Your Thanksgiving Scolding, Get It While It's Hot

I've been reading articles all week about how to "cope" with Thanksgiving. I don't get it. This is by far the coolest --and warmest-- holiday of the year.
Thanksgiving is a paid day (or two) off from work and school. It's secular, non-dressy, no gifts are even involved.
The whole purpose is comfort: hanging out with friends and loved ones, eating delicious food, watching television for hours, taking long naps. Coming home. Or going someplace fun.
And, if you're lucky, spending quality time counting your blessings.
Plus, a bonus for those who care about such things: a whole weekend to shop til you drop.
What other country would think up such a great holiday? And what other country would try harder to screw up such a good thing?

Psychic Shock
But there they are, the ubiquitous articles on how to protect your delicate ego from interfering family members.
"How to get through a visit with your parents ... or your children."
"How to manage a meal dodging weird Uncle Harry." (Stab his wandering hands with a fork and apologize profusely). "How to refrain from flipping off annoying Aunt Sylvia." (Say something you know will either please her or --if she's annoying beyond redemption, go ahead and piss her off).
"How to shut the kids up." Um, I mean, "How to keep the kids busy and involved." (Turn this over to the older kids or younger couples. Tell them it's a rule and/or good practice).
Then of course there's the media frenzy braying about Thanksgiving travel and crowded stores.
I have some advice for those who buy into such cynical pandering to the greedy, neurotic and disenfranchised among us: Get over yourselves! Stop kvetching! Oy vey, Enjoy already! (Okay, sorry, for a minute there I made Thanksgiving a Jewish holiday).

Parents
Younger complainers: if you can wait days in line for concert tickets, iPhones and X-Boxes, surely you can spend a few hours in an airport, train station or car to bring joy to those who love you more than any rock star ever will.
Grown children: Stop whining about schlepping to Mom and Dad's house. Remember. these are the people who spent time, effort, money and countless sleepless nights helping you make it to adulthood.
If they didn't, or were abusive, mean, nasty, horrible parents, don't go near them! You're an adult, you have the power now. Use it without guilt and with my blessing.
But if they did their best, give them the love and respect they've earned. Show up, bring something, smile, help with the cooking and the dishes. Appreciate how lucky you are to have a family and a place to call home.

In-Laws
Couples: Stop arguing over whose side of the family to visit and which mother will pile on the most guilt if you don't. Remind yourselves and your parents that doing so pulls you apart.
If they love you, they should encourage you to respect each other. Try to please each other. Make your own decisions. And refine your ability to share.
If that doesn't work, use the big guns. Remind them that too many people have no families, homes or food on Thanksgiving or any other day.
Say you will pick a side to visit this year and donate money to a shelter in the other side's name. Then promise to switch visits next year.
If economics are involved, make the best plan you can, be gracious, firm and loving. Don't let yourself be bullied. It's your relationship, not theirs.
Ex-Laws: Never ever ever use your children as holiday leverage. Do not involve them in a power struggle over who loves who more. Work out a holiday schedule responsive to YOUR CHILDREN, not your personal grievances.
You are giving them memories. Will they need a shrink or learn to create a loving Thanksgiving themselves?
Assist/send/let them go to the other parent without guilt, anger or anything but a big smile and a "Have a great time!"
If you're a real class act (and, well, a little passive-aggressive), help them make something scrumptious to take along.

Reality Check
There's only one thing that should be really hard to handle at Thanksgiving: the empty chairs of loved ones -- unable to come, far away or gone for good.
How trivial to whine about your family's "issues" when others are spending Thanksgiving at a child's hospital bedside. In their own hospital bed. Trying to connect from Iraq and Afghanistan. Or bereft and alone.
So...

Give Thanks
Do yourself a favor. Drop the anti-Thanksgiving attitude. Count your blessings for the things you have ... and the things I hope you never have to face.
Then take another moment to remember --and if possible, help-- those for whom Thanksgiving is only another day of pain, or a painful reminder of loved ones missing and missed.
If you can't do that, then you're just a big turkey.
PS You'd also do well to remember there are those who might be dreading dealing with you. Help them get over it. You'll thank me.
Have a very Happy Thanksgiving! Or else.
Now, go. Eat. Drink. Enjoy.

Salon.com
Comments
Both practical and with the exact right attitude.
I especially liked this: If you're a real class act (and, well, a little passive-aggressive)
I love when there are combo platters like that.
Happy Thanksgiving Sally.
And I do mean HAPPY!
I've always loved Thanksgiving for reasons you mention -- it's like all the good parts of Christmas without the bad ones, like having to shop or decorate. Good food, company, warm times. And I've traveled many times on the holiday thru bad weather to spend it with family and always been glad I did.
And if all else fails, you can always be thankful you're not a turkey.
Rated.
Funny, though, the Pilgrims didn't look Jewish.
thanks and you, too.
race you to the table of yummy food? ready, set ... GO.
Happy Thanksgiving, everyone, and please pass the gravy!
Rated.
Have a happy Thanksgiving, everyone!
Oh, and well said as always. Rated (why is that "rate" icon so.... so..... depressing? Oh, I know!!! 'Cause it looks like it should be holding a hot turkey drumstick and it isn't!)
Rated for straight talking!
Way to put it into perspective!
:-)
Rated.
Plus, I know you know we are doing our level best to make the absolute most of this bittersweet Thanksgiving at Karen's, filled to the brim with family, friends, great food and love.
A few notes:
Roger, I always add a dash of passive-aggressive to my stuffing. Along with beer (ah ha! one of my secrets is out!)
john walker, you called me Stella. What an enormous compliment!
neil, you make a totally valid point. Here's to those who give thanks by unleashing their inner bitch/bastard.
femme, in my book anybody can be a mensch. Thank you for calling me a mensch... or did you call me a guy?
Ash, you added an idea that I forgot! If necessary, gather in smaller groups and do phone calls. Perfect.
Mare, you know I love you (and I did give you fair warning. ;) I'm sorry you won't have your kids around you, that does suck, I hope you're going somewhere fun, you have so many friends and family. As for those stats on suicide, I've heard they're a bit inflated. I'd say if someone kills himself over a dinner, he was going to do it anyway. Regardless, that's why I suggested we all look around and take in those who have no one or nowhere to go.
All Canadians: you had yours already. Tell us, are you scarred for life?
Excellent food for thought--and for combating the whiners out there. Cheers and a happy Thanksgiving to you!
Claytonia, you're right, I'm right... we've become a Whiner Culture. It sure as hell stops at my front door.
JK, c'mon over, I make the best stuffing you ever tasted.
mistercomedy, we all have some sort of family... a family of friends. I so hope you do. Wish I could invite you over and fill you full of good food and good companionship. Hope somebody does.
Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!
Monte
An excellent post, providing insight on so many levels. Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!
I'm not grateful that I did not get an EP for mine,
but I'm grateful that you did get one.
I'll stop whining now and pass the gravy.
Rated
Deven, give Mom a kiss for me. Freaky and The Ape's husband too. I draw the line at Bob. heh
Andy, I have no idea what you mean. People love to spend time with me. Um, as long as I make the food.
Teendoc, loved your post. Send this to anybody you want.. as long as they don't own weapons and their houses are locked up tight. Oh my god!!
Trudge, we're all giving thanks, so I'll share mine with you. But only Freaky (besides the OS PTB) knows how to make one.
(I may have to re-read this warmed over for Christmas.)
Nora, I'll have another one for XMas/Hanukkah alone the same lines.
Cindy, you have an interesting perspective as always. But unless there's tension among you, a private, nuclear Thanksgiving dinner can be a blessing in itself. We've done our share of those and enjoyed them a lot. Beats having to set up, cook and clean up for hoards, makes time for more bonding.
Of course, five sibs, their husbands, kids and a few grandkids, plus the couples or singles with no place to go, plus my mother's invite-any-strays-you-want policy did make for a lot of fun.
This is the 5th year of a new tradition at Karen's, a small gathering of 8 or 10, everybody cooking something. What else can I say about that. Really, do count your blessings if you can.
Rita, what I just said to Cindy applies here too. Thank you, my new friend, for sharing --and appreciating-- similar interests and passions. Next year in Citizens Bank Park!
Cindy, ah, now I get it. When you said, "Holidays tend to be quiet and a bit melancholy at my house." I took that to mean you wished for a bigger family. Now, I stand corrected. And wish you and your family wonderful blessings every day.
I go to a lot of AA meetings and this time of year there is a tendency to hear lots of complaining about the holidays and family members and get-togethers and such. At one meeting I couldn't take it any longer and I said something like "You know, all I'm hearing is a lot of crap about how everyone has difficult family members and so forth. One day it dawned on me that I was THE ALCOHOLIC SON (insert BROTHER, UNCLE, AUNT, PARENT, SPOUSE, FRIEND, ETC) and maybe they were talking the same about me. Think about it." The room was quiet for a few long seconds, and then everyone started laughing and laughing. The meeting went very smoothly after that, and nobody whined anymore that evening.
I'll be saying it some more I fear.
Wishing you a pleasant holiday weekend.
Just Fredcat and me.
I have a MAJOR Tbone which I'll be putting on the REAL coals for dinner.
Some whole grain garlic bread(new to me).
A side of acorn squash.
That is ACORN just to stick it to the repiglicans of the underworld.
And a glass of milk.
I'll have a little lemon pudding pie for dessert.
As I said~~ahhhhhhhhhh, peace & quiet.
rated for agreeing totally.
Note to marytkelly, re "I wish it were really all that simple": Never, ever, confuse "simple" with "easy."
The smaller groups idea is the way to go -- I love my stepfamily but when we're all in the same house and the booze begins to flow it gets pretty loud and obnoxious and that's when I make my adieus. My mom finally gets that and is fine with it.
I especially liked (and can identify) with your advice about abusive parents -- I've long ago let go of any guilt about not associating with my father for that very reason.
It would be fun to have a big family and actually laugh at the dinner table. The one thing we always laugh about is memories of the year my step-dad's bandaid fell off when he was filling bowl full of dressing. My picky daughter found it and promptly ran to the bathroom to puke -- that is always hysterically funny to the rest of us.
Happy Thanksgiving Sally. My advice is to stay as far away from stores as possible -- always -- but especially this weekend.
Or is it just that too many people are writting too many Self Help Books - to go along with our 'pill for every ill' culture?
Do I sound Bitter? Sorry!
tomreedtoon, clearly you have issues and I'm sorry to hear that. Perhaps you should write about your anger, it sometimes helps. But, er, on your own blog please.
ZaZa cat, I appreciate the general appreciation, sorry you didn't like this post, but it wasn't a lecture, just a lighthearted "scold." Which, as Lisa notes, is a word not nearly used enough any more. I'm sorry you have some anger with your in-laws but I don't think anybody needs a religious holiday to feel the spirit of humanity... it should be felt every day of the year.
Cindy, how'd the no cooking go? Hope you enjoyed! :)
Sandra, thanks for your perspective on my perspective.
Ann! We don't see you nearly enough. Peace to you too.
O'Really, you can always sit at the children's table as long as you don't teach them strikethroughs. ;)
blue, glad you enjoyed... me and the wine.
XJS, here's to peace and quiet.
Lisa, as said above, people should scold more often, I agree. (I think I just did a little, didn't I?) Am sure yours was lively, hope it was lovely too.
Ollie's daughter, it's never easy but we just do our best, right?
Judy, isn't it great how we always laugh til stuffing comes out our ears? Another great TG, in both senses. (But damn, I didn't bring home any Piiiiiiie).
Nick, I like when people agree, especially with me.
almostdone, I also like "don't confuse 'simple' with 'easy'."
skeletn, what a story: The Year of the Bandaid Stuffing! Hope you had a good, booze free time (my preference too).
JimRin, we all need to chill. Nothing bitter about that.
Mimi, no politics today, sorry, I'm too full and about to have leftovers.
I am indeed very blessed.
I love your scoldings!
Hey, people, the point (I think) Sally was trying to make was that this is the only holiday that isn't preceded by a trillion ads telling you what to buy for your loved ones. There are even Columbus Day sales. Yikes! Maybe an occasional turkey ad, or cooking advice, but this one has the fewest commercial obligations of all of them. Personal obligations are up to those involved, and life remains a series of choices.
I think you made a good point, and to those who ragged on you, Feh!
I have always loved near-end-of-year celebrations, not for religius matters at all, but for the chance to organize a nice dinner and be with my extended family. But there are many people really afraid and anxious about these celebrations coming soon, even within my family; I don´t get it.
I´ll keep this post and translate some parts into Spanish for some friends - acquaintances - relatives, maybe they can take things in a different perspective as regards our Christmas and NewYear Eve. You´ve done public service here, LOL!
Kisses!
and it's true, there is nothing like catastrophe to remind you what's important. of course, now the fights are over who has already visited the hospitalized unit and for how long and...
ah, family.
Interesting visual. The whining of America.
aim, so glad you stopped by and enjoyed. And you got a free turkey, cool! Let me know any time you feel scolding-deprived, I'm here to help.
Judy (my favorite big sister), what can I say, ZaZa isn't happy with me and Tom seems determined to damn me with (not so) faint praise.
(Tom, the front page doesn't change on weekends/holidays. There's a lot of good reading here, can be found along the sides or on the top links).
Marcela! I would love to hear what your friends think of all the fuss over America's Thanksgiving Day. Of course there's angst over family in every country, let's hear how you and your fellow Argentinians handle yours.
4M, glad you enjoyed. And Happy TG to you.
Harvey, of course I'm nuts. What else is new.
bstrangely, you definitely win for the best story! Talk about throwing around guilt... who visited the hospital most has got to be a classic. Hope all turns out okay. Seriously.
Geoff, it's the GUILT tripping that makes me think Thanksgiving just might be a Jewish holiday in disguise. And while you know I love you, you do the worst Jewish imitation I've ever seen. ;)
AHEM: what, nobody liked my TAGS??
Del, perhaps you could make it up to your sister by shopping with the helpful tiffany, above. heh
"People usually don't get the clue that if we ignore you for the majority of the year, there's a reason for it. Especially family."
"Honestly, it's just that a lot of people don't enjoy spending time with their families. For very valid reasons."
Spot on. (I'm sorry, Sally, for sounding so grumpy... but I do have my reasons.)
thank you for this. Maybe you should get started now on your Christmas post. I'm really going to need your practical and down to earth perspective this time next month.
Bless You Sally Smith!
incandescent, if you think I grew up in a shiny happy nuclear family, you haven't read any of my serious personal posts... a Jewish Tennessee Williams could have written my childhood. And while I mean what I say here, this post was meant to have a lighter tone than some have apparently taken it.
So, to you and ZaZa and others who feel I am being unrealistic, I will say this, in all seriousness: I don't do guilt. I don't hand it out and I don't let it rule my actions. I believe that grown people have a choice. And those who allow guilt to guide their interactions with their families are doomed to be justifiably unhappy and resentful.
I'm sorry if you have genuine family troubles and I get that many people do. But I hold tight to the Eleanor Roosevelt view (paraphrased), People only have as much power over you as you give them.
Gina, thank you! (But, you know, if I'm going to go for all that fame Tom thinks I want, my name isn't Sally Smith... ;)
We are still eating Turkey, but not tonight. The one pie is officially gone. We got a lot of strategic shopping done without being out too long.
I spoke to the people I love the most and not to the pains in the asses. That is really good for everyone and I bet everyone appreciates it.
I feel relaxed and happy. That, I think, is what the holday is all about.
We are the elders in our family now. We intend to demonstrate good judgment and happiness, and most of the time we do, but when we slip up, we hope we are gracious and responsible about it so that our family is as thankful for us as we are for them.
At the risk of sounding sappy, I have to say that I give thanks every day, most sincerely. After loosing my parents when they were very young to medical fates no one saw coming, I take nothing for granted. Thanksgiving is the coziest, most relaxed, warm and generous holiday for me. I love it no matter how large or small the family gathering. Come one, come all. I love it when one of my kids aske if a friend who has no place to go, can come to our house for Thanksgiving! The more the merrier! Goes with the territory of coming from a big family.
You echo my sentiments for this holiday to a tee.
Cathy, you nailed it too. Warm and loving and only with those who make you feel that way.
Thank you both.