Orbital Matters

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith
Birthday
April 06
Title
Ms.
Company
The Solar System
Bio
Everything posted here, and more random thoughts, are also posted at my web site: http://kepkanation.com.

Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 3, 2009 12:13AM

This Week In War: Report Time

Rate: 5 Flag

It seems to be a big week for war reports.  I don't mean journalists standing in front of blazing cityscapes (we've got enough of that within our own borders at the moment).  Instead, I'm thinking of several big written reports that have hit the desks of the nation's war deciders this week.  Juan Cole at Salon has ably summed up the release of casualty numbers from Iraq today, which seem to point to -- not much, beyond that things aren't getting appreciably worse, so maybe they're going to get better.

Then there's the McChrystal Report.  This was supposed to land on President Obama's desk today, making for a little light reading over the Labor Day weekend.  That Press Secretary Robert Gibbs is talking down the importance of the report, oddly, makes me think it's incredibly important and might just knock Lush Life off the president's bedside reading table.  More on the report [The Guardian]:

[General] McChrystal has been working on the review since Obama put him in charge of the war in June after firing his predecessor, David McKiernan. The document has been sent to the US military's central command (CentCom), responsible for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and to Nato headquarters in Brussels.

The review is expected to confirm that protecting the Afghan people against the Taliban must be the top priority. The document has not been published yet, and the severity of McChrystal's assessment was difficult to gauge. But at an event last week, according to the BBC, he likened the US military to a bull charging at the matador-like Taliban and slightly weakened with each "cut" it receives.

This is, in a way, McChrystal's coming out party as the new Commander in Afghanistan, the culmination of the 60-day review that Defense Secretary Bob Gates ordered when McChrystal took over for Gen. McKiernan in June.  It may also be the opening salvo in a battle to get more troops sent to Afghanistan.  At the least, it's a plea for those above McChyrstal -- read: President Obama, Secretary Gates, and probably the Joint Chiefs and NSC -- to come up with a new plan, including new victory conditions, for Afghanistan STAT. 

The report comes on the heels of the contested, violent elections two weeks ago and the highest American casualty rate (302) for Afghanistan since 2001.  Just today, the deputy intelligence chief in Afghanistan, a stalwart ally of current president Hamid Karzai, was killed in a suicide bombing.  All of this, on top of the recent deployment of 20,000 additional troops, has led to unsurprising and increasing American frustration with the war in general -- just check George Will's latest for a summary.

Will the McChrystal report kick war planning into a higher gear?  It seems like it has to -- but I've got absolutely no idea about which direction things will go.  It seems equally likely that Obama will decide to start a drawdown as it does he'll order a larger assault.  The center, however, cannot hold.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Sigh. How are we going to protect the Afghani people from the Taliban when they ARE the Tali...oh forget it.
I just wish "O" would understand you can't win a war there unless you killed the whole resident population.
Don't think more troops will do anything but bring home more dead soldiers.
"O"s Vietnam. yup
They are sending more people into a trap.
Make a waste, call it peace, and get, while the gettins good.
i posted "look at doonesbury" yesterday. a picture etc...

but it doesn't matter, no one at os has anything to say about american military adventures. and when the next terrorist response comes in, you will all cry "innocent victims!"

slow learners...
It seems to be the very definition of FUBAR.

Al -- totally not my plan.