Scott Christian

Scott Christian
Location
Los Angeles, California, USA
Birthday
August 29
Bio
Scott in his former life was a playwright but is now a tender of culture, sports, music, and literature. He spends most of his time attempting not to impose his obsession with baseball, motorcycles, and the music of U2 on the general public. In this regard, he has largely been a failure.

MY RECENT POSTS

Scott Christian's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
APRIL 7, 2010 2:25PM

Architects of Obsolescence

Rate: 11 Flag

When I was a kid growing up I wanted to be a cartoonist.  My hero was pretty much Bill Watterson, the creator of Calvin and Hobbes, one of the funniest and most brilliantly drawn comic strips ever to grace American newspapers.  Then I chucked it all and decided I wanted to be a writer.  Basically I went from the dream of one dying profession where few people get paid well to the dream of another only slightly less terminal profession.  I used to get a lot of grief for this but now, one decade into the 21st Century, a hell of a lot of other people are starting to know how I feel.  Thanks to the forward march of technology, most of America has priced themselves into obsolescence.

 

It’s easy right now to blame the economy for everything, but there is a much more insidious trend in the American job market.  Think about it, when the dust settles, how many jobs are going to be lost or severely blighted by technology.  Manufacturing of course has been feeling that pinch for a long time.  Experts have been saying that America is on the road to a white collar economy for years.  But what is that white collar economy supposed to look like?  If you’re in health care or finance, good for you, enjoy your new status as a one percenter.  But what about the rest of us?  Engineers?  Unless you’ve got Chemical in front of that title, you may as well fill out an application at Starbucks.  Remember those heady days when a web designer could make piles of money?  Knowing HTML once meant guaranteed income.  Now all you need to know in order to create a web site is how to Google the words “Wordpress” and “template.”  What about graphic designers?  When I first moved to L.A. over a decade ago, one of my roommates was an art school grad plying his trade in the world of graphic design.  There was money in that because it required a lot of skill, technique, and know how.  Especially when using computers.  To be a graphic artist meant you had to actually know how to draw.  Now thanks to the advancement of Adobe Illustrator, anyone can cut and paste their way to a usable logo, advertisement, or even movie poster.  The experts now need not apply.

 

I could of course go on like this.  Blogs have killed journalists and magazine editors (don't worry, I see the irony of writing this in a blog), Apple has pretty much single handedly killed off film and music editors, not to mention record companies, although I don’t know many people mourning their loss.  Google and internet research has shuttered libraries.  And then to pile it on, thanks to the bad economy, thousands of companies have learned to make due with less employees, which means if this nightmare ever does rebound, there still won’t be enough jobs waiting for us.  So what’s left?  Everyday when I check my email, my homepage has some article about industries that are growing, or the best degrees to get for a job, or whatever.  And every damn one of them is in finance, health care, or a combination of the two.  Let’s see, I’m not a doctor or a nurse, I’m not an accountant, so that pretty much means I’m screwed.  With all of this great technology we’ve invented, it’s kind of interesting that no one ever stopped to think about its consequences on our way of life.

 

Maybe we all should have paid closer attention to American manufacturing.  First automation came in and took away thousands of jobs decades ago.  Then global outsourcing pretty much took care of the rest.  Well, here we are in the 21st century where technology has eliminated thousands of white collar jobs.  How long before global outsourcing takes care of that too?  What color collars will we be wearing then?  It’s interesting that in our culture, and I mean developed world culture, not just American culture, we’re so concerned about the latest and greatest that we never really stop to consider whether it is truly beneficial or not.  I keep seeing Obama go on and on about making our education system focus on science and the jobs of the future.  As I understand it, the jobs of the future are pretty much engineering drugs to keep us happy and working on or with some form of fuel technology.  Great, good for all of the kids who are good at math and science.  What about the kids who are creative, who like to paint or draw or play music and who maybe don’t have much interest in quantum physics.  Meet the welfare recipients of the future I guess.  What the hell are we doing to ourselves?

 

I’ll tell you one of the major problems that has driven us to this point,  our education system.  It is and alway has been about jobs.  It is a factory where we teach young people how to be commercially viable.  It isn’t an education in the sense of trying to figure out the world.  Most of my college grad friends can’t even spell Kierkegaard let alone know who in the hell he is.  But that doesn’t matter, as long as you qualify for the job of the future.  It’s a shame really, that we’ve reached a point in our evolution where we have so much information and so little knowledge.  Thanks to reckless enthusiasm we’ve single handedly made three quarters of our population redundant.  And this is progress?

 

I do have a solution to it all, although it is not one many people will be interested in: I’m out.  I hereby remove my hat from the ring.  I no longer have any interest in being commercially viable, I only have interest in a life that is humanistically relevant.  I will write and I will paint and I will probably end up on the street, but I frankly just don’t care anymore.  I refuse to become a medical records clerk because it pays and has dental just because I happen to be good at things no one cares about anymore.  I don’t know, maybe there are others out there who feel the way I do and who are willing to stand up to all of this insanity.  Maybe we can start some kind of cool revolution with a barricade in the street and a guy on top dramatically waving a giant flag.  Most likely though I’ll just end up poor and hungry, but, and here is the important but, not soul crushed and ashamed of myself. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Scott - let me know how this works at dinnertime tonight. It is all so achingly tempting. Nice post.
there is a quote by someone I forget. "school does not exist to educate, it exists to create obedient workers"
....
your lament is very similar to marxist ideas. capitalism as a race to the bottom. it would seem in the US we are really living out marxism every day without admitting it.
what you dont realize in the essay is that there are individuals that are fabulously wealthy & successful in this current system. they are in the minority. the real issue is wealth disparity. and it is very slowly dawning on the public that wealth disparity is not a rule of nature, but in fact an outcome of the dynamics/"rules"/laws of a political/economic system.
I love me a good Revolution!!!!.Im out too.I hearby officially throw my hat( albeit tentativly) out of the ring .Im going to read this again.Great post.
I'm with you! Thanks for this. Wisdom is not a marketable commodity.
Scary. I have been unemployed for over two years after a long career in which I never was out of work, only briefly with babies, my choice. I am slightly over 50, and seem unemployable. I am not ready, though, to pull my hat out. I can find time to be creative after work hours if someone would only see my worth and give me some kind of job!
But, you are so right about the reasons this is happening and how long it has been developing. Very good, thoughtful post.
The world never changed. You just assumed it would.

Even Wikipedia has a link to "starving artist".

At least you're not ugly too.
Maybe we can start a commune on my farm and grow our own food and live off of the land. Bring the solar panels and wind mill though. I'll supply the milk and seed and land.

We "starving artists" have to stick together.
Nice piece. You are not alone.
David Simon told Bill Moyers that America doesn't have use for about 15% of the population, that the economy would only improve if they disappeared. I think that number is rising, not going down.

Another artist whose name I can't remember said, that 'until we make the samba as valuable as the semiconductor' then society is severely limiting the size and quality of it's culture.

My brother is a school administrator trying to introduce mild reforms in some steering commitee, he wants to move away from the 'selective' model and move us to the 'nurturing' model. He is getting flack for wanting to put the word 'curiosity' into the mission statement, the parents say all children don't need it. John Taylor Gatto, and other posters, agree, our school system is for obedience and weeding out, not fostering children.

I wrote him recently that this should be told to the children at a young age, 'Be Very Afraid, This is All a Test, If you are Weeded out You Will Eventually Starve or Hold a Little Caesar's sign."

I would be with you and join an eco village, but don't you know, they only want people with a lot of money.

I have difficulty espousing any allegiance to humanity at this point.
I disagree very strongly with this line:

"Now thanks to the advancement of Adobe Illustrator, anyone can cut and paste their way to a usable logo, advertisement, or even movie poster. The experts now need not apply."

Have you ever used Illustrator? This is not an easy to use program, in fact I often get clients who want me to teach them how to use it.. "so they can do what I do" I have them download a free trial and I wait. Nine times out of ten I get a call a week or so later from them asking for me to complete the work. Adobe Illustrator and Adobe Photoshop are NOT easy to use programs. Just go to Amazon and see all the "how to books" for these applications.

Regardless of "technical" knowledge designs skills are always in demand. Anyone who has technical skills with advanced design applications can find work. Things might be tight right now, but there are many of us (I include my self in this group) who are doing very well using Illustrator and Photoshop to make a very good living... and yes in the middle of the greatest recession of our times.

It's not all doom and gloom! My mortgage is getting paid! and I'm busy.
I see everybody becoming self-employed, and millions of new small businesses springing up. And bartering as well as money being used. If we all have businesses and all use each others businesses we can spring forward. Can't we? I'm sorry you'll be hungry and poor; stop by my house, I'll have a garden and will feed you and in turn, you can sketch something for me to hang on my wall.