Scott Mendelson's Blog

Open Salon's resident movie nerd and box office geek.

Scott Mendelson

Scott Mendelson
Woodland Hills, California, United States
April 02
A ten-year Salon reader, Mendelson also has a film and politics blog/column at Mendelon's Memos: located at: He is also a free lance voice over artist and occasionally contributes film reviews for

Scott Mendelson's Links

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 28, 2011 9:56AM

MPAA: Women enjoying sex = R. Women hating sex: PG-13.

Rate: 14 Flag
There's a choice quote in this Emily Browning interview over at Nylon Magazine, which was reported by Cinemablend that merits a mention.  Its implications are kinda shocking,.  The crux is the discussion of changes that Zach Snyder had to make in order to ensure Sucker Punch (review) would win a PG-13 from the MPAA, which apparently took seven tries.  I'll let Browning lay it out:

"I had a very tame and mild love scene with Jon Hamm. It was like heavy breathing and making out. It was hardly a sex scene... I think that it's great for this young girl to actually take control of her own sexuality. Well, the MPAA doesn't like that. They don't think a girl should ever be in control of her own sexuality because they're from the Stone Age. I don't know what the f**k is going on and I will openly criticize it, happily. So essentially, they got Zack to edit the scene and make it look less like she's into it. And Zack said he edited it down to the point where it looked like he was taking advantage of her. That's the only way he could get a PG-13 (rating) and he said, 'I don't want to send that message.' So they cut the scene!"

I've often defended the MPAA when films are given harsher ratings for breaking clearly-outlined rules (if you have more than one 'f-word', you get an R, period).  I've long argued that the real enemy is the major theater chains that won't screen NC-17 or unrated movies, as well as the major networks and newspapers that won't carry advertising for them.  But this is a clear cut case of the MPAA showing some powerfully puritanical colors. So, just to clarify, it appears that the MPAA had serious issues with the idea that Emily Browning having consensual sexual relations with Jon Hamm, but they had less of an issue with the idea that Jon Hamm was taking advantage of, perhaps even raping Emily Browning.  Let me repeat that one more time: the MPAA was more comfortable with the idea of a young woman raped by an older man than with the idea of a young woman making her own choices in regards to her own sexuality.  I don't even need to further editorialize here.

Scott Mendelson

Your tags:


Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:


Type your comment below:
The very excellent movie: This Film is not Yet Rated goes into terrific detail about this.

thanks for being proof that chromosomes don't make people feminists or not feminists. thinking will do it....

That is ridiculously twisted. Good for Emily Browning for speaking out about it.
My favorite movie Midnight Cowboy was (I think) the only x rated movie to win an Oscar.
The MPAA's rating hypocrisy is sickening. Thanks for an excellent article.
That was an issue between Blue Valentine and Black Swan (I saw neither, yet) in that they both indicated oral sex being performed on the woman. Michelle Williams appeared to be enjoying it and they got an NC-17, instead of the R rating the other got. There was a huge lobby against the decision, which was finally reversed. God forbid they aren't just handing out gratuitous blow jobs- that's family friendly.