
"I was supposed to be directing this children’s movie, so I told John Wells I probably can’t do it. Then I went home, and my wife and my manager slapped me around and said this is Crichton and Spielberg. This is a big deal." Anthony Edwards
This week and next I'm averting my eyes from the current domestic and global pile up ... for one hour, Thursday night at 10 PM. There, for the past 15 years I've been watching my favorite show, ER.
For the last four years I've seen my favorite characters leave the show, one by one. Now, it's finally time to curl up in my comfy leather chair and say good-bye to the whole shootin match.
Yes, I pined when Doug Ross/George Clooney left, but it was predictable. Carol Hathaway/Julianna Margulies too. When Carter said goodbye in 2005, hooboy, that was tough. Even though we knew he'd be back from time to time.

C'mon ER junkies, you know who Carter is ... and you know who you are. Noah Wyle, by the way, insisted on including the heartrending and eye-opening episodes about the genocide in Darfur, some of ER's best and most important work. Along with addressing critical health issues. Take a look. It's an impressive list.
I've welcomed and enjoyed most of the new characters over the years, but the first team was the best. And for a very long time, ER was one of the best shows on TV.
New York Times tells us ER was the most watched show on TV for three years, pulling in over twice as many viewers as any top show today. It stayed popular year after year and remains the 2nd most watched show on NBC, after Law and Order.
To tell the truth, all the hoopla around Battlestar Galactia ending its 5-year run has me feeling a little self-conscious about declaring my allegiance to a TV show 15 years old.
Still, I'll say it loud and proud: I've been a loyal ER fan since Carter was a pup.
"One of the few good things about modern times: If you die on television, you will not have died in vain. You will have entertained us." Kurt Vonnegut
And in fact, it's not really John Carter/Noah Wyle who stays with me. It's Anthony Edwards, ER's late Dr. Mark Greene. His swan song was an Emmy winner. Arguably the best episodic TV death ever.
I've been thinking about it and wondering how John Wells and team are going to top it with the series' finale. Especially since the tragic loss of Michael Crichton. My conclusion: they can't.
The Death of Dr. Greene
Back in the day, Mark Greene was the Carter, the Pratt, the Abby, the hub of today's ER. Yeah, yeah, George Clooney's Doug Ross was the Heartthrob, but Dr. Greene was the Heart and Soul.
Greene was Everyman, overworked, underpaid, faced with everyday problems: stress, marriage, fatherhood, strained friendships, workplace politics, aging and dying parents, divorce, remarriage, and finally, his own mortality.
The show allowed his character to handle it all with gumption and frailty, success and failure, but always with insight, sensitivity and essential humanity. Finally, he becomes a respected hospital physician, remarried with a young child, struggling to keep his life, his marriage and his troubled teenage daughter Rachel afloat.
Then, bam! Brain tumor. But not handled like your grandmother's soap opera. ER gave us a brutal and honest look at the whole painful, messy process. In depth. Real. Horrifying. Uplifting. Finite.
They did it cleverly too. They made it a voyage. Confusion. Misery. Discovery. Hope. Anger. Acceptance. Death. They gave him time, perspective, awareness, dignity. And they gave us a hell of a ride.
The apparent final Dr. Greene episode was in fact prologue to the end. Greene says good-bye to the staff, and to us. He walks away from the ER forever, having handed the ever present hospital basketball, his mantle, to Carter. The hour moves forward with other characters, other plots.
Then a letter from Greene to the staff arrives by fax and Carter reads it aloud. At the end of the letter is a postscript from Greene's wife ... saying he died that morning. She's sent his letter along to let them know he was thinking about them near the end.
Stunned. Silence. As in real life, even when you know it's coming, it hits you like a runaway train. Greene's letter and his wife's note are tacked to a communal bulletin board. We watch as the various characters read the messages, and absorb the news of his death.
It isn't until the next--and truly final--Greene episode that we are shown his last days. Certain scenes resonate. Greene's wife finds him in the kitchen in the middle of the night, writing a list of things he always wanted to do before he died. (Years before The Bucket List, by the way).
Some, predictable male fantasies, he'll never do. "Hit a home run to win the World Series for the Cubs." "Climb MT. Everest." Some, he manages. "Jump out of a plane." Others, poignant fatherhood dreams, are heartbreaking. "Walk his daughters down the aisle."
And finally, his deepest wish, and greatest challenge, "Fix Rachel."
That's the one that shapes the last show. Trying to reconnect with his difficult, rebellious teenager, he takes her to Hawaii, where he grew up. He wants her to know he rebelled as a teenager himself, to understand him as a person and as her father.
He wants them to share the past and the present ... if not the future.
In one scene he reminds her that as a child she loved The Wizard of Oz and would beg him to sing "Over the Rainbow" whenever he put her to sleep. She denies the memory, and him, seems not to hear, or care.
She doesn't want his generational backwash, sees no value in groking his life or comparing it to her own. And of course she's so very angry. Especially at him. For leaving her. But as he deteriorates and moves closer to death, she begins to understand what was, and what never will be.
She comes to him early one morning. He's lying in bed, facing the sun as it rises over the ocean. He struggles talk, tells her he wants to leave her with some wisdom to guide her, save her. "Generosity," he tells her. "Be generous. With your time, with your love, with your life."
"I will," she says. You can see that she's recognized the enormity of her pending loss. She stops fighting him. Wants instead to connect, to ease his pain.
Gently she places earphones on his head, kisses him good-bye, and turns on the CD player. First we hear a 4-string ukulele and hypnotic humming -- then a soft, haunting refrain, "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" sung by Israel Kamakawiwo'ole ... her generation's version of the classic, a wish and a gift for her father.
She's found a way to show him her love, and Greene's final smile is beatific, a man at peace.
Schmaltzy? A little. Moving? Absolutely. Will ER's swan song top it? Not a chance. But for two more shows, I'll wallow in whatever they give us. And I'll always have reruns.
Watch this and see. It might give you a little peace too.

Salon.com
Comments
And as I've gotten ensnarled in the medical system over the last few years, I appreciate the stories that ER told over the years - things that were outside of my experience back then. The crowded ER waiting rooms, the struggles with insurance companies, the overworked nurses, etc. ER may have prettied them up to some extent, but at least they were talking about them.
Moving into modern times .... The Defenders with E.G. Marshall ... the original Kung Fu with David Carradine ... the exceedingly guilty pleasure of The Gong Show ... and I must have seen every episode of Law and Order at least 5 times.
Now I'm such a boring old fart, my only regular watches are Olbermann and football, tho I will be cheering on my Spartans in the NCAA tourney. Oh, and I do love IFC, the History Channel, Bill Moyers and Charlie Rose.
All in all, I guess I sound like the perfect customer for all those Big Pharma prescription drug ads -- but I take NO medications other than beer and scotch.
I haven't watched ER in years, but I will be joining you (in spirit) for the next two weeks.
Very calming.
Emergency Room (well, it's the show's title)
Edwards Returning
Everyone Retreats
Exit Respected
I've watched so many favorite shows go off syndication, and I've always felt cheated by their demise. Even when I knew it was going to happen. Then there are shows that SHOULD have died but didn't. Sometimes, I just don't get it. I'll miss ER, it has been a marvelous show with some truly memorable characters.
Oh, my own true ER story (you'll love this one, Sally):
While we were on vacation in California last year, my brother took us to a local joint he frequented called UWinks (it's an eatery with a touch-screen on every table, you can play trivia against the other tables every Thursday night). We sat down at our table, getting ready to order food and setting up the touch screen with our "team" name. It was myself, my wife, Victor, and my daughter at one table. A rather raucous group of four people was at the next table, and one of them turned around and started kidding around with Victor. I had to laugh to myself, and get Carol's attention. It was Scott Grimes. He is such a fabulously normal guy.
Thumbed for the memories of things past and things to come.
Thank you very much, Sally. Keep being generous!
I have to say that at its best it was very very good.
Have you ever listened to the late Eva Cassidy's rendition of Over The Rainbow? If you haven't, please do. It is absolutely beautiful.
rated
Great ER/Clooney story, which I probably won't put in my wrap, unless I do: Nora and I met George Clooney a few years ago at a screening of "Good Night and Good Luck." She was beside herself; she'd been watching ER since she was 8, she was a big Dr. Ross fan, and she told me she was going to tell him that. I said, Nora, he's a famous actor, director, producer, he doesn't need to hear about his long-ago TV career. Being Nora, she defied me, and when we got to Clooney she said, "I've loved you since ER!" And he grabbed her in a big hug and said, "I love it when fans remember my early work!" He also said all kinds of nice things about Salon and was just unbelievably sweet to both of us. Sigh.
His trajectory was pretty compelling - the Baltic war, loss of his family, and he was the one who first did Doctors Without Borders, on the show.
The episode when he was the only one NOT shot, because of the cross around his neck; next episode Carter finds him amidst a heap of stinking corpses: for whatever it's worth, those episodes were amazing to me. I KNEW what the tv show was trying to depict, having followed it as an actual ongoing news event. I felt proud of ER for tackling some bigger subjects, and maybe getting more people involved in awareness of international crises and humanitarian aid.
I'm glad everyone came back for the final episodes.
What's TRULY amazing: Chuny and (can't remember her name jazz singing nurse) have been with the show from the first episode. So cheers to the nurses that kept that ER going. And Frank. They really kept the show going.
I'm a fan! I love syndication!
And i actually HATED the Mark finale because he says to his daughter, "Don't cry for me" - WTF??? And she agrees. Denying his daughter her grief - telling her it's not OK to grieve?? That was so not Mark but also a real disservice to people who need to understand that grief is OK - which most Americans do not. Honestly, that's when they lost me, even though I watched for a couple or more years after that.
Tom C.: I was also a huge "St. Elsewhere" fan. What an eclectic bunch of characters that was!
These days there's hardly anything on to tempt me. I can't stand "Reality" shows, and I don't have cable. I've been indulging in NetFlix's InstantView format. Lots of classics there.
The last few nights I've been watching the first season of "Murder, She Wrote" (while knitting). Remember when TV shows had scripts, and production values, and costume departments, and sets to be decorated? I don't remembering enjoying MSW as much when I was younger. Now that I'm a bit older, I am in awe of how much energy Angela Lansbury exuded, doing that show.
I'd have to say Abby and Carter are my two all time favorite characters. It was happiness to see her pop up alast week and Noah is knocking the socks off Carter's role in this endgame.
Sigh. I will be sad when it is gone. Except of course, for syndication.
Like Sheldon, I liked the story arc involving Lucy, especially the very last episode where, after her death, Dr. Romano (Paul McCrane) went in to attend to her personally and tenderly rather than let the nurses do it.
Heck, I'm not ashamed to say that I even liked Romano, and hated what they did to his character in the end.
I can't answer everybody and am sure there are more than a few NNTR's, but I have some general and specific R's of my own:
~~~Joan and everybody, read the NYT piece I linked here, it's a great review with many great quotes from many of the actors, two I used at the top.
~~~Yes, the show changed radically, not so much when Clooney left as when Edwards did. They thought they had to appeal to a younger audience (why is everything always about "younger"??), when they should have been tending to their core constituency.
~~~Maura Tierney is one of the best and more overlooked actresses around... except by ER. She did one or two guest shots and her Q-ratings hit the roof, so they gave her a bigger recurring role, which made her eventually a pivotal character. You can have John Stamos and all the other young studs they tried to wrap the show around, if anyone picked up Greene's and Carter's mantle, Abby Lockhart did.
~~~I said in my piece and I'll say again, ER showed us the horror of Darfur before our own news outlets did. They made it real and horrifying and generated a much better public understanding of genocide and how it can rip nations apart.
~~~Lucy and Carter, what a team. I wish they'd kept her around longer. Their stabbing's were so intense, as was Lucy's death.
~~~One of our OSers has a daughter who appeared in an ER arc as a young girl for whom Carter tries to find a new liver. Her experience with Noah Wylie was exceptional, he was a genuine, good guy.
~~~Goran Visnjic. Dr. Kovac is undeniably hunky, and had a lot to contribute in terms of world wide social consciousness-raising and some pretty good acting, but he never did it for me, personally.
~~~I loved the special episodes they used to do and are trying again by bringing back former cast members. Remember when a documentary team followed them around for a day, interviewing everyone from Greene to the janitor? James Woods as a brilliant professor and, we find out, Abby's mentor, dying of ALS. Ray Liota as an alcoholic with an hour-long death scene. Cynthia Nixon as a stroke victim whose entire experience we view through her thoughts. You think of some, let's all help Joan with her piece.
~~~Bill and Marcela, I loved your comments, what a great connector ER was.
~~~I loved Rocket Romano when he was at his best. They made him into a cartoon, which was a real disservice to the actor and his character. Kisses to anyone who can tell me the blockbuster music and dance movie in which he made his debut.
I shall now receive my kisses.
On a far different subject indeed, I forgot to give ER credit for showing the horror of Iraq, the courage of our soldiers and the stories of struggle for military families.
The kid who was a resident and under too much pressure - he threw himself under the el train, and lived. His dying body ended up in the ER, someone was trying to page him, and the pager was going off from his mangled body...whoa.
I love ER.
I never liked ER and would always find a reason to be in another room when my partner decided to watch it on TV. Even from the other room, I would find myself listening to the stories and hearing the characters. Occasionally, I would run to the doorway to see what was happening if the dialogue fell off. Then I would sheepishly ask if my partner needed anything from the kitchen.
The story you relate is exactly why even those stories we don't like can still be moving and meaningful. I'm gonna go blow my nose and wipe the tears from my face. Thank you for that, too.
Rated
aim, the firefighter arc, the over-stressed and under-prepared intern Benton rides so hard he cracks, then Carter's anger at Benton ... those stories were all small gems of pure reality. Carter's cousin hooked on heroin, his relationships with his parents and grandparents. I didn't like Kovac and the Archbishop but I got its importance. It was the Buddhist nun dying of breast cancer that tore me up and gave me peace. What about Benton going to the deep South and dealing with racism in the end of the 20th Century? The list is endless. And isn't that a statement?
dicea, some of what I just said above are the reasons you were drawn in despite your apparent lack of interest. That was the power of the show at its best.
Blue, it had its ups and downs for sure, but I liked the mature Susan too and her very real struggle with her out-of-control sister. The same sister who'd abandoned her baby to Susan, then devastated her when she came back clean to claim the baby after Susan had so bonded with the child. Her efforts to cope, the way she helps Greene in the beginning, then sends his wife to him, her betrayal when Carter gets the one attending slot because he gave millions to the hospital... that kind of politics happens all the time. You're very right when you say GOOD dramas are a dying breed. I can't believe Life on Mars was canceled and that stupid, predictable Bochco young lawyer show stays on.
Mal, the "Generosity" episode, and sentiment, have stayed with me, obviously. There are so many others, mentioned here and too numerous to mention. Especially Darfur. Horrifying and illuminating. Abby's family's struggle with bi-polar disease and her own alcoholism. Benton trying to keep his senile mother out of a nursing home, his sister's child killed, just being in the wrong place at the wrong time, then his own struggle to care for his deaf child. ER gave us more than most give it credit for.
Annimal, I agree, I didn't like Carter's involvement with Kim at all, none of it. He'd have done better with Mary McCormack (whose new show we love). Still, Darfur and the focus on the AIDS pandemic in Africa was eye-opening, to say the least.
Suzn, yes, soap opera and just plain stupid took over for a while as they tried to attract a younger audience. But, as I've said, there were many worthwhile moments, especially the arc about Michael Gallant going to Iraq. Chilling doesn't begin to describe.
That was always the bottom line about ER... just when you thought it was letting you down forever, Crichton would come up with another winning story line. He'll be missed. So will the show. It'll leave a Great. Big. Hole. But it also left its mark and can be seen or taped every morning at 10am ET on TNT. It's recently started over, Mark isn't divorced yet, Carol hasn't left Tag at the alter, Doug is still a screw-up. Yeaaa!