High Altitude Hot Air

The view from 6200 feet...

sierrasong

sierrasong
Location
Lake Tahoe, Nevada,
Birthday
May 04
Title
Benevolent Dictator
Company
Middle School
Bio
Nearly 30 years in the middle school biz...hope to graduate one of these days! Have taught English, choral music, drama, computer applications and just about anything else you can imagine. Oh, and how can I forget publications...I'm responsible for the yearbook and the school newspaper. Also did a stint as the librarian. Wide ranging interests and a long-time Salon addict. Two kids, two grandsons and a dog round out the picture! Originally from Marin (go figure) but 32 years at Tahoe has definitely spoiled me. To quote Nora Ephron, "I feel bad about my neck."

MY RECENT POSTS

Sierrasong's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 18, 2008 2:31PM

The red dress

Rate: 20 Flag

 September, 1957. The red dress. 

First day of school, September, 1957. 

 

I’ve been in school forever, or so it seems.  Monday morning, bright and far too early, I start my 29th year of teaching. 

 

I couldn’t wait to be old enough to go to school.  You can’t tell from the picture, but I was so excited that day.  I was horridly impatient for my dad, who felt it was necessary to record every major milestone of his children’s lives on film, to just be finished with the pictures, already!  I was itching to take my treasured, brand new Alice in Wonderland lunchbox (with a thermos!) and head off to kindergarten.  In the 1950’s we had school clothes and play clothes and girls never, ever wore pants to school.  This was a problem for a tomboy like me who lived in her brothers’ hand-me-down jeans and flannel shirts, but at the same time, I was over the moon to be grown up enough to have a school dress and a red one at that. Red, always my favorite color; the color of blood and love.  I was the youngest of three – all of us adopted - exactly three years apart.  My brothers had been in school for years it seemed and finally - finally – it was my turn. 

 

One of the main reasons I wanted to go to school was to escape my mom.  With my brothers away most of the day, there was no other target but me.  When the rage would build up, I would look for a place to hide, out of her direct line of sight and strive to be as quiet as possible.  The penalty for not hiding well enough were purple hand marks on my upper arms, red slap marks on my face and white wooden spoon marks on my bottom.  It was imperative to disappear.  Disappearing, even for the terrified, can be boring, so in order to entertain myself, while keeping one ear tuned to her whereabouts, I taught myself to read.  What better way to make yourself invisible and silent than to read?  I started by writing my brothers’ names on their lunch bags, laboriously tracing the letters in their names.  L-E-E and B-R-U-C-E, and from there I progressed to the rest of the alphabet.  There was no stopping me.

 

On her good days, for she had some wonderful days which only confused me more, my mother would give me old catalogs to cut up and paste on paper.  I would choose my favorite items, maybe a doll from the Sears Wishbook or a piece of interesting furniture, and carefully cut them out and paste them on scrap paper.  Painstakingly, I'd copy the names under the pasted images, sounding them out as I worked.  I especially loved the gardening catalogs with their beautiful flowers and colorful vegetables.  At that age, due to a congenital heart condition, I wasn’t allowed outside much, and those catalogs transported me into a sunlit garden where I made up stories about sad little princesses and talking birds.  It was also where “bad girl” lived.  She was the one who was always making my mother angry.  It couldn’t be me, could it?

 

I knew my mother didn’t realize I could read and I kept it my secret.  If she knew, it would become a weapon to be used against me.  She had weapons for all of us.  They were terrible and cunning weapons designed specifically to inflict the most psychic harm on whomever they were directed at.  I don’t like to think about them even today, as if pondering them will make them real again.  Later when she found out I could read, she knew just how to wound me.  Destroy or hide my precious books.  She's scratch out my awkward penmanship with my indelible pen and then break the pen. And so I hid my treasures, my books and papers and pens, well.  But at the same time, I felt empowered.  I had a window into the grownup world of scribbled notes, grocery lists and oh, yes, my brother’s love letters.  I don’t think he’s forgiven me yet.

 

Reading was the beginning of a lifelong love affair with words.  I would read anything I could get my hands on: newspapers, my father’s medical magazines, even the backs of deodorant cans if nothing else was handy – reading the multisyllabic chemical names of the ingredients seemed somehow exotic.  Once, in a fit of kindness when I was about seven, my mother took me to the library.  I was stunned.  A whole building full of books just for the taking (and of course for the returning as well!)?  Bliss. 

 

And school?  It became my haven, my escape, my paradise.  I was free to gobble up all the words I wanted until I was full to bursting and was still offered more.  A banquet for a begger.

 

We have a choice in dealing with our family backgrounds.  We can either repeat it or we can vow to never emulate it.  I chose the latter.  I became a teacher because I knew there were others in red dresses or red shirts, eager to be filled and, at the same time hiding terrible truths.  Others who needed a safe place with someone who really did love them and wouldn’t rip pages out of the books they treasured.  I do my best to lead them to that garden and show them they will be out of harm's way there. 

 

And so, as another school year dawns, it's time to go pull the red dress out of the closet and get ready to share the feast.  After all these years, red is still my favorite color...

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
you are a wonderful beautiful special person. no wonder at all in my mind why you are a teacher. isn't it interesting how some model their parents and others vow to make a break. I was determined to be the father to my kids to make up for the one I did not have.

you make a difference in so many lives Marsha, thank you
Barry said it better, but thats some portrait you paint. Thanks for sharing it. BTW, I'm pretty sure I had that dress too.
I actually teared up reading your post. The picture is what did it. I wish I could hug you then.
I had a lot of the same issues you did - but with my father. I imagine it would have been much more difficult to have to deal with a mother figure in this context.
This was wonderful - really.
I started this thinking it was going to be a light little read about school clothes...Marsha, you went straight to my heart with this one. I read a lot as a child too, for many similar reasons. Libraries still seem like a safe haven. Good ending, and good choice. Thanks for this...
Marsha, I am amazed at the background and challenges we share. It's too late and I'm too raw after reading your post to share too much but we shared mothers. Funny, my mom doesn't remember doing any of the things I have finally told her she did. In fact, I think she feels I am inagining it all (I always had such a vivid imagination she eagerly tells me).

Like you, I chose to break the cycle. The only egg shells my children walk upon are out in the chicken and duck pens. And that's a very good thing.

Giant hugs. I hope we meet in person some day. :-)

I might sound corny but I am feeling the love right now. And that's all we need (oh, and that pesky mortgage payment).
Marsha, that's such a strong and compelling story from the past. It shows how resourceful you are, as you found the best ways available to you in shielding yourself from daily wrath. Your mother's alternating good and bad behavior make me wonder if this was a type of sociopathic affliction. Kudos for breaking away and becoming a person that is 180 degrees different from your mother!
Hi Marsha:
I am so sad for all the you experienced in your childhood. I am beginning to wonder if at OS birds of a feather flock together, or if there was/is a lot more abusive behavior in homes than we ever imagined. I have written a little bit about my mother's unhappiness in my second post here at OS. I think it is cathartic for us to share. I believe we are opening doors for others to have an understanding that they are not the only ones to have endured an abusive childhood.

I am a little surprised that with your father being a doctor that he missed this, or thought it was normal. I am not assigning blame, of course, but our understanding of this behvaior has changed so much since we were children. When we think the world is a mess, it is probably because we know more now than we did then. The kind of abuse that you suffered was always kept secret -- I kept mine secret as well.

I think it is fair to say that we grew to be strong, loving women. There is always the potential for good to come out the other side of a harsh experience. Thank you for sharing.
Thank you all for your wonderful comments. I am now up and getting ready for school - I hate 6 am.

My mother indeed was a sick woman and my dad DAD did realize it. We found his journals after he died and he very clearly knew of her potential for harmful behavior but he was afraid of her too. I think I mentioned here before somewhere that, as an adult in therapy, it was a suprise to me how much latent and unacknowleged anger I had towards him - the father I adored - for not sheilding me from her.

We were the perfect family from the outside. Rotten to the core on the inside. Yet, somehow all three of us kids have succeeded. One brother is a PhD biologist, the other an attorney (after being in alternative education for the troubled kids). I'm the slacker who's amiddle school teacher. We got fed by those in the system; we are fortunate. It only makes sense to give back. I didn't write this to sound like some kind of saint, I'm surely not. Just doing my best.
Ooooohh...full of typos. I neeed coffee.
Marsha you are strong beyond words. As are many here on OS, apparently.

I could say more, but really, that's the most important and only thing -- that you are strong enough to get to the other side of this and do differently with your life than your parents did with theirs, by neither being one who inflicts such pain, nor one who hides in fear from pain. Good on ya. :)
Marsha, thank you for this post. What an amazing OS opportunity has offered to so many. I started school a few years before you, but, again, somewhat similar story. In the 50s, you could NOT let on to "outsiders" that things were not "normal" at home. So many of us grew up learning how to protect family secrets. How amazing it is to have a non-judgmental place to let those secrets out. Thank you again.
Julie took all my words! Well, most of them anyway. Marsha, thank you for sharing this, for trusting us, for trusting yourself and for doing the hardest and most important job outside the home --no, not rocket science-- teaching young minds to grow.

To this day I still remember favorite teachers, the library, even the smell of my navy and gray lunchbox with its own thermos... no fancy characters allowed. And I do think I started early school years in dresses too now that you mention it.

I cringe for you and your pain. And I empathize, deeply. There appear to be many of us who've found writing to be yet another way to exorcise demons and rebuild ourselves into whole, caring, contributing, solid human beings. Bravo for us all!
Just wanted to send you my best wishes and let you know that I also empathize (my father was an animal - I speak about him briefly in one of my blog posts). It's so true that there are other "red dresses" out there. I know that when I was little, I felt like my home life was a horrible secret that no one else could understand or relate to - sadly, that is not the case. I'm so glad that you were able to break the chain and heal through helping other people.
Middle school is where I discovered my best teachers - the one who really and truly made history come alive. Another who mandated that the twenty page term paper be based on adequate primary sources and not pre-teen jargon and who had a little something extra to say on May 4, 1970 (my town was just a hop, skip and a jump from Kent). Slackers? Unh. Unh.

I admire you from taking precious life lessons from your painful and hurtful experiences and translating them into something profound and deeply meaningful for the students lucky to have you in their lives.
Beautifully written, chilling and hopeful at once. It sounds trite, but thanks for helping kids -- you're in such a unique position to recognize the ones that really need it and I bet you're amazing at reaching them.
I echo all the sentiments here, especially Madeleine's. Your students are lucky. Beautiful post.
I just wanted to thank you all for your heartfelt comments, I was very touched and I appreciate each and every one of you. I just walked in from a 14 hour first day at school (some people just DON'T know when to quit!). Reading back over this, I think it seems like I was trying to portray myself as some kind of saint. I'm not. I'm as messed up as the next person. I've have had a million (and twelve) hours of therapy and it's *those* wonderful therapists that I thank for helping me to be able to live in the world and contribute to it at the same time.

The fear will never leave me, however. It just expresses itself in other forms like the anxiety I wrote about in July. know it's a legacy that I'll have to live with and I'm ok with that.

A special hug (a big one) to those who expressed that they too had been wounded in similar ways. We ARE survivors and we have shown that from bad can come good. Just look at the flag bearer for the US Olympic team this year. It's all around us.

So bravely look back into the past and see that little boy or girl in in red, crying and forlorn, and hold him or her close to your heart. You'll both feel better.
One other note...Donna - you don't know how right you were! I sat down to write a breezy, it's-the-first-day-of-school-again kind of post and it morphed into this!! I wasn't even really aware of it until I finished. I guess it just needed "gettin' out" first. I'll do the blithe post another day!
What a beautiful and moving story. Thank you.
Marsha - just got back here (yes, we need a better way to track comments and responses to them!) - funny how my experience as a reader mapped to your experience as the writer. And I think that's part of the magic/mystery/alchemy of writing - you sit down to write and where you end up is not at all where you thought you were going. The surprise of what comes to the surface if you give it a little room...
This just popped back up in the cue stream because of Donna's comment.
I wish there was a way to put a favorite tab on some entries. I just love this one.
Everyone's said it better, but I wanted to chime and say how much I enjoyed this piece. It kind of reminded me of the slave narratives we read where reading provided an almost magic and definite psychological defense against things happening in the real world. Isn't it nice to tap into a vein of people who empathize with this amazing phenomenon? Great work and have a good new year.
I am so glad you linked to this in your comments on my post, Marsha. I missed this piece when you published it. Our common problems and solutions are so close it is scary. And even more scary is how many of us have suffered, endured, through such similar childhoods.

Yet, as you say, it would be wrong to say that the tormenting parent was all bad, for my mother had very good days when she was nice and loving and kind. But that kind of bipolar behavior led ultimately in my case to a love/hate relationship that was very tangled and took many years to get straightened out in my head.

I was in my early 40s before it all came together for me and I could leave the worst of it behind. I too can thank many hours of therapy, and likely why I did my doctorate as a double study and became both a theologian and a Christian counselor.

I have listened to many stories like ours since then, and listened to many who were wounded so badly that, while I knew the source of their problem by listening around the edges, they did not.

Some never recover in spite of all the help. We did, and I am eternally grateful for that. Clearly you did too, and, yes, it is no wonder that you became a Middle School Teacher, a profession that I would hold up proudly against a PhD in biology and a lawyer any day of the week. There is nothing second class about what you are doing.

God bless you. And God bless the children.

Monte