Out of My Mind

The Musings of a Woman Who Thinks Too Much

Nelle Engoron

Nelle Engoron
Location
California,
Birthday
May 01
Bio
You can email me at "nengoron@gmaildotcom" & follow @NelleEngoron on Twitter. My archived radio shows on last season's Mad Men are available (for free!) at: www.blogtalkradio.com/madmentalk **My "Mad Men" commentary for Season 5 is on Salon rather than here -- go to http://www.salon.com/writer/ nelle_engoron/ to find all my Salon articles. **My book, "Mad Men Unmasked: Decoding Season 4," is available on Amazon in both e-book and print versions.** I'm a writer/editor/consultant who lives in the SF Bay Area. I write about all kinds of things, but am particularly intrigued by movies, relationships, gender issues, belief systems and "Mad Men." (Scroll down left sidebar for links to a selection of my blog posts.) I'm working on a novel and a memoir, neither of which is about Mad Men!

Nelle Engoron's Links

My radio show
My articles on other sites
Movies, movies, movies
Mad Men writing on OS
A sampling of other blog posts
My book
MARCH 26, 2010 1:43PM

Open Call: Your 10 Most Influential Books

Rate: 20 Flag

 

 

Some conservative bloggers have kicked off an intriguing exercise of listing the 10 books that have most influenced their view of the world. 

An important caveat is that these aren't your favorite books, or the ones you most enjoyed reading, or maybe even books that you would argue are good (at least not now), but instead those which shaped your thinking for years after you read them.  (Of course, that thinking may well have changed later, including perhaps in response to yet another book!)

I became aware of the exercise from Ross Douthat's NY Times blog post describing it, but he says the idea originated with Tyler Cowen, who includes links to other lists here

I haven't come up with my own list yet, but wanted to go ahead and post this as I thought it would be a fun Open Call for the weekend: 

What 10 books would be on your list and why?

By the way, if you're like me, there will be ample fiction on the list, and not just the non-fiction heavy lifting on the linked lists!  You should also feel free to follow Douthat's example and list some books from childhood (after all, don't those often shape us quite profoundly at impressionable ages?).

Have fun and have a good weekend.

 

I'll update this post with links to your lists if you PM me.  Also, if you could link back to this explanatory post on your own, that will really help to let other people know what the Open Call is about and that I'm keeping a list here, etc.  - thanks!!

 

LINKS TO POSTS BY OS MEMBERS FOR THIS OPEN CALL:

 Douglas Moran

 Silkstone

Voicegal

Skeletnwmn

ClarkK

Jeff Howe

Kim Bentz

Undertow

Emma Peel

Aunt Mabel

Lainey

Stellaa

Sagemerlin

OcularNervosa

Fernsy

hyblaean-julie

Lori Hackett

Libertarius

Procopius

Abrawang

foolish monkey

Deborah Young

M. Chariot

greenheron

Vanessa Seijo

Joan H

odetteroulette

Jane Smithie

ardee

Cranky Cuss

Eva T. Made Vaudeville

Diotima

James Kastenholz

LC Neal

MrsRaptor

Jesse Mitchell

Gordon Wagner

Bobbot

Placebostudman

 Brian B

ghostwriter

Ralph Tingey

blumondayz

Jenniblu

Natalie K Munden

Patty Jane Maher

Nola Librarian

O'Really?

Kit Duncan

Dr. Susanne Freeborn

Gwool

Niall Kursk

Lorianne

HenryR

Caroline Marie

Sparking

Damion Chaplin

Jeanette DeMain

Pavanne Veltman

Jimmymac

Xenonlit

MontanaRose

JMBeanie

ladyslipper

Ann Nichols

Philip Rodgers

Alaska Progressive

David Cox

Eric Lightborn

Loserface

Hourglass Figure

Kathy Riordan

Sweetfeet

Shiral

Bellwether Vance

yekdeli

Dorinda Fox

KDStorm

AtHomePilgrim

Kind of Blue

Harry's Ghost

rmgosselin

malusinka

thegooddaughter

Daniel Walsh

Mothership

DHAustin

Geraint Istitt

KatC

Sean Fenley

BikeLizard

Lucy Mercer

Bob Mullany

Poor Woman

Cindy Capitani

Peter Winkler

T. Michael Stone

vzn

Schopenhorror

Abbie McGee

Anthony Duval

lemon pulp

mimetalker

naivebutlearning

missingK8

Bernardine Spitznogel

ChillerPop

Tom Cordle

Mrs Michaels

moviegeekjn

Cindy Prochnow

Lea Lane

Hawley Roddick

 OESheepdog

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You've really got me thinking here...
I've got myself thinking, too! I've already got 15 on my list, and that's with deleting 5 I'd put on, and I'm still coming up with more. Interestingly, most are ones I read before age 25. That worries me!
I like the way this was framed. A "favorites" list would just be another in a long succession of boring exercises we might get into. You make this truly an interesting and thought-provoking exercise. Thanks. -R-
Oooo, I will have to give that one some thought. I have a pile of books I refer to on a regular basis.
Thanks, Poor Woman. I've seen similar exercises framed as "soul's code" lists - a key to yourself, in perhaps ineffable ways. Sometimes we don't know or can't articulate why something was meaningful to us, we just know that it stirred us profoundly and stayed with us. This exercise is a bit more intellectual, in asking what shaped our views, beliefs and thinking about life and the world, but still very intriguing, I think.
What an intriguing idea, food for thought.
Very, very good - thanks for sharing. Wowza - tough - but is Monday a good time to report back? Or should we do our own post? Love this idea.
As I likely won't do my own post to respond to this, I will start off by saying that early on, the Nancy Drew series gave me my first sense of strong and brave women and then Louisa May Alcott's, "Little Women. The Diary of Ann Frank, without a doubt, Gone With the Wind, big time...so many from earlier in life shaped my views and appreciation for strong female writers and protaganists.
To answer questions:

Yes, I'd love to see people do their own posts on this!! I suggest a list with anywhere from one sentence to a paragraph on each book's meaning and impact on you.

Monday or even later is fine! no expiration date on this Open Call.

If you don't want to do a whole post, you can put your list in Comments here (as Just Cathy started to do), but if you have more than a paragraph or so, I'd suggest you do a post. And again, I'll link people's posts here if you PM me.

I'm working on mine but probably won't have it done and up till Sat.
this will take some time and thought. I saw the blog you reference. Can't say that many listed were of interest or meaning to me. I did not look at many since they were pretty redundant, but I did not see The Bible, was it there?
Great idea! I'm in on this!
I will enjoy thinking about this one this weekend. I could do many lists of ten: ten most influential as a kid, ten most influential as an artist, ten most influential in terms of character, ten books I've read more than once...etc. Good idea, Silkstone :-)
Greenheron, I think that's a great idea and one that I'll throw out to anyone who's considering this and feels overwhelmed -- to narrow it down to a subset of books that have influenced you in one dimension or aspect of your life.

I've been working on my list and explanations off and on all day and I'll say that even though it's a bit of work, it's also been a lot of fun and quite illuminating!

One cheat that I saw others do on the lists I linked and which I'm doing as well is to pair some books that have equal and similar influence on you (share the same themes, had the same impact, etc). That way you can avoid making some difficult decisions when trying to keep the list to 10! I also found at least one fascinating pair that I hadn't clued into until trying to do this exercise.
I have to go with more than 10...and I still culled dozens and dozens...

TEN MOST INFLUENTIAL

1. Open Veins of Latin America/The Nobodies-Eduardo Galeano

2. The Search for the Tassili Frescoes-Henri Lhote

3. The Mediterranean, Civilization and Capitalism- Fernand Braudel

4. The Great War for Civilization-Fisk

5 Looking for Dilmun-Geoffrey Bibby

6. The Paranoid Style/Anti Imtellectualism in American Life-Hofstader

7. Through the Grand Canyon frm Wyoming to Mexico-Kolb

8. Street without Joy/Hell in a Very Small Place-Bernard Fall

9. Muqaddimah-Ibn Khaldun

10. The Histories-Herodotus

OTHER CONTENDERS

Look at Us-Saroyan
Monopoly Capital-Baran and Sweezy
From Ritual to Romance-Weston
The Golden Bough-Frazer
Social Justice in Islam-Ibn Qutb


INFLUENTIAL NOVELS

Every Man Dies Alone-Hans Fallada
Bleak House-Dickens
Death in Venice-Mann
The Sound and the Fury-Faulkner
Across the River and into the Trees
Under the Volcano-Lowry
All the Kings Men-Penn Warren
Appointment in Samarra-OHara
The Way We Live Now-Trollope
Heart of Darkness-Conrad
The Sheltering Sky-Bowles
Post Office-Bukowski
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep-Phillip K Dick
Mulberry Empire-Phillip Hensher
This is a total challenge. I dunno . . . I have a hard time remembering the names of books I've read.
My list made me realize that I must go out and buy the rest of the books I no longer own so I can put these 10 together on my bookshelf knowing I can always reference them and re-read them at my leisure.
This is gonna take me allllll weekend. :)
Interesting exercise. In my case, I think the most influential books overlap pretty much with my favorites. But I'll have to think about it.
Great idea. Here is the link to my response: http://open.salon.com/blog/emma_peel/2010/03/26/open_call_10_books_that_influenced_me/comment
I'm thrilled so many have taken the plunge! I'm updating the link list above as fast as I become aware of new posts.

I've been so busy after posting this that I haven't had a chance to read most of your lists yet, but I will!
Ooh fun! I'll get started right away! R
count me in but I couldn't stop at ten.
Wow! I'm thrilled with how many people are doing this!!
Our list is up to 48!

I think that's all of them so far, but if I've missed anyone, just let me know (most folks aren't PMing me - I'm checking the feed but I don't know that I'll have time to keep doing that).

I also notice as always that Open Call is like a game of "Telephone" - people see other people's blogs on it and go from there, and sometimes the topic does shift a bit. Linking back to this post on yours is a good way to let people know what the Open Call is about, and also so they can find the list of linked posts above and read as many as possible!

I have to do a bunch of work I have to do today but wish instead I could read all your lists...I'm going to do that as soon as I can.
I haven't had this much fun in ages. Still trying to understand why "influential" is more interesting to read then "favorite" but it just is. It's like we get a little window into why each of us is who we are.
Lainey, I agree! The "influential" angle makes all the difference from the usual list like this. Books that shaped us.
Silkstone -- I'm curious about the common titles. I've noticed lots of lists with Lord of the Rings, Stranger in a STrange Land (or at least some Heinlein book). I guess it would be a lot of work to compile all of them.
Thanks for a wonderful Open Call!!!!
Skel, I only have time right now to update the link list above, but think it would be great if someone else looked at that -- a "meta" post on patterns in these responses would be fascinating!

We're up to 54!!
This is a great open call Silkstone. Thank you for it.
Great idea!
Count me in!
Here's mine:
http://open.salon.com/blog/caroline_marie/2010/03/27/lucky_13_most_influential_books
Ann makes 65! I can't believe how many people have done this...it's great.
This had to be the most intellectually satisfying exchange I've ever encountered on OS. I expect to be reading and rereading all of the submissions for at least a week! Thank you, Silkstone, for elevating the discourse, for bringing some real sustenance and nourishment to Open Salon.
I can't wait to come back and look through all these lists!
Thanks for compiling all the lists. I will be browsing through them on my next foray into Amazon. One for sure: "War and Peace".
83 responses!

I'm overwhelmed at how many people have responded to this Open Call, but I guess it's no surprise that writers would feel strongly about books.
Great open call. I'll have to think about this some more. What are yours?
Caroline, mine's linked above (2nd on list) or just check last entry on my blog. Hope to see your list!

101 responses so far!! I'm stunned.
The most wonderful surprise, reading responses to this brilliant Open Call, is that one gains a unique perspective on what it's like to be inside another head. Some lists give me a glimpse of an inner life that may not be so very different from mine. But the lists that are far from my own list give me the most to ponder, because, with the help of the written explanations, I get a glimpse of what it is like to be the person to whom these books are so important. And it's very different from being me. Who knew we are so diverse in the ways these lists imply?

If you have time, please add a link to my recent response to your open call.