Treat Williams, not Fred, but there's a striking resemblance, so this is how I remember him.
Brian B got a lot of us thinking and reminiscing with his post Do You Remember Your First Kiss?. I was going to answer as a comment, but you know me, there's a story here.
First, I want to clarify that I don't count little Billy in third grade running up to me at recess on a dare and pecking my cheek--or even my mouth--then running back to the other boys gathered laughing and cheering.
That's not the kind of experience that qualifies as a real "first kiss." And unless a spin-the-bottle kiss was a doozy, not a hurried, embarrassed buss, that doesn't count either.
Here's what counts:
His name is Fred, called Freddie back then, literally the boy next door. Well, one of them. The oldest and hunkiest of three brothers. Football player, top of his class (soon off to Harvard in fact), dark hair, almost one eyebrow in that sexy Treat Williams way.
The middle brother, the one my age, had a crush on me. I couldn't see him for my overwhelming crush on Freddie, who never seemed to see me at all.
One early summer day, as usual there was a gang of neighborhood kids in our rec room (wow, isn't that a dated phrase?) I have no clue what Freddie was doing there, he was 17, no 18. I was barely 14, my friends and I were babies to a high school star stud, college bound.
He was always on my teen radar, though I knew I was decidedly not on his. But at some point that day I saw him looking at me in a way I instinctively realized was "interest." My heart started to pound. I still remember that. I know now it was mostly fear.
But at the time, OMG, Freddie was staring at me. Intently. I didn't see him move but suddenly he was beside me. He said, "What's this door?" In a daze I told him the cedar closet. He took my hand, led me inside, closed us in. It was a room-sized closet but we stood close, not touching, eyes trying to adjust to the almost total darkness.
I could feel his presence on my exposed skin, hear his breathing. The hair on the nape of my neck moved, sent a frisson of pleasure down my spine. His scent washed over me, light sweat, not unpleasant, English Leather, something else. I know now probably musk. Definitely male.
My mind was racing... what now, should I turn on the light, should I say something, maybe this was a mistake, where, how... and then he kissed me.
I thought they made this stuff up in books, but as his lips closed over mine, soft and hard at the same time, urging them open, his tongue gentle and then firm in my mouth, I nearly swooned.
Oh, the sweet contradictions of a real, grown up kiss. The heat of his hands, one against my waist, the other on the back of my head as he pressed me closer. Our bodies tensed, touched, from kiss to knees ... and I actually felt the room begin to spin.
He slowly pulled away, dropped his hands. I staggered a little, he steadied me. Lifted one hand to lightly touch my cheek. Stepped back. "No. No," I barely heard his whisper. We stayed still for a minute, not speaking. He opened the door and left.
I was devastated. The perfect boy of my dreams had finally, finally kissed me, but found me wanting, rejected me.
Oh, the difference between 14 and 18. He'd not rejected me, but my inexperience and youth. He'd pulled himself back from making a big mistake. Less for him than for me.
It was years til I understood --and appreciated-- that gesture. And still, it was almost the perfect first kiss, sweet, dreamlike, a taste, a hint of a future of genuine passion.
Why almost perfect? In my dizzy, hazy excitement, I didn't kiss him back. Because I didn't know how.
~~~~
I've come to realize that was a good thing. Karma. He might not have been able to remain such a gentleman and I'd have started that part of my life far too soon. At least I learned what a really spectacular kiss should be. And I'm very, very good at it now.
~~~~
I didn't remember this story, or the kiss, for a long time. One day a few years ago my younger sister, teasing me and giving away that she'd read my diary way back when, quoted all I could manage to say on the subject: "Freddie NoLastName at last!"
~~~~
My mother and his mother are still friends, live near each other in Florida. She just saw Fred and his wife last week while he was visiting his mother. I wonder if... no, he wouldn't remember.

Salon.com
Comments
What happened with the middle brother?
~~~~
Hobo, I strongly believe there are lots of first kisses, especially the one with The One.
~~~~
Mrs. Michaels, the middle brother went to Yale, Harvard MBA and LSE, is happily married with a nice family and still, even in this market, obscenely rich. Incredibly charitable too. Not at all surprising. Of course now I'm itching to see both of them, just to catch up. No hanky-panky, I've got what I want.
~~~~
Cherie, glad you could laugh and get closure. Truth is, I never saw him again and it was 40 years ago. Time flies but memories linger.
John you did NOT kiss Treat Williams! But if you did, maybe he just wasn't that into you.
Michael, you were licking girls faces at age 18? Maybe you have cat genes.
Lea, it wouldn't have been crowded for long, I'd have been out of there and you'd have a better story to tell.
All these years later, nothing has changed.
In college, I played the romantic lead, Bill Starbuck, in the musical version of The Rainmaker. But sadly, I was not able to plant a real wet one on my leading lady during our onstage kiss -- she was my sister. Trust me -- it really is true what they say about kissing your sister.
it lasted a few short months...years later when we were eighteen and I had a summer job at a local restaurant as a hostess , he came in to see me and stayed to talk while I had my break
Anyway..this boy, Larry was his name, came in to talk to me...he was about to get engaged...I was stunned, I mean we were eighteen, what about college? Looking back on it, I think that meant he was going to have a "live in "relationship, this was during the sixties and we weren't always as open and forthright with such details, no matter how films and fiction today depict that era..
But what struck me was how he explained that I had been his first love, had never left his heart or mind and that he wanted to make certain...he still seemed a fourteen year old to me.
I saw a shallowness or lack of depth or something slightly disturbing about myself then...I think I had a hint that I didn't really want to know just one man my whole life. And at this point I was still a virgin and would be one yet for a couple of years!
grandma, your story is special, and a special part of your past. I didn't mean to suggest that every first kiss is the best, only that mine was. Or, in later years when you meet someone and the chemistry is buzzing, the very first kiss can be the best of that relationship. I'm glad I waited too, it was worth it to know, and take responsibility for, what I was doing.
Ah, to have the hormones we had then and the brains we have now...
Does the smell of cedar still make you weak in the knees?
But nevermindallthat...now you know how to kiss. Perhaps you will show me what you've learned....