PRog

The Capitol of Pablovia
MAY 5, 2009 3:04PM

My Life is a Lie

Rate: 8 Flag

It's well known where I work that I don't believe in God.  (I'd say about half the 100 or so people I encounter on a daily basis know.)  Among most of the people it's hardly an issue.  Among a handful it's become a regular topic of conversation in an enjoyable, bantery kind of way that occasionally spirals into extended exchanges about the nature of belief in general.  I enjoy these conversations (as much for the distraction they provide as for the points raised by all sides).

Among a couple of people, my atheism is obviously an "issue."  We’re pleasant enough toward each other (in that obnoxious, sickly-sweet kind of way that perfunctory politeness invites), but frankly, I think they're nuts.  I won't go into specifics, but believe me when I say these people (from different Christian sects) jettisoned from reality too long ago. 

Occasionally during a department meeting (anywhere from 4 to 20 of us in a room at any given time) a situation will present itself for me to insert some jokey (hopefully witty) atheistic comment (usually under the guise of political correctness or grammatical accuracy), or one of the more rational believers will jab me a little (verbally that is) and there will be a chuckle among those who get it.  

The other day someone said to me, "When you see the light..." in a tone that implied, well, that I'm an idiot.  I saw him later and told him, politely, that I was insulted by his comment (one I've heard dozens of times before).  He immediately and profusely apologized, though not because he understood why I was insulted, but simply because I had pointed out his indiscretion.  (To his credit, his apology seemed sincere.)

I asked him if he understood why I was insulted.  (Again) to his credit, he was honest, and said, "frankly, no." 

And there's the problem.  I'm not an angsty teenager nor am I a curmudgeon.  I’m a grown man with a wife, son, and a friendly (relatively) well-trained dog.  I had a bar mitzvah at the appropriate age after 5 years of religious education.  I'm also (if I may say so) relatively well educated about the major faiths.  I often find myself having to explain to self-titled Christians way too much about their own religion, a "faith" they've obviously inherited and could no more discuss than why they are right handed...it's just what they are, and they never really think about it.  They are "Christian" in the same way they breathe - autonomically.   The irony is that he was born into his belief system, while I developed mine. (Not that I invented atheism, but I had to come to it on my own.)  As Richard Dawkins says, there are no Christian children, only children of Christian parents. 

When my colleague said, "When you see the light..." what he was actually doing was dismissing every thought, feeling and experience I've ever had in my 41 years as pointless, or at best, shallow.   As if I had not (intellectually or emotionally) earned the mantle of atheist, rationalist, humanist.  He was telling me that my belief system was so unconsidered (by me) as to be nothing more than a whim.   Good thing he pointed it out to me, or I might have gone through the rest of my life reading books about science, philosophy, history and religion and continuing to make my own decisions about what I believe instead of being dictated to by the clergy.   

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
On the subject of God people get insane. It's something I try not to touch anymore. I just avoid the topic, unless I feel like someone has something new and enlightening to offer, which doesn't really ever occur. You are braver than I.
Actually I think your life is big truth. And you can explain it clearly without using religious text and do it very well. Great post.
"The irony is that he was born into his belief system, while I developed mine. "
Very good point! I don't have to agree with your beliefs to respect your process and destination. I think many Christian parents are doing their children a disservice by not encouraging the children to question the foundations of their own faith. Besieds, it is my belief that God prefers his people to have a strength of conviction that can only come with self discovery. Following the path of least resistance shouldn't be the basis of any life decision.
When you see the light, jump out of the way because it is an on-coming train. lol

You wrote, "Christiansit's [are] just what they are, and they never really think about it. They are "Christian" in the same way they breathe - autonomically. "
This is an interesting point since this is what faith is all about. You just accept it. Like when you walk into a darkened room and turn on the light switch and you expect the lights to turn on. You don't think , "will they turn on this time?"

Rated
It's a variant of the Foxhole calumny. Humanist/atheist positions are generally the result of introspection and thought. You can't expect them to get that, though, if they've never done any.
I find myself in the same situation. After explaining to a lady at work what I believe she asked me if I would go to church with her. Confident, I think, that if I just heard the right sermon I would be on the "straight and narrow" (emphasis on narrow). I explained to her that I know a lot of the Bible and if I attended with her I would challenge her minister any time I disagreed with him. She stopped asking.
Obviously it's different where you work. However, in my entire working life nobody in any office I worked in had any idea about my religious ideas, talked about religion, or pushed their own. Of course, I live in Canada where we tend to mind our own business rather more than (it seems to me) in the U.S., esp. some areas.
Great post...

Rated for your honesty, your clear-storytelling and your courage. Religious belief fascinates me...always has for some reason. Throughout my life, I've often found the conviction with which some profess their outrageous beliefs (alien abductions, ghosts, demons, devils, etc.) to be more convincing than the content of such belief--especially as I have gone through transitions and vulnerable times in my life. I yearned for stability and strong, clear answers in such times.

But I think there comes a time when some of these ideas need to be challenged in a respectful, yet clear, way--even if we are only able to turn the tables long enough to encourage those we interact with think deeper about their own ideas (and to seriously investigate our own assumptions).

To move forward and make progress, I believe we need truth and the courage to face it--whatever it may be. Any belief that forbids deep investigation and honest inquiry into its core convictions simultaneously admits its own weaknesses and is--in my opinion--not worthy of my continued devotion. Others can feel free to stay within such a tradition, but I'll try my luck finding hope, meaning and purpose elsewhere.

Thanks again for such a thought-provoking post!
Plus, Agnostic, the dude can write an English sentence, which goes far with me.