Scott Christian

Scott Christian
Location
Los Angeles, California, USA
Birthday
August 29
Bio
Scott in his former life was a playwright but is now a tender of culture, sports, music, and literature. He spends most of his time attempting not to impose his obsession with baseball, motorcycles, and the music of U2 on the general public. In this regard, he has largely been a failure.

MY RECENT POSTS

Scott Christian's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 24, 2009 1:09PM

This Just In: American Asses Are Too Delicate

Rate: 7 Flag

So you may have thought foreign oil, bottled water, or SUV’s were the scourge of the environment, but apparently you are wrong.  The freshly minted responsibility for the destruction of the Earth falls squarely across the supple and delicate backsides of the American population.  An article today in the Washington Post examines our irrational need for the softest toilet paper that money can buy.  Apparently the biggest culprit, and most detrimental to the earth’s supply of trees, in this epic battle against raw ass is Quilted Northern Ultra Plush, a 3-ply mega toilet paper that makes cleaning yourself feel like a Swedish massage.  They say that when the end comes you never see its approach, so perhaps it is no surprise that the Earth’s last gasp will come at the hands of something so seemingly innocuous as toilet paper.

 

To be fair, toilet paper isn’t actually destroying the environment, it only accounts for 5% of deforestation, but it certainly isn’t helping.  The problem is that soft toilet paper is high on the list of American demands, for home use at least, and by design must be made from virgin wood pulp, i.e. chopped down trees, the older the better.  While that sandpaper we all use in public bathrooms is 75% recycled, in order to achieve appropriate levels of softness for the plush stuff, a maximum of 5% recycled paper is all that can be used.  Companies like Kimberly-Clark have stressed their attempts at becoming more green but the real problem is us.  We want our asses to be cleaned delicately, not to be scoured like a fresh arrival of prison inmates.  Once again, we find ourselves on the losing side of a battle against our own culture.

 

That 3-ply toilet paper even exists seems a bit excessive.  I’ll admit that I’ve probably been less than environmental in my TP procurement, I usually look for the cheapest that isn’t some form of Soviet torture, but I cannot count myself among the 3-ply crowd.  I do however feel, after reading this article, a sense of guilt over how many houses I’ve toilet papered in my youth, although we were at least using the cheapest stuff on offer so hopefully it was mostly recycled.  At the end of the day though, cleaning your backside really shouldn’t qualify as an area of luxury and it does seem to be an example of where our consumerism has gone off the reservation.  The article produces some good perspective on where toilet paper and ancient forests should fit into the scheme of things when it quotes Chris Henschel from the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society.  “It’s unbelievable that this global treasure of Canadian boreal forests is being turned into toilet paper...I think every reasonable person would have trouble understanding how that would be okay.”  Well put.

 

Certainly we Americans are no strangers to rampant consumption, but 3-ply toilet paper does seem a bit much, even for us.  Seriously, are we all trying to live like spoiled pashas.  Why not just use rolls of imported silk.  Or better yet, live minks.  Let’s make a promise that next time we’re at the store looking for a little backside sanitation we all skip the tree murdering aisle and go a little green.  Or, and I know this is hard on the American ears, we could do as the French do and just shoot some water up there.  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Damn it, Scott. I was going to do a TP post. Now you've stolen my thunder. I think your piece is full of shit. Party pooper! And I'not even going to type in LOL. Oops.

Le Monde works pretty well if you like ink in the area where the sun don't shine. But I remember the days...

I love this kind of humor. Welkl done R.
Most of the pulpwood going into toilet paper (and all paper) comes from tree farms, not from virgin mature forest. It's not a big deal. I would rather used recycled paper for all other purposes, and use the softer stuff on my softer parts.
This will cease to be a problem when we come up with nano-enzyme devices capable of transforming our fecal matter real time into oily slush that requires no wiping, especially with the help of a small bidet like device containing similar nano-enzymes. Until then, we should all do our part, take a few pain pills and use that sandpaper they called recycled TP.
I vote live minks! hilarious...
rated.
The thing I found weird on coming to America from the UK is the incredible softness of the TP - to the point it's hardly safe to wipe at all vigorously. I won't have some of those expensive TP brands in the house, due to my aversion to sticking my fingers through it into what it's supposed to be removing. Cottonelle I think is the worst. It's like using a pad of cotton wool. You're almost guaranteed to end up with stinky fingers. Despite the claims of the paper manufacturers, the recycled paper we get at work is quite soft enough for my butt, while having enough tensile strength I don't have to think carefully about how hard I wipe.

In the UK we used to have this hard shiny parchment-like stuff. It wasn't in stores after about 1960, but my college alma mater apparently had about a fifty year supply (with the University's name printed on every sheet!) stored away somewhere, so that was the last place I ever had to use it. I used to crumple it then flatten it out again. Interestingly, only the med school had the soft stuff because a med student of my acquaintance dug out some research showing it was more hygienic and complained to the faculty, who gladly obliged by making the switch.

The absolute worst TP I ever saw was a sample brought back by a colleague who visited the Soviet Union in the early 80s. It had wood chips in it, BIG wood chips. Paradoxically it was also pretty thin and fragile.
"At the end of the day though, cleaning your backside really shouldn’t qualify as an area of luxury". Dude, have you ever had hemorrhoids?

Until I can afford one of those Japanese wash, dry and spit shine auto-toilets I'm all for the softest TP I can find.
In the Soviet Union, they didn't actually buy the toilet paper; they bought Pravda, instead. Many toilet paper holders had a compartment for neatly torn newspaper. Public toilets didn't, but they generally didn't have toilet paper, either. Strictly bring your own, which is why pocket sized packets of Kleenex (or the equivalent) sell well.
I consider soft toilet paper an extravagant luxury and have been a recycling advocate far too long to consume anything the least bit plush. But when my Mom comes to visit, guess what she does? She shows up with a big package of the 3-ply good stuff and says something like..."well I went to Costco and I had to bring you the extra rolls I didn't need..." Then I tell the kids, "Don't get too used to this!" She also brings paper towels, ziploc bags, aluminum foil and saran wrap. All the things I somehow manage to do without and also feel too guilty to buy, but gladly use after she's gone!
I'd be afraid of getting scratched or bitten by the mink.
I would hope that exposes like this will wipe this problem out once and for all. We need to do 2 things: 1) use no more than 2-ply paper and 2) keep our fingernails clipped short.

Oh and by the way, I went back and retrieved a post I did here in late April on this topic called "The Great American Wipeout". Here's the link:
http://opensalon.com/blog/just-walt/2009/04/26/the_great_american_wipe-out
I hesitate to say it... but... ahhhhh... HEMP paper! Completely renewable, annual crop... and can be used to make everything from TP to super expensive stationary. Matter of fact... it's what the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence are written on.

Around here we use single ply ScotTissue or TP made from recycled materials.
Honestly, I think the 3 ply stuff is actually kinda gross. And then they perfume it, which makes it even more silly.