Sgt. Mom

Sgt. Mom
Location
San Antonio, Texas,
Birthday
February 21
Bio
Retired military, novelist and mother, sucker for animals and homebody

Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 1, 2009 10:27AM

The Perils of POD Publishing

Rate: 7 Flag

Strictly speaking, unless your last name is Grisham or King, Steele or Rowling or any other scribbling royalty lurking meaningfully on or near the of the NY-Times best seller lists, life is bleak and full of frustrations. And also very short of people who are nice to you as a writer and welcoming to you and your books. No wonder so many of them turn to drink, or otherwise crash and burn. Even the flash in the pan overnight successful ones fall to this -  Grace Metalious, anyone?

Those of us at the bottom, toiling and marketing in obscurity take our little successes where we can, lonely beacons shining in a dark and generally frustrating world. Everyone who reads the Book and loves it, or recommends it to a friend, or drops a favorable comment in an on-line forum; that's a light like Erandil in the dark places of the day. Not quite up there with royalty checks in three figures, but the trick to being happy is to be happy with what you have.

A couple of months ago,  I found a comment in a discussion forum about off-road vehicles; a contributor quoted a bit from To Truckee's Trail about storage arrangements in Dr. Townsends' wagon and drew a very neat parallel between that, and how modern off-roaders now install storage for long treks -  that just about made my evening. Such crumbs as do nourish the writers' ego on these long winter evenings after looking at my ranking on Amazon.com. ( All my books are available in the Kindle format, by the way, for those who love expensive toys - but none of the reviews for the printed editions carry over to the Kindle version.  No idea from the admin responses in the author forum as to why -  just another way that the non-royal scribblers are incessantly kicked in the teeth by a cold and unfeeling world.)

Ah, yes -  reviews; absolutely necessary to obtain,  in order to market your book. Think of them as word of mouth made solid and permanent in print. In the grand halls of the literary industrial complex, competition is fierce to review the books of the scribbling royalty and the well-connected commentariat; even so, it will take months. Almost always, the book is made available to a select few way in advance, and rumor has it that sometimes reviewers are paid and quite healthy sums too. It's a necessary step in marketing the book, think of all those lovely complimentary quotes on the back jacket, or in the first couple of pages.

At a lower level - naturally the one occupied by other indie authors  - reviewers are also paid ...  by getting a free copy of the book. It's one of those nice little freebies available to those in the loop and I confess to having scored a nice little collection thereby. (I asked to review a book a couple of years ago,  for no other reason that I looked at the description and thought what a wonderful Christmas present a copy would make for a certain friend.) The suspicion is, however - that many sooper-high-powered reviewers for certain outlets are getting tons of copies of books, working up a cursory review from the cover copy or the information kit that came with the book, posting that review, and selling the books. Not cool - at least I have read the books I review, cover to cover.

It took months and months over the summer of 2007  to assemble my collection of reviews, for Truckee's Trail, which pushed back my marketing plan by a considerable period. Good thing that it was a POD book, as a traditional publisher would have pulled the plug by the time one single fiscal quarter had passed. Oddly enough, even though I am not doing that much to market it, these days - it still sells respectably. On the other hand, a traditional publisher would have been able to squeeze a review out of the San Antonio Express News, whose book editor informed me snottily that their policy is not to review POD books of any sort, not even by local authors. Don't know what their reasoning is, probably afraid of getting literary cooties or something. God knows there are some simply dreadful books out there, but last time I looked, quite a lot of them came out of the traditional publishers. Indie writing may be the next wave, just as indie movies and indie music have offered an alternative to the traditional Hollywood blockbuster and the manufactured and wholly synthetic mega-hit. And most writers these days have websites, and sample chapters posted - at the very least, the "Search Inside" feature on Amazon. com - so, figuring out if they are good writers, or at least OK and you want to read more -  is not this great insurmountable challenge.

Gosh, it's fun, being on the cutting edge!

 

Author tags:

literary, books, writing

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
sgt mom - glad your sales are respectable and you dont need to give a damn what that damn snotty paperwoman says.

i stole your line and made it my banner, bc i am really really trying to learn how to be happy again.
Good for you, Sarge. Any interesting or quirky but untested idea or author isn't going to be given much time to develop a following. I certainly hope the concept of taking matters into one's own hands and loses its stigma. If you publish and you sell, it doesn't matter (and shouldn't matter) how you got published. You're selling!
And what a lot of us indie authors are discovering - is that the people who are reading and liking our books don't give a rip about how they came to be published. Only the old-line newspapers and the scribbling royalty seem to care in a big way.
My latest - the Adelsverein Trilogy came out last December, and over the last six months more and more people in the local area have discovered it - so I am doing more and more book-club talks, every month, as readers recommend the Trilogy to their friends.
Great to know that your books are selling well. Good luck with that.

You might be interested in my post about this topic (posted it just a few days back): link.
Hmm, I still can't decide between POD publishing or waiting for the traditional route (a.k.a. dying in obscurity). What ever happened to building a reputation through chapbooks?

Still, congrats on your success! I do hope the literary world follows music and movies with a move towards independent authors.
These days, Patrick - it's called blogging!
I'm with you in spirit, Sarge, but let me tell you the flip side of the story. I'm a long-time contributing editor of the Women's Review of Books, and I will testify that book reviewing is not a luxe occupation. When I was on staff at WRB, review copies of books collected in teetering piles that were almost impossible to go through thoroughly. The injunction against self-published books was always a way to winnow down the constant flow, the assumption being that a "bonified" publisher acted as a gatekeeper.

I no longer believe that's true, although the constant flow of books remains. Print review outlets are contracting, but there are plenty of online book blogs and review sites. In many ways, there are more outlets for reviews now, even if a reviewer doesn't even get paid with a free copy of the book.

There are all sorts of benefits to indie publishing, including control of distribution. (Amazon, in particular, makes this much easier for authors now, and I never thought I'd be singing the praises of Amazon.) It's certainly very hard for non-celeb authors to build a following, but it always has been, especially for anyone outside the publishing mainstream: women, minorities, working-class writers without Iowa credentials and elite NY contacts. The Women's Review of Books got rolling 20-odd years ago because the number of women authors and reviewers who appeared in the NY Times Book Review at the time was shockingly small (not to mention the NY Review of Books). The situation is a little better now, but it's still not great in those bastions of literary gatekeeping.

I think you're doing exactly what you should be doing. One of the ironies of book publishing today is that indie authors often do a far better job of promoting themselves than dysfunctional and underfunded marketing departments.

It's true: the mainstream media is dying. Thank God.
Oh, yes - I know all about the tottering piles at the mainstream outlets ... and why they give the stink-eye towards POD books, in an attempt to keep the piles from toppling over entirely. For which I can't blame them - a great many of them are truly awful. (But so are a lot of main-stream published books. Really, I couldn't make it farther than one chapter of the Da Vinci Code - I kept falling flat over sentences that sounded like entries in the Bulwer-Lytton Bad Writing contest!) And I do review for a couple of on-line review outlets, as do a lot of the other IAG members. Personally, I have the luxury of being very, very picky about what I commit to read and review. I've simply insisted that before I say yes, I've got to scan a chapter or two, just to see if I want to read the rest.

There is just some amazingly good POD stuff out there - quirky, heart-rending, original, lyrical - produced by writers who are really buckling down and working seriously, and using every opportunity to get their books in front of readers. The very best and most committed that I know of are setting up as boutique publishers, in order to cut the POD costs down to where their books are competitive with main-stream published books.
POD books are being smeared with the same opinions that once affected vanity press. Lack of approval by some "unbiased" third party. The good thing is that POD authors have more ability to promote via the web and build a following. The industry is changing, without a doubt. We're seeing more publishers finding people via blogs and social media and approaching authors, instead of the other way around.
Oh yes - definitely some traditional publishers are getting wise. One of the IAG's other founding members, Dianne Salerni (She did a terrific YA novel called High Spirits, all about the Fox sisters, who inadvertently founded Spiritualism) just got a very nice traditional deal to re-publish High Spirits, and an option on her next book. Some of the other member/authors have books which have done equally well, but in some cases, they have gone around the block a couple of times with the traditional publishing establishment, and rather relish the control they have over their books, as independents.
Yup, to be a POD author with limited financial resources is tough. And how true your words about some of the trash that gets published conventionally, while some excellent work languishes in the POD backwaters. I am personally grateful to you Sgt. Mom for the encouragement (and indeed reviews!!) you've given me. I'm now encouraging others in in my social circle who've written some very good stuff to get started and I'm passing on the URL of the excellent IAG, (plus others) so they can get moral and practical support.
It's the wave of the future, HG - the current way of doing traditional publishing just can't carry on any more in the manner it's become accustomed to. There are too many awful, schlocky books pushed out there because they are thought to be commercially appealing to large numbers of people - at the expense of the quirky, original, and relatively unknown.!