
I know not why Staff Sgt. Robert Bales committed these most brutal atrocities. This is not written to excuse his behavior or condemn it, although I do so in the strongest terms. I write this because even though Sgt. Bales admitted killing these men, women and children, he had an accomplice. It was the American government that sent this man to 1,192 days of hell. Despite head injuries, the loss of part of a foot and his personal plea that this would be a hardship on his family and serving three tours in Iraq, they sent this broken man to Afghanistan. When is enough? When does killing and seeing your buddies killed become too much?
There has to be a breaking point. The Vietnamese broke Senator John McCain and no matter what I think of this man's politics, I salute his service and for him to be broken by his torturers tells me anyone can be. Senator McCain might be many things, but in my view, he's one tough SOB and they must have really put the screws to him to make this Admiral's son talk. He has spoken of this and has said the worst thing that has ever happened to him was not the physical torture, but having to tell his father "They broke me". This is what drives these men. Not some kind of pseudo patriotism to the Flag, but their buddies and their family. Sgt Bales was fixing to lose his house and on his fourth tour and he snapped.
It is estimated that 31% of the men and women sent into combat zones have some type of PTSD. That is after only one tour. No one, no psychiatrist in the world can tell you what percentage of soldiers who have been deployed four times to combat zones have Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome. How this country and can send these soldiers over to these damn places to kill and be killed, to see atrocities that we cannot imagine in our widest dreams and to watch their closest friend die or lose limbs is a travesty. Our minds are not wired that way. We are not born killers, we are taught to kill and in any fucking world this is wrong.
Old men sit in smokey rooms puffing on their illegal Cuban cigars with a "wink, wink" thinking the law doesn't apply to them. President Kennedy is said to have ordered boxes of Cuban cigars imported to the White House because he was fixing to sign an executive order banning all contraband from coming into America from Cuba. I guess the rich and privileged deserve their inside knowledge about cigars, and wars. When it comes to wars they love to plan them, however incompetent they are, but do not think about asking their children to go. No, they have their Ivy Leagues colleges to attend. War is now a poor man's game and has been since World War II.
But when does this insanity end? When does a soldier's brain snap from seeing these awful, awful things. They fight and kill and see their friends die in the daytime and then go on Skype at night and their wife gives them the news they are losing their homes. Or perhaps a son or daughter is acting up and they cannot do a damn thing about it. They can only get up the next morning and do it all again. The human mind cannot work this way. I know absolutely knowing about psychiatry, nor am I a neurologist, but even an idiot like me knows you can't keep sending these brave soldiers into harms ways every other year. By the time they are rehabilitated from the last tour, their bodies and minds partly adjusted, they are sent back, regardless of their personal situations.
Don't tell me this is what they signed on for, that's bullshit. They signed up because there are no jobs and they are poor and want to go to college. Some even signed up to experience the army and find out what war is like, after experimenting with it on their game boxes. Hell, the army recruiters even give out the war games to make it look glamorous. It doesn't take long for a person to find out it is indeed hell, especially when they see their friends brains splattered all over themselves. Sgt. Bales should be locked up for life. What he did is unforgivable and there are no excuses for slaughtering whole families. But there is another culprit. The United States government is just as guilty as Sgt. Bales, maybe more so. Hell, we taught him how to do it!


Salon.com
Comments
Lezlie
If he was that far gone that this was the ONLY way he had to get attention, I find THAT to be the tragic part. Those 16 people in Afghanistan would not have died this way if the Army and the military in general would get off of their fat-assed high horses and realize that THEIR actions have definite and intense consequences. I am sick and tired of the military sucking up over half of the GDP in this country, for low bid and no bid contracts with no oversight to go to contractors who feel justified in doing as little work as possible for as much money as they can get, and leaving the enlisted personnel to suffer the consequences with no recourse for betterment of their situation. Yes, they volunteered but as you say, recruiters don't tell the whole truth; they say what is needed to get someone to sign on the line.
All you have to do is see the photos and hear the stories to know that the military needs to be rebuilt from the ground up. They have lost their mission.
r.
HUGGGGGGGGGGG
Do you know what they call the person who finished last in their class in medical school? Doctor.
My friend, you aren't the idiot. We have two problems at the top, one is a large group of sociopathic freaks. It's some sort of defect and they're more like animals than humans . The other is people who think they know everything when they know next to nothing. The military gets the worst of everything and that includes medical care. As a former Marine I experienced that personally, and often.
Who knows what the percentage of doctors making grave mistakes every day is. They assume because they're doctors they have the right answers, every day they make mistakes and arrogantly refuse to admit them or learn. That's simple incompetence. Only an incompetent idiot would have sent that man back into battle. Do no harm, pfttt.
We have the same problem with all these Ivy League economists who presume because they have a fancy degree they're intelligent and competent. Clearly most of those military neurologists and psychiatrists are stupid and incompetent, like the economists. It's that simple.
You're far more intelligent than many who have an education but no problem solving skills. You also have tremendous courage and stamina which is sadly lacking in many. We defer to titles and income levels, not actual behavior or results. Bad system.
Yes, the problem is us, we need to start demanding those who are defective or incompetent change, or we replace them. It will get worse until we as a people do.
We have military leaders who are (in MY opinion) dumber than a box of rocks and completely lacking in common sense sending the walking wounded back into a situation that is GUARANTEED to elicit a "flight of fight" response and then we wonder WHY they "flip out. "
1. Make military service more attractive in terms of benefits and/or money.
2. Reinstitute the draft.
3. Limit your military activity to your actual resources.
It's not that I'm a fan of the draft but I'm also not a fan of letting one or two classes do all our fighting for us. One of the reasons we got out of Vietnam is because a lot of people who were willing and able to exercise influence did so because they wanted their kids out. There aren't major antiwar protests because so many people who would ordinarily participate are completely insulated from the war. I would actually favor a form of universal service, not all of it military, with military having the shortest service and best benefits.
Fundamentally, Scanner, you're right: US Government policy led to this because we had no business even allowing a guy with that kind of background over there. That doesn't reduce his responsibility in the same sense that a poor inner city kid who sells drugs and commits violent crimes is responsible for his own actions, but his behavior is still predictable given his resources and so complaining about that which is predictable after having made the choice that these actions weren't worth the resources it would take to prevent them is hypocritical. If we play with fire and get burned, we have no right to blame the match.
This isn't meant to be 'the token Brit' knocking the US either. It's just we're not sold the same social crap unless it's an attack on our country or somewhere we perceive we still own.
This recent case with a US trooper won't be the last with the pressures they are under and it could be a Brit soldier next. Who knows? It's all wrong and predictable.
Good post Kenny. Rated with an Ug.
p.s.
Cuban cigar smokers are innocent.
For this we will all suffer...somehow.
Here is another interesting little piece from a couple year's back about PTSD and the suicide of a young soldier named Noah Pierce. I think it just helps to augment what you have brilliantly written here...
http://www.vqronline.org/articles/2008/fall/gilbertson-noah-pierce/
H. Rap Brown
http://www.vqronline.org/articles/2008/fall/gilbertson-noah-pierce/
The effect of maintaining a small corps of career soldiers was that there were no replacements from the general population when it came to redeploy. Think about the situation before Desert Storm. Hundreds of thousands of troops went into and out of service during the Viet Nam era, but most spent only one tour in Viet Nam. Only the career military went back for 2 or 3 or 4 tours. The canon fodder tended to be draftees, not career soldiers. This is not to say career soldiers and marines weren't in combat situations, they were. My active duty service was 2 years with the first spent in Viet Nam. I couldn't be sent back again before my active duty responsibility was satisfied. My father was in WWII in Europe. He was in for the duration, but the duration was "only" 2 1/2 years for him. My brother served 6 months in Viet Nam as an airman electrician. The tours in Iraq and Afghanistan have been too long and come too often because our all volunteer professional army is too small. Returning to the draft would put "skin in the game" for average Americans and have the effect of making it harder for government and industry to get us into unjustified wars, and produce enough troops to prevent the current perpetual redeployment that grinds men and women up. R
Thanks you, Scanner, for having the guts and clarity to look inot the mirror and tell.
Very few here in the U.S. have been willing to accept the responsibility that this about us, not just about "him".
Rated.
Strongly agree with all of this Scanner.
Yet we continue to continue.
Wrong does not make right.
ever!!
-R-
back in the day (ww2, korea)
which seems like nonsense to me,
or
guys these days are just too damn...human.
ww2 and korea guys came home to THE PROMISED LAND
OF PROSPERITY. the US in the 40's and 50's...
that must have alleviated their ptsd etc.
Now everything is a lie.
We all know it.
These brave fellows and gals go overseas to stand up
for something that MEANS something, and
of COURSE to be paid & taken care of.
Well, one still means something: america means something.
what does it mean?
untrammelled freedom of mind heart loins and thought.
nothing less.
http://www.aopnews.com/today.html
RATED
-R-
One thing I would disagree with is that the military is actually an elite though, Enlisted to Officer Corps in terms of IQ, education, physical fitness, compared to cohort. On average, both Enlisted and the Officers have better life-opportunities than people in their own age cohort, if on average, for many the military is the best one, overall.
....seems very suspicious to me too.
Exactly.
Humans are not cut out for modern war. Hand to hand scuffles...yes. But not this.
Excellent post. Thank you.
The Daily Beast and CNN reported the same thing:
http://www.thedailybeast.com/cheats/2012/03/18/taliban-soldier-didn-t-act-alone.html#comments
rate
This will change only when the rich and privileged can no longer opt themselves and their children out of the wars from which they profit so handsomely.
(ˆ◡ˆ) ♥⋯ ❤ ⋯ ★
What will happen is exactly what happened when Bush I and Cheney were in office, we will pull out due to political pressure at home (not due to any victory there) so we have not only raped and pillaged Afghanistan and left a vacuum which the Taliban quickly filled, but we we are not at war with the Taliban, technically, we are at war with Al Qaeda, not the same thing at all.
Again, the Taliban and Al Qaeda are not the same, and everyone in the field admits Al Qaeda are no longer in Afghanistan (Pakistan is another story).
Re: slanted coverage on Afghan sites, they say the exact same thing about our sites, they are anti-Afghan, because who in their right mind would be pro-Afghan?
Greg Mortenson, that's who. And look at what happened to him, because the girls he educates wear scarves on their heads, and there is a large group of people in the U.S. who want to see his charity destroyed, just like they want to see all of Afghanistan destroyed.
These are the "Kill them all and let God sort them out," folks.
We are only destroying ourselves in the end, and taking half the world with us.
What drives me crazy is that these people who go off the deep end never seem to kill those who caused their torment. You'd think that if they snap they'd snap at those who caused them such intolerable misery.
Over and over again, we see the bullied kill those that didn't even bully them. Otherwise, as Lezlie says, it's predictable.
Soldiers just don't snap and there has to be more to it than that and the media shouldn't be rushing too much to come to conclusions or present propaganda on the subject. The impression that some people might get is that he snapped for no apparent reason which is the usual impression the media gives people.
It always turns up that there are signs ahead of time and this usually includes escalating violence and often indoctrination from early childhood. The attempt to make him seem like a model citizen that helps his neighbors son with disabilities is highly questionable as it has been presented to the public.
Even without full reporting on this incident other similar incidents have indicated that this isn't entirely isolated and it is the inevitable result of the process that we use to raise children and fight wars. the specific details aren't inevitable but that something like it will happen is inevitable which should be enough to indicate that we should stop fighting one war after another based on lies, assuming the many other reasons aren't good enough.
BTW if you check out the Open call author tag you'll see it only shows those that delete the plus sign and replace it with a space, which excludes your blog.
http://open.salon.com/topics/open+call/most_recent
Yes that poor soldier looks like he's A-Wall, he's snapped. There are many many things people in everyday ordinary lives see and hear that drive them batty. Just imangine on the war fields, it has to be beyond the imaninations of most. Even the hard core police and detectives can't toughen up under certain circumstances. What is the matter with people is what is the matter with the whole system. The system is not truly set up for people to succede as much as it is set up for people to fail. It is the easiest of the two, I can't understand for the life of me, why some people aren't phased by criticism, others are not phased by racism, others are not phased by biased comments, and yet it's their whole pre-occupation. That is why Scanner there is a good and bad, and crossing those lines caused great problems to arise. It is more than fairness to ask our soldiers to go into areas where they know and yet actively put their lives on line in order to preserve the greater good of humanity. It takes a true hero to want to help those countries that are betrotted by tyranny and make great strides to behave in ways that are ignorant and brutal. I would hope that this example is used to help isolate those soldiers who know their mental capactiy has all but vanished to continue on with a so called "normal" life. I appreciate your attention to this matter.
So the big question is, if the problem is US, the solution cannot be of human intellectual origin. Where does that leave 'us' ? To the final frontier of human nature itself! http://www.energon.org.uk
afghanistan
iraq
nonsense
wars fought for gung-ho mofos in the conservative right
yet this tragedy
needs to unfold
no one knows why
this happened
speculation is a dangerous
mofo game
Nodding our heads quietly and letting it happen.
Which is why pieces like this are so important. It IS about US!
Because only the "volunteers" now fight wars nobody gives a rat's ass. Old men would think twice if they knew their kid was gonna get 4 months training and get dumped in Kandahar.
r
GREAT post, ScanMan!
-R-
btw, Obama needs Israel to play nice and not enflame gas prices before the election. It is a way Israel can control him or even get rid of him, since the Iran War RANTING and PREPPING and sanctions will drive up gas prices and if many Americans don't think about the big picture of global genocides (sadly), they do notice the price of gas and that will have a big influence on their votes. fwiw libby
--r
average # of combat hours for U.S. soldiers in WWII=10
Average # of combat hours for U.S. soldiers in Iraq/Afghanistan=240