Starting from Here

Roy Jimenez

Roy Jimenez
Location
Sonoma, California, USA
Birthday
July 01

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 8, 2010 1:31AM

A Modest Proposal: TSA Edition

Rate: 41 Flag

This morning I took my daughter to SFO for her flight back to the Big Apple.  The sight of that unusually long and slow-moving line to the security checkpoint led me to ponder the question uppermost in the American mind this holiday season, viz, "What we can do to ensure our safety in the air in these days of terror and random crazies?"

Pundits and experts tell us that by the time an aspiring mass murderer has made it to the airport with a reservation and boarding pass, it's almost certainly too late to do anything to prevent him -- did you notice that it's always "him"? -- from acting on his nefarious plan.  The bad guys are always a jump ahead of the minimum-wage (thank you, Senator Jim DeMint) public servants at the screening stations, who at best are prepared for the last attack, never the next one.  So we give up our nose-hair trimmers and shampoo samples, take off our shoes and soon surely our underwear for inspection -- always put on clean underwear, you never know when you might find yourself in an accident or a security checkpoint -- even though we know it's a charade.  If good intelligence and police work haven't stymied the potential terrorist before he arrives at the airport, then it's already too late and we can only trust our fate to a higher power or an alert Dutch tourist.

And now that the requirement for a warrant no longer forces government spooks to focus on targets where there's at least minimal probable cause for investigation, they're too busy just keeping their heads above the avalanche of spam emails, high-school sext messages and thank-you calls to Grandma for the sweater and socks to have time to connect dots like warnings from worried families about their sons' jihadist obsessions and online anti-crusader rants posted by newly recruited CIA assets.

All of this has me worried -- and it should have you worried too -- but driving back from the airport this morning, I was struck by the perfect solution.

You see, I'm of an age where periodic colonoscopies are now recommended, and I had my first one a few years ago.  To prepare me for the procedure, a drug was introduced into my bloodstream which had the effect of putting me into a dreamlike stupor until the nasty bits were over, at which time a counter-drug restored me to my normal semi-alert waking consciousness.  This is a wonderful medical technology, and one which holds the key to a foolproof solution to our air transportation safety problems.  We should simply sedate all air travelers before allowing them to board the plane, and then safely revive them at their destinations.

Not only does this plan obviate the need to worry about the criminal or terrorist intentions of any passenger, but it has other benefits as well.  Travelers will no longer be bothered by loud or misbehaving children of any age, by the drunk businessman in the next seat hitting on them, by the seat in front lowering into their personal space, or by kicks and pokes from the seat behind.  There'll be no need to relieve the boredom of air travel with insipid romantic comedies, and no temptation to throw away the children's college fund on useless gadgets from SkyMall.  Tasteless airline food will be obsolete, and the flight attendants' cart will never again block access to the restroom at a critical moment.

And think of the added efficiency -- comatose passengers could be stacked like cordwood, making it possible to squeeze dozens more passengers on a typical flight without ever compromising the quality of their flight experience.  After all, having a video camera and the medical equivalent of a Swiss Army knife poked up your rectum is at least as uncomfortable as being buckled into an economy class airplane seat, but with the right pharmacology it's as pleasant as that walk on the beach you see in all the prescription drug commercials.

So write your congressional representatives today and tell them to get behind the pharmaceutical solution to transportation safety.  After all, the alternative would be targeted intelligence with diligent analysis of data, a foreign policy that denies propaganda victories to our enemies, and honesty with the American people about the real risks and tradeoffs of living in a connected world.

You don't seriously think any of that's gonna happen, do you?

Author tags:

travel

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
When you get right down to it, almost any problem can be resolved by looking to better living through chemistry.
You're a genius! I put this up with my plan to take over Cuba and give it to Israel for a new home. Both plans are too practical however. I hate to rain on your parade. I am taking the train -blowing up an old amtrak car wouldn't make much of a splash so I think I am safe. I would write my Congressman but he would need help with the big words. Your plan has great merit. Nitrous Oxide could work also.
This is indeed a modest proposal compared to where I thought you were going. I imagined I'd get a colonoscopy, too, in one neat package. Many people may not be able to afford them at some other time, and I'm sure it's one of the many places the TSA will want to inspect these newly pliable passengers anyway. So why not put it all into a neat bundle? Plus, even while we sleep, we have to worry about “sleeper cells,” right? :)
Will the airlines be serving up any Irish babies for snacks?

Nicely done :)
But does it give you the munchies?
Can I get a new i-phone in the bundling?
The visuals this post gave me are pretty interesting! Maybe you have a point, though. If fingernail clippers are considered a life-threatening weapon, then anything is possible.
I've had the same thought, bunk 'em up.
Roy for president! Or at least for director of homeland security! The passengers would thank you since flying has become a form of aerial colonoscopy, and not the pleasurable experience that it used to be. Great post.
At my age, if I'm not taking it up the ass at the airport, I'm taking it up the ass at the doctor's office.
For a visual component of your idea, see the sci-fi movie, The Fifth Element. Space travel, yes, but on the same commercial basis as our airlines. (Now, if the costumes were always done by Gaultier, it could be perfect.)
The TSA and politicians, all players in the theatre of the absurd. Me, I'll drive.
I like the idea of being stacked like cordwood....but that might create aproblem w weight discrimination...figuring out who is on the bottom, middle and top. The sedative could be offered on a select menu prior to boarding...think of the jobs thaty would come out of this industry for folks in the healthcare profession!
Free drinks might work too - except for those who react badly (loudly)...and doesn't work on the jihadists...

Seriously tho, if airlines agreed to refuse passengers who buy one-way tickets with cash and who have no luggage, that would eliminate some of the danger...
Here is a theme song for your post.

The Ramones I Wanna be Sedated

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMD7Ezp3gWc

"I Wanna Be Sedated"

Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do and no where to go-o-oh I wanna be sedated
Just get me to the airport put me on a plane
Hurry hurry hurry before I go insane
I can't control my fingers I can't control my brain
Oh no no no no no
Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go....
Just put me in a wheelchair, get me on a plane
Hurry hurry hurry before I go insane
I can't control my fingers I can't control my brain
Oh no no no no no
Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go I wanna be sedated
Nothin' to do and no where to go-o-o I wanna be sedated
Just put me in a wheelchair get me to the show
Hurry hurry hurry before I go loco
I can't control my fingers I can't control my toes
Oh no no no no no
Twenty-twenty-twenty four hours to go...
Just put me in a wheelchair...
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-ba-bamp-ba ba-ba-ba-bamp-ba I wanna be sedated
Ba-b
Excellent idea!! I have had a colonoscopy and 2 stents installed in the last 3 years and I can tell you, that whatever they use for those procedures to keep you under are absolutely the best way to fly.

And you always wake up feeling like you have slept for 8 hours.
Rated.
I wouldn't mind spending flights in a coma. But sadly, the terrorists would only find a way to swallow time bombs. So the procedure would probably have to include a full colonoscopy before take-off.
ha! the comatose passengers stacked like cordwood...you're onto something here.

let's do it.
Several people have written on this subject, but only you have seen fit to find the humor in this deadly serious business. Goodonya.

Actually, Rick Lucke had a simply brilliant idea -- more bomb sniffing dogs. But of course that's far too practical to be taken seriously -- and it won't line the pockets of the hi-tech portion of the Homeland Security Industrial Complex.
I remarked to a friend yesterday, when a lot of discussion of this security crap was on the radio, that I would go naked through a voluntary fast-track security line if it got me through a bit quicker. Then I thought better of it. Can you imagine some of the sights you might see? Impatient people come in all shapes and sizes, some of them less attractive than others.
Actually, I think the cordwood technique was tried before -- it's how the ancestors of most African-Americans got to this country. And I don't think it was a helluva a lot better for the ancestors of most of the Irish.
Lonnie, I'm usually a fan of herbal rather than chemical solutions, but in the case Big Pharma has the answer

Spud, you too are a genius, and think of the benefits to Cuba of the Israeli airport security protocols

Kent, you're a marketing genius (we're all geniuses here on OS), I honestly hadn't thought of the benefits of the colonoscopy bundle

Lainey, yum

cartouche, see Lainey

scupper, we'd have to work that out with AT&T, but since they're already in the anti-terror business, data collection department, maybe there's real synergy here

Procopius, yes, anything is possible in this best of all possible worlds

Kathy R, bunks, hammocks, sliding trays, it's all good

Zuma, if appointed I'll refuse to serve

O'Really, this makes taking it up the ass a consummation devoutly to be wished

Ardee, been there, seen that, but you raise a good point, for only $20 million you could get reamed in orbit

Chuck, you can't drive or operate heavy machinery when you're using my prescription, sorry

Gary, part of the beauty of this plan is that it eliminates the need for discrimination in the form of profiling, everybody must get stoned, re: your second point, would air travel be covered under the public option?

Myriad, stop making sense

Stellaa, everybody wins, except the America-haters

Dorinda, I wish I'd thought of that, it's the perfect musical accompaniment

Blackflon, welcome to my world, the benefits of a full night's sleep on the NY-DC shuttle

Norwonk, you put your finger up the problem, but bundled colonoscopy is the solution

dolores, it's a win-win-whee solution
Tom, you've got to laugh to keep from crying, and re: your 2nd comment, see, the method's already been proven efficient, and my idea makes it comfortable too

GeeBee, what if we bundled cosmetic surgery for the aesthetically disadvantaged
Charming idea, but one step short of "green." I say, board the passengers, give them a nice "trip," then send them home again before the euphoria of sedation wears off. More drugs, less bombs, cleaner skies -- it's a win-win-win scenario!
Well, I supposed if we're all zonked on drugs when the plane blows up, it won't really matter to us. Until we never reach our destination.
Congrats on EP Roy! I'll be back to fully digest later.
Risa, your idea sounds like a variation of Star Tours at Disneyland, but it won't get you where you want to go

Deborah, thank you so much for taking my modest proposal seriously

Sparking, you noticed, thanks
Well hey...sounds better than paying First Class airfares. You are a genius!!

Very funny Roy.
having just come back from a trip to South America that took twenty-four hours of travel time in one direction, I am in favor of your unique but oddly familiar approach
I must say, I like the way you think!
Buffy, you bring to mind another advantage of this system, it erases class discrimination

Nikki, you'll never get those hours back, but comatose you'll never miss them either
This is uncanny. My wife had hers today. All day it's been driving proceduring and then more driving. Slapped the chains on the Toyota to be doubly extra sure to make it home in shirtsleeves and I fired up the Dell to escape, only to find colonoscopy references. That puts us within six degrees of preparation, worse than the procedure. I'm with you on the risk management aspects of cordwood.
Stacey, nothing's inevitable except death, taxes and tasteless colonscopy jokes
BTW, you should really consider using Oakland Airport if at all possible - a thousand times less hellish to deal with than SFO.
lorelei, I agree that Oakland is better than SFO, but from where I live, Sacramento is the best of all, no contest
I don't like flying. The idea of being put under for the trip (wake up IN your hotel room) sounds ok to me.

There are places I'd like to go, but the discomfort of flying is not something I'm going to volunteer for again.
Gordon, of course we're talking about safety here, comfort is just a bonus
What a novel approach and unique solution. Why not?, taking a pill is the answer to so many other problems. Maybe the reason we have no TSA intelligence is because they are on drugs and comatose...pushing all those papers around...
I had this idea three years ago. Plagiarist. :-P

But honestly, I'd HAPPILY pay extra to have that little mask deliver pure nitrous oxide...
I love this idea. Pump me up.

I’ve flown on an airliner twice --- a two-way ticket. I felt safer during the two or three times I flew in a two-seater, so I think a good dose of tranquilizer would be okay with me, if/or when I fly on an airliner next.
Leonde, I thought it was a unique solution until I read Verbal's comment

Verbal, it just shows that great minds think alike
Rick, I'm surprised how many of my readers appreciate this modest proposal because they want to be sedated when flying, of course the real intention is to incapacitate the bad guys
We need universal healthcare before your plan will work -- can you imagine the cost of a round-trip ticket if we added the cost of drugs?! ;)

Miss you!
Now that full body scans are a near certainty in our future, the TSA might as well do the colonoscopy while they're at it since the next available place to hide explosives will be body cavities.

Ah, what a brave new world awaits us.
Bryn, we could get the drugs from Canada, though I guess then we'd need a new agency to screen the incoming drugs
Dave, the idea of bundling a colonoscopy or elective cosmetic surgery with air travel has come up already in the comment thread, travelocity or expedia could surely come up with attractive packages to include hotel, rental car, and supplemental drugs to offset side effects
This is brilliant. I'm worried too. Excellent writing. :)
thanks, sweetfeet, we should be worried, because airport screening is as big a joke as this post, and any attempt to address the issue realistically is lost in a cloud of politically-inspired fear and distortion
As a nurse I can appreciate the job security inherent in your proposal, for people like me are going to have to take the place of the minimum-wage screeners, plus we'll get free air travel.
Brilliant, Roy. Absolutely brilliant.

Why are you not the new head of the TSA? Your solution is just as much of an imposition as the current administration's, except that yours would actually work to enhance safety.

I'm voting for you next time - no matter what you run for.
Dan, of course, you nurses would have to be willing to work for minimum wage

c'mon, tomreedtoon, you're pulling my leg, your science fiction solution is completely impractical, I can tell you're only joking

Jamie, I'm not the head of TSA because Jim DeMint threatened to put a hold on me
You're a genius! I've also been on the med you discussed and was amazed at how fast time seemed to fly. Imagine how popular this would be with tourists to Australia.
You're a genius, Roy. What a plan! When the captain announces the altitude, the term "high" will have a new and improved meaning.
I swear I didn't copy Dr. Spudman44 or Rennaissance Lady on the "You're a genius!" outburst. (Note to self: read prior comments before attempting to write one of my own.)
Alternatively, we could give the drugs to the airline screeners. They would be less grouchy and would do an equally good job.
And they can combine national health care with homeland security. Less administrative costs!
hi, ren lady and lisa k, I notice that you and most of the other commenters are focused on side benefits of my modest proposal, I certainly never intended that air travel become an opportunity for recreational drug use, I'm strictly interested in transportation safety

scribe, welcome to my world

sirenita, this plan only works if we drug the passengers, but there may be other reasons to drug the screeners

lefty, when this plan is submitted to the CBO, I'm sure it'll come back revenue-neutral at least, and it's synergies may be the keys to
restoring a budget surplus
Roy, I can think of many other applications for this procedure. Board meetings, congressional hearings, the Republican National Convention. You may have made one of the most important discoveries of the modern era.
aw shucks, Coyote, now I'm blushing
pigop, you're kidding, right?
Yes, that seems to be the direction the US is headed, but just basic, clear-headed security procedures can do wonders. Just look at Israel's track record on air travel safety, and they get along entirely without drugs.
Judy M, Israel has an impressive record, but scaling their system up to the hundreds of international and regional airports in the US alone would be a daunting task, still, it's instructive that they don't rely on the kind of massive, intrusive and basically worthless screening that US air travelers are subjected to

the sad fact is that anyone who proposes honest clear-headed approaches to transportation safety gets royally reamed by the media stars and politicos who exploit fear of terrorism to get attention
Not only that, it would help people like me who are scared of flying!
patricia, you have nothing to fear but fear itself . . . and the fearful fearmongerers who feed on it
What business lobby doesn't get served through this modest proposal.
sheepdog, now that you point it out, I don't think there's anything here to benefit the financial services industry, I guess we'll have to take this one back to the drawing board
I can't add much to these comments except to say that if they would only institute your excellent idea I might fly again! I ALWAYS enjoy "being in a dreamlike stupor" & this would be simpler than those full body scans where I'd feel like I had to get in shape before entering the airport.
thanks for your encouragment, suzie, based on these comments my proposal would be a big hit with the American public, and could be the key to Obama's re-election campaign
Oh, the angst of a parent saying goodbye to a child at the airport! I hated those moments more than my annual pap smear!

So well writen and relavant piece, Roy! And I do remember the days of air marshalls, back in the 60's and 70's, when I was a wee flight attendant during the latter. One of my roomies was on a famous hijacking and was held hostage for 4 days back in the day. It was all happening so long ago. You'd think "they" would have learned a thing or two since then!

Not so much!
Cathy, as one who's really been there, done that, your endorsement of my proposal is much appreciated