theory of Relative Pain - kind of like dicea said somewhere, there's no way to compare it.

Bottom line is - mine is my responsibility.

___________

I have thought about the Episcopals actually. I think that the politics of an organized ministry would kill me (waaaaaaaay to constrained) or I might blow up the place.

______________


As for being created in G-d's image - my heart and my gut tell me that is true. And I will claim it for all living creatures, because I know it must be correct. I see it every day.

Yet the inevitable, completely counter-everything hook that is stuck in my guts - it's barbed. Remove it, and bleed out. (That's where "Hook, Line, and Sinker" came from.)

____________

@Webb - Blessings, sister, truly. That is never disrespectful to point that out - you are absolutely 100% bona-fide correct. I would kiss both your cheeks for your warmth and love and concern (and I'd give Robin a manly hug).

This is exactly the shit I'm in. Some days are better than others.

____________

I'm the only person I know who had to go to therapy because of war in the Middle East - the threat of the apocolypse. That was 3ish years ago.
(and yes, for the record, I know how insane it sounds. I have to listen to the shit in my head - I know . . . )
Maybe writing this out and seeing that it's a bit insane will allow you to let it go. You have yourself in a bind here, and if I were in your shoes, I'd look at my conflicting beliefs and choose to get rid of one. Writing does a lot of good for me in that way regardless of whether others read it. You are in charge of your own beliefs, and you can change them if you want to.
Owl, I served for eight years in the Episcopal Church as a lay minister as a Gay Christ Loving Jew. I took communion to prisons...for those who requested it. Pedophiles. Many of them. It was a huge part of my therapeutic experience. I am in a debt of gratitude (that word doesn't describe it) to the Episcopal Church. If they call on gay issues...I ANSWER. I got to meet Desmond Tutu during my tenure....

I marched in Gay Pride Parades as a lay priest...for the Episcopal Church. Parade go-ers wept as we went by....such is the Love of Christ.
@Leslie - Exactly, I totally get what you're saying, and you make a valid point. You echo precisely what I hear from myself every time I examine this issue.

@Robin - That is amazing - and good to hear that they've come that far. I would love to hear more about how that impacted you. And I will think about it, too.
Owl, you are loved.
putting up a new vid for Owl....
During this intermission, I just want to say are you not incredibly sick of the saga?

And . . . I keep coming back to this: "You are justifying a horrible experience by trying to couch it within context."
@Leslie, I've given your comment more thought as well. Part of the reason I rarely do a full-on address of this issue with anyone except Raven is that I really am not, in day-to-day life a total freakazoid on this - I recognize it as my responsibility to deal with, and my choice of beliefs.

That being said, I can only hope that this much openness doesn't backfire and become something else - that I haven't been outed as a looney (not the Canadian coin) or worse. Typically, when I post, I consider the consequences of what feedback I may receive. In this case, I . . . uh . . . responded to what got accidentally tapped.
Saga, Owl? This is your soul we're talking about....
The vid leaves me speechless . . .
And the Butch Soul, in touch with her creator..whatever name we give it...ROCKS.
And so...strap-ons...are not transgressive...they are a gift from my creator...in Stone Butch Blues...Leslie Feinberg says something like...

...with that (strap-on) you can remind a woman of every pain she has ever known....or you can give her incredible pleasure. I didn't know what that meant...but I've spent the rest of my life thinking about it.

-Stone Butch Blues, Leslie Feinberg
Clearly you are living proof of the Creator/Butch connection . . . I'm stunned . . .
I'm . . . spent. I've got to pack it in for a bit, get my ass home. Raven picked up a couple nights of bartending, so she'll be headed there pretty soon too.

That song is perfect . . . for the post, and for the dialogue.

My gratitude for this forum, and to you, Robin, is beyond words. Thank you for your generosity here - in all ways. I am deeply honored, and have much to think about.

And - "Stone Butch Blues" changed my life. Great quote.
Owl...stunned? My blog says...a butch soul's guide to the universe! Heeehehehe! Yes! And you are clearly an example of a butch in touch with her creator...but you and I still get in the way some times....
Hey, Owl...make love to Raven. Fuck herrrrr....spiritually...a butch knows this....
Your comfort is paramount here, Owl. Pushing the envelope a bit is scary, but laying it all out there and feeling intense fear? Not so good. Retraumatizing people is no help at all.

I'm really big on risking it all to be honest and open, but I've not been much harmed by it. I do it all the time, in person and on the
Internet. I use my real name. It is liberating for me.
Leslie, yes! I'm Robin Sneed and I'm Butch. I'm here, I'm queer! And, G-d made me this way. And a strap-on has been sexually healing for me..and spiritually...AND...my wife hit that about two weeks after meeting her. And....deep...thing here...it was healing for her too....
Honored to know you, my friend. Truly.
I am Elena Kelly and I am a femme transsexual lesbian. It is more than liberating for me as I say those words with pride. It is as if the Universe itself comes into alignment with my soul merely by uttering the words. Oh Rev. Robin, thank you, thank you, thank you! And a bucket full of blessings all over you this day.
@ Owl... thank you, and blessings returned to you and yours.

Also kissed cheeks *smiles*

"I'm the only person I know who had to go to therapy because of war in the Middle East - the threat of the apocolypse. That was 3ish years ago." I didn't have a therapist, but if I'd had one, I would have been there too. I know my Bible, and erm... yeah. Three years ago it looked to me that the Apocalypse was on our collective doorstep.

You're not alone, not by a long way.
Robin.... Thank you for this post, and the conversation.... broadened my experience in a good way.