PRog

The Capitol of Pablovia
Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 30, 2010 1:20PM

Trauma, Trains and Jonathan Franzen

Rate: 10 Flag

For the holidays (yes, I said "the holidays") my three year-old son received, among other things, a train set.  He's been saying for almost a year now that when he grows up he wants to be a train conductor.  He is our first child, and I, in my ignorance assumed that, a) he wouldn't be using the phrase "when I grow up I want to be..." until he was at least seven or eight, and b) once he did start saying it the noun at the end of the sentence would change more regularly than the temperature in Chicago.

Like many kids his age he already has some toy trains, small wooden rectangles painted in bright colors that can be pushed along slotted "tracks," but this is different.   This set is not only bigger, it's powered, the trains trundling along grooved tracks, whistling and tooting and climbing up relatively steep inclines, and it's also remote controlled.

The set, as any smart company will do, is expandable, with multiple sets of characters, cars and seasonal (as well as holiday) themed sub sets that can be added to expand for miles, beyond what most cities probably have as actual public transit.  

I watched him all weekend as he pushed the throttle back and forth, stopping to load and unload the cargo car with miniature bundles of logs and crates, stopping at the station (whispering to himself, "All aboard," and " An inbound train, toward the Loop, will be arriving shortly"), then moving along to continue its trek.

He sat cross-legged outside the loop of track, watching as if from a distance.  He laid on his belly, his legs bent at the knees, his feet casually bouncing off the rug.  He moved to the center of the loop, the train circling him in Lilliputian fashion.  All of this he did over the course of hours, without a hint of self consciousness; which is as it should be.

Nothing could have made me happier. 

Then I started reading Freedom by Jonathan Franzen, and he fucked it all up. 

In many ways there's nothing new here: domestic instability, a wife who finds sex with her husband boring, obstinate teenagers who devastate their parents, wannabe rock stars coming up short of their dreams.  But Franzen (love him or hate him) being the talented writer he is, makes me want to punch him in the face.

Doubtless, these aren't people he's writing about, but "people" - types and archetypes.  His deconstruction (dismantling?) of the "American dream" is neither new to me nor is it original in its conceit (the literary kind, not the egomaniac kind).  I know that life is hard (my father had to escape Nazis in Poland when he was four years-old), if not impossible (24,000 children will starve to death today). I don't look at the world through a lens tinted (positively or negatively) by religious ideologies so I don't expect salvation or damnation.

It's my own fault.  I should have put the book down after the first paragraph when we learn that our protagonists were "not quiet right." (But seriously, who could stop reading at that point?) So I soldiered on, absorbing blow after blow of domestic discord, familial flailing, marital malignancy, until...well, what?  Until I look at my wife, two kids and pure-breed Gordon Setter (HOLY SHIT! When did all that happen?) and tell myself that will never be us (NEVER!)  Wonder when the rot will set in. Remind myself repeatedly that it's just a novel, it's just a made-up story.

It's raining as I write (more rainy than raining) and the temperature is just above freezing.  I'm at work (though only pretending to work).  The mood here is somewhere between ambivalent and hostile (depending on the person and the amount of coffee/sugar they've consumed).  My wife just sent me a text; our son said:

"Oh, what a perfect day for playing with trains."

I couldn't make this up if I wanted to. 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I thought you were going to refer to the father from The Corrections, who worked thanklessly for the railroad company. Yes, it is just a made-up story, enjoy your son and his trains while you can.
Got "Freedom" for Christmas. I am not done yet, but I'll get there. I hated "The Corrections" because it was so depressing. I still think of that family and feel so sad and tired. But I am giving Franzen one more chance. When I finish, I will let you know what I think.

In my view, it's always a perfect day to play with trains!
I loved trains as a boy. Still find them fascinating. Have no interest in Franzen. No interest in reading about fictional dysfunctional families. Too common in the real world. Boring. Fiction has to either amuse me, make me think or do whatever else it takes to hold my interest - maybe just give me energized, careful writing. From excerpts I've seen of Franzen's work I'm not even sure he's that good a wordsmith.

I trust you enjoy playing with trains with your son. My dad used to take us on rides to the train depot just to watch the trains. It was always a thrill.
Thank goodness for unselfconscious childhood.
I liked this post a lot. Yeah, I just finished Freedom too. The thing is, I think he's got us down pretty pat. Humans, I mean. His insight into relationships is devastatingly on target. People are banal, really. I don't mean that in a bad way. I suppose I think it's true that Franzen captures the negative too cannily and doesn't quite catch the glints of joy, at least not very well. Those little glints are what we live for, aren't they? Your son and his trains are one of them, so grab hold, my friend.
Whew.

Thank you.

A bad moment for me just now, needing to "kill" a little "time" (injure a bit of eternity? -- thanx, Thoreau); logging on a bit ?"durcheinander"? to OS for some recognisable voices.

I've been having altogether hideous and ridiculous arguments with people about Jonathan Franzen for equally ridiculous (whether or not hideous) reasons for longer than I can figure out why or how I got into the whole thing in the first place. I think maybe it was the day that Salon (and/or whoever all else?) highlighted the prez decision to buy this book while he was on Martha's Vineyard that pushed me over the edge. [Some of my friends know Franzen personally which just muddies the whole thing up for me!]

-/-/-

Delighted, here to get these images of your kid and his toy train! I have an old old set (before digitalization) I keep wondering whether any child anywhere might want to play with by now. I still remember the ones me and my then also-kid brother loved to play with ... all those years ago!

Rated with thanks!

podunkmarte
I loved "The Corrections." So far, just can't make myself care about "Freedom." Was reading it while home visiting my own dysfunctional Midwestern family and just couldn't relate to any of the characters.

My step-nephew is 18 months old and got a train set for Christmas that he seemed to like, though...
I read Freedom but Franzen misses the mark with the Berglunds and it is because of the very thing you find with your son, that all parents find, their humanity. Franzen has no children so he must write looking over the hedge which he does well but as you and i know it is the great secret of parenthood that you miss when you dont have kids...sorry franz. Also the book is horribly dated, he ignores the plight of all middleclass people, their struggle to make ends meet. Go play with the trains and your son, bro. The New Yorker writer will wait.
http://www.jknew.com

Air Max SHOE(Air Max 24-7,Air Max 2011,Air Max 2010,Air Max 2009 ) $30
jacket(THE NORTH FACE Down,Prada,Nike,Moncler,Gucci,G-STAR,Ed Hardy,CK,BURBERRY,ARMANI,AF ,) $40
Woman Boot: (Christian Louboutin,CHANEL,VERSACE,TIMBERL,SKECHERS,PRADA,Polo,DG,COACH) $40
(NIKE,LV,Jordan,GUCCI,Fineview,FENDI,FADEDGLORY,FADEDGLORY,ED Hardy,Dior,)
Tshirts (POLO,Lacoste,Hollister,LV,Levis,ARMANI,Affliction,AF,Versace,TRUE RELIGION,TAPOUT,Prada,)
(Christan Audigier,Calvin Klein t-shirt,BURBERRY,BOSS,BAPE,) $ 16
Handbag (Paul Shark,Paco Chicano,GUCCI,G-STAR,FRED PERRY,Ed Hardy,DSQUARED,Diesel,DG,COOGI) $30
Sunglass (ADIDAS Armani burberry carrera DG lv,ED Hardy,Oakely,Gucci)$13
dty dtukjsr dtuykdtyu
FRanzen again? YIKES!
Skip him and read his nemesis William Gaddis instead. Gaddis's "The Recognitions" (yes Franzen aped the title and tried to steal much else from it) is The Great American Novel that everyone talks about. It's the only work this country has ever produced that begs comparasion to Musil's "The Man Without Qualities"

Having done that Gaddis went on to write J.R. -- the attack on capitalism that karl Marx couldn't quite create. And more. . .

http://fablog.ehrensteinland.com/2010/09/05/holden-franzen-vs-the-world/
I haven't read Freedom, and I couldn't make it through the first chapter of The Corrections, so I'm no expert on Franzen, but I definitely agree that some writers (and film makers) would do better to at least occasionally add a character or event that isn't COMPLETELY fucked up. I mean just a little fucked up is realistic sometimes, right?
This post brought back images of my son (now 23) happily intranced for hours as he pushed buttons to let his Winnie-the-Pooh train go from one section of track to another.

Franzen's characters in Freedom have no moral compass. Not one of them. He writes well, but to what purpose?

Your son already has a clearer sense of purpose. So does mine. Enjoy the joy.
Christmas Festival gift . To your friends,
a pleasant surprise . Reputation , quality, absolute guarantee .
The same style, not the same, the quality with the price . please log in: " fashionsb "com .
so what, move your mouse Our services: "customer is God."