Words from another yard

Links and comment from Scott Rosenberg

Scott Rosenberg

Scott Rosenberg
Location
California,
Birthday
June 24
Bio
Salon cofounder and former managing editor, author of "Say Everything" and "Dreaming in Code." Also blogging at wordyard.com. Now working on MediaBugs project (at MediaBugs.org).

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 9, 2011 11:58AM

Sting culture and NPR’s capitulation to falsehood

Rate: 16 Flag

There is much more to say, but I’m angry, and I want to say this quickly: We’re all on notice now. Keep your eyes open and your ears cocked. Public life is becoming a maze of entrapments, and the press is enabling the deceit.

Yesterday James O’Keefe, the conservative trickster who has previously targeted ACORN and other organizations with fraudulent schemes aimed at exposing what he sees as liberal bias and malfeasance, unveiled his latest act: his confederates impersonated Muslim donors and recorded a meeting with an NPR fundraiser, Ron Schiller. Schiller said some impolitic things, some of which were true, others of which were overstatements, none of which was that different from what you can hear in any bar and on any blog. (Unless you believe nobody has ever charged that there are racists in the ranks of the Tea Party, or that anyone has ever suggested NPR might be better off without the federal funding that conservatives are constantly threatening to cut.)

NPR rejected the bogus Muslims’ bogus contribution, but Schiller’s words got him suspended yesterday. And today we learn that NPR’s CEO, Vivian Schiller (no relation), has resigned too.

In a saner cultural moment, a serial liar like O’Keefe would not be taken seriously by the rest of the media or by a board of directors. Here’s why (courtesy TPM):

Previous tapes by O’Keefe’s group have later turned out to be misleadingly edited, including the video that launched them to stardom featuring O’Keefe posing as a pimp in front of ACORN offices, so it’s worth taking the overall footage with a grain of salt until further details emerge. Last year, O’Keefe’s credibility took another major hit when he reportedly tried to invite a CNN reporter onto his boat to try and seduce her as a prank, an effort that was revealed when one of his own colleagues blew the whistle to the press.

But just as the White House dumped Shirley Sherrod the moment Andrew Breitbart’s doctored video of her supposedly damning admission of racism surfaced, NPR’s board chose not only not to fight but to cave in immediately to O’Keefe’s tactics. By not fighting back, NPR has invited an open season on truth, and ushered us into a new age of mistrust.

You should go listen to O’Keefe’s tapes of Ron Schiller’s statements — first, to see that much of what he said is harmless and reasonable, but more important, to ask yourself whether you have any expertise or standing to determine the recording’s authenticity. How can we possibly trust O’Keefe’s reports when the essence of his technique is deception? Who knows how this recording was edited or doctored? Does the phrase “consider the source” mean anything any more?

Sting operations conducted by law enforcement officials have a dubious record themselves, but at least they require oversight and must meet court standards of evidence. For public actors like Jame O’Keefe, the oversight, we assume, is performed by the media. The press prides itself for serving as truth’s first line of defense, democracy’s bullshit filter. This week it failed in a big way.

The larger problem here isn’t Viv Schiller’s ultimate fate, and it’s not even the final disposition of Congressional funding for NPR — an institution I admire in many ways but which, let’s face it, we’d survive without.

The problem is we are crediting creeps and letting liars take over our public discourse.

This is hardly a partisan concern. Roughly similar tactics caused major headaches for Wisconsin’s embattled Republican governor recently, when he got taken in by a caller impersonating conservative billionaire David Koch. (This led Wisconsin’s legislature to start talking about outlawing prank calls.) Increasingly, public deception carries little apparent cost.

If a James O’Keefe can win attention and scalps by ruses and lies, why should he stop? And does any public figure have a big enough megaphone and a strong enough spine to say to him, “Have you no decency”?

BONUS LINK: Jeff Jarvis: ” The stations’ interests and NPR’s interests are no longer aligned.”

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I agree, sort of, with much of what you wrote, but I, for one, could not live without NPR. And I think you have to assume dirty tricks. And, speaking of Ron Schiller, you have to qualify who you are talking to in a professional capacity before you shoot your mouth off--and even then... He was strictly amateur hour. In 25 years in the development profession, I have never seen such indiscretion on the part of a very senior person at the top of the profession.
When will we accept that we're all humans and not slaves to any fixed idea.
Ok, who was the actor who played the part of Schiller in this made for neogoon tv movie?

To bad that woman who o'creep tried to get on the boat so he could needledick her didn't actually get touched so this punk could have been arrested.
The problem is not the video, or who made it. The problem rests only with the person who opened his mouth and proved that he was a fool. Face it, if he had gone to the dinner and just talked straight business, and left out all the stuff that got him in trouble, there would be no video.

You may not like the person who made it. The DA's office will use drug dealers to turn on drug kingpins. Does that mean the DA used lies to convict someone? Maybe. I'll also be willing to bet that before these tapes got put on the air they were frame checked for missing or added frames. So until you find some proof, not what you think or want to believe, I'll go with my own eyes.
Really Mr. Rosenberg! It actually a very old story of opening one's mouth and inserting one's foot. The fact that you agree with him has little influence on the results.
The video WAS doctored, "Bonnie Russell." And Shirley Sherrod didn't have time to object because she was ordered to "pull over" in her car and FAX a resignation. What's at issue is the craven cowardice of the Obama administration in that case ( and I trust you know Ms. Sherrod has launched a lawsuit against that lower life-form known ans Andrew Breitbart) and the craven cowardice of NPR.

This is nothing new from them. They censored Nathan Lee's review of "Outrage" -- Kirby Dick's great documentary about Beltway closet queens -- because Lee dared to mention the subjects of the film. So what they're doing here is scarcely a surprise.

The" Tea Party" is nothing more and nothing less than a coven of elderly white racists -- bankrolled by the Koch brothers. But it's Politically Incorrect to say so.
"The" Tea Party" is nothing more and nothing less than a coven of elderly white racists -- bankrolled by the Koch brothers. But it's Politically Incorrect to say so."

Well, that and it's dead wrong. But I was only in a local Tea Party organization for a whole year and a half and starting from the very first meeting, so what would I know?
What is with people?
The GOP has ideololical man-humpers, staff jumpers, hooker lovers, and supporters of muderers of abortion doctors , and these are just the folks who are in office, that we know of.

And a few stupid and insensitive comments about a POLITICAL PARTY
You know what "meme" to spin "Sgt. Mom."
nice, two paragraphs of 4-5 get posted...nice
the rest wasbacially, pleas folks, there is no stampede of less than pale folks beating a path to the GOP party, and therrhetoric from their leadershiop leaves a logical and drect link by virtue of actions, that say the GOP does in fact have racists and folks who are not "confortable" with the Muslim community, but then again facts and reality are void and unknown to those who use fraud and deception to display their own truths. Hmm, so should all the Bachmans and the Limbaughs resign for their veiled accusations of socialism and open threats of armed conflict if thier ideas are not followed ? The GOP fans the flame of the ignorant the scared and the less tan, it hides behind
the Holy Trinity of the GOP- 6uns-6od-6old
Much is being made over what Schiller said about NPR being able to survive without public funding, but this is something that any development officer would say while trying to reel in a major gift -- especially one of this size "with no strings attached." Nobody wants to give their money to an organization if they believe it could possibly fold. Even those who give to help the poor or victims of disasters need to believe that those organizations that they donate to (Unicef, The American Red Cross, etc.) will be around to distribute the gift to those in need. Instilling confidence that your organization could survive even a worst case scenario is something that development officers find themselves doing more and more these days.

When NPR researched this group, they figured out that it was possibly bogus pretty quickly. If only that research had been requested before Schiller took the meeting.

But sadly, this incident is an argument for more public funding -- not less if you think about it.
The problem I have with all of these "sting" operations is that quite often people say things that are really stupid when they're not expecting to be on tape or camera. I've said a lot of really stupid things over the years, a lot of which I myself don't even agree with, mainly because I don't expect to be called on everything I say, nor do I call everyone else on everything they've ever said. This whole political crap makes life so much harder to live because a lot of the people who end up getting targeted are often not political people (like the first ACORN video).
NPR and PBS are the only decent media still left in this country. The major networks deliver homogenized corporatized "news-lite." NPR and PBS are the only ones who still practice true journalism. I applaud their courage in showing both sides of controversial issues, even if they are very unpopular. It's the only free press still available in this country. That's why the Republicons want to cut funding--because they can't control NPR.

I'm starting to think NPR would be better off without the paltry 2% funding they receive from the government--as long as it doesn't kill them.

If NPR and PBS go away, I will have to resort to listening to BBC World News and Deutsche Welle for objective international news.

Too bad they weren't wise enough to recognize an entrapment scheme when they saw one. I understand PBS was approached by the same group of imposters, but grew suspicious when they couldn't verify their credentials.

Shame on CEO Schiller for capitulating to the neocons and resigning =(
Hmmm. I don't know if it's really accurate to compare the "prank call" to Gov. Scott Walker and what James O'Keefe does. The "prank call" to Walker gave us valuable insight into the character and trustworthiness of a state governor. What of value, exactly, did O'Keefe accomplish?

Finally, I'll add to your post that sleazebag O'Keefe is on probation -- his federal felony charges in relation to his attempted "sting" on Louisiana Sen. Mary Landrieu were reduced to a misdemeanor.

We always should consider the source, indeed.
I am a huge fan of NPR and listen daily to various programs: Fresh Air, Talk of the Nation, All Things Considered, Prairie Home Companion, etc. I would be devastated if they went off the air. I agree with you that this type of guerrilla journalism is not what we need and doesn't serve the public interest. Great Post. R
David E, you'd love it, if it were just a "meme" and I was just "spinning". (Excellent use of skeptical quotes, BTW - but I really was a sergeant and am a mom.) Of course you'd love the Tea Party to have been an astroturf org, cooked up by the GOP, led by whomever and funded by the Koch brothers, who must be the chosen Emmanuel Goldstein of the moment - because then you'd know how to take it down. The fact that it might instead be a libertarian-inspired, leaderless, distributed insurgency of self-directed cells, and there's no possible way to get a choke-chain around all those necks and control it ... That's what scares you and gentlemen like Mr. Schiller most of all, I think. That you don't really, really know ... and that there IS no way for the usual powers to exert control over a leaderless, distributed, popular insurgency. So, hug that GOP-Koch Bros-Astroturf belief to you like a security blanket, if it comforts you. Free country and all.
ACORN manifested systemic corruption, misfeasance, malfeasance, arrogance, voter fraud, and, as per an internal ACORN review: "long-standing management weaknesses, including a lack of training, a lack of procedures and a lack of on-site supervision."

O'Keefe EXPOSED ACORN, because the main-stream press would not. See the LA Times editorial from March 24, 2010. Even the Times smelled a rat in ACORN. Your trying to depict O'Keefe as somehow tricking ACORN is a tip-off to where you're going, and the rest of the piece confirms it.
Let's get the record straight on the public funding thing: Ron Schiller said long term NPR could make it without public funding. Meaning, given seven to ten years of a concentrated initiative to get more individual subscribers on board with sustaining memberships, a concentrated national initiative (in the works) to do more outreach, more corporate, foundation and organizational support, a comprehensive campaign and maybe some some luck with a planned giving windfall, the network might be able to make up most or all of of the funding it now gets from the government. This is an entirely reasonable proposition, if still a daunting goal. Schiller said that if federal funding were cut now--and he said it covers 10% of the budget of the entire network, all-in, little station budgets included--that lots of (primarily rural) small stations would go "dark." But try to message that, in all its detail, to the bozos on the bus.
It will be taken down wghen the Koch brothers are taken down -- and Fat Tony Scalia and House Nigger Clarence Thomas along with them.

I'm a 64 year-old black gay man who has seen things you can't possibly imagine, so can the fucking blather about what "scares" me. To quote John Garflield in "Body and Soul" (written by my late friend Abraham Polonsky) "What are you going to do? Kill me? Everybody dies."
@TheBadScot
You've got game, but I call Bullshit on your ACORN rant. Mr. O'Keefe created a fiction from whole cloth with his ACORN pimp video. A fiction that was investigated by multiple Law Enforcement officials and found to be a big fat lie. ACORN may have been inefficiently managed, but there is no reason to conclude they were criminal. Mr. O'Keefe on the other hand is a criminal and a liar whom you apparently trust despite the evidence of his dishonesty.
Anthony, baby, did I use the word "criminal" anywhere? ACORN was a mess, O'Keefe exposed it. (Malfeasance is unlawful activity, but not necesarily "criminal". ACORN'S voter registration drive--registering bogus voters--comes to mind)
@TheBadScot
Voter registrations that came to light because ACORN followed the law and turned in the applications they were presented with and flagged those they found to be suspicious. Yet another bogus accusation.
I think the idea of public radio and TV is a good one. But, being public it should be totally funded by the public that listens or watches. If it is funded by the government (even in part) then the public has lost control.

It is time for NPR to bite the bullet and sever ties with the political process. If the listeners want to keep it on the air then they will pay to do so. That way NPR will be beholden to the public not the a government that swings left and right depending on the the political climate.
Hmmm, so the public radio, should be funded solely by the public who watches it, then the same should be said about all religious groups who get tax breaks, as they should not get funds, not have tax breaks covered by the public, who do not believe in their dogma. So goes the subsidies for corporations, who offer public stock, since they don't need tax breaks , as it is a fund your own casue ideology you GOP's have right?
let them spend their own funds from their own supporters, not the tax money all citizens put in.
This is the idea I see from you folks who just hate the fact that some money (which could easily be covered by responsible tax payers portions put in to the same tax base you tightwads contribute to) who like freedom and free speech and freedom of ideas and educational television for the children. But ideology and political obedience and zombie mentality prevails yet again in the mindless walk to the end of days so many of you GOP junkies get your fixes from.
just yet again the, kill the free thinking and hope reality and true virues get forgotten clan, dumbing down the nations sheeples and praying to the profits, not the Prophets, while claiming reliogous superiority and moral highground. UHM, NOT, but maybe some of you folks must be high, if you think this is in any way what justice, fairness and freedom of expression means.
I would comment on spending taxpayer dollars for media and the arts but am too busy reading the canon of timeless Soviet literature and viewing the "best of Soviet art" that resulted from state control of the media and the arts.
OK now, have finished the canon of state sponsored art, took only a minute or so. Where were we?
I don't know where YOU are, but I'm still watchig "Battleship Potemkin," "Storm Over Asia," "Arsenal," and "The Man With a Movie Camera."

Not up to the level of Michael Bay I know but they're pretty damned good.
"Meaning, given seven to ten years of a concentrated initiative to get more individual subscribers..."

After 40 years they can't make it, but just give the another 7-10 years. If they can't make it after all these years how is another 10 years going to help? Why couldn't they have done that10 years ago?
It's a pretty sad thing. The Tea Party is a bunch of racists. Oddly enough, you just can't say it. Schiller had already given his two week notice too. How can this possibly be such a big deal? Sherrod Brown had to apologize for saying that "Stalin and Hitler" sought to eliminate unions. It was factually correct, except for the fact that Lenin did it before Stalin had the chance. The point is instructive. Just like the fact that the Tea Party is a bunch of bigots. Now we may lose NRP, and gain more O'Keefes, and Breitbarts, and the like. Unreal.
After the well-publicized Acorn stunt, it's incredible and dishearteneing that anyone would rush to judgment over anything from the same source. And as you say, expect more of the same. This is Salemization.
True Believers ARE idiots. You're proof of that "Bonnie Russell." They're racists too.

Now go home and wash your hood like a good girl.
catnliar: "but just give the another 7-10 years."

WTF does THAT mean, penis breath?
He was actually right the tea party is a cult as Mahar I think says in public. But the bigger problem is the lack of real media trying to do a good job instead we have a situation where the rich routinely try to entrap the poor and it will lead to an even bigger income gap and virtual slave state or a collapse in society unless the media is reformed.
This is absolutely correct:
"The" Tea Party" is nothing more and nothing less than a coven of elderly white racists -- bankrolled by the Koch brothers. But it's Politically Incorrect to say so."

And so are those hateful ANTI-American idiotic traitors who support them.
For those who have not had their ears to the ground regarding long-term national public radio funding strategies, I just received an email from Minnesota Public Radio stating:

"That’s why we’ve set a goal of doubling the number of members who support MPR in the next year."

It took them more than 35 years to get to the membership number they have today. They now want to double that in a year. Note: they have not failed on any of their previous goals. The longtime CEO here is leaving MPR to lead a national effort to increase membership support.

Clearly, public radio has seen the handwriting on the wall.
Why isn't O'Keefe in jail already? As for Schiller, he's the kind of twit that gives Liberals a bad name.

What I wanna see are the tapes of meetings between Jack Abramof and Tom DeLay, between SoT Hank Paulsen and Lloyd Blankfein, between Don Rumsfeld and Saddam Hussein (back when Rummy was peddling him WMD, between Rove and whomever orchestrating the firing of DoJ attorneys, and most of all I want to see the tapes of Bush and Cheney telling Tenet to cook the books on the Iraq War and Cheney and Addington telling Yoo to concoct the torture memos.