Orbital Matters

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith
Birthday
April 06
Title
Ms.
Company
The Solar System
Bio
Everything posted here, and more random thoughts, are also posted at my web site: http://kepkanation.com.

Editor’s Pick
MAY 2, 2011 1:23AM

Bin Laden is Dead: What Does it Mean?

Rate: 13 Flag
Flag in front of White House 5-1-11

It is an ending like all meaningful endings, an ending that leaves us with more questions than answers. What will it mean? What was it all for? Why now? Why then? What happens next?

Somewhere, in a million-dollar complex in an apparently secure and quiet suburb of the capital of a shaky ally, Osama Bin Laden met death in a particularly messy way. It was not a robotic killing, not, apparently, a surrender, not an uprising, not even, it seems, a betrayal. It was a small, quick mission after months and months of planning. He was shot in the head, shot in the chest, as well, it sounds. He had bodyguards. He used a woman as a human shield.

I expect those details will change. I expect, however, that the feelings I see on television will not. This is a victory. It is a long-awaited period on the end of an extremely long sentence.

Bin Laden's story is well known. He was a wealthy man who used his influence and his affluence to encourage the worst kind of paranoia and hatred. He drew together a band of like-minded, fear-mongering men, and with them concocted a plan that sent terrorists onto American soil. That plan left nearly 3,000 citizens dead in New York, in Washington, D.C., and in Pennsylvania. It also changed the way we think of our personal safety in ways that can never fully be forgotten.

The time before bin Laden is not precisely the time before 9/11. He was here before it; he was the shadowy figure behind international attacks, a vague but growing threat to those who -- before -- were tasked with worrying about the vague and distant threat of terrorism on our safe-seeming shores.

So I see -- I choose to see -- the outpouring of cheer among my countrymen and women not as a celebration of one man's death; I see, in these smiling faces, relief. I see the belief that this will mean something is going to get better, that something will now get easier. While I don't believe that, really, I do feel some recognition. I see and even share the hope in these young faces that the America of our childhood fables still exists -- an America that can overcome by might and right, an America that does, as the President said, stand up and protect its citizens:

[A]s a country, we will never tolerate our security being threatened, nor stand idly by when our people have been killed. We will be relentless in defense of our citizens and our friends and allies.

That is the fairytale we have always been told of America. It is the exceptionalism we have lived without since September 11, 2001. In some ways, demanding its return, we have cried out for vengeance. We have cried out for a physical justice that, tonight, has been meted out halfway around the world.

Death is not worth celebration. Relief, though, is. There is no return to the normal that existed before 9/11, but there is comfort to be found in the promise -- the bloody, vengeful promise -- of American-style justice being fulfilled. Photo Credit: Matthew T. McGregor / Flickr / CC License

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Did you read Joan Walsh's piece on Salon? I myself am wondering if this is an end or a beginning, or perhaps, something in between. I'd settle for in between.
Edited to add: I expect a big market spike from this, but am up too late already tonight to write about it. Should be tomorrow's big story, on the heels of this news and the Berkshire Hathaway annual funfest in Omaha.
I think that you have said exactly what many people are thinking tonight, Saturn. Thank you for this thoughtful essay.-R-
There are a couple of things that we can reasonably know. 1) there was more cooperation between the U.S. and Pakistan than had been the case in previous years. 2) it is an organization decapitation, and not merely the killing of a guy hiding in a cave.
Just read Joan's piece, Kathy. I think it has to be a beginning and an ending, right?

Thanks, Grace.

Bill, I wish I could share your optimism that it's an organizational decapitation, but I fear there are dozens ready to take his place.
hard not to notice that terror alert levels are UP.
Good commentary. Thanks.
Wanted: dead or alive. 10 years later it has come to pass.
This won't change much if anything. there will be a lot of celebration in the streets by the people that are less inclined to think things through but when it dies down there will be a lot of questions raise which will probably be ignore or ridiculed by more rational people.
well said, saturn. and relief is the right word. i imagined how different i feel now, knowing he's dead, than i would if he had never been captured or killed. that difference is huge.
"Death is not worth celebration."
I have to disagree with that. I am not relieved. I am genuinely happy Bin Laden is dead. I am even happier he was killed, and happier still that he was killed by a U.S. serviceman.
It’s been reported that the Navy Seals killed him in about 2 minutes but were at the compound for 45 minutes and retrieved computers and other evidence. While we now have been rightly alerted about possible reprisals I think this would be a good time to say - to those whose names may be linked to the evidence - to give themselves up. Even though they probably wouldn’t, it seems like the right thing to do.
Tried to rate. I echo many of your comments. In my head. Thanks.
I wonder if this means American and NATO forces will withdraw from Iraq and Afghanistan? Or will they stay and cite new reasons to justify their continuous military presence? This is a real test for America. They didn't find WMDs in Iraq, but still stayed. Now they killed UBL, will they stay in Afghanistan?

The record is clear: the USA will stay in these regions for another 100 years.
hello everyone,Welcome to our website
====
http://www.mallclothes.net/
======
Dear friends, do you want to have some different things?
the good shoping place,the new season approaching,
please input our website.
====
http://www.mallclothes.net/
======
Believe you will love it.
i was initially minded to verbally despise this shoddy nonsense, but that is not fair: a girl's gotta make a living somehow, and hooking is illegal.
if you think there is
Relief
from
THE WARMACHINE
you are
[just like OBL]
DEAD wrong.
Oh yes!! Some deaths are so worthy of celebration!! I can't wait for the next monkey-bar trained, cave dweller to follow suit and give us even more to celebrate!
What makes it even better? Knowing it was harsh interrogation techniques carried out at the secret black ops sites that provided the information that led to killing Bin Laden. Where are all those posts now claiming how no credible information comes from such methods??? I have no doubt Jon Stewart will forget all about having to credit such methods for the victory. Olberman...oh, even worse for him. Such a disgraced idiot, truly the world's worst person in the world, day after day after day...