There was a time when education challenged us to be more, to reach higher than we thought we could, to dare failure because to think, and to succeed at thinking well, was a noble human endeavor, the wellspring of soaring achievement as well as the source of our considered values, our sense of greater community, and the seat of our morality and compassion.
But times have changed and knowledge is overrated. Contemplative silence can't be monetized so why bother, pass the chips and salsa please. Thinking is so yesterday, it leads no where bigger or better necessarily, it's soft and chewy and my teeth are bad from all those sweet sweet lies I chewed up and swallowed down. Of course dental insurance is out of the question especially since I lost my job but change the system you commie pinko motherfucker and I will start toting my gun to your gatherings. Just leave well enough alone.
Thought brings no reward, no fame nor fortune ; it may even be a detriment to same so what's the point? Reality shows do tell us one indisputable thing about today's reality; you don't need to think through the problem, you only need to think you're better than the people who can. You might know all the answers but those of us who don't can band together and vote you off the island. Knowledge is power but lack of knowledge is a blunt instrument.
I'm sorry I didn't hear you can you repeat that,there's five thousand big screen TVs all playing that video of the town hall where the young woman compared the old Jewish fag to a Nazi. Everyone was outraged! Some were outraged at him, some at her, some at the news channel for playing it, some at their neighbor for siding with the girl or was it the fag. All I know is that I'm right to be afraid of things changing because of this outrage I feel. It's so strong, see.
This is America where the thinking President has the same popularity rating and influence as moronic emotional charlatan extrordinaire Glenn Beck. This is not the land of education, it is the land of opportunity to erect an Ikea in a big vacant lot so that eveyrone can furnish a room for under $600, a deal so great you are bound to say what the heck why not buy all new furniture and throw away the old stuff, or sell it on eBay because you know what they say, one man's junk is another man's treasured landfill.
The leaders on TV have a lot of money but otherwise they're just like you and me, they know their money doesn't make them better than anyone, that a good education is overrated and anyone can suceed at anything if they really try and deserved the right connections. Heck George Bush only had a C average at Yale - he wasn't an elitist about being able to go there, he was always a guy you could sit down and have a beer with. Why call a professor or read a book when you can just pray to God and ask Him what Jesus would do if Jesus were the leader of the free world and had to catch some terrorists and kill them for thinking God could actually be on *their* side when our side is right, you can tell because we are way way more successful.
Fifty some odd years ago, ordinary Americans valued education so much they stood by while the government rammed science and math down the adolescent American gullet. Those parents did everything but hold their kids mouths open while the government force fed them calculus; they would have protested I guess, if they weren't so busy hoping it wasn't too late for the US to equal the superior scientific, mechanic and intellectual achievements of the Russian space program.
Thank God we live in a different time now where no one will stand idly by while the socialist President urges everyone to do better, because we are the generation of supercaring parents and we don't want our kids to be exposed to any idea we haven't vetted it first - because we care that much - unless of course it's on the internet, because who knows what the heck our kids are doing on the internet, I don't know about you but ever since I found that video about the two girls and the one cup that my nephews downloaded I don't even ASK any more, and let me tell you, don't ask don't tell is a good policy for more than just the queers in the army.
We do not need to seek educational challenge for our selves or our children unless we want to and it is our right not to want to. Besides school is challenging enough what with all the trips to the school we have to make to get the teacher to give a higher grade to my child who suffers from an attention deficit spectrum disorder caused by gluten free soy products or if a peanut is within seventy five yards of the shcool premises. It is essential and in fact I demand (as is my right) that no child bring peanut products to school so that my child can learn in an unobstructed environment how to become a radio show host or a pharmaceutical salesman or a lobbyist. A good education is key they say but really how much can we expect from a teacher who by the way only makes one fifth of what I make so how can I possbily respect her anyway?
I hear people moaning about the lack of civility in our society but polite doesn't get you any further in life so why bother. Polite doesn't sell. Infomercial pitchmen and faked breasted blondes and smooth talking faux millionaires - that sells. You can't compete on polite - and even if you could no one cares who wins or they're too polite to say if they do. But you can compete on blonde and breasts and smooth and faux. You can even win, sometimes millions. If not dollars then fans but who's counting except for the people at home with their texting thumbs poised to raise another idol, or bring another down.And so we stumble down the road, cursing and exposing ourselves and giggling along to the soundtrack laughter of the jungle; we eat red meat and apple pie because we were told by the marketeers in their slick haired sincerity that it's in our American DNA to do so and never mind that it is killing us, pound by clogged, slow-moving pound, but not to worry because there are pills that will make it not seem to matter and of course it doesn't because we can buy bigger clothes and cars and houses and even coffins so everything fits no matter how fast we expand, we do not need to change to fit in the world when we can change the world to fit us.
When you get right down to it the most important thing is not knowledge but love; we are not an elitist nation full of notions about royalty and class systems and caste systems like you find in the uncivilized places where brown people walk about in the dirt. We are one nation under God and we celebrate freedom (except the sexual and homeless varieties) and we love our neighbor like ourselves except for the homosexual and the terrorist and the unbelievers and the abortionists and the kids having premarital sex and most of all the socialist speechifying president who thinks he can tell us about the value of education when anyone can tell we just don't want to hear it, everything is fine just the way it is.


Salon.com
Comments
(I've always felt that if you had to pick one consumer item as a metaphor for all that is wrong with America it would be Billy Bass, but I digress...)
http://ocw.mit.edu/OcwWeb/Brain-and-Cognitive-Sciences/9-01Fall-2003/CourseHome/
They have it directly on iTunes- you can download the whole class in a few min. I fell asleep to it last night. Now, when you average all my years of schooling up, I'm maybe a C student- yes I did pull all As to get into nursing school, but that was a short focused effort. Normally, I'm a floater through life. Now when a floater can find good internet material and educate themselves on what they really want to learn- our education system cannot be all that bad. And I went to mostly lousy schools- hell, just look at my punctuation and grammar skills, it's obvious. Access is loosening up I guess is my point- you don't have to be rich anymore. Course you still have to pay for degrees, but real education can be found in a library and online, you just have to be able to read- which still does need to be focused on in all schools.
Capitalism is all about making as much money as possible, as quickly and efficiently as possible without consideration for any negative consequences.
And as a society we seem to have forgotten that money (and capitalism) are a means, rather than an end. And so we've let the system control our nation and our culture, instead of exercising reasonable control over the system in order to keep it working in the service of our larger goals as a nation.
But now, nothing matters except money and power. Education, culture, values, spirituality, charity, knowledge, service, art, literature, etc. - all just distractions, waiting to be ground under to feed the machine.
I absolutely love this rant, Sandra, it is so spot-on.
I do, however, have to take exception to one thing:
ever since I found that video about the two girls and the one cup that my nephews downloaded I don't even ASK any more
I was JUST getting to the point where I no longer had that image in my head and you HAD TO BRING IT UP, didn't you? ;-D
Once upon a time they used to teach citizenship in school.
Brilliant, Sandra. Simple brilliant. Rated.
You're gonna need some wine soon! You have a great way with words and the rant flows like hot lava in an ice storm! Run for cover!
Highly Rated
Julie makes a good point about the resources available to anyone with a yen to better themselves today, but that, too, has pretty much always been the case. This is, after all, the Land of Opportunity. It has always been, and remains today, a place where anyone with a good mind, a strong heart and a little luck can make something out of absolutely nothing.
brava!
When I went off on my diatribe about advertising here, some took exception, but you have touched the nerve I was trying so hard to touch -- the dumbing down of every aspect of our culture in the relentless pursuit of ratings in order to sell people shit they don't need in the first place.
And now that the Supreme Court is about to loose unfettered the rest of corporate America on us expect the air waves to continue the assault and onslaught delivered upon us by banksters.
No, none of this bodes well.
You are my hero.
“There was a time when education challenged us to be more, to reach higher than we thought we could, to dare failure because to think, and to succeed at thinking well, was a noble human endeavor, the wellspring of soaring achievement as well as the source of our considered values, our sense of greater community, and the seat of our morality and compassion.”
Education in the US has been pretty consistently mediocre for over 100 years. Major changes have included racial integration and disability rights being honored/enforced, but little has changed in the classroom. Your opening sentence is true for me personally, and I’m sure for you and in fact most OSers, but not for a large number of Americans. I guess I would argue that good education still does this (your first sentence).
But I did enjoy your rant and I trust that it made you feel better.
When the Russians launched Sputnik they interrupted movies all over the country to make the annoucement, and school curricula were rapidly advanced to challenge students to BE the future of the US - even in the poor school rooms of Applachia (read Homer Hickam's novels).
I'm not sighing over good old golden yesteryear, I'm just saying, education definitely had more intrinsic value to our culture once upon a time, even if we are, as a nation, more anti-intellectual than some Eastern and Western European cultures. Strangely, the chaos surrounded the desegregation of schools in the 60s is something of a testament to this: white people didn't want black people in the 'good' schools, getting the advantages that had historically been white. Blacks getting an education were considered 'getting above themselves'.
I had very supportive administration's in each of my first two high school teaching positions. They held kids feet to the fire with a "5 absence rule". Five absences and the student failed the class. It was up to the parent to make a case for exemption...like "My kid had mono; West Nile; pneumonia!"...not...Janey missed 22 days of school for various reasons including "shopping for a homecoming dress"; "picking up her friend at the airport"; and "picking up her car from the repair shop". Those are actual parental excuses, by the way, and there are worse!
I do remember the day when parents didn't just automatically assume that the teacher was wrong, because little Johnny is, of course, a genius and should never fail.
Sorry Sandra...didn't mean to babble on so long...you hit a nerve...but a good one!!
Julie does make a valid observation about access improving. But that can be a negative as well unless the values you speak to are in place.
And then we get to values themselves becomming commodities so back we go into the circle of crap.
I wonder if a central problem from a writer's perspective is that we've let the standards of a real substative commentary---like this one--degenerate into a "rant." The normal paen to self indulgnce we see not just on this site but everywhere.
What you've done here is show those of us (and I have no CLUE how many of us there are) HOW to do this kind of writing. So we got something here that more rightly should be in The New Yorker or Harpers---as opposed to something that will sit next to the the latest on Kim Kardashian. (Who btw. . .passed out in about 20 seconds and was about as exciting as a meal at Applebees. . .but I can say no more on that)
And of course you've also inspired me to try to write the same kind of piece.
Not the first time that's happened.
He never had the nerve to tell me I could do better, and he never served up any books for me to read like this new guy. The know -it -alls always accuse me of not liking books. I love books, especially the thick ones I stand on to reach things high up on my ammunition shelf....
Thanks for the dialogue, delivered in a way that seemed conversational, rambling, and fraught with quasi-functional
non-awareness.
Well done!
Consider the reading lessons of the average Greek high school class: Cicero. Livy. Tacitus. Herodotus. Xenophon. Socrates. The thinkers who founded and defined the humanities. The brave soldier-scholars who created, defended and improved deliberative democracy. Their works are compact, accessible, magnificent. Who reads them now?
Modern HSers think we fought the Nazis in Vietnam, and think the origins of democracy began with Reagan.
Consider the lowly chart. X and Y co-ordinates, two of them, all there is to it, yes?
Nope. Charts can contain up to 8 parameters/co-ords and can thus deliver subtle ideas, rich contrasts, and are not difficult to read, really. Unless you ask Newspaper editors. Edward Tufte surveyed US Newspapers and found less than 5 charts in an entire year that used more than 2 co-ords, nationwide. In Tokyo and New Delhi they use more such charts in one day in their papers than we use nationwide in a whole year.
They require Calculus in their HS's. We are pathetic.
We must expect more from our children. They rose to our expectations 50 years ago, they will do so again.
If all we expect them to do is twitter at greedy airheads on reality TV, they grow up thinking reality is just a thin shadow play, rigged for the cruel and fashionable.