The place I'm from is settled mostly by French and German immigrants who pushed Indians off the land to farm it, a fact that is reflected in the town names: Millstadt, Germantown, Mascoutah, Cahokia, Kaskaskia, and Belleville ("The Bee-yoo-tiful Village! my dad would crow as we drove past the row of fast food restaurants at the intersection of Main Street and the North Belt Line, much to the hilarity of us kids).
The Beautiful Village is my home town, where I grew up and went to high school. It's right across the Mississippi river from St. Louis. When I grew up there, Belleville was 99% white; the Main Street of Belleville runs into East St. Louis, home of Olympian Jackie Joyner Kersee, which was (and I'm sure still is) 99% black. There was a half mile of no man's land between the two towns, a lick of quiet street lined by car lots.
It's the kind of town you don't know about unless you live there, or unless some news happens there. And as it happens, my hometown is in the news.
If you don't feel like following the link to watch the video, I'll summarize: on a Belleville school bus a black student beats a white student while both black and white students a) cheer, b) act horrified c) ride peaceably together d) join in, e) restrain others from joining in, and f) all of the above.
The incident prompted Rush Limbaugh to declaim ""In Obama's America, the white kids now get beat up with the black kids cheering."
I'm a little mystified by the import of that little word 'now'. What happened in America (as represented by Belleville, one presumes) before? Maybe Rush doesn't know, but I do.
Belleville has always been in the racially-tinged news, the only diference is, in the past there was no Obama to blame for the goings on. Back in the 80s, 60 Minutes did a story on Belleville, "The Most Racist Town in America?" a story in which the phrase "arrested for driving while black" was coined.
There was a great outcry from the white Belleville populace, and my parents and their friends were among those offended by the story - though I have heard from them, varoiusly, over the years the following comments which one would think might give them pause when complaining about the 60 Minutes story (but didn't):
"I don't mind it when they talk white, but I hate when they talk nigger."
"I don't want one walking across my yard."
"If you act like a nigger and talk like a nigger, I'm going to call you a nigger."
"That makes me sick." (at the sight of a white woman and black man holding hands in Burger King - this uttered by a man wearing a hat that read "Chevy's the Best! Piss on the rest!")
"Know what a ho-di-do is? That's a black man running for the elevator: Ho'd de do! Ho'd de do!"
"Know what nacho cheese is? That's a black man complaining of theft: Hey! Tha'ts not 'cho cheese! Dat's MY cheese!"
In the Beautiful Village, as anywhere else, the acorns do not fall far from the trees.
I went to a big consolidated high school - lots of kids from surrounding small towns all in one big bustling mass. It was impossible to know more than half of your classmates, but we all knew Keith Chambers - he was the sole black student in the entire school of some five hundred kids. I knew him a little bit - he was a wrestler, and for awhile when I dated a wrestler I'd find myself i in the same car as Keith, going to this event or that.I'll never forget the night my boyfriend Tracy made the remark that included the punchline "stupid nigger!" There was an odd silence in the car, a silence that coalesced around Keith, though no one looked at him.
"Keith, sorry, man," Tracy said.
"It's OK," Keith said, his face impassive. I wondered how many times that happened to him. I figured a lot, since it was a word I heard all the time at home, and no one ever said they were sorry, because there was no need, right? When you're all white and all right, some words don't do more than scratch the surface -that seemed to be the thinking, anyway.
Lest you think I am painting a story of a progressive angel amidst corn-fed ruffians, let me just say I laughed at the nacho cheese 'joke' along with everyone else, in the same embarrassed "We shouldn't be laughing at this" way. "You were young!" people say ...and I was, but I was old enough to know I wouldn't want that joke told about me.
I once pointed out to my mom that it was racist for news anchors to mention the color of a suspected criminal only when the supsect was black. My mom said "But blacks commit most of the crimes!""They don't commit crime because they are black, mom," I protested. "They commit crimes because they are poor and desperate and with no hope or prospects. Color has nothing to do with it."
"Hmmmph," my mom said. "It's their own fault. East St. Louis used to be a nice place to live."
And it was, before white flight and some spectacularly failed public housing projects and long-term political corruption led to a decade of unemployment that exceeded 80%. My parents saw this phenomenon soley in terms of color (or, more accurately, the impact they perceived that color to have on the value of their home) ; they were unable to conceive that color might be what is known around the social scientist water cooler as a 'spurious causal link'.
So Belleville is racist, no doubt about it. Except there is another side - there is always another side.
There is my mom, working at City Hall. Her job was to train new employees. She got to know a bunch of them. Her favorite was a young woman, Deedee, who had a husband in the army and was raising two kids on her own and going to night school on top of her full time job. My mom was full of admiration for this girl, who happened to be black.
One day mom came home so upset she was nearly in tears - rare for mom, who I have only seen cry two times, and only then after a considerable onslaught of vicious verbal abuse.
"My boss and her boss said to me, "Don't you think she (DeeDee) moves kind of slow?" mom fumed. " ''They all do' - that's what they said!"
I pictured mom sitting silently by, just as she did when dad was pulling one of rants. But she surprised me.
"I told them I never heard of such a thing! I told them they had a nerve! I told them, DeeDee moves faster than me and all the other fat white women working there! I told them DeeDee was the hardest worker I've ever seen! I told them-" at this, she stopped and pressed her lips tightly together until she was sure she wouldn't cry for this woman who likely never gave her a second thought.
"It wasn't fair," she seethed. "It was wrong."
Then there was my dad; if you've lived in the burbs, you know his type, which might best be defined as Mr. You Better Be Out There Mowing Your Lawn Every Saturday Or Suffer My Deadly Stare As You Drive Past My House. Not long after I moved off to college, a black family moved into the neighborhood, and people were grumbling.
"What's the problem?" dad gritted at the skinny grizzled guy in the wifebeater who liked to remark at neighborhood gatherings that the place sure was going down hill. This was the same guy who had not one but two, count 'em two, cars up on cinder blocks with big sticky pools of oil spreading beneath.
"He mows his lawn, he trims his shrubs," dad continued with the rising inflection that we had long since associated with a pressing need to find a fox hole and pull it over our heads.
The skinny white wifebeater dude snarked some more. I guess he didn't get the memo about my dad.
"HE TAKES CARE OF HIS HOUSE WHICH IS MORE THAN I CAN SAY FOR YOU, YOU TRASHY SON OF A BITCH!" dad bellowed. He said more - lots more - but that was when I beat my strategic escape, it never being a good idea to be in dad's line of sight when he was like that. I almost felt sorry for the wifebeater. Almost.
So, my parents said racist things but valiantly defended - at some risk to themselves - the very race they so casually slurred. They uttered pejroatives about a group but praised individuals of that selfsame group. It's something I've thought about often over the years.
I don't have some grand, thoughtful conclusion here, unless it's this: I don't talk to my parents about racism any more. Not because I think they can't change, but because I know they can - it just won't be due to anything I will ever say.
They will only change as they gain wider and deeper experiences with people.
They will only change when they are confronted with actual similarities, instead of rumored differences.
They will only change when they see, for themselves, the need for change.
Which is pretty much how everyone changes, come to think of it.
Which makes us, one and all, residents of the Beautiful Village.
Peace to you all.


Salon.com
Comments
And I completely understand what it is like to come from an overtly racist area of the country. I know I've told this before, but I remember walking home from football practice one day with a couple of guys. When one of the boys veered off to go to his house, the other confided in me, admiringly: "You know, his dad is a great n***** hater." What a quality to be admired for, huh?
Racism is a learned behavior. Many of the people I grew up with heard racism in their homes. Not everyone shook it off the way you and I did. (And I don't even think it is possible to grow up in that environment and not be somewhat tainted by it, by the way.) And it strains credulity for Rush Limbaugh to look at a single incident and say this is "Obama's America". How spectacularly offensive!
It's been my general experience that criminals do not commit crimes as a result of their financial situation or lack of prospects, no matter their race. Believing that might seem like it makes everything kinder and gentler, but it's an excuse. One that in a society that throws parades for sex abuse victims, makes sense. It's still wrong, though. Celebrating victim status and providing excuses for crimes, won't really do a favor for anyone, except the criminals who can feel a little less guilty when they rape you or slit your throat for a wallet.
It's frequently said that alcoholics are selfish and only change when they need to for their own survival. It's the same for everyone. When the incongruities in their OWN life make racism untenable, then people change. For many that comes early, for others later. The problem is, the later it's delayed, the more investment the racist has in his old belief system, and the bigger counterweight it takes to tip the scales the other way.
I'm keeping a link to this. I may well spread it around.
And then there was the old friend of mine who told me yesterday that the real reason for the health insurance crisis was "all the blacks" wanting free health care. . . . .
Thanks for telling the story exactly like it is.
I can remember segregation as a child, and the one bus running out some 13 miles to pick up the kids from the one black family who had not moved away. And take them to the 'black school.'
I do hope the south joins a upward movement to learn something, like the fact that we are all humans first.
It still never ceases to amaze me that people will routinely claim that they are not racists and will quantify this by saying, "I have a black friend who". That in and of itself is a racist remark. I think of my friends colorlessly and never describe them as black or white. When we can all get to that point and place, I think many things will have changed. I hope to see that happen in my lifetime, but I doubt (sadly) that it will. This makes me wish we had all been born blind.
Sometimes, I think moving to Vermont put my kids at a disadvantage, because Vermont is not a very racially mixed state. I've had to explain to my kids at times that not everyone who has dark skin is from Africa, and that it didn't matter if a person looked different from them; what mattered was whether they THOUGHT that person was different BECAUSE they didn't look the same. It is a constant education for them, but they appear to be learning it well.
I wish I could say the same for the rest of the folks here, but as with everyplace else there are those who still cling to the old ways.
I'd like to add that I loved Rich's comment, and totally agree with him. Even when we have the good sense and good fortune to get past the racism we're exposed to as kids, it still taints us.
It is the triumph of anecdotalism in our culture that allows people to take one isolated incident and use it to characterize an entire era. Anecdotes may illustrate some phenomenon nicely, but they are never sufficient to support an argument. Of course statistics are problematic too, but at least they purport to summarize wider experience.
Anecdotes are by definition isolated incidents. It is always possible to use such incidents to "prove" one's idle and quite possibly wrong preconceptions. It is pitiful that major voices in our culture so abuse isolated reports to further their too obvious agendas. It is even more pitiful that these voices receive such a wide and respectful hearing.
I saw similarities in our backgrounds. With some folks, the sweeping generalizations made against groups are the result of lazy thinking. Although I cannot speak specifically to your situation as such, I know the folks in my immediate family resort to the kind of laziness, then try to redeem themselves by the championing of individuals.
Like you, I not longer discuss race with family, and I do not react to racist jokes and stories.
It's funny how if placed in closer proximity to the problem that sometimes the walls come crashing down.
As far as the fight on the bus. That driver should have been fired. (I don't really know if that happened or not as it's not pertinent to your story).
We would also fight on the bus when I was younger, but the bus driver, male or female would slam on the brakes and put a stop to that activity immediately.
Getting kicked off the bus would cause a fate worse than death once the folks would find out about it and they always found out. That behavior just wasn't tolerated by parents or the bus drivers.
They will only change as they gain wider and deeper experiences with people.
So true...your writing continues to educate and inspire.
my father was exactly like your dad. we have come a long way, yet not so far. great post.
As a minority, I reject racism in all forms. I'm especially appalled by racism practiced and preached by minorities, all under the pretext that reverse racism is somehow justified.
Excellent post. Rated.
But then there is the more personal racism, where the societal racism described above is targeted onto actual individuals that you know. You don't like that person because he is different (black, white, Hispanic, Asian, whatever). Your attitude about that person's race makes it impossible to see the person as an individual. It is this type of racism that your parents were able to overcome. And that's why it is so important that society strive for diversity in schools and the workplace. We will not be able to overcome societal racism until we can begin to see the individuality of people who are different. Some will never get to that point, but many will, and that is a great thing.
"Now"? As in, before Obama, the white kids woulda been beating up the black kids while other white kids laughed, that's the way it's always been and that's the way it oughtta be? God, what an assclown.
We had only two black families in my hometown: the doctor and his wife and over-achieving kids, and the...other family, whose surname was truly unfortunate: Hood. You really didn't want to mess with the Hoods.
Did I say thank you for this?
First, I'd like to address your comments about throwing parades for sex abuse victims. I presume you are referring to the local, state and national events sponsored by Take Back The Night. Maybe it seems like a party to you, but as a longtime participant, I can assure you that there is nothing celebratory about being a sex abuse victim. The vast majority of the participants are victims of incest, and their gathering/marching is meant to mitigate culturally imposed silence and shame surrounding incest, which in effect protects the practitioners of incest and allows it to continue unabated, unrecognized and unpunished. It's not a celebration.
Of course poverty, drug addiction, lack of resources and hope aren't the only reasons to commit crimes. Some people are just antisocial and commit crimes. I fail to see how trying to understand it is 'making excuses' for it. If all crimes were due to a haywire gene, I'd want to know that, not because I need an excuse for the criminal, but because knowledge and understanding are the only real paths to workable solutions.
just some people's situations and abilities dont equal their wants.
in such a town, it sounds like your parents were brave people.
Understood. How many times can one hit the same bent nail and expect it to straighten out?
I told him that my ex-husband is Mexican and that I've been to Mexico so many times, and I've had nothing but good experiences with the Mexican people. I then said that there are a lot of Latins who live in my area, and they're some of the hardest workers around. I added that in the area I live in (huge metropolitan area) there are people from everywhere, and it's something that I'm used to and that I enjoy.
My cousin is from a very rural area, and I was born in that same area. But, I've lived in both rural and metropolitan areas, and I've evolved beyond the prejudice attitudes of those who influenced me while I grew up. Even though he has a degree in the culinary arts and has lived in some metro areas, he still harbors those small-town attitudes and prejudice ideas that he acquired from those around him.
I'm sure a lot of people don't even give much thought to thier racist comments... in terms of figuring out why they even make them. I'm sure not all have had negative experiences with "people of color." I'm sure they're just following the prejudiced attitudes of others... mindlessly... and unfortunately... while others are flat-out blatantly racist.
I do believe, however, that I'll be able to influence my cousin for the better, as he is mild mannered and is a good listener. Perhaps we all can help by doing our little part to help educate those who are open to being educated.
THAT is one of the biggest attitudes that needs to change.
I love the way you showed the complexities of this issue, and I remember the furor in my parents' neighborhood when a Hispanic family moved in.
Fantastic line, absolutely true. Great post, Sandra.
you realize that members of minority groups are more likely to be accused and convicted of crimes in America, correct?
If social forces like poverty are not to blame for this differential rate of criminality, real or alleged, then what factors would you cite to explain it?
By which I mean, what non-racist explanation would you offer?
Also, you should not equate 'criminal' with 'rapist' or 'murderer'. Most folks in urban areas who are accused of crimes are accused of fairly minor crimes of non-violence with an economic component, such as selling or using drugs.
When my sister's ex husband divorced her, she went into a major depression for a couple of years and sent her 6 kids to live with her ex and his "new wife." This woman was a piece of work, she hated one of the girls and made her live on the porch and told my nephew that he would be sucked down into hell for all the bad things he was doing. The poor kid was terrified of the ground after that.
In the mean time, my sister met and started living with a "black man". My mother was up in arms! Whatever failings William may have had, he demanded that my sister bring her children home.
My mother called me to complain that my sister was going to bring her children to live with "that man."
I asked my mother "do you ever listen to the words you speak, or do you just blurt out whatever comes to mind?" I went on "You would rather have your grandchildren live with a woman who, while white, WON'T LET THEM IN THE HOUSE, than with a black man???"
She relented then, but to her dying day, she set about trying to break my sister and her "black" husband up. What a sorry sight.
As far as I am concerned, William gets high marks for helping my sister through her major depression and reclaiming her children.
You are all so right. It is hard to break free from a racist upbringing - but it is possible.
Brava for giving those outside of our area some insight.
This is arguably the best post of your's that I've ever read. Compelling!
And, I wasn't surprised at all about your familial experiences. My family was like that too. My Dad grew up in the hills of Kentucky essentially a fieldhand of a "cash renter" farmer father. My Mom grew up just outside Detroit the daughter of a milkman. I heard many, many racial slurs growing up and even today the "n-word" will cross my "church-lady" Mom's lips frequently.
I grew up in Tampa in the 50s and the only "minorities" we typically knew were Cubans who lived in our lower-middle class neighborhood. They were "white" Cubans though. The rest of the city had signs on water fountains, restrooms, etc. for "white" or "colored".
And yet, my Air Force NCO father knew the meritocracy of the military which elevated him and black NCOs alike based on their ability. My Mom knows that goodness is in the heart rather than in the skin color.
They "overcame". Unfortunately in today's America it seems as though we are reverting back to attitudes of the 1930s through 1950s. And it's more than a bit frightening.
And, it's not alright to say black people are criminals because of the color of their skin. I think we all agree on that one.
But, it is o.k. to say an entire town is racist because they were at one time 99% white. That's a new one for me.
I am compelled to mention another excellent theory on the racist tendencies bubbling to the surface since the election and would love to hear your thoughts about it. I fear for the soul of our country and how some in power are using overt racism to their political advantage.
http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/the_daily_dish/2009/09/not-racism-projection.html#more
But, it is o.k. to say an entire town is racist because they were at one time 99% white. That's a new one for me."
Who said a town is racist because it was 99% white? I haven't seen that claimed or implied anywhere.
Note to Rush, Obama didn't invent racism. Neither did you, though you sure like to perpetuate it.
I think all races have complex relationships with the other races, and very few people are either entirely color-blind or entirely bigoted. It's in that gray zone that most of us exist, and it's a lot harder to pin down. But far be it from the likes of Rush to explore any nuance of human existence.
I apologize if I misunderstood what you were implying.
These would be the same people who, at the same time, voted for Obama and are in grief that part of the country is so racist (and it's undoubtedly true) that many people will blame anything on Obama BECAUSE he is black and go to great lengths to believe crazy lies (death panels). These same people are sad over this. And yet yell "those blacks" at the television set.
It's hard to figure out.
my comment about diversity/sameness looks like i am intentionally contradicting you and procopius.
which i did not mean to do - i rarely read comments before i comment, and i just have always thought sameness is where its at - cause we are all the same in all the ways that count.
As I read this I was picturing (first) Limbaugh's face in some of those old photos of smiling white men and women standing under trees where young black men were hung from and then to my own parents. And then my own parents, my mother railing against my father's slurs which always seemed to me to be uttered without any hatred or bitterness, just learned expressions unformed by any personal experience.
It was always a source of puzzlement to me; hearing things that sounded bitter, but pronounced like they were common everyday terms for regular people. Sounds like you and I lived in similar households.
I have to agree at this point, however, with Pres. Carter's assessment yesterday, that the election of Pres. Obama has caused more vile bitter racism to come to the surface in this country. It is there, it is inflected with real emotion and it is amongst the most damaging things existing in our country today.
I live in the city the UN calls the most racially diverse in the world. There is no black and white, rather it is black, brown, beige, ... well, you get the idea. And the languages spoken on the subway often make me feel like I am travelling abroad. And I love it. When I first moved back here, it challenged my comfort zone - as well it should. Those old comfort zones need to be shaken and stirred regularly.
I think there will always be a need to define "the other" and that race (skin color and/or culture) just happens to be the easiest after gender. If it isn't race or gender, it's religion or politics. It's my hope that in the future, everyone respects and appreciates these differences, instead of using them as a way to make themselves feel superior.
Your conclusion about not talking to your parents about race is also wise. The topic has come up with me recently at a party where the Obama speech at schools brought up the racism charge, and the conservatives I know were offended to the max and just stopped engaging. In fact, my husband just last night made the argument that Jimmy Carter's recent foray into the arena--saying baldly that people are uncomfortable with a black man as President--hurt rather than helped any kind of progress toward health care reform or anything else on the President's agenda. While I agreed with him regarding the outcome--it just put people into outraged camps--I defended the ex-President's right to say what he thinks in his old age rather than constantly remain in strategy mode. Still, it really is a conundrum. I think Obama himself chooses the route that you do with your parents. Just ignore discussions of the meta issue and work toward improving relations and policy, even if it means on the individual level.
Regarding the video: that's the first time I've seen it, and I've saved this for last because it's the most important thing I want to say. Race had nothing to do with what went on there. I knew this immediately upon seeing it. I expected to see something far more egregious regarding the "racial hate" element, but as a long-time educator in urban schools, I am telling you and everybody else, that that poor kid who was being picked on is a victim in every sense of the word and always has been. The looks of shock and embarrassed laughter and outright glee and horror--the whole gamut--that transpired around that bus were not organized by race.
Our school taught that there was the Civil War and then the Civil Rights movement and NOW, it's all legally resolved. Happily ever after! Still, I hope we're growing with each generation - My mom thought she was more understanding than her parents.
Such a great piece of writing, Sandra - Kudos!!
I was one of six black children in my high school, the only one in my graduating class. Your post brings back long forgotten memories of the many times someone apologized for using the N-word in my presence. It wasn’t lost upon me that my fellow classmates typically uttered this word with impunity, in their normal course of social interaction.
In 1967, Illinois Governor Otto Kerner Jr. was tasked with convening a team to investigate the root cause of race riots in the US. The Kerner Commission concluded, among other things, that the polarization of our society contributed to fear and mistrust among the races. One of the solutions eventually implemented in many cities over the next decade was forced busing.
The growing pains that many of the children of my generation experienced helped to make us a more tolerant nation. We have come a great distance since those turbulent times, but there is still much work to be done. Sinister forces continue to use fear and ignorance in order to advance their personal agenda. Those who are vulnerable are susceptible to being seduced by the music of the piper.
Limbaugh is a charlatan. He’s Chicken Little, running about and telling everyone the sky is falling. Children fight all the time, for many reasons. Leave it to Rush to brand this isolated incident as having profound social implications.
I think it was Thomas Paine who said, “These are the times that try men’s souls”.
Racism has been a problem in this country since its inception... toward Native Americans, blacks, Latins, and many other minorities (not to mention sexism as well). Many other places also endure racism. From what I see, it's mainly WHITE people who are the racists. The whites in Australia are very prejudice against the Aboriginal people there... and the aboriginals were there first. In many European countries, there's racism towards black people, Indian people, etc. White people took over South Africa, which has created so much violence.
So, if things are going to change, the WHITE people need to get their shit together... because they're the most guilty of the racist.
Super rated!
Marcela
I thought this would be one of your signature short stories, from the title. You write so well, regardless of genre.