Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 20, 2009 5:02AM

Goodbye my love, hello my friend

Rate: 99 Flag

 

I remember when we met, you were walking through the plant and looked up and smiled at me and my face turned fire red and you said, concerend "Aren't you feeling well?" Unaware that I'd been watching you for weeks, and had even bought a dress in voodoo like anticipation of our first date.

I remember our first date, we played racquetball. You hit me in the ear with your racquet, hard.  I lay on the floor grunting with pain and you squatted next to me with this panicked "God, don't let her cry" look on your face. 

I remember how at work we used to sneak up to the top of the grain elevator  and kiss,  keeping our eyes open because it was loud and we had to wear earplugs and wouldn't hear anyone coming.

I remember driving to work together each morning that first summer,  your blue Oldsmobile smooth on the two-lane highway bordered by rows and rows of corn.  I would  squeeze myself between you and the steering wheel so I could hug you all the way to work.  I liked to feel your arms and legs shifting calmly with the motions of driving. I always found your quiet  confidence, your unfussy competence so soothing. 

I remember our first fight, though not what it was about, just the passion of it.  "Are we breaking up?" I asked in a moment of startling candor.  I wasn't looking for reassurance, we both knew that.  No, you said, without hestiation, and everything, really, was settled in that instant.

I remember telling you about my anorexia. "You seem normal now," you remarked,  and remnants of the disorder slipped off me as easily as a shawl on a hot day. 

I remember the way you shook your head in disbelief after meeting my parents.   How I didn't feel vindicated so much as sorry for them, to be judged wanting by someone like you.

 I remember how excited I was to drive your sister's little Spree when you took me home to meet your family.  How I drove it in a parking lot to get the feel and ended up crashing into the grocery store, and how I was worried about the Spree but you were worried about my gashed open knees.  Years later you bought me a Honda scooter, with kneepads.

I remember our wedding, how young we both were. Those were in the pre-mega-wedding-industry days, and we were poor anyway. I had a $100 dress and my preparation was to wash my hair and put lipstick on. You stood at the altar and when I arrived and when you saw that I saw that you had accidentally shaved your sideburns off in your nervousness, we both had to suppress our laughter.  

 I remember our fist apartment with the awful yellow formica kitchen and that hideous seven foot couch with the prickly fabric that no one ever sat on.

I remember buying the waterbed and thinking it was just great.  I remember ten years later begging you - begging - to get rid of it. By then you'd decided the heater sucked too much electricity, and we were sleeping on a big bladder of freezing cold water that even 2 layers of sleeping bags could not insulate us from.

I remember bringing home Harpo, how you thought, because I had him in a box, that I found him.  You were enchanted utnil I 'fessed up that the place I'd found him was the mall pet store. 

I remember how mad you were when Harpo peed on your pillow. A week later he pooped there and we wondered what on earth was going on with him.  Soon enough, he let us know by climbing into your open suitcase while you were packing for another of your long business trips, and sitting there with his back to you.  This melted your puppy-proof heart and the two of you became good friends after that.  Cute is not a word you liked much, but the sight of you walking around the house after a long business trip with him absentmindedly tucked under your arm was, really, the cutest thing.

I remember the first time we had a dinner party, two other couples came over and you and the guys barbequed chicken.  I sawed into a breast that was raw on the inside with scorched sauce on the outside. We ended up eating corn on the cob, peas and strawberries  and drinking copious amounts of beer.

I remember when you told me of the grandfather who died before we met, how you feared the cruelty of the Parkinson's disease he succumbed to, and whether it was genetic. I remember promising I'd take care of you no matteer what, and how, if it comes to that,  it is a promise that I will keep.

 I remember the time you forgot to get me a birthday present. "That sure was a weird gift," you remarked about the Christmas-themed sweatshirt my mom sent. "At least she got me one," I said. We were in bed and you sat up quickly. "Did I not give you your gift?" you asked.  I thought it was odd you'd forget such a thing, until you brought it to me and realized, you'd bought me a vest that was identical to one I'd worn to work that day.  "Well, at least I got you something you like," you said, and we laughed about it and regifted it to your sister for Christmas.

I remember when we bought the house in Houston, mostly for the pool. I remember us standing in the huge living room and laughing that we were living in such a grand place. We high-fived each other but later had an argument when I realized you were serious about setting up a Nerf basketball court there. 

I remember how you really hated to spend money on clothes, and were truly indifferent about it until you took a sales job and had to go to a big meeting.  "What should I wear?" you asked me, standing in front of your mostly empty closet.  I shrugged and told you the truth - that the others would be wearing khaki linens and nice button downs and Italian shoes but if you felt OK in jean shorts and tennis shoes, you should go for it.   You asked me to go to the mall with you to 'get a few things' and though we only had a few hours, I'd been preparing for that moment over ten years of marriage, and got you a full wardrobe, shoes and a decent garmet bag AND to the airport on time.  You groused about the bill ($1200) but had the grace to call me from the meeting and tell me "You saved my ass, totally." 

I remember when I took an unusual day off from work to hang with my friend Sue by the pool for the day.   I woke to the sound of a hose being sprayed.  It was 6 a.m. and you were out on the back patio in your tight whiteys and tennis shoes, hosing pine needles and dog poop off the concrete before you left for work.  You weren't much for mushy words but you had your ways of letting me know how you felt. 

I remember how you always had such a hard time selling any house we'd lived in, which is how I knew you were happy with our life together. 

I remember how the drift began, how we started spending less and less time together and how for awhile it was disguised with the noise and motion of our busy lives.  

I remember how, when I left my high stress job, I tried to do something about the space between us, but was no match for the momentum of our falling away from each other. 

I remember one of my trips back home, how dad said "Why is he never with you? You tell him I said, he should be here." and how I had no answer for that, hating that he of all people could say the very thing I'd been thinking myself. 

I remember thinking, I can't go on like this but going on anyway, and wondering what you were thinking because I'd lost the knack of knowing without being told.

I remember  your quesiton, "Don't you want to be with me anymore?" and noting, even then, that you didn't ask if I still loved you; you knew that I did because why else would I be crying so hard?

I remember our friends' sorrow at the news, and the lack of surprise some of them showed, and how this stung me with sadness.

I remember the terrible guilt I felt, and so didn't protest at the accusations of my parents, their cold refusal to see the divorce as anything but my fault. 

 I remember all the tears  I shed, an ocean of them (and a tributary even now, as I write this) at the thought that I had not lived up to my promise to you, for better or worse. 

I remember how kind you were to me, without blame, when we moved on. 

I remember how you raced to get there in time when Harpo died, and how upset you were that I had to make that terrible trip to the vet alone.  I remember  how as we cried together I wondered if you felt, as I did, the loss of this link to our old life. 

I remember how you always asked me, How are you? And waited to hear the answer. How though we spoke with less and less frequency  you were nevertheless as interested as ever in what was happening with me, and how you clearly wanted for me only to be happy.

I remember deciding the best way to honor you, a man I still admire more than ever, was to forgive myself as you so clearly wanted me to, and find what joy there was for me.

I remember meeting your girlfriend, and how strange that felt.  

I remember listening to you tell me of her illness, the worry you showed, and how it soothed my  heart to see that you had, indeed, found love again.

I remember  the day you shared the  news of the impending child, the honesty with which you expressed your surprise and joy at the turn your life had taken.

I remember how happy I was when you wrote to say that you were stopping to visit on your way across the ocean to the place where you live now, a place where you will be married and raise a child with black hair but maybe your blue eyes, a place where you will live out a life that I will only hear rumors of.

I remember that, at that last dinner, I mentioned I'd finally thrown out Harpo's collar four years after he died,  and how you reached over to cover my hand when my voice wavered slightly. 

I remember it all and how could it be otherwise? You are the person I've spent more time with than any other.  I remember it all, with a smile at the man you were, and are.

I will always remember that you were once my love, and the kind of man you have chosen to be means that you will always be my friend.  It is a gift I will  try to be worthy of. 

Good luck to you, Clint.  Thank you for everything. I hope you have all the happiness you can stand, and then some.

airplane

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Sandra, this was beautiful to read. Not many people in my circle of family and friends understand how my ex husband and I can remain on such good terms. I think you'd get it.
Heartbreaking. Amazing. Sad and lovely. And that's about all I can squeeze out right now through my tears for you.
Hugs to you.
Beautifully told!! Excellent beyond the word excellent.

Rated as such.
I enjoy learning about you.
Very touching, Sandra. Beautifully told.
This is a gracious and heartfelt evocation of a remarkable relationship. I admire the reconciliation you've achieved in mourning the loss of this man but not this love. Thank you for sharing the memories as you anticipate a very different future.
Rated for honesty and clarity.
I was so close to this. i wish you some happiness too.
This reminds me of some of the anecdotes from a wonderful book by Daphne Rose Kingma, called The Future of Love. Kingma's ideas invlove the proposition that there's more than one "right" way to live a married (or commited) life, and that an ending is not necessarily a failure.
Thanks for expressing these complexities so well. People need to read more stories of this sort.
What a love story! The plane sailing off into the sun was perfect touch. I almost cried...and I don't even know you. Great post. R
As I began reading this, I sensed that the happiness would not last, though I was hoping it would. I'm glad the story ends on a positive note, though it is "sadly positive." The dissolution of a marriage is always tragic, even if it ends in friendship, which it rarely does. After reading many of your posts, I now automatically picture you sitting by a pool outside a nice Houston home. If you tell me that you actually live in a Minneapolis apartment, I will be devastated.
Breathtakingly beautiful...heartbreakingly honest.
-rated-
Sandra, my heart goes out to you. I know you know of Karen because of the comment you left. And I see *us* in the two of you ... allowed to slip away. I know when this happens, there is no one person to blame. It just occurs. But God bless you for your candor and for sharing your "letter" to Clint. Ture love never dies. He is blessed by having you in his life in whatever form.
Very beautiful and poignant. Thank you for sharing this on a reflective Sunday morning...
Wonderful reflections, heartwarming and real. And so glad you still have the friendship, as that so often fades. Says loads about you both.
"no match for the momentum of our falling away from each other. "

I want this not to be such a terrible truth.
Thank you for this.
Lovely. You are fortunate that it all turned out as it did.
Sandra, what a beautiful tribute to a loving relationship. There is no guarantee of being "together" forever, but as this shows, you don't have to end it with hate and bitterness. I needed this today, so thank you for sharing it.

~sigh~ you've got me all choked up now. :)
This made me want to cry. It was so moving. I am glad that you have a lifelong friend and have found love again to boot!
Why did you have to make me go and cry? Why? Probably because you are right. About everything.
Wow.

I can't think of anything else to say.
I am too moved to form an intelligent reply. So sad. So real. So poignantly expressed.
I totally understand. It is a good thing to come to a place where you can be friends, understand and let go.

Letting go...another toughie on life's road.
So sad, and yet so loving.
Beautifully heartbreaking, Sandra. Such a wonderful journey.
This is absolutely beautiful, Sandra. A testament to how even unhappy endings create new beginnings. Tender, painful writing at its best. I feel you in this piece with every single word. xoxo
Isn't it amazing how much love in so many forms our hearts can hold? I feel enriched having read this.
If you tell me this was a writing exercise of pure fiction called "I Remember" I will be sorely disappointed. It has all the attributes and poignancy of the truth. So if it is, please don't tell me.
perfect. some loves don't work as boyfriend love but are excellent friend loves. i loved this.

and i had a waterbed/boyfriend scene like that. STILL can't believe how long we slept on that clammy damn thing. :::shivers::
Sandra, as always this was gorgeous. I share the sentiments you expressed so clearly here. I suppose one of these days I should sit down and write a personal version to my (first) Ex-Husband.

There's a lot to be said breaking up well, not losing connection to the person who was the closest to us during a period of our lives.

Hugs.
Underneath it all, the love remains. You are refreshing proof that people don't automatically have to hate one another after divorce. Sometimes they can still remain close even if they can't remain married. As usual, your gorgeous writing tells the story perfectly.
Shit. I hope you're happy, getting me all choked up on a Sunday morning...

We all went through that waterbed phase back in the day, didn't we?
Beautiful. Sweet/sad. Thank you. Rated. D
that's as sad and sweet as anything i've read in a long time.
Lovely, poignant, and I think you need to listen to this:

Hello Like Before
I find this incredibly moving and full of wisdom, even as it nearly made me cry. I love how you still recognize the good in the man and the relationship you had rather than marking it off as a "failure." Even relationships that end have value in teaching us and making us who we are and if we're lucky (as in this case) making our lives richer for awhile.
Just beautiful...you have a gorgeous heart, Sandra...xox
Sandra, this is one of the most exquisitely precise and therefore moving portraits of a relationship that I've ever read. Your words and feelings are so specific and evocative that I felt like I was seeing a movie, and was there with you both in every scene.

And I'm so glad that you still love him. I think that when we truly love someone, we will always love them in some way, no matter what.
How brave you are to let someone go you love but have moved away from and then still be freinds. I tried that with my first husband but he had so much anger. Yours is such a wonderfully well told story.
A bittersweet love story told with poetic beauty. Very well written, moving, and heartfelt.
so warm and still loving, a tribute to you both and testament to the possibility that loving relationships can mature in unexpected ways without recrimination
How sweet, sad and honest; yours is a beautiful love story.
Kisses,
Marcela
Magnificent writing. Moving. Sad.
"Poignant" comes to mind. Thank you, Sandra.
I knew the ending to this, but it still carried me along. Masterfully wrought as always.
you are the rare thing, Sandra: a whole human being, awake to her own life.

Reading this made me a think a ridiculous thing: the whole point of America, of all of that is good and peaceful and thriving, is to allow us to live like this: to embrace all that comes and all that goes, with firm and loving hands. beautiful plainchant writing.
great gosh amighty, that was a good start to my monday. (seriously.)
So touching but, heartbreaking. Very well written!
Beautiful story, well told, very touching, thank you for the wonderful post
I hope my to-be-ex can write something like this about me at some point. I gave her my all and finally ran out of the ability to give, but I never stopped loving her. I hope she can understand that some day.

Thank you for writing this.
It's a good thing you have a hotel for a heart, Sandra. No, not the Overlook Hotel, more like the Ritz Carlton.

There's plenty of room there for guests. From here, it looks like a lovely place to be.
Very beautiful. The two of your obviously loved each other very much. So sad when that kind of love changes or morphs into something else. In my family, there is no explaining to others about our exes. Whatever works, I guess. My ex was in town for two months this summer when his mother died. he was over several times for dinner and even made homemade pizzas for me and the boy child.

This morning, my sister and her ex husband left for Thailand to visit my ex husband. (he lives in Thailand) My cousin is already there visiting for two weeks. Try and explain this to people!
so heartbreaking and moving.

shit...i have to tissues here at my desk!
Amazing, amazing. Beautiful work, Sandra.
This was quite evidently written by a very mature person, which is not to suggest that you come across as old here. I just mean that you are not resentful or angry, even at yourself. It must be kind of harrowing for couples who pin their relationship hopes on the fact that they care for each other a lot. Sometimes that just isn't enough. That's ok though; life goes on.
The motto of my 4th grader's class is "It's not what happens to you, it's how you handle it." I have never heard anything so wise. You seem to have lived it perfectly.
This was touch and vividly written, each recollection a frozen moment in time.

Some people have to go through years of therapy to get to this stage emotionally, in the aftermath of a failed relationship. You’ve mastered one of the greatest secrets of life.

Whether standing on the mountain or trekking through the valley, it’s important to cherish each moment of the journey.
Sandra--

I needed to read this today as I struggle to deal w/the loss of friendship w/my closest guy buddy.

It's really hard to see someone suddenly make such bad life choices. But I've learned that I can't stand by and watch the train wreck. He's chosen his bad life, and I can only hope he comes to a good, or at least safe, end.

Thx for sharing.
Wow. I read this earlier and had to come back to comment. I understand how life (and love) can be chapters in your life. It's nice to know that you still care for, and respect eachother. To part doesn't always have to mean anger...sometimes it is just time.

This is lovely. A wonderful tribute to a man who obviously deserves it.
So beautiful, Sandra. The truth of it hurts, and makes me want to hold my Spousal Unit a little tighter at night, lest we too know that momentum.
Beautifully writ; heartfelt.
Beautiful, my friend. What a gift, I hope he reads this.
I like this for many reasons, but mainly because it's a showcase for your inestimable memory and your considerable gift for evoking both tears and laughter, sometimes within the same few words.

I do have a question, though: gruting?
Wow. Just wow. Amazing writing.
You are amazing Sandra! When my mate blew up our world, I knew she strayed after 25 years,although she denied it to me, and the kids. Maybe that makes a difference in the way things play. I never harbor any resentment but you, wow!! rated
Sandra, this was beautiful in so many ways, at so many levels. It brought back my own memories and the grief I carry with me because of a break that turned into a crater where there seems to be no hope of building any kind of bridge. We all lose those we love in some ways, but when there is still some kind of connection, even if its only the thinnest of a fiber, it's easier to move on, remember, and smile. Good for you and good for Clint...and of course, spectacular and emotive writing. Thank you.
This hits so close to home right now. thanks for sharing
I haven't been on OS lately and it was touching to read another of your wonderful writings. A well deserved EP and Cover!!

:)
beautiful. touching. sad. yet somehow uplifting. thank you for sharing so much of yourself.
Sandra, this is elegant and so moving. Deceptively profound in its honest simplicity. Good writing and a lovely/loving story. Love is just that way.

thanks.

xoxo
Hoping for you the same outcome you hope for him.
Sandra, you made a grown man cry! I'll think of this all day...rated
this is such an ordinary story, so American and beautifully told. I too have a strong relationship with my ex, he and I are best friends now, but we were never really in love. we just liked each a whole lot. we managed, for the sake of our son to remain friends, which evolved into best friends when he married a woman I came to adore when she too, became my best friend. we were known for years as John and his wives.

good stuff.
I think I was writing "ordinary story, extraordinarily told" but got waylaid. I want you to know I absolutely loved it in case you didn't get that from my comment.
So poignant, mythic and strong:

"I remember deciding the best way to honor you, a man I still admire more than ever, was to forgive myself as you so clearly wanted me to, and find what joy there was for me."

Isn't that the most important part? It seems that part allows us to move on.

What strange synchronicity between our pieces this week.
My heart just aches reading this. You are wishing him all good things, and I am wishing them for you. Beautifully expressed Sandra.
love love love and rated! as always. i love you so much for your recent kindness.
You're a beautiful writer. This is causing me to sit, teary-eyed, with my family just a few steps away... rated.
I want to thank everyone who came here to read and leave such incredibly generous comments. This is something I wanted to do for a long time, but did not want to try until I was sure I could stay away from self-recrimination, guilt and blame, and keep the focus on where I really wanted it to be - on my ex, a good man who deserves the best.
Heartbreaking but beautiful. Your friendship with your X is something special. After 42 years of marriage, I am still a very close friend to my X girlfriend. My wonderful wife still insist on my visiting her when we are in town. Breaking up is always sad... A big hug to you - you are special.
This is how it should be. Great loves, great friends.

xoxo Sandra,

denese