The Galavanting Scrivener

Thoughts from here and there

sheller53

sheller53
Location
Seattle, Washington, USA
Birthday
January 31
Title
Adventurer, Writer, Puddle-Jumper
Company
The Great, Big, Wide World
Bio
I'm an adventurer who loves all things words, but am not against good cheese, chocolate, and wine, either. If I'm not trying to figure out a way to stay dry while biking in the rain, I'm usually trying to find a way to get above the rain clouds and into the mountains.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 2, 2009 3:30PM

My Wedding Cake: Part I

Rate: 9 Flag

 

weddingcake

I don't even like cake.  But I do like projects, which means I've (perhaps foolishly) decided, among other things, to make my own wedding cake.  The other day, after placing a few cake-decorating books on hold at the library, I visited an awesome cake-decorating supply store in North Seattle to see what, exactly, I was getting my hands into (aside from copious amounts of butter and sugar, of course).

After talking to the store's owner for about 20 minutes and jotting down a page full of time-tested advice from her, it turns out that this cake-baking/decorating business isn't going to be as difficult as I had originally thought (famous last words, right?).  With some good freezer space, a little help, and lots of Pillsbury-cake-mix boxes (she also gave me a simple and great-tasting recipe whose star ingredient is white cake mix--see recipe below), I'll have my cake made in no time. 

It's the day-of preparation that the owner warned me about.  Luckily, my paternal grandmother was raised in a bakery, is an excellent cook, and is more than happy to help me assemble the cake on the Big Day.  We'll see what comes of one part bride to ten parts stress to 15 parts Pillsbury Dough Boy (hee hee!).

 

Basic Sour Cream White Cake*

*Taken from the The Cake Mix Doctor, by Anne Byrn.

Vegetable shortening (for greasing the pan) 

Flour for dusting the pan 

1 package 18.25 oz plain white cake mix 

1 cup sour cream (don't skimp on this - it's the secret ingredient!)

1/2 cup vegetable oil

3 large eggs

1 tsp. pure vanilla extract

Directions:

1. Place rack on center oven and preheat oven to 350 deg. F. 

2. Grease pan and then dust with flour.  Shake out excess flour and set aside.

3. Mix the cake mix, sour cream, veg. oil, eggs, and vanilla extract together with an electric mixer for 1 minute on low.  Stop, scrape sides with a spatula, then increase speed to medium and continue mixing for 2 minutes. 

4. Pour into pan and bake until light brown and center of cake springs when pressed with finger (35-40 minutes for 13" x 9" pan)

5. Remove and place on wire rack for 20 minutes.  Run dinner knife around edge and invert on rack and again on another rack so it cools right side up.  Cool appx. 30 minutes.  Frost as desired.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Good luck. I've heard about the cake doctor, and I've made cheesecake filling (for chocolate zucchini cake) out of prepackaged frosting, cream cheese and eggs. It is very, very good. Are you going to use fondant for the icing? I have never done that, but when I watch other people do it, it looks easier than all that piping and stuff. But then I'm artistically inclined. :-] Good luck!
this is not your fault, but i had to click on this article, since the editors so cleverly retitled your post, "i'm making my own wedding cake"...

and placed it alongside this picture of boxes of cake mix. i'm still impressed with your bravery, but damn editors. the cake mix doctor is returning to qvc friday, and this really seems like advertising to me. if you click on the linked blog, there she is, with the wedding cake right there. here's the video, and the wedding cake is the selling point for the book.
http://www.qvc.com/qic/qvcapp.aspx/view.2/app.detail/params.item.F08250.desc.The-Cake-Mix-Doctor-Returns-by-Anne-Byrn-wBonus-CakeMix

sorry, that just seems like a super weird coincidence.
@latethink: thanks for the luck - I'll need it! I heard that fondant icing is not very tasty, so I'll probably try to figure out an alternative, but we'll see...

@bstrangely: Crazy - I had no idea! The owner actually suggested the recipe (not the whole book), so I don't think it was tied to any sort of advertising. So I just copied the recipe in the bookstore. But thanks for the head's up.
I had a friend make my wedding cake (17 years ago, now). She is an artist and a gourmet cook, so I knew it would be lovely and delicious, which it was. Here's the backstory, which I didn't find out about until later:

After making some schmancy recipe she probably got from Gourmet magazine, she went out and bought cake mix. The schmancy cake was AWFUL, she said. Tasted awful, looked worse. She swore me to secrecy on this, but also informed me that her sister, who makes wedding cakes for extra money, swears by cake mix and wouldn't use anything else, which my friend only discovered after calling her in tears when the other thing didn't work.

It's all in the frosting, anyway!

Good luck!
PS - thanks also for the tip on the supply house. When I get up to Seattle, I'll check it out. I live in Gig Harbor, so that isn't often, but it sounds like a great place!
I'd call in Freaky!! Good Luck!
Wow, you are ambitious! Maybe Freaky Troll will stop by and give you some advice...the best cake is a moist one and the sour cream will help assure that. Grandma sounds like she'll be a big help, because afterall, it will be your wedding day...lots to focus on that day.
i'm sure you didn't! it's just really odd. good luck with your cake! i actually really like fondant. buttercream and whipped cream are too rich for a lot of cakes i've had and i just wind up scraping it off. i just found a recipe for marshmallow fondant you can make in the microwave.
http://www.cakejournal.com/archives/how-to-make-marshmallow-fondant
Yes, I have heard that fondant tastes like marshmallow, so you are probably wise to pass on that. Books and the cake store should be a good help for piping and decorating. You know I used to make cakes from McCall's and Betty Crocker cookbooks, even Boston cream pie and they were foolproof. But since I know I can make a scratch cake, I have no guilt about using mixes. Sort of like buying pie crust. I can make it, but why should I? Good for you too for trying to save instead of being extravagant.
I made my own wedding cake. It was a fun project. I had chocolate butter cake, raspberry buttercream and an outer coating of something called creme ivoire that gives a sort of fondant finish but is primarily white chocolate and tastes really good. All the recipes were from Rose Levy Berenbaum's "The Cake Bible".

The one warning I would make is that the kind of cake that comes out of a mix doesn't have the same structural integrity of a traditional (typically butter cake) wedding cake. If you are trying to do something with tiers I would be sure to do a dry-run to make sure it works.

Good luck!
I'm just going to ignore that comment about not liking cake. Obviously the stress of the wedding is making you say crazy things.

You can't go wrong with jamming me repeatedly into buttercream frosting - barring that, you might look into getting a press in pattern stamp. They have them in simple lace patterns, or quilted patterns. I'm going to release one soon that mimics my foot stamp.
Good luck with that
My wife was a professional baker in another life and she has made wedding cakes for several of our friends. I think she only remembers the good aspects. I remember the anxiety, dread and multiple trips to the store.
Good Luck!! (marriage this time)
We had gorgeous cheesecakes with raspberries for our weddings...I didn't make them...but I did take a tip from the book "Bridal Bargains" and lied about the purpose for the cakes...did you realise that there is sometimes up to several hundred percent, just for it being a WEDDING. We told them it was for a retirement party, kept the decorations simple and had the florist decorate the cakes further, and picked up the cakes and "assembled them artfully ourselves.

However, my Irish hubby DID make whiskey cakes for the groom's cakes...how many grooms actually BAKE their own groom's cakes! Whatta guy!
I think you're nuts, but have fun! ;)
Totally unsolicited suggestion

I made two wedding cakes for friends at the beginning of the year and I suck at decorating with icing. What I did after frosting the cake was coat the outside of the layers in shredded coconut and edible sparklies in order to make it look more "decorated."

Good luck and I hope you will share pics!
I made my own wedding cake decades ago for a mere 350 people. One layer was a great tea-cake (like pound cake), the other a wickedly spicy gingerbread cake - coz I love it! All from scratch and it was fun.
The two tips: make a cake with a solid crumb to handle frosting, transport, etc.
Make it early - over and over if you must as I did - and freeze the layers. Decorate the day before and the cake will thaw just fine in time...oh - and soaking everything in Jameson whiskey just before freezing helps.
Cake was great.
Other nice touch - his nickname was "Block" so we spelled that out in children's wooden blocks next to a bride - all the staid people (this was decades ago when people cared about such things) - meaning his family and my mother, freaked at that.
Still have that "Block" - lost the actual groom in some move a long time ago and never missed him.
I'm getting married soon and did a lot of research about this as I really liked the idea. I gather that baking and decorating a wedding cake isn't so hard. TRANSPORTING it is. So, make sure you have a plan for that.
WOW.

and good luck.

first though, you just have to do a test cake. you don't want any surprised.

keep in mind if worse comes to worse, you can pick up a great plain cake at costco, it will be a huge rectangle, they will decorate or not as you wish.

you can buy a few of those and cut them up and decorate according to your plan. they will make a yellow, chocolate or carrot. and they have some terrific fillings, like a strawberry mousse. they're rather dense cakes, not quite a pound cake but not a light crumb either. you can tier them using the cardboard they come on (maybe double it) and bamboo skewers. you can decorate any way you like without having to actually bake a cake.

I like white coconut as a decoration because it gives the appearance of lace and it's easy. some silver jimmies, and viola..instant stun factor.

again, good luck. this is madness, but the best kind. really. you'll be a legend among your family and friends. meanwhile enjoy yourself and don't get too crazy.
Congratulations on your upcoming wedding. I am sure your cake will turn out great! Post photos and let us know how it goes.
Cake mix from a box?!?! What about the really-rather-simple Joy of Cooking wedding cake recipe? Cream the butter and sugar when the butter is @ 65 degrees F. Makes a huge difference. It's easy and box cake just doesn't taste very good. Box cake mix? Ew. For your wedding? Double-ew.
Great project! I made my own cake, from a great book actually called "Wedding Cakes You Can Make" http://www.amazon.com/Wedding-Cakes-You-Can-Make/dp/076455719X, and it worked out wonderfully. The caveat, is - give yourself enough time! Everything takes about 3 times as long as you think it will... I made and froze the cakes about 1 week in advance, made the frosting in advance, crumb covered the cakes the day before and then waited until the day of big event to frost, assemble and decorate. I was also 6 months preggo! Yikes. The end result was fab, and the cake looked and tasted amazing, but I almost cut off my thumb while torting one of the frozen layers. Luckily no blood on the cake! I bucked up and didn't go to the emergency room but instead had a giant bandage on my thumb for walking down the aisle! Sexy! The scar will always remind me of our wedding day... :-)

So the lesson? Delegate or give yourself loads of time!

PS. Also skip the fondant, unless you are getting married in a hot climate. I find most people peel it off and don't eat it. Buttercream is just as easy to work with and tastes delicious.

Good luck!!
To all comment-posters so far: thanks so much for your support, suggestions, and, well, comments. I should add that I did do a trial run (testing both the Pillsbury cake mix and the Betty Crocker cake mix) for my fiancé and family, and within 12 hours the Pillsbury-version cake and all its cake-mix crumbs were gone! So for any skeptics out there, I suggest waiting until the cake-mix boxes go on sale (I bought mine for $1/box) and trying the recipe. Of course, my taste buds are not so refined, so I am sure that there are many, many better-tasting cakes out there. But for what I am going for, I think this will work just fine.

The wedding's not for a few months (I just wanted to buy the cake mix while it was on sale), but I will definitely post pictures, and I'll make sure to delegate, as some sage people suggested!
Good Luck. I think that the main thing is that it tastes good. How it looks is less important. You have probably eaten lots of wedding cake that looked splendid but tasted like cardboard. Wouldn't it be nice to be able to say afterwards, in addition to "I made my own wedding cake", "My wedding cake was delicious. I really loved it." And of course you know that these days we are all being told by Michael Pollan to cook our own food,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
I saw one of the other posters suggested using whiskey to brush the cake in order to keep it moist. I have always used simple syrup (1 part sugar to 1 part water) with some liqueur added to it. Amaretto and Frangelico are particularly good. You might want to track dow a copy of "The Cake Bible" by Rose Levy Beranbaum (another poster referenced it). It has fabulous, foolproof recipes in it and invaluable advice for putting together your cake. Good luck making your wedding cake! And even better luck with your marriage.