Stories From A Life

Been there. Done that. Writing about it.

Sally Swift

Sally Swift
Location
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
Birthday
June 14
Title
VP, Repartee
Company
Swift Retorts
Bio
sally: a journey, a venture, an expression of feeling, an outburst, a quip, a wisecrack ... me

OCTOBER 4, 2011 4:50PM

A Mother's Pain

Rate: 40 Flag

i love you 

The pain is intense. It woke me in the middle of the night he left, was waiting for me in the newly silent morning, is hovering still. I know from embattled experience it will stay as long as it stays. Gradually it will abate. Until the next time.

For now, I am bereft. My child is gone. Again.

I am embarrassed, ashamed to be riding this pedestrian pain. As if it were unique. Rational. It isn't, but you don't choose pain. It finds you.

I know my pain is disproportionate, inappropriate. Especially compared to the truly cataclysmic losses others have suffered, or are facing. All over the world. Right here in our own family. Ah, a clue. 

I should be grateful for the gift of his being. And I am. I should be celebrating his progress into adulthood. And I do. He's happy and healthy. He's living his own life so well. He's thriving, achieving, independent and successful. I am relieved, filled with joy and pride.

And I am bereft. My child is gone. Again.

He's doing what I did at his age. What his father did too. In another city. In another world. Which is as it should be. Our parents barely seemed to notice. My mother couldn't wait for us to leave, was eager to abdicate motherhood as much as she could.

Not me. When he first left for college I was blind-sided by the pain of my empty nest. I learned to cope. Then he began his career here in Philly, moved into his own apartment, showed up whenever he wanted (couple of times a month, tops). For three years I was lulled into complacency.

This July brought the next career opportunity, exciting, special. Not far away. But. Not. Here. Outwardly I cheered, I helped, I tried not to step on increasingly grown-up toes. I didn't fall apart when we left him in his new apartment and drove home.

I didn't call, sent only the occasional necessary text or email. He called. When he had something to tell me. Or just wanted to talk. Inwardly I was okay. I thought. But I wasn't.

I was bereft. My child was gone. Again.

It's not about "too tight apron strings" as they used to say. It's a measure of how deep and strong is the comfortable, loving bond we share. Each time it's severed by distance, even for a few months, I am lost in a world of hurt.

I don't cling, I never did, I hope I never will. We encourage, support his independence. But we miss him fiercely. Maybe because we've always been The Three Bears, a tight knit only-child family circle. We genuinely enjoy each other's company.

Most parents say they can't wait for their grown kids to be out of the house. I think they're lying. If only to themselves. I applaud parental pride, equally appreciate the importance of separation, self-sufficiency, personal responsibility. We promote that credo ourselves.

But still. So many years, so much worry, so much love, so much painstaking effort. Yes, it pays off. But not without a steep price. The bonded family dynamic changes. Forever.

Much as we try to build walls against it, waves of pain roll over most of us when our children leave for good. The sea of life erasing our carefully drawn preservation of that loving past.

We all have different pain thresholds. Mine is low. After a while it will surge and I will be strong again. But for now, it's hitting me full force. Dragging me under.

I am bereft. My child is gone. Again.

So I understand better the joy in my mother's voice when I call, when I visit. Her motherhood instincts didn't resurface with aging and creeping decline. The underlying need to see, to hold, to love your child, no matter what stage of life, is ultimately primal. Hers never really left.

But ironically, when my own pain leaves so does a large measure of that understanding. Of patience for my mother's needs. I never want our son to call or come to us out of duty. I want him just as he is, comfortable with the give and take within our nuclear family unit. So far so good.

So why am I so devastated after each visit? Why can't I brush this pain away like dusty cobwebs in an empty basement? Because our basement --our home-- was full of life for so many years. Throughout his childhood and coming of age it vibrated with activity. Then it sat empty. As did I.

For the past week, it sprang back to life. And so did I.

Now it is empty again. And so am I.

Thanksgiving can't come soon enough. It's worth the pain.

 

 

photo taken by author's niece, given to author

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Started this Sunday night. Finally pulled it together today. Please don't judge me. Just know it's okay to feel the same. Or not.
Um, I could have written this. And have, actually several times. I so get this. Especially the word, "bereft." Yes. ~r
Sally this was beautiful. I hope he reads it. I understand--No really--I do. My son is back east for a few months and I keep hoping and dreaming of him walking through the door, slamming it and saying: "Got anything good to eat?" as he opens the fridge. I have these sudden aches that come from nowhere. I will not relax until he is back in the Northwest where he belongs. His voice over the phone seems almost unreal when he calls. I didn't really realize all of this until I read your piece. Now, should I thank you? Hmm...
Thanks to you, I think I understand my sister a little better. Nicely crafted.
Joanie, I know you know this. You've written of it much better than I. But if I didn't let it out, I might have imploded. You know that too.

Spud, thank you, but I don't want him to read this. I don't want him to feel one iota of guilt over my pain. He has his rite of passage, I have mine. Just tell your son you love him. And stock the fridge.
I get this completely. My son moved out of the house right after my husband died...a double whammy and it hit me very hard. He's doing well, but I moved to another state and hardly see him. I don't make demands either. When we talk it's really good, but I still miss him fiercely. -R-
So very touching Sally. I am lucky enough, at least for now to have my 3 daughters in the same town and one (the one who is pregnant with twins) moving in with me next month...I might feel different then - ha! but I think all mothers will understand your feelings.
I couldn't have written this. I can't even empathize. What I can do, Sally, is sympathize and admire your motherly love and the passion you put into this song, and tell you that altho my mom has been gone now for seven years yesterday, I still feel the urge to call her every Sunday night at 9 as I did when she was alive. The love cuts both ways. The pain is proof of its truth.
Stacey, I'm glad to add to your understanding. Do cut your sister a break.

Christine, I can't even begin to imagine your pain at such a double whammy. And that mother-son thing, it's so special. Hope you're coping well.

trilogy, mothers and daughters seem to pull apart and reconnect with much more ease. So glad yours are close by and Mazel Tov on the pregnancy!
Chicken Maaan, we crossed. I am so sorry for your loss and so grateful for your validation of the view from the other side. You made me cry, but cleansing tears.
Hmmmm, Sally ... I think maybe you just shone a light on something in my relationship with my deceased mother. Thanks.

And thanks for posting, period. What's it been? A month? Too long, anyway.
It gets easier I think, believe it or not, when they get older. I'm not sure why. Meanwhile, good that you can get it out so beautifully,
oh Sally, this was so good
My dear, this one really hit home. I put on a strong face for the world, but if I'm honest, I too could have written this post (just not as well as you have.) I even share your tendency to lose my understanding of my mother's need to connect with me more often than I am comfortable with sometimes. Thanksgiving will be here before you know it. Start cooking!

Lezlie
Such a beautiful piece. I feel so much for my children, and now two seniors in college, one a sophomore and no one here. It is really hardest on my husband I think, he calls them, texts them, and they do the same to him. He is very close to them. I am the go to person when they need big comfort, questions answered, advice. I recognized early on that I had to be this person otherwise they would never be able to grow. So it is a mix here, but so difficult. Thanksgiving will not come soon enough. I guess I have to learn to text and keep my phone charged. Ah, the modern age. Thanks goodness my husband is so savvy. This year I keep living in the past, the past of all the kids and friends under foot, the parties, the toys...ah.
when my own pain leaves so does a large measure of that understanding

is true of any pain.

i cannot see how this terrible trickily navigated pain
can be nature's design.

i might be ignorant. i lived with mom or 37 yrs. eased her into death.
my duty.
I understand this, though I'm not there and I don't know if I ever will be. I have two kids, younger than yours, and the older one has a severe disability, so the dynamic is very different.
he is one lucky kid!

my husband still grieves for the time he lost with his grown children as a non-custodial parent
I never wrote it better at all! I'm just amazed that once again, I get what you are saying as though I had written it myself. xo
we raise them to be independent and if we are fortunate enough accomplish it we suffer an abiding grief. I weep for the loss of my darling daughter every day, but will not ask for her return.
holly, I never dreaded it because I never knew it would have such a profound impact on me. I wanted to let others know they weren't alone, surely didn't mean to scare you. We all handle it differently. And you're such a fighter.

B Re, anytime I contribute to helping us understand our most complex relationships, I'm glad. Thanks for noticing my absence. I'm going to try harder to write again.

Lea, I thought of you as I was spilling my guts, and drew strength from your living example. If you say it gets easier, I can handle it better now. As always, thank you.

And Julie, as always thank you!

Lezlie, as much as I wanted to let others know how many of us feel this way, it helps to hear the same thing from other mothers. Bless you for understanding both sides of the generational sandwich.

Sheila, I can't imagine a nest empty of THREE! Yes, please do learn to text. I also can't tell you how much it means to see "love you mom" on my phone.

James, I am in awe of your strength, courage and devotion, no matter the throwaway emotions along the way. You did the most important mitzvah a child can do.

ksal, I am so very sorry. This must seem incredibly trivial and self-indulgent to a parent with such enormous responsibility. I salute you for your courage and apologize for such lame whining.
Kathy K, thank you too. I am so sorry for your husband's much greater and more lasting loss. Again I feel like a whiner. Oy.

Joanie, can we call it a tie? You never fail to knock my socks off.

Sheila, I know you know. I hope you're healing.

Ben, you convey so much with so few words. But I fear there's a troubling back story too. Please, don't let anything stand in the way of, at the very least, contact.
Sally, thank you so much for sharing this painful intimacy. I too understand, even though I strongly nudged two of my three out of the nest. Now I do call them, and I wonder what I wanted in an empty nest? I guess I just knew they wouldn't be whole until they stood on their own, and they would never appreciate a mom until they didn't have one, or were one. It is the way of the human. You are wonderful. Maybe the extended family should be all in the family compound eventually...
You are correct, even when we want them to grow up, the words still seem incorrect. Okay, you have to grow up, I mean (make better choices), but it still brings back memories of (us) growing up and growing pains we faced and challenge. We need nobody to say to us as children, (your annoying) or complicated. But to our own selves it was a long stretch to grow up, and provide a place for our own sanity. A place where we could look back and be like I can look at this road and know for my own personal self what this road looks like. Regardless of what others might think, but for the parents that have to look back, it is an obvious moment of remembering all the things that got us to this point. It is the moment of having this warm infant grow out of it's newborn imprint that is quite clear with the holding of a finger, to the first beautiful coos and the simpliest of words. It is the idea of watching this wonderful human being, (yours) nonetheless become a living breathing part of your culture and life, now come into his own place as a human being in society. It all comes down to this, the love that is shared is shown again in being able to see your child as your reflection the way you see yourself.
I empathize too - my only child/son left home on the West Coast to go not to college exactly...but to a 3-year circus arts school. . . in Montreal. After he graduated, off he went to tour the world, which he has been doing for the last six years. Quite a shock to a mother's system. We are very close, but no amount of skyping or emailing or phoning comes close to just one big huge hug. One hopeful thought, though: Maybe it would help us to look back over all those many years of watching them evolve/grow/move from one stage to the next. We may have mourned the loss of our darling infant as he morphed into a toddler, but soon we regrouped and celebrated the joys of toddlerhood...until that too was gone but replaced by the appearance of our kindergartner. So...they may not be as physically near us now, but the amazing evolution continues, and for us parents, always the shifting back and forth between mourning and celebration. . . perhaps? Just a thought...
It's one of my greatest fears (with two young boys) and you write about it so openly and honestly. I hope the writing helped ease some of the hurt.
Excuse me. I think I need to call my folks now.
No, actually, there's nothing trivial about it, nor self-indulgent. A third of your family is missing. Our experiences are, for the time being, different, but I get it.
Oh how I dread the thought of this pain.r
Sally, what a great tribute you've written. One can only hope that your sense of loss is ameliorated by pride!
I don't have children, but I do remember the sad look in my mother's eyes every time I left her house. So happy for my many wonderful memories of her. Let this be a reminder to all of us to be more gentle and loving to our aging parents.
P.S....Beautifully written!
hey, sally. terrific piece, especially the perspective from the middle toward your son and then back to your mom. the real empty nest thing (that some of us thought we were totally past and had avoided, heh) happens when education is over and they actually *move* away. no matter how often the visits are, the realization is there every time i drive away from her house to come home, and some of those trips are very, very teary. but not all, so it does get better. after a dozen years or so. :)
I so completely understand this, I just could never ever put it into words like you have...
beautifully done.
Cheers to Thanksgiving!
I just had a talk with one of my daughters way up in Alaska. I just wish they were down the street. Not back in my house but in the neighborhood. The world is so far flung now.
I feel your pain and have felt it as my two sons left the nest. But this is part of a mother's role, just as real and necessary as that first time we put the baby to our breast and literally give nurture. Be prepared for your son's finding a significant other, and if that other is a woman, be prepared to give and love, or you will be totally shut out with a lock on the door. That happened to someone I know. Otherwise, be proud and happy that your son is doing so well. Some children, more nowadays, I think, try to fly from the nest, but their wings are broken, and they have to return, heads hung low. That causes a different kind of pain.
Carol, I hear you. And in spirit, at least, we are one big connected family. Maybe in a compound someday.

MOMS, you speak beautifully to the dreams we have for our children.

Jane, clown arts, how cool! I know the feeling of remembering his childhood, but fortunately, I can see and hear him any time at any age on home video and dvd.

Regina, bingo, the writing was amazingly cathartic. The pain is (mostly) gone now.

Stim, get on that call to the folks right away.

hugs, me, it's part of the process. My next hurdle will be his (future) wedding I'm sure.

Steve, you nailed, it, most comes from pride and of course love.

P&P, thank you. This is so important to those who still have parent(s), "Let this be a reminder to all of us to be more gentle and loving to our aging parents."

Candy, thanks for the validation and um, the view ahead. :)

Just Thinking, you write so beautifully, you could tell your own story too.

Bob, as usual you say a lot with a little.

zanelle, away but nearby is a major focus of the pain. And Alaska, wow!

Pam, thank you for your wise take on this subject, though perhaps I wasn't clear about our situation. I stressed our pride and support of his independence and think much of his success stems from knowing he's loved but given lots of room. He won't see this piece, he's far too busy and I'd never show it to him. No Jewish guilt coming from this mom.
"So I understand better the joy in my mother's voice when I call, when I visit. Her motherhood instincts didn't resurface with aging and creeping decline. The underlying need to see, to hold, to love your child, no matter what stage of life, is ultimately primal." God, I miss my mom. To be loved this way is irreplaceable. No one else can give us this kind of love. I was a mother's child, and now I'm not.

I'm bereft. My mom is gone.

Thank you for sharing this achingly lovely remembrance of that bond.
I am a mother,too,and my son left soon after completing Highschool.I knew I had to let him go,I always did.Now he is Father of two children,and I see the children more than I see him.
It hurts.
I would like him to drop by maybe once a month for a cup of tea.
It will not happen,because he prefers going home to his wife and children.
I know it is good this way,yet it hurts.
Thank you,Sally,and everyone else.