Orbital Matters

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith
Birthday
April 06
Title
Ms.
Company
The Solar System
Bio
Everything posted here, and more random thoughts, are also posted at my web site: http://kepkanation.com.

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 17, 2010 12:36AM

Lady Gaga Says, "'Telephone' Your Senators about HCR."

Rate: 19 Flag
And now, for something different.
 
ladygagapost.jpg

Lady Gaga's latest music video, "Telephone," premiered last week, and as it quickly became the hottest thing since (and including) sliced bread, I suppose it's not much surprise that the video and commentary on it showed up everywhere. The crowning achievement of bizarre commentary, however, goes to the Atlantic's "culture channel," where writer Aylin Zafar promises "a frame-by-frame analysis" of the nearly ten minute video.

Gaga Headline from The Atlantic

This cannot go without mocking. "Telephone" (which is truly, and I say this from experience, Not Safe For Work -- as are some of the pictures that follow) isn't exactly crying out for the type of English-class analysis that the Atlantic brings, unless that class is doing a unit on Fun Dance Videos that Want to Sell You Stuff (of which this would be maybe a supplementary video, after, say, any Kanye West production).

But if we're going to try and lend meaning to a thing that seems to just want to tell a fun story, why don't we make the story about something we like?

I present "Telephone," Lady Gaga's newest argument for the passage of the Obama health care bill.


Here we have Gaga entering Prison, also known as "Life Without Health Care." It will be Hobbesian: Nasty, Brutish, and Short.

gaga_4.jpg In fact, she's quickly stripped of even the slimmest protection she has against the world (COBRA), and left defenseless and alone.

gaga_5_6.jpgEventually, she strikes a deal that allows some relief: she signs with Blue Cross Blue Shield, symbolized by the triangular headphone (which looks like a shield), but is soon a prisoner, chained by their exorbitant rate increases.

gaga_7.jpgThough the Atlantic says, "Her smoking glasses are a cloudy veil that obstructs her view of reality, allowing her to base her feelings on senses alone, blurring the genders of the women around her," I see this as a bid to perhaps find a partner with better health care. Gaga, after all, clearly has a smoking habit, and cessation programs aren't cheap.

gaga_8.jpgThe price of coverage is high, though; what you must do to maintain it can make you a stranger even to yourself, a prickly, coked-up stranger.

gaga_9_10.jpg

Then, after all that effort to get on a plan, Gaga finds that she's not going to be accepted after all because she has a pre-existing condition. Her body is literally a crime scene, wrapped in tape the health insurance companies won't cross. She is again exposed, which is terrible, since her smoking habit seems to have been replaced with an eating disorder.


gaga_12_edit.jpgThere's hope, of course, in the form of the health care reform package -- but it's uncertain. This is a reminder to Democratic voters (here depicted by the prison guards, as they are the ones in power) that there are Plenty of Fish in the sea for voters in fall 2010 if they vote against health care reform.

gaga_13_14.jpg Finally, Gaga is freed from the health care prison, again armed and dressed and ready to dance in the world. Her friend Honey Bee picks her up in the Pussy Wagon, clearly a "fuck you" to Bart Stupak and a sign that HCR should pass without stripping women of any rights.
gaga_15.jpgNow that she has health care, Gaga can take risks, like eating pre-packaged foods filled with preservatives.

gaga_18.jpg

Gaga, clearly starving, and Honey Bee travel to a diner, where Honey Bee's abusive partner is waiting.


gaga_20_edit.jpgGaga returns to the day job she once hated (how do I know she's returning? How else would she get a job there a few days out of jail?). But she doesn't really need the job any more, because she has health care thanks to the passage of health care reform!

gaga_22.jpg
She puts poison in the syrup. Much like when Republicans tried to poison health care reform, there's no real reason for this other than spite.

beyoncetyrese.jpgNo reconciliation here!

Instead, we see a woman freed from a relationship she was clinging to only because her partner had good benefits. Hooray!


gaga_23.jpg

The Atlantic: "Thus begins the epic dance break—celebrating a new America. An America that steers away from gender constructs. An America where you don't have to wear pants!"

An America with health insurance!


gaga_24.jpg

Beyonce says, "Call your Senators! Tell them to vote to pass health care reform!"


gaga_26.jpgLady Gaga is now fully covered. And leonine. In fact, this outfit is meant to mock Aetna, which also features a person with one bare arm as their logo:

Aetna


gaga_28.jpg At the end, we see Lady Gaga and Honey Bee fully covered -- by health insurance -- and victorius. They are going to brave the big bad world together, without entangling employer- or partner-provided health care.
All screen captures from YouTube/Vevo as uploaded by The Atlantic.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Only in NY could anyone possibly think this is art
I wonder how they got the rights to Tarantino's Pussy Wagon?
Apparently, he suggested using it, according to the Atlantic's article, BBE.
Brilliant. Completely brilliant.
well, truth be told, I've been avoiding Lady Gaga for a variety of reasons, mainly because...umm...I'm old and a sort of a nebbish nerd.

But I have to say, that was a gloriously supersaturated superassault on the visual cortex. Wonderful art in an astonishing presentation. Sadly, I think the Atlantic's Alyssa Rosenberg doesn't get it, even if she has the advantage of age and culture proximity that my self cloistered hermitage precludes.

And, you rock Saturn...thanks.
Your interpretation is intriguing. I take the idea that there are messages encoded in mass media very literally. I don't know what exactly those messages are, but they are certainly there.
This is awesome and amazing and it cheers me the hell up.
Really? And I thought it was about health hazards, pneumonia from not enough clothing, food poisoning from room temp mayonnaise. And possibly, selling records.
I'm already on record at how much I like Lada Gaga. Sexploitation notwithstanding, she's a Grrrl Power woman, and I love it.

And Beyonce (along with Pink) and LG all kicked ass at the Grammys. Which is how it should be.

[Also, it's nice to see a PussyWagon be a tool of empowerment.]
oh, Sorry, forgot the reason for commenting:

Saturn, your take was funny and viable. (G)rrrrated!
I am somewhere in the land between having a headache from the song and never being able to get it out of my head, bbd and L&P. It's nefarious.
I've been afraid to even watch this notorious video thinking it might brainwash me into...uh, something. But now that I know how to read it with your secret decoder ring blog post, I feel safe! (Well, as safe as a self-employed person paying for her own health insurance can...)
OK, I've watched it. To quote Marcellus Wallace, two things:

1. Does Lady Gaga send Madonna residuals for her entire career? If not, I'd sue for that if I were Madonna.

2. Has anyone counted up all the product placements in that video?
Silkstone, to answer your last question, Salon covered it. They figure it's an extended Miracle Whip commercial.
And I agree with Connie, Saturn. Yours is one of the most entertaining takes on the vid so far.
well, Kathy, that is not my mother's Miracle Whip! guess they're trying their product's image.
that should have been "trying to change their product's image".
Heh. Yeah, there's a ton of product placement -- it's almost as much an ad as a video, except that I feel you need a decoder ring to even know what's being advertised sometimes (for instance: those headphones are actually branded Lady G. merchandise, I believe). Then again, I guess Levis has been giving us confusing advertising for years, so why can't everyone get in on the act?
I watched this video yesterday as it was a very hot topic in La Acera, which is the Puerto Rican blog space where I write in Spanish.
Maybe, I'm just old but I was bored out of my mind by 3:32.

I think your take on the video is far more entertaining than seeing it as the grandest thing on aesthetics since Andy Warhol.

And I agree with Silkstone, Madonna's been there done that.
brilliant! you, and Lady G and B. though you tell it with much satire, and that's so much appreciated. the video is fun tho. ...
Very funny analysis. It shows how far you can go with a little Deconstructionism.

BTW, Healthcare? Boy, was I ever fooled. I thought this was an attention-getting, asynchronous attempt to get people (mostly men thus the "Caged Heat" sections) to watch/listen to a song about a young lady just wanting to have a girl's night out and not be bothered by a clingy boyfriend. But, what do I know.

BTW2, the last frame can be interpreted as the people getting wrapped in all the burqa-like redtape a government run healthcare system would generate. But, that's just my POV.

Long live Derrida! R
Saturn, you have clearly missed your calling. YOU should be a music video producer. I can't begin to imagine the sordid visual assault you could muster to tell the story of TARP betrayal and the battle for economic recovery and credit reform.
Now, if only CSPAN ran music videos..... sigh
How can something that "looks" so sick represent health care?
Saturn, this is funny, but I like Gaga. I love camp (I love drag!), and I know that there isn't enough of it in the world.

Lets have a political/music video with all of our prominent Senators in drag and in bed with all our prominent lobbyists. Will some music video producer in touch with Gaga please steal this idea?
Everything lady gaga does is taken out of context. She has been successful because she is good. Now all the pictures of her half naked are part of her persona. We have tons of concert pictures that show even worse. If interested in seeing more, check out pictures by clicking our name. Loved the write up and glad to see others talking about Lady Gaga as well...she is that good.
Everything lady gaga does is taken out of context. She has been successful because she is good. Now all the pictures of her half naked are part of her persona. We have tons of concert pictures that show even worse. If interested in seeing more, check out pictures by clicking our name. Loved the write up and glad to see others talking about Lady Gaga as well...she is that good. www.newestladygagasong.com
Thanks for this post. I definitely agree with what you are saying. I have been talking about this subject a lot lately with my mother so hopefully this will get him to see my point of view. Fingers crossed! Resume Samples
I really love this Video. I found this great blog about Celebrity Latest News