Shannon Kelley

Shannon Kelley
Location
Santa Barbara, California, USA
Birthday
June 11
Company
self-employed
Bio
Shannon Kelley and her mother Barbara Kelley are both journalists, and have just written a book called "Undecided". Together. (...Right??) This blog is a taste of what you'll find in "Undecided", a book about choice overload, analysis paralysis, grass is greener syndrome, longing for the road not traveled, and how the success of the women’s movement has left women stumped in the face of limitless options — and how to get over it. The book comes out on May 3: if you like what you're reading here, get the book here: http://www.amazon.com/Undecided-Endless-Perfect-Career-Life-Thats/dp/1580053416. And subscribe to our blog here: http://undecidedthebook.wordpress.com/

MY RECENT POSTS

Shannon Kelley's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 2, 2012 6:45PM

Did Facebook Bring Down Susan G. Komen?

Rate: 18 Flag

The interwebs – and the San Francisco Bay Area, which is quite literally Facebook territory – have been abuzz since news of the social networking site’s IPO broke Wednesday.   Within hours, anyone with a mic or a keyboard was thoroughly a-riff:  Would the projected $5 billion trigger a new housing boom?  Would it save the California economy?

Or was Facebook nothing but a data-mining outfit, selling our info to the highest bidder, and before long, so over.  With nearly half the world’s internet users logged on, how could it grow?

But while the opinionators were opinionating, a good percentage of the social networking site’s 845 million users (58 percent of them women, by the way) were madly liking, sharing and updating their news feeds to call out – if that isn’t too mild a word — Susan G. Komen’s decision to defund Planned Parenthood.

The irony that an organization that proclaims its dedication to curing (there’s some debate on that, too) breast cancer would pull the plug on the funding for free mammograms was way too much.  The backlash was fast, furious and viral.  And it was in our Face.

Within hours, Komen was under immense pressure both within and without the organization.  They backpedaled.  Top officials resigned.  Racers for the cure decided, well, not to.  Comments like this one — I was sort of done when they partnered with KFC to turn the buckets pink – that was a key notion that they weren’t terribly concerned about women’s health. — took on a life of their own.

And Planned Parenthood?  By Wednesday night, it had received $400,000 in donations.  On Thursday, New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg pledged to give Planned Parenthood $250,000.

For far too long, Planned Parenthood has been in the crosshairs of conservatives, who have tagged the organization as nothing but — as the erstwhile presidential candidate Michele Bachman once called it, “the LensCrafter of big abortion” — when in reality, Planned Parenthood is a prime provider of health care for women who can’t afford it.  (Abortions only make up 10 percent of the services it provides.)

As we’ve written before, we know of one woman, in fact, whose life may have been saved by Planned Parenthood. She discovered a lump in her breast shortly after losing her work-related health insurance. Where did she turn for a mammogram? Yep, Planned Parenthood, which ultimately shepherded her through the scary process of not only the diagnostics, but ultimately surgery, chemo and radiation.

And so, while some folks might look at Facebook  and see a cashbox that will fill our local watering holes and pump some life back into the California economy – and while others argue that it’s nothing but a narcissistic echo chamber that keeps us fixated on the trivial — at least for today, we can see it as something else: the social engine that may well have saved at least one woman’s life.

By the way, this was my favorite update.  To which the only possible response is “like!”


Tagged: Facebook, Planed Parenthood, Susan G. Komen

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Yeah.... Pink Kentucky Fried Chicken buckets really WILL make things all better!

Seems like th SGK had this blow up right in their faces. If they think Right-Wing Political pressure hurts, they ain't seen NOTHIN' yet! They knuckled under and severely undercut their own purported message. Thanks but no thanks, I'll donate to Planned Parenthood and the American Cancer Society from now on.
All goes to show, I think, that the sound of the right-wing noise machine is not representative of the general opinion of the population, and those who heed it heedlessly may well find themselves in trouble.
I was always skeptical of SGK. It was all the pink probably...The line "It was in our Face." was very clever, BTW.
Agree. PS, I have always heard that abortion care accounts for 3% of Planned Parenthood's expenses, not 10%.
As I'm a by now alas curmudgeonly old geezer and I'm not (gasp; wudja believe?!) on Facebook I'll be singing a slightly different tune here. Namely: At least she (Susan herself?) put forth a decent apology and statement of explanation. Would that candidates for electoral office could do so well. ?! :-( ;-) Any way, three (or more) cheers for Planned Parenthood -- they've been around almost as long as I have. Let's all of us "keep on truckin'", best we can. ;-)

R
There is no doubt about the power of social media. And now I feel much better about the copious amount of time I spend on it.
What were they thinking? I mean really, how bougie and sheltered do you have to be to think that defunding PP is a good idea if you're running a group like Komen? Ridiculous people, and I'm glad the online horde pushed back hard.
RATED
"(Abortions only make up 10 percent of the services it provides.)"

More like 3%. Stephen Colbert did a marvelous piece about this that is also rapidly spreading across Facebook at the moment.
http://gawker.com/5791100/watch-stephen-colberts-defense-of-planned-parenthood
For a while, I've been amazed and impressed at the power for social change that Facebook has unleashed. I thought that the email campaigns of previous years were making a difference, but they're nothing compared to how viral a campaign can get on FB in the course of a day. It greatly reduces the ability of legislators to sneak an evil piece of legislation through without protest.

Komen can kiss my ass. I'd rather support Planned Parenthood and the American Cancer Society.
I started off Hating FaceBook. There are still many idiosyncrasies and peculiarities that I find cater to a lowest common mass appeal than they do for something, to sound a tad snobbish, uplifting. When I joined it, I decided I would do my best to try to raise up the bar by finding ideas, causes and things to discuss with others that were more than, "It's 10pm and I'm drinking an iced latte in front of Starbucks," type worthless drivel gossip.

Susan G. Komen for the Cure was witness to the power of social networking galvanized to enforce social responsibility. No matter what Zuckerberg and Co were thinking, doing or hoping when they created FaceBook, what happens now is ultimately in the hands of the userbase to a large extent. Not necessarily what the interface looks like, or how the messaging and connections sections actually function, no. How it's actually used in our world, our societies and people it brings together for various reasons is completely out of the inventor's control.

FaceBook's true potential, which many may see as a serious weakness, is that it allows people to speak out, connect and communicate wherever an internet connection can be had. I think, in most cases, the potential for ensuring we truly empower people in a more democratic way through social networking is the greatest reason for using FaceBook.

I started off Hating FaceBook. I don't know if I'd be willing to completely give it up at this point. Not so I can gossip, but so I can connect with others willing to speak up, speak out and demand their personal power be accorded them from our politicians, leaders (hah!) and execs attempting to maintain control through it.

SOPA, PIPA and Susan G. Komen for the Cure. Progress in action. What's next?

--R--
Silly wabbits. They forgot about the internets. Huh-huh-huh-huh-huh.

Rated.
Yeh, I just went over to the dark side -- pressures of my job- I've recently joined Facebook. It's one helluva way to keep track of trends-- not to mention "friends."

Hey, can I look you up on Fbook? Maybe we should start an OS subgroup -
Shannon - Would it not be interesting to know how many abortions are performed regardless of % of services.
Well it is 300K+ per 3M served as you said. 10%. That is like saying I sell 3M hamburgers a year and only 300K pizzas, so I am not int he pizza business.

So one in ten walk in and get an abortion. And you have to assume not all who walk in are pregnant so the % of pregnant women who walk in for "options" that get an abortion is higher than 10%. If even 10% of total served are pregnant than the math says 100% of pregnant women get an abortion.
If 20% walk in pregnant then 50% of pregnant women are getting abortions. etc.

You cant justify abortion clinics just because they do other things other than abortions. That makes no sense at all. It is not clear that PP does just that to cover the abortions.
How is it any different than a dedicated clinic performing 300K abortions?

I don't hear much push back for the other services provided.
So why not separate the services so we can know exactly what % women walk in pregnant and walk out not.
Then we will have the truth instead of rhetoric and statistic manipulation.

And lets have a clear accounting of ALL the donations and who is giving money allocated to include abortions and those that are not. Let the players show there faces and let them all reap the rewards/criticism.
Everyone that is awake now knows Koman's position. It doesn't matter if one thinks she did the right or wrong thing or changed her mind for right or wrong. The point is now everyone knows and can respond accordingly.

So let them all come forward. But they won't.