This is my entry into Denis Faye's The Great Easy Fiend Humiliation Contest. It should be noted the contest isn't limited to High School. But this is the story it brought to mind for me.
You'd think anybody's Most Humiliating High School Moment would have something to do with looks or sex or--at the very least--PE. Not mine. My worst high school moment was an academic faux pas. Even decades later I still cringe at the memory.
Of course I had my share of minor humiliations along the bumpy road of early adolescence. The unfortunate "pixie" haircut. The perfectly executed high dive which lowered the top of my bathing suit. The rope climbing incident. The unrequited crush who told his friends I wasn't cool enough.
All pale in comparison to the mortifying Poetry Debacle.
To really understand, you need some background. I come from a long line of academic and professional achievers. All the way from my grandparents' generation to the present, we're lousy with PhD's, MD's, JD's, MBA's and MA's.
From pre-school through prep school we know we're going on to college and grad school. From earliest childhood we're lovingly introduced to the wonder and power of imagination, words, intellect.
Our bedtime stories were Lewis Carroll's Through the Looking Glass. Laura Ingalls Wilder's Little House on the Prairie. Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings' The Yearling. And oh, Louisa May Alcott's Little Women -- my all time favorite. Our mother would read one chapter a night. Which we'd discuss the next day and try to predict what would happen.
Little Women introduced me to the true beauty of a compelling story. My connection to the March family was so strong that the chapter-a-night rule became agony. So I taught myself to read. And finished the book on my own. I was four years old.
Then I found a volume of poetry. Huge. Almost too heavy to lift. Fell in love with Frost, the Brownings, Emily Dickenson. By age six I was writing stories and poems of my own. And could recite from Dickinson's Time and Eternity, Because I could not stop for Death.
I'm not unique in our family. We're intelligent, engaged, competitive, curious and accomplished. I don't mean that as hubris or elitism. It's simply the natural outgrowth of a confluence of culture, dedication and genes. And a tradition that stressed educational excellence. Intellectual fulfillment. Personal best.
So it's no wonder I still shiver with embarrassment over my untenable gaffe in Miss Pabst's 11th grade Advanced Literature class at The Baldwin School, best of the best. To this day I don't know where my head was, why I spoke before I thought, who spiked my morning cocoa with Idiot Juice.
We were studying poetry. Specifically Randall Jarrell, new to all of us. My first clue should have come when Miss Pabst warned, "This is not Elizabeth Browning, Young Ladies. Nor does it resemble those trashy romantic novels you all love so well. This is about Real Life."
Then she read aloud his taut, intense poem, Death of the Ball Turret Gunner as we followed in our books. The title alone should have been my second clue. The words themselves should have clinched it.
"From my mother's sleep I fell into the State,But I wasn't paying attention. And I certainly wasn't thinking. So when Miss Pabst asked me, one of her shining lights, for my impression of the poem I just winged it. I said (God, how I hate this, even now), "I think it's sweet. And sad that little guy left his mother."
And I hunched in its belly till my wet fur froze.
Six miles from earth, loosed from the dream of life,
I woke to black flak and the nightmare fighters.
When I died they washed me out of the turret with a hose."
Randall Jarrell, Death of the Ball Turret Gunner
Sweet? The agonizing death of a heroic WWII soldier? Sweet?
Dead silence in the classroom. Then a few nervous twitters. Miss Pabst's face frozen in shock. Turning red before my eyes. And finally, twelve 16-year-old girls exploding with laughter as I quickly reread the poem and grasped the enormous stupidity of my bluff.
Here's my paltry defense. I didn't know that a ball turret was an attachment to the rear of a B-17 bomber. Or that ball turret gunners were the soldiers who squatted painfully in that small space, manning machine guns to protect the plane during its bombing runs.
Plus, I was a city girl. The only animal life in our neighborhood--aside from the ubiquitous fancy dogs--were squirrels. Dirty balls of fur. I saw the words "mother's sleep," "wet fur" and "washed me out" -- and made the leap. Down a rabbit hole of Dense.
Death of a Ball Turret Gunner is a small poem encompassing a huge idea. Every one of Jarrell's words was meticulously chosen to convey the visceral and impersonal horror of war.
Regardless of my own knowledge--or lack of it--had I shown the proper respect for those words, I would have learned from them. And spared myself the humiliation of trivializing a fiercely important anthem to peace.
I had other high school moments. My slip fell down at my boyfriend's prom, for example. (I just stepped out of it and we continued dancing, leaving it on the floor with--I hoped--no connection to its owner.) But that's a funny memory, not a shameful one. At least not to me.
It's been years since I thought about the Poetry Debacle. Thank you, Denis. Not for calling up my most humiliating high school moment. But for helping me remember that the written word has power beyond imagination. And that war is hell.

Salon.com
Comments
(Man, I'm gonna take hits for hubris no matter my disclaimer... but what the hell, that's part of my point and I'm not changing the text now).
Mary, as usual, you go for the silver. And your story is hilarious, it will absolutely win. I told Denis all I'm trying for is Honorable Mention since it's a "literary" contest site.
dolores, I've heard many pro-life arguments that the poem is in fact about abortion. Sure, one could see it that way (one can see almost anything the way that suits) but I never did. State is capitalized, aka the government. Flak jackets had fur collars, sometimes linings, no heat in the ball turret. And according to my late brother-in-law, they did often have to use fire hoses to get gunners' remains out of that tight little space. The truth is skeevy enough without adding abortion to the mix.
R McC, I like your attitude. And thanks.
Lea, I knew you'd get this but thank you for the extra cherry on top. I do love poetry, but only by a treasured few, which includes, btw, Shel Silverstein.
You weren't kidding. Talk about having nowhere to hide. Bluffing can be risky business. I've tried it at home, when I zone out. Never works.
Rich, I hear ya. And you're in much more dangerous territory at home than I was in high school.
I was only joking...I had no idea that was actually something people used. yuck!! okay...see if I had been in that classroom I could have humiliated myself much worse than you did, and you wouldn't have had to feel at all bad all of these years.
It's obvious that you got over this particular humilation with a wonderful sense of humor and an inner compass that adapted and tuned up your performance.
Education was the only thing I really ever coveted. Going to school as long as I wanted to go made me feel rich beyond measure, and I learned from classmates that it is really hard to understand or relate to folks like me for those who couldn't wait to complete their educational obligations.
I can think of lots of humiliations along the way, not getting into honors English by one point on the entrance test, for one. I can still feel my hot red face when I read my test results and felt a dream die. I didn't have a clue that if I had told anyone with authority about myself that they might have given me a second shot later.
Since I didn't have an academic advisor, at that time, I just didn't know what to do. Experiences such as that are the only reason I would ever have been jealous. But I learned by the end of the first semester exactly what I had to know and do to kick ass in college. And once I had a decent education I have never in my life had any reason to feel any actual jealousy towards anyone at all.
I don't think I was reading at 4, that would have meant my family thought to give me a book, chuckle. But in first grade I blazed past everyone else into the 4th grade books that I could access. More than that I couldn't get my hands on until later.
Your story manages to level the playing field for me in a way. I thought all that humiliation was simply a product of being from a trailer trash family, not like that is necessarily a bad thing, but that it left me winging it more often than I could get comfortable with and was the reason for a lot of overachieving on my part. I just didn't know how to recognize where I fit in or how I compared to others either. Still don't particularly, but at least I am not blind about that anymore.
This is one of the things I have come to value on OS, lightening bolts of insight come to me in response to what wonderful writers like you are bold enough to share. Thanks, I think I needed that perspective Sally! I apologize for such an over long, over share, but you inspired me to insight with your writing.
Thanks again.
Seriously, poetry lends itself so well to this kind of debacle. Words do have power - the power to lift up, tear down, and sometimes to simply confound.
Thumbed (but not a John McCain "My Friends" thumb - just a "Nice Going Sal Gal" thumb).
Suzanne, what an incredible story, I am literally humbled at your achievements, especially comparing our backgrounds... wow, did I have it easy! I know that, I knew that, but on the other hand our learning competition was fierce and not just for academics but for attention and love (another story all together, eh). Please take your comment, add to it and make a post of it, there are so many life lessons there, much more than in my post. Seriously.
Bill, we are on the same plane. Garp was the book that made me say, Hey, writing is attainable, i.e. I can do that. Of course I'm no John Irving, but still, the sense of potential and the literal push it inspired in addition to the incredible entertainment. Thanks for letting me off the hook, good to know boys wouldn't necessarily have gotten Jarrell's point either.
You tell a great story.
I believe this is a sterling example of "A high-class problem."
There is no dearth of such incidents in our lives. Only we need a lot of gaiety in ourselves to share it, don't we?
For those of you who want to know more about the ball turret gunner I suggest Catch-22.
day dreamer, we've all had our share of embarrassment, but this is about humiliation, a much deeper emotion which can leave a different impression and even a scar. You're so right, we can't share anything painful without the ability to laugh.
bobbot, I am absolutely just another human, you have not idea how much so. I'd like to think I have an ingrained sense of superior advantages rather than superiority. I was privileged to take a course in grad school taught by Joseph Heller -- now there's a superior human.
I added a link to my high school portrait post which I'll put here too. If you're interested you can see that I'm no stranger to humiliation where The Baldwin School is concerned. My High School Education, Lessons in Anti-Semitism
Re The Slip
Just fyi, the bf's prom was held in a hotel ballroom, slightly darkened, swirling disco light ball (can you imagine??) and packs of couples slow dancing to a live band. Chaperones were probably swigging from flasks. I felt a bunching around my hips, shook them a little to straighten the dress, felt something slide down my legs, looked down, uh oh, the special long slip that came with the gown. I only froze for a split second, then just gave a little back kick to move the nylon pile away from me. BF got the message, danced us away from it. I have no idea what happened to the slip from there, during or after the prom.
bobbot, virtually all our senior portraits are embarrassing as hell, that's the fun. C'mon, be brave and post!
Now that it's out do you feel better?
Karin, it does make a picture, doesn't it.... empty ballroom still echoing with the aftermath of loud music and spinning lights, not to mention teenage lust, sweat and tears. The chaperones sitting exhausted at an empty table in the corner, their heads pounding from the noise and the booze, their feet aching from standing so long, their eyes stinging from the clashes of too many varieties of too much cheap perfume and cologne... and then, one by one, they notice a puddle of pink silk lying abandoned on the floor. (Okay, Karin, your turn!)
Melinda, I bet you're right. Now that it's out I feel better in the sense that I poked fun at myself out loud, in public, and was not scorned. Inside, it'll always bother me. The things we'd do over if we could.
(He became a critic in later life. Check out this screed:
"In the bad type of thin pamphlets, in hand-set lines on imported paper, people's hard lives and hopeless ambitions have expressed themselves more directly and heartbreakingly than they have ever expressed in any work of art: it is as if the writers had sent you their ripped-out arms and legs, with 'This is a poem' scrawled on them in lipstick."
There's more surrounding that quote, quite merciless stuff, @:
http://www.rjgeib.com/thoughts/gunner/bad-poets.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
If it's any consolation, he was quite brilliant, and probably committed suicide.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------