AUGUST 31, 2009 1:57AM

The Which House

Rate: 38 Flag

 

The Which House

 

 Small, I imagined me-sized houses. I always liked a story that featured a cozy cottage with a fireplace.  Even the witch’s house in the Hansel and Gretel forest didn’t seem frightening to me.  It was more like a consolation prize for having the kind of father that, on the word of his new wife, would lead you into the woods to kill you, and never mind that he felt bad about it later.   

My imagining of that house, and how I'd come to live in it, merged seamlessly with the stories of my childhood, unfolding in a story as clear as memory itself: 

Imagine that, the uneasiness of that, following your grim father into the silent woods, all around you the snow gone quiet and gray in the late afternoon light. The fear when he hoisted the axe.  Wathing him whirl with the blade still aloft and walk quickly away,  the realization of what almost happend. The relief that is not cool and celebratory, but hot and complicated.

How the sweet smell of the woods is suddenly apparent though of course it was there all along, following the father even now as he strode home to claim his reward.

The witch who is not old and ugly, they are never old and ugly because if they were think how easy they would be to avoid.   No, the witch is more like a Which, as in, which person can you trust, the pretty lady with marshmallow blonde hair and bubblegum pink  smile who lives in a sweet candy house in the woods, or the father who would rather kill you, gimlet-eyed, than go without sex?

The Which would laugh a lot and say things like, you gorgeous children you! Look at your mouths, your sweet mouths, I could make a meal of your sweet little raspberry mouths! Things that sounded nice until you really thought about it, until you collected up all the things she said like that and looked at them all in a row and realized they were like individual teeth that, when together, formed a great big grinning  sharkbite mouth.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I've always been appalled by that story. But we have plenty of similar modern cases. And sometimes it's the mother.....

In Italy and some other Mediterranean countries, cute children are called "eatable" or "biteable." This makes me think.
Why Sandra, what big teeth you have!!!! RATED!
I once saw an ad in a German newspaper for a small straight jacket for children, so parents could tie them to the bed and be able to go out for an evening when they couldn't find a sitter. Some parables have a deep truth behind them.... scary!
I've heard a version of this tale in which it is the mother, not the step-mother, who tells the husband to take the pair into the forest. Makes for even uglier implications. Being a peasant in the Dark Ages -- good times. As for the Which, she seems to be an apt symbol for a person, an organization, a political party, etc. that doles out a luring promise of reward, followed by another and another that leads you unwittingly down a dark trail. The question becomes whether one can see the "teeth" before the Which closes the cage door and begins to fatten you up.
Sandra,
I’ve always felt that storytelling is most spellbinding when readers are not only drawn into the tale but actually want to explore and enter into the details. The details - like a story within a story or a world within a world - have a captivating power.

You’ve done a beautiful job of that kind of storytelling here.

Descriptions like yours allow readers to willingly indulge in the mysteries and fears perhaps because the “door” of knowing it’s “just a story” somehow seems fully ajar for us to leave - even though we’d be loathe to even think of using it.

I remember how spellbound I was as a child when I first read Madeleine L’Engle’s “A Wrinkle in Time” (speaking of characters named “Which”). You have that gift as a writer and you use it well.

Rated and appreciated.
You are a writer of the senses and the emotions triggered by them. Fairy tales should always be told like this, complete with smells and sounds and sensations, and real motives darker than the desire to eat a child.
"My imagining of that house, and how I'd come to live in it, merged seamlessly with the stories of my childhood, unfolding in a story as clear as memory itself:"

I think you are saying a lot more here than immediately meets the eye. Imaginings in childhood that are as clear as memories---I have a few of these myself.
You are right. The scariest thing is not knowing whom to trust, especially when you couldn't trust a parent.
Toothy meditation, Sandra.

Does it bother anybody else that this "classic German fairy tale" is about a cannibal who wants to put people in an oven? Some folklorists conflate the eugenics-prone Wicked Stepmother ("I must kill the other people's children") with the later appearance of the Witch herself.
br-rr-rr.
Funny how sometimes our escape leads us right back to where we started, isn't it?

Excellent as always, Sandra. :-D
I don't know why, but this story conjures up images of that nut case and his wife in Antioch who kidnapped Jaycee Dugard 18 years ago. Indeed. Who to trust?
Oh, I got a chill! I used to think of my brother and me as Hansel and Gretel...orphans following crumbs...I hated that fairy tale growing up. xox
I pretty much don't trust "sweet" people, right off anyway. There are some truly dear, sweet people in the world, but in a lot of cases it's a facade that is designed for some other purpose.

I'd rather know what someone is like out front, warts and all.

d
Oh, that gave me a shiver. Very nice--just the effect some fairy tales should have.
a lovely path you've led us down

I've always been thrilled by the witch. She's a force of nature. It's the parents hate and I've never been able to forgive. Especially the father, they always make him out to be some sort of victim.
Reading between the lines is even scarier! Excellent writing...as always!
Scary. But there was a nice Which in the Phantom Tollbooth ...
thanks everyone!

Ah, but Steven, the Which was not scary in the usual sense (ugly, evil) but nor was she benign: her real name, if you remember, was Faintly Macabre and her job was to regulate the use of words. She became so strict and controlling that people were afraid to talk at all.

Dennis, thanks for the kind words.
Bill, well said.
mah, true enough
Ralph, the better to tell stories with, my dear!
sirenita - yes, the real motives are always the ones to watch for, and easy to obfuscate; the obvious terrors (a witch who wants to eat you ) are easier to deal with than the darker ones (a father who would be the agent of your death instead of protecting you)

scoubidou - it doesn't bother me b/c I read all the Grimm tales in their original form, and they make no attempt to be reassuring to children. What I object to is the adaptation of the tales in a sanitized version that makes no sense.
MAWB - no way!
denese - agreed, if only they'd cooperate!
fabflamingo - exactly
Sandra, you inspire me. :)
The obvious evil, the father---I can face head on.
Facing the pretty witch---that's the tough and scary part for me.
Oh, Sarah Palin and Karen Hughes are waiting for me on a conference call. Gotta go. . . .reluctantly. . . .
I've walked in that forrest. I've met that witch. rAted!
Delia - its the source of the most effective horror, that.
The night were dark and the sky were blue,
down the alleyway a house wagon flew
Hit a bump and somebody screamed,
you should've heard what I'd seen
Who do you love?
Who do you love?
Who do you love?
Who do you love?
Ah. Sandra. Cooperation is overrated.

denese
And I pretty much figure you are a dear and sweet too.

d
As usual, Sandra, great work.
I don't know about the house, but the music in Humperdinck's opera is sublime.
awesome Sandra- just f*ing awesome
There is nothing more terrifying than a children's story! I grew up shivering to Hans Christian Andersen tales - this reminds me of that. Have you seen "Coraline"? It's scary as hell!
I don't think we ever really know someone and find reason to trust wholeheartedly until 2 things happen in the one-on-one relationship:

1. we each show our darkest side in a disagreement, then make up., reasonably and completely.
2. when each one makes a painful sacrifice in some form for the other.
silkstone, "Coraline" is a freakshow of horror. I loved it, but it would have troubled me deeply as a child.