Saturn Smith

Orbital Matter
Editor’s Pick
JULY 9, 2009 4:32PM

GM Says Good-Bye, GM Says Hello

Rate: 7 Flag

Remember the Good GM, Bad GM plan?  It was a speculative plan for GM to enter and exit bankruptcy quickly by essentially splitting itself into two companies, one that would buy all the "good" assets -- Buick, Cadillac, Chevy, GMC, and the working capital (factories, etc.) -- while Bad GM would get to keep the less profitable parts (Hummer, Saturn, Saab, crumbling factories, and apparently a golf course in New Jersey).  Well, today, a judge said GM can go forward [NYT] with the good/bad split, and at a press conference tomorrow, the GM CEO is expected to announce that GM will leave bankruptcy after only a few weeks.

What's that mean?  Really, not much, except that this is a particularly anti-climatic ending to something that could have gone very, very badly.  As the NYT article notes, the big battles were actually fought during the Chrysler bankruptcy hearings, where bondholders and others with complaints were shown exactly how hard and dirty the government was willing to play ball.  The weird part of this, as was noted in a great Planet Money piece a few weeks ago, is that any other company of this size -- if there were other companies of this size -- facing bankruptcy without government support would have languished for years in court, and would have faced lawsuits over the pressure that their bankrupcty manager applied on all parties to come to an agreement.  Here, since that role was filled by the mysterious auto task force, bankruptcy was just a brief pit-stop for GM.  From The Times earlier this week:

In fact, government-imposed deadline for concluding the G.M. case by the end of this week helped the court work through 850 objections in three days of hearings last week. Normally, such issues could take weeks.

I'm glad to see GM out of bankruptcy, because a leaner, greener, functional GM could ultimately benefit the entire country's economy.  I do worry, though, that this has gone so fast that it may have done some permanent damage to the bankruptcy system in the U.S., despite assurances from the administration that these are special cases.  Too many times of late we've seen things that start as exceptions become the rule.

And while I'm being a little storm cloud about all of this, I'd like to see the Obama administration, which is about to own Good GM, come out and explain exactly who's doing what behind the scenes.  I have yet to see even a concrete title for Steven Rattner, who seems to be running this auto task force, and that old story about 31-year-old Brian Deese doing the heavy lifting is still hard to believe.  Again, I'm glad to see GM out of bankruptcy -- but I hope tomorrow's press conference provides not just back-patting for that accomplishment, but some clear goals and outlines of where this new vehicle is head, and who's driving.

 

 



Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
could you imagine if the health care revamp moved that fast?!

I still do not fathom the good gm, bad gm back in business deal. Did they just make a pit-stop at the dump to drop off all the bad debt and mainline back to a new duplex next Grandma's big white house? (scratching head).
dude, can i do that?
I'm also still a bit puzzled about how the good/bad split works, so if you feel like writing a post explaining that more, have at it!

I'm mixed as you are -- desperate times call for , well, if not desperate measures, at least expeditious ones. But you're right that exceptions establish precedents which often beget new norms.
Sounds like a case of multiple pesonality disorder; maybe some meds should be required. And a lot of psychotherapy, too.
"personality"

I can verify that once you hit that post button, you can't just sneak in a small editing change. The train has left the station!
As much as I am in support of Obama and his approach to doing his job, I have to say: Don't hold your breath on this....I don't believe that they themselves are absolutely sure of the nature and course of what will follow this "exception" to what would be considered normal a bankruptcy resolution.......
As it relates to the past years of complacency in the automotive industry, such a bailout will only further substantiate an industry that will never be capable of remaining competitive or sustainable.

With fleet sales declining, and/or moving to imported brands, the big three will have a tough time ahead. Allowing them to "capitalize" on their bad assets/paper while retaining the good will not solve anything. Only the complete and utter revamp of their business model will ensure that the US will indeed (someday) have a world class automotive industry.

For now, the big three will sup from the governmental buffet, and buy itself another 10 or so years.
I think this is what the Republicans call "the invisible hand of the market" at work.
Aaron, do not lump Ford in with Chrysler and GM. If you want to buy an American nameplate, it should be Ford, Lincoln, or Mercury.

Why?

Guess who didn't come running to the government for a bailout? Guess who didn't file for chapter 11? Guess who has been working on green vehicles and green factories for a long time.

Ford.

So, we should reward Ford for its behavior by buying their vehicles.
Whenever government enters into a situation as a party to a negotiation, the hazard of massive unfairness arises. You cannot, no matter how rich or popular you may be, stand toe to toe with an entity that gets to make the rules and have any kind of real negotiations. Especially in bankruptcy where old contracts are inoperative and specialized rules apply in any event.

I have no doubt that many people got screwed quite unfairly in this process of these bankruptcies. It was unavoidable.

Greater transparency at this point would probably only make us angrier without allowing us to do anything about it. It is a done deal.
In the 70s, Richard Nixon told Golda Meir that he would trade 3 of his generals for Moshe Dyan. Golda being Golda, she said fine, and asked for General Motors, General Dynamic, and General Electric.

Do you think we can get a similar deal from Israel for GM these days somehow from Bibi? Maybe a Colonel in the Mossad, and some fighter jets, or something? Squad of IDF commandos? Free lessons for 50 years for the Army in Krav Maga?