AUGUST 17, 2009 2:06PM

Killed Bill: I Didn't Want to Write on Health Care, Dammit!

Rate: 79 Flag

Michael Steele appeared on some newschat today to congratulate the barbarians at the gate. He helpfully informed us that the “47 million uninsured” were really only “more like 18” or so million. Well, yeah.

 

Was it really six million or only five-point-five?

 

Let’s set aside the millions, Mike. Let’s talk about one person.

 

Me.

 

I am uninsured, Mikey. I am also uninsurable. I have diabetes, which I discovered after I developed a problem walking. That really impacted my job, Mike. And I also discovered I am hypertensive—like tick-tick-tick hypertensive.

 

Currently I am on a five-dollar medication that sometimes seems to work, because the hundred-dollar medication that actually works is a mite out of my price range. And I wonder how long this will go on. If the doctor comes to require me some tests to determine how to continue to treat my condition, I can’t afford them. A lot of doctors will refuse to treat people who can’t afford blood tests, because they can’t be sure what the medications are now doing to you.

 

Rush Limbaugh says right now we have the best health care in the world. He’s right; there is no Soviet equivalent. But that health care is in a glass case: you can’t get to it. I’m sure Rush has no problem—he could afford to go through a cancer regimen out-of-pocket, he makes $20 mil a year.

 

They all tell me under medicine socialista that my health care will be rationed. Dear hearts, it is already rationed. It is not accessible to me. I cannot afford test strips or my finger-gepoken device. And it is difficult for a single middle-aged male to wade onto the Medicare rolls, rest assured.

 

The laymen tell me, “Well you can go to an emergency room, they can’t refuse treatment.” No, they can’t refuse emergency treatment. Great place to if you need a spear removed. Or even if you have a sore throat. They don’t hand out test strips there either. And they will—even at three in the morning—send a payment office geek down to inquire as to why you have a four-hundred dollar balance on a previous test. Doctors don’t make house calls, but hospital collection agents nearly do. In fact, they are generally more attentive than ER doctors.

 

I watched my Mom’s last dollar swallowed up by Mammon Memorial Hospital. She had a stroke, then a string of cardiac incidents. I can’t tell you how many nights I wearied away in those waiting rooms. I actually outlined a novel in a hospital lobby one night. Don’t tell MMH: they’ll want a royalty if I ever sell it.

 

She was treated on decreasing ledges of quality care based on her ability to pay. She was subject to lectures and life-evaluations by cornpone healers and their bagmen (and women).

 

My own current economic pratfall was—as is all too common—occasioned by the unfolding treatment bills. You need an agent of your own (and perhaps a lawyer) at your side to explain, calculate, spind, and mutilate the minutiae of what your lavishly-rewarded insurer won’t actually pay for. Oh, they have that yearly deductible, but on that casual thyroid test, they pay almost nothing on a surprise thousand dollars. You find out you are not covered when you thought you were. “Didn’t you consult subparagraph b on page 611?”

 

Yesterday I watched Glenn Beck tremblingly hold up an Internet print-off of a Nazi-era poster explaining the Nazi philosophy of the cost-ratio of treating the infirm. He began, once again, to tear up. “This hand reminds me of my…little daughter…she has…Cerebral Palsy…” Of course. And we know about the Death Panels, who are going to eyeball the cost-ratio of the quick and the dead.

 

We already have functioning Death Panels, Glenn. They’re called Insurance Companies. They decide who is a cost-risk and who isn’t. They deny treatments; they end lives.

 

I’m not going to dump it all on the town hall howlers, either. Sure, they have funny accents and talk to Jesus. It’s fair enough for them to have, and express, opinions. And I also thought the way those opinions were expressed would be self-illustrative. “Are you the member of a gang?” Sean Hannity asks a guest “Great American.”

 

I’m a born again Christian!” the man who made monkey arms at Senator Spector trumpets. He then starts pulling newspaper clippings out of his pockets and rifling through them. Ai yi yi. Even Hannity looked worried. Cut to the B Roll.

 

I don’t like the opportunistic Mr. Spector. Magic Bullet Theory indeed. I don’t like Senators in general. But even my pity was moved for Spector when that Born-Again was shambling towards him like a Lovecraftian entity. It is true that politicians need to be yelled at: they need to feel our pain. But it looks like most of us haven’t done any of the yelling. Woody Allen was right: baseball bats are more effective against Nazis than a sharp piece in the Times.

 

…Feel a little betrayed? The same people who were snickering twenty-minutes ago about “supermajorities” and “filibuster-proof” and “the death of the Republican Party” are now telling us they can’t get the public-option done because of “obstructionist Republicans.”

 

Wha-aa-aa? Did I miss a midterm election?

 

No. We have some rats in the bed. We have people who have traded private interests against the public good. You knew where the Republicans stood.

 

I did get fooled again. I thought the public option was bulletproof. I in no way liked the involvement of the IRS in its “enforcement” and, frankly, my longtime left-winger bud has worked out a better payment plan on his free time as a hobby. But I was tending towards supporting any plan that would give me any health care.

 

Many of the status quo folks asked, “Do you really believe Obama could get you health care without raising taxes?” Even Obama admitted he would raise taxes on the “most wealthy” to pay for the plan!

 

Come closer, I have to whisper.

 

I would be willing to pay more taxes for health care. Shhh!

 

Yes, I don’t even expect Steven Spielberg to carry me. I would be willing to pay more taxes for health care. It’s worth it to me.

 

That is the greatest kept secret of the whole debate. It’s a question not a single person has asked (that I’ve heard)!

 

Would you be willing to pay more taxes to um—live longer, and not live in pain?

 

Glenn Beck, holding a Nazi poster sadly and invoking euthanasia.

 

How many people have you helped kill with this killed bill, Glenn?

 -30- 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Totally with you on this, Scoub. Messed up country we live in.
Wow! You're a hell of a writer Scoubi, and this is as great an epitaph for the end of "Yes We Can" and the public option as I'm likely to read anywhere. If Zerry and the gang had any cojones (or appreciation of excellent writing) at all this would go on the cover; I wonder if they'll man up and put it there?
I am as mad as hell guys--AND I CAN'T DO ANYTHING!
We're completely fucked. We've always been fucked really, or at least for the last couple decades, but this is the nail in the coffin as far as I'm concerned. Everybody strap yourselves in for the plummet into third-rate-nation status.
Owl, how is it we live in the richest country in the world and can't even participate in its society?

Nanatehay, I wouldn't want to push off all those reviews of the Mad Men season opener ;-D
Drew-Silla, Third World, we are there!!
You're right Scoubs. We wouldn't want to take up space that could be used for cooking shows or "So You Think You Can Dance." I don't know what I was thinking:P
Rated and I empathize. I am sorry.
I too have wondered how we went from: "the Republicans are dead" to "It's the Republicans fault public-option failed."

I am insured but I STILL can not afford to get sick. A few months ago I suffered a stroke. My doctor went crazy ordering all kinds of tests and meds and I finlly had to say: "WHOA". Hell even 20% of those kinds of bills are out of my reach...so what good is the insurance?
I have been home three days now, having suffered another...mini stroke...this time, not a major one. I have not gone to the doctor...I still can't afford to jump through his hoops. So I guess you and I are in pretty much the same boat.
oh lord, this is a powerful piece. you can write, dude. you can write write write. and i feel your pain. my husband's bills for the pancreatic cancer treatment that he didn't survive were like 500,000 dollars or more. we lost our house, we lost everything. then i lost him. i know so much more now, but almost no one survives that disease. and god, i know what you mean about paying taxes for health care. i go to a PA at a poor people's clinic. she's wonderful, but god forbid my brian tumor comes back. the major medical complex here in portland doesn't take medicare!!!!!! the main huge medical hospital where all kinds of research is done and behavioral health clinics -- i'm bipolar 2 and panic disordered -- are there and they don't take the medicare that i have. i can't even think about it because i get so angry. i'm so sorry about your diabetes and your not being able to afford the strips. shit. that's insane. love love love and gratitude for your superb writing and your honesty and pathos.
Everybody needs to read this post. I see "empathy" in your tags; that's something in short supply in this country, as every deluded town hall pawn and corporate interest there is scrambles madly to maintain a status quo that consigns millions to "we don't give a fuck about you" status.
i love your voice. this is priceless, "But even my pity was moved for Spector when that Born-Again was shambling towards him like a Lovecraftian entity"

fox is feeding them. they feed our insurance dead babies, while they claim to be pro-life. they feed our hospitals the poor elderly, struck down before their time because they came to health care too late. victims of our system that will only take notice of catastrophe, but not the walking wounded.

why won't open salon emphasize our voices similarly? they may believe it is maturity that keeps such fights sequestered, off the cover, but that maturity will kill us all if we lose this.
"Would you be willing to pay more taxes to um—live longer, and not live in pain? "

ONLY if the Indian Health Service is either completely abolished OR everyone who is WHITE is forced to use it EXCLUSIVELY.
Wow, Torman and T'L--I fear for you guys. And I don't know what to do. This is the PROOF that our system does not work, because at this point we are not much more advanced than Victorian London.

Why doesn't the Limbaugh Brigade see that the exclusion of the many is NOT a national success story, that the selfish aquisition of wealth is in itself not a noble thing? If I hear one more prancing warble about "the Founding Fathers didn't intend for this," I am going to scream. Pardon, but the Founding Fathers didn't use toliet paper and their greatest intellect stood around in storms hanging kites. Those guys were barely better than savages. Sorry, but it's true. It's time we grew up and took responsibility for founding our own futures.
MrsRaptor, seems to me we all ought to have the same level of health care. If anybody's getting shorted--and I know it wouldn't be the first time--that needs to be swiftly birched.
No argument from me, scoubi--only thing I can add is to Ms. Raptor. IHS is a disgrace--and why we still have that instead of rolling everyone into the same system is beyond me. I truly believe that as long as all the government officials had to use whatever we did, and had to give the same percentage of their income to get it, THEN we'd truly have the best health care system in the world.
This is so so so so so so so so excellent. Times ten. Times ten hundred.

Damn.

Did I make up the memory that you're in Ohio? In Boehner's district by any chance?
putting this on digg...
scoubidou--

IHS is the OTHER government run health care program, the one that politicians NEVER talk about. It provides what can best be described as "third world" medical care to the Indigenous People of the US.
Dayna... I figure that the ONLY way that we are going to get rid of IHS (and I have written a couple of blogs about just how abysmal IHS medical care is) is to either make everyone use it OR do away with it completely. I just can't see the folks in DC getting rid of IHS... it's the only government run health care that actually operates at a surplus.
Scoubi... would you consider re-titling this? Maybe something like:
" Mad Men Fall Off American Idol Stage and Top Chef Contestant Tests Positive for Diabetes!"?

Something like that, so you get a cover placement?
We in Canada pay for our (universal single-payer) health care thru taxes. It costs us (other people have blogged the figures) a minute fraction more as cost per capita for us than for you. And we cover everyone. Why people are willing to pay by way of for-profit insurance companied I'll never understand...
All politicians who are elected are subject to a mandatory operation which is covered by an excellent health plan. I don't know the medical term, but basically the doctor surgically removes your spine.
I just heard the house of reps is going to pass a bill with a public option. WTF? I'm so confused. These are troubling times... my type II is acting up. rAted!
I've been to two town hall meetings -- one of which I wrote about on OS -- and one thing is for sure: conservatism is dead. Today the style "conservative" means nothing more than a bunch of cranky old people demanding UNLIMITED taxpayer-funded medical interventions via our socialized healthcare system for the elderly, all the while railing about the evils of "socialized medicine" and screaming "euthanasia" at anyone who tries to introduce a modicum of fiscal sanity to the system.

And all the while never bothering to ask whether all this relentless medicating is doing them any net good.

http://open.salon.com/blog/xylocopa/2009/08/10/theyre_as_mad_as_heck_and_theyre_not_gonna_take_it_anymore
Scoub,

I have some friends. They're cool and really good people. But at the end of the day, they don't know me. Not many people do unfortunately. However I envision us hanging out having real conversations that provide intellect, depth and a core understanding of our surroundings. I know at the very least that you would understand me and I would probably let you.

Now for this.

I think I've commented on this issue until I was blue in the face. I even went so far as to formulate a semi comprehensive rant on my own blog space concerning this.

Imagine for just a moment that we found a cure for cancer. Not a specific cancer, but all cancers. Take a moment and just think that through. Thousands upon thousands of lives every year saved and made better as a result.

Now take a moment and think of what would happen to our unemployment rate in this country. Think about all the privately owned hospitals that are listed on the stock exchange. Think about how many jobs would be lost, how many hospitals would fold and oh..most importantly..how many stocks would tumble to the ground.

This is not a fight against republicans, blue dog democrats or people who still enjoy having the confederate flag prominently displayed above their sofa. This is a fight against the insurance companies that know that the world they they live in will no longer be with a public option. Much like the pharmaceutical companies and hospital institutions. When money is on the line, you will pay in blood.

The fear I have is not only in the health care system. That's just one piece. But let's look at everything from the 'Nabisco Oreo Sugar Bowl' to soft drink companies bartering deals with elementary schools to have their Coke Classic in the vending machines..In return, the school receives free text books with references to 'Suzie had 4 Sprites(tm) and gave bobby one Sprite(tm)..How many does suzie have left?

This has all been happening in front of our eyes since the 80's and now when it comes to our lives being directly affected, we've all decided to dust off our asses and get vocal.

I rarely believe that things are too little and too late. However in order for us as a society to get a grip as to what's happening, we're going to need to start thinking outside the box as to what exactly America has become. If you have to fasten on your tin foil hat, please do so, but for god's sakes, please look beyond the fact than making phone calls to our representatives is our viable option.

If I'm a shallow asshole in a place of power getting paid 2 million a year to defend blue cross blue shield and start up contrived town hall meetings..well you can bet my shallow ass is going to stand and deliver for you.

I joked with Nan several weeks ago about the fact that I was looking forward to seeing Robocop in the flesh. But really..how far removed are we from a future where corporations will run our cities and governments completely? Well it's already happening.

Why do I fear this when I'm way up here in podunk nowhere, Canada? Because Canada has always been about 7 to 10 years behind the US and it's only a matter of time for us as well. To provide some clarity, I see regular officers now in a town of 5,000 where the last time someone was killed here, I think it was due to someone getting shot by a farmer for stealing eggs, wearing full battle gear on a regular basis. They could go as is into Iraq right now and fit right in.
Every single word you wrote. Yes. This. All of it. Tax me, baby, tax me.

They can't possibly tax more than I make--which is sure as shit something you CAN'T say about medical billing.
uninsured and uninsurable here too- well, at least until I get a job that offers benefits, since I can only get insured as part of a group package :/
I also want us to start having at least a month vacation every year like Europe. Healthy is only partially fixable by medication and readily available health care- simply lowering the stress on the average American would dramatically increase the quality of life.
This is one of the most powerful things I have read on health care - especially that secret you whispered. And guess what? I WOULD PAY MORE TAXES, TOO, FOR HEALTH CARE FOR EVERYONE. My sister has been trying to find insurance for the past 5 years, she and her husband waiting to have a baby until she was covered, waiting until she is now almost 40 and pretty soon she'll just have one and the government will end up paying for it. Thanks for sharing your story.
Excellent and rated. And yes, it SHOULD be on page one!
rats in the bed indeed.... man o man scoubidou. haven't seen it summed up so succinctly as you have here... and I've tried my own self as have so many others. something gotta give
:( Well written and well spoken. When people can't afford the basic needs such as medical help, then there is something wrong with the system.

I watched a woman yesterday, a coworker of mine, almost pass out, because under the new prescription plan we're under at work, she can't afford to buy the pills to keep things in check like her blood pressure.

Rated. And Tink picked.
This is a great piece, unfortunately born from your painful experience. I too, would be willing to pay more in taxes for a public option, and I have insurance. It's the right thing to do, and it's worth it for me so that I don't have to worry myself silly about my or my family's future health insurance.

denese
This is just as clear and on point as anything I've read. I'd love a chance to put some jerk like Beck in a room with you and listen to him try to explain away what you're saying. Thanks for sharing your harsh truth with all of us. We'll keep fighting the good fight.
Thanks to nanatehay who steered me to your post. Well said without a hint of victimization or "poor me". Just stating the facts. Clear. Realistic. Thank you for sharing. And feeling powerless is a terrible way to feel. And yet, so many are.
Excellent. And on the money~~
Rated~~
A point I keep hammering away at here on OS: right now, 58% of all health care expenses in this country are born by the taxpayers. On a per capita basis. that's more than all but three other countries. In plain English, we're spending more per capita on health care than Canadians do -- why can't we have the kind of health care Canadians have?

It's not a matter of asking for a handout. It's just a matter of demanding our tax dollars that we're ALREADY paying be spent in a rational manner.
I'm so sorry for you.....I'm so sorry for all of us...
Sorry for my delay in getting here. I have been gone most of the day. I suggested to Kevin Lee to start a website and invite the American public to submit their health care horror stories. Between both of your experiences and exceptional talent, I can't imagine that a publisher would not be running to the printing press. And (as usual) Manchu Wok has it pretty much all figured out. All this genius, all this talent, all this heartache and the powers that be seem to miss the point again and again. Hugs to you scoub.
Thank you for this voice - Thanks for posting this.

peece,
dj
As a person who pays over $550 a month for private insurance, YES! I would pay higher taxes to see that number come down!
Where do Libs go when we get pissed off at getting traded off for the lobbyists? Where is OUR fucking backlash?
Okay, first of all, Glenn Beck did not shed a single tear. Yes, he cries but tears are conspicuously absent. Do you ever watch those true crime shows when the poor guilty widow cries but her mascara stays miraculously intact? That's Simple Glenn, who greedily grabs that extra "n" when one will do. Of course, I'm a skeptic.

More taxes for healthcare, so what? So it goes to taxes instead of insurance, same same. In the long run it's less money than we're already spending.

PS - I stolt the extra "n" comment from my brilliant wife.
I could be wrong on this but I believe that the Republicans and Blue dogs are blocking this in committee in the Senate. It will be dropped out of the senate bill and then added back in again when the two houses marry their bills. While I am not holding my breath, I am hoping that this proves to be true. At that time the dems will have enough votes to pass whatever they have come up with and have no excuses for leaving us behind.
It's quite disappointing. Everyone needs good health care. It's not like the person walking by you on the street, or their kids or the person handing you back your change at any store, or the person cleaning houses, or the one doing the dishes in back of the restaurant--or the people picking your veggies and fruits don't get sick--and it won't affect anyone in the community.

They should have gone for expanding medicare--making it available for anyone who is uninsured. And yeah, I'd pay more taxes for that.
You are phenominal, and you are so so right! I am taging this an sending it to everyone I can, and posting it on facebook. Our current system is criminal.
This is harrowing. What a jacked up situation when a miserable minority of dumb people can hijack one of the greatest movements forward in our time.

They can party tonight, but if we keep this up and grow some spines, ourselves, we will put the food back on the table where it belongs.

Rated! Zumapick!
Yowwww! An eloquent and gut wrenchingly real testimony on why we need healthcare.
White light.
Rated and Facebooked by Forever Mom. Even on Medicare she pays over $400/month on medicare, supplemental medical insurance + prescription ins + $100/month on prescription co-pays.
Thank you all, I can't even begin to do justice to these wonderful comments. As you all may have noticed, I generally avoid politics. But this is so fundamental to our common survival that I had to yelp. My sense of...desolation on this point has become profound.

Indeed I wonder where OUR backlash can be totaled. This debate has run aground on sheer emotional appeals in which the greatest emotional crisis has been discounted. Instead we get craziness with old Nazi posters and other irrelevant fear-mongering.

A lot of people have been attributing this horror to "far right forces." As said, we have a lot of rats that aren't normally part of those forces, but they do love those lovely campaign contributions. Let's take names. Let's remember that the "far right forces" also have actual names, as with "double-nickels" Glenn Beck. Let's remember who these people are...and, uh, what they have done for America.

Some of you have commented on why Dog gets Digged, but never makes it to the front page. Don't sweat it. You are my strength.
The editing on this site is for shit if this isn't on the cover. Sorry Kerry, but you blew it here. [rated]
Heck, I'm not rich by any stretch, but I'd be willing to pay more taxes so more folks could be insured...bleeding heart liberal that I am...rated!!!
Thank you so much for sharing your story. There's a million sotires out there just like this one! God forbid the insurance companies, private hospitals and drug companies have to give up profits so that lives could be saved! Excellent writing.
Your infirmity has not interfered with your common sense, nor your cogent ability to put it into words that all but a congressman can understand.
I would be willing to pay more taxes for health care. Shhh!

Me, too. I already pay 15% of my gross earnings for health care insurnace with a $1000 deductible. I just had a series of exams for which nothing was paid, so adding my deductible into the 15%, I will be payikng at least 17.5% for my health care related insurance and expenses this year.

I am one of the "lucky" insured but one of ___% (who knows?) that are paying for expensive insurance that covers nothing?

Oh, yes, hopefully, if I need major medical, my battle with the Russian roulette of "will I be dropped" gives me better than a 1 in 6 odds of staying insured during a major illness. If I thought about this too much, I might just make myself sick enough to need my insurnace -- it is called "STRESS" guys. What a racket....
Up is down, left is right, and a ranking of 37th makes Americans' health care the best in the world.

I second the cover suggestion to our editors.
Creatures like Puss Limbaugh and Steve King, both of which have personality problems which should be treated by psychiatrist, but instead prefer to vent themselves on the radio instead of the pschiatrist couch.

I say the Public Option or Civil War!
A couple of things--
Public option needs to be in any health care reform legislation.
I'm with Myriad on the single payer system.
And I agree that this should have been a cover but unfortunately the writer's name doesn't have a planet in it or a PHD after it and it wasn't a lameass TV show review so it obviously didn't merit a cover.
WHOA! What a passionate piece of writing! And yes, you touched upon the most important part of this whole debacle: the need for the people to speak up and demand reform.

I hate to sound cheesy after your eloquent article, but why other countries seem to have health care and a better way of life is that over there, as it should be here, "the people shouldn't be afraid of their government, the Government should be afraid of the People".
Completely righteous, I have nothing to add. I'm scared as hell. What happened to the crackdown on lobbyists(or should I be laughing at that line)?
Hot damn, you hit the nail on the head. Nails, I mean. There's so much here that rings true--the sellout Dems, the fact that rationed care already exists, the worthiness of health care as something to pay more for. You rock.
Good stuff. I've reddited, stumbleuponed, and digged it.

It is a very important story to tell. People scream "rationing" but they don't realize that rationing is already here. People like you have been dealing with rationing for a long time now.
Great writing and quite a post. The next time you write your elected officials it is time to tell them that we have a constitutional right to health care, it is in the preamble, "Promote the General Welfare" right along with common defense, domestic tranquility and justice, all things that we provide at the national level with government agencies, the military, the police and the courts.

Let's take the rational road here and use the Constitution as is it proves the point clearly, we can use the document for more than protecting the rights of AK-47 dealers.
so fucking rated

this exact thing you describe just happened to my best friend and I am too sickened for words

the death panels are here right NOW and so many people still don't want to see it
Scoubi, I have no doubt that a government heath care would benefit you. I also have no doubt that it will take away from others to provide to you.
I too am uninsurable should I lose what I have. My health absolutely sucks and it is just for that reason that I DO NOT want to depend o the government to take care of me.

Would I pay taxes. Yes I would pay tax for help someone like you to get insurance like mine. I WOULD NOT pay taxes so that you and I (and everyone else) can both be on a government plan.

There is no doubt that a gov plan would reduce my level of care. I do not believe that it is a necessary for many to be brought down to bring others up. I think that you situation can be improved significantly without my going down significantly.

I just don't happen to believe that that will happen under any notion that Obama has. No doubt you would immediately benefit, but can you see the possibility that in the long run it will just be fucked up for everyone? You will get your $100 pill for now. Then over time we will both get the $50 pill and we will both be fucked.

I am not against everyone getting medical treatment. I just happen to strongly believe that the gov. will totally fuck it up.

Is it just possible that many people are against this not because they are cruel or to cheap t pay taxes, but because that truly think things will be worse than better. Well I am one of them.

For all you supporters here, can you truthfully tell me that you are totally confident that you situation wont get worse? Are you so sure that a few specific reforms wouldn't be better than gov takeover of the system?

How about this. Clean up the waste and corruption in MediCare and then offer a similar plan to younger people that really need it, tax as necessary, and then leave everyone else alone.
I am absolutely certain that it would be cheaper and better for everyone for me to help you pay for an insurance policy (and you would get one, just like every retired person gets Medicare now.) than it would be to have the gov run it and it be "free"
Joseph, I am always the wrong person to ask, "Do you think things can't get worse?" I have a perfect faith that things will always get worse. And they have; that is why we are discussing health care.

This is no longer a poverty-only issue. I have a friend making $45,000 a year, with three kids. He works for a too-small business which cannot negotiate affordable insurance. So his children have $4,000 deductibles each. About 18% of his income is eaten up by insurance costs. Does that sound like an American success story?

Ask yourself this, when you are afraid of a health care parity, rather than a reward for productivity. Are private retirement accounts still offered since the advent of social security? Do private schools exist since we have public-option education? Those private versions, for those who can afford them, are as cushy as ever.

I'm not perfectly enamored of the current health care plan. I made some of my concerns plain in this column. And I also respect your concerns. You sound thoughtful on the matter. I certainly do not want to imitate an English bureaucracy, but I do think health care affordability will now have to be maintenanced by the government. Let's face it, the golden goose tends to kill itself exuberantly, and the government has to clean up the mess.
Excellent piece, scoubs -- closer to a baseball bat than a sharp piece in the Times.
Great writing. Found today and rated, as well as send along to friends. You have a great skill and are using it well.