Out of My Mind

The Musings of a Woman Who Thinks Too Much

Nelle Engoron

Nelle Engoron
Location
California,
Birthday
May 01
Bio
My Season 5 "Mad Men" commentary is on Salon.com rather than here (see my last blog post). *****My e-book, "Mad Men Unmasked: Decoding Season 4," is now available on Amazon! ***** I'm a writer/editor/consultant who lives in the SF Bay Area. I write about all kinds of things, but am particularly intrigued by movies, relationships, gender issues and "Mad Men." (Scroll down the left sidebar for links to what I've published elsewhere as well as a selection of my blog posts.) I'm writing a novel about religious and romantic obsession and have completed a memoir, "Seeking," about my (successful) quest for love, which included personal ad dates with 200 men. Email me at "Nelle@NelleEngorondotcom" Amazon author page at: amazon.com/author/nelleengoron

Nelle Engoron's Links

Books I've written
Articles of Mine on Other Sites
Movies, Movies, Movies
Mad Men Commentary
Musings, Memoir & Humor (on many topics)
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 4, 2010 7:32AM

Chinese Wall: Mad Men, Season 4, Episode 11 (Commentary)

Rate: 16 Flag

 

 Peg

 

They’re about the meaningful life a woman leads when work is done. ~ Peggy

 

Ah, but a woman’s work is never done, as the old saying tells us. Sometimes just getting through her life is work. And sometimes work is her life, because she’s ambitious or she gets tangled up with her boss…or both. This week the women of Mad Men get worked up and worked over and the “Chinese Wall” that’s supposed to separate business from personal life comes crumbling down for some, while others desperately try to rebuild it and regain control. The men, meanwhile, act mostly weasel-y and desperate, and are so married to their careers that they offer their families mere trinkets while missing the most important events of their lives.

 

There’s no business in here, son. ~ Tom to Pete  

Like a cornerstone pulled out of a building, Lucky Strike begins the cascade of possible ruin when it “goes South” (weren’t they there already?), jumping to BBDO before the 30 days that Lee Garner Jr. had promised Roger. Perhaps Lee knows that Roger wasn’t using the time anyway, having delayed delivery of the bad news to Don and the other partners until it’s too late. (“Good news is always worth waiting for,” Pete’s mother-in-law says about a different delivery, and Roger clearly feels the same way about bad.)

Cosgrove’s the first to learn the truth while celebrating a night out with his fiancé and future in-laws, when a BBDO exec casually offers him condolences and he figures out that it’s not for the loss of a fellow mad man who’s died, but something they care about much more – business. Starting a daisy chain of desperation, Ken rushes to tell Pete, who has to leave the hospital where Trudy is laboring to produce what everyone is expecting from her, a feeling that her husband will soon sympathize with, although at a funeral instead of a birth. Pete continues the chain letter of ill fortune by calling Don, and soon all the partners are convened at the office, where Roger has to pull a Sally-at-the-deli with a faked phone call that supposedly brings the overdue news.

Having “worried every day what would happen if this happened” (something that’s true for him on many levels, as we saw last week), Don seeks solace with Faye, who reassures him that he’s the most wanted man on Madison Avenue (not to mention on every couch).  But her loving attention is repaid by Don asking her to break that Chinese wall of confidentiality and tip him off to unhappy clients at the other agencies she consults for. When she says she can’t do that, Don blithely replies, “Sure you can,” demonstrating once again a lack of moral fiber that must be one cause of his emotional constipation. When she rightly complains that, “You want to throw me to the wolves to save your neck,” he doubles down on his insensitivity by dismissing her concerns as meaningless since she’s a mere employee of her company while he’s an owner of his firm. Furious, Faye tries to draw a line between work and personal life that’s apparently invisible to Don, declaring, “I would never use you like this because I know the difference between what we have and this stupid office.”

But Faye ultimately fails to maintain that line, caving after she’s “thought about whatever you are in my life right now” (notably unspecified) and offering Don the tip that Heinz isn’t happy with their aptly named agency, Ketchum. Having faced her earlier fury, Don accepts this offer with surprise rather than the relish we’d expect. But then, he’s a man in a pickle by that time, having already moved on from Faye with a tryst with Megan on his office couch.

That soon-to-be second Mrs. Donald Draper continues her eerie similarity to Jane Siegel-Sterling by playing as innocent as Bambi while getting her man exactly where she wants him – in her target sights. Rather than acting the damsel-in-distress as Jane did, Megan’s tactic is to cozy up to Don over client strategy statements, demurely saying she wants to know more about the business not only to avoid those silly little mistakes she’s made before, but because “ultimately” she’d like to do Don’s job – or, uh, Peggy’s (a hedge against any possible charges of hubris). Don’s either come a long way, baby, or he’s enamored of Megan, because he fails to give her the sexist put-downs that Peggy’s had to endure for her ambition (such as reminding her she started as his secretary and has a job that a “grown man” should be doing). Instead he seems fascinated to find out Megan’s a plucky Montreal girl who came to the Big Apple not because she’s an artist (which she insists she’s not) but merely “artistic,” having “dabbled” in writing, painting and acting.

Playing Don like Cosgrove’s gold violin, she overcomes his nanosecond of hesitation at sleeping with her by reassuring him that it’s merely personal, not business, and that she just wants him for tonight and won’t throw a morning-after hissy like Allison did. Despite the fact that she’s just admitted she thinks about him all the time, Don falls for this “co-worker with benefits” offer as if he’s dealing with a female Don Draper.  And Megan leads him to think that’s precisely what she is, not just because she wants his job but because she says that, like him, she judges people on their work and “everything else is sentimental.” Memo to Don: Unless sex is work, that means what you’re doing on that couch is sentimental. She may have pulled your Clio out of the trash, but you may have to pull your ass out of the fire for having fallen for one of the oldest lines in the book, “I don’t want anything from you but this one magic night.”  Didn’t you notice how “wifey” she acted with you afterward, telling you she wanted you to go home, get some sleep and not drink any more?

 It’s the last days of Rome. I was in an agency that went down. The women get sex crazed. The energy is very good. ~ Stan

Showing once again that she’s moving ahead of her boss and mentor, Peggy both separates and combines work and pleasure adeptly in this episode.  Having run into Abe at Jones Beach, they end up at her apartment making salty sandy love that leaves them both sweetly besotted.  “I’m not usually like this,” Peggy murmurs when they can’t bear to separate (in any sense) and when she moonily wanders late into the “all hands” meeting announcing the loss of Lucky Strike, she hardly seems to care. (After all, what’s a cigarette matter when you’ve met your match?) But as the news sinks in and she's told by Don that she must singlehandedly nail the Playtex glove presentation, she reacts with a feeling that every Catholic girl recognizes after enjoying sex:  “Every time something good happens, something bad happens.  I knew I’d pay for it.” 

But she soon returns to her usual competent self. Don brusquely tells her she’s not paying for anything, and she doesn’t, landing the client with a persuasive presentation despite the smeared lipstick on her teeth (which she’s able to laugh off easily in her victory). Incorporating her sexual satisfaction into the campaign, and emulating the “poetic” conclusion that she admires Don’s pitches for, she enthuses about “all the things a woman wants to touch” – an integration of the romantic into work that the client admits he hadn’t thought would be possible. Even after naively falling for Stan’s juvenile groping trap, she shakes off her reflexive sexual guilt, laying the blame precisely where she should by exasperatedly asking him, “Why do you keep making me reject you?”

Maybe it’s a good time to get out of this business. ~ Roger  

While Peggy seems to be smoothly integrating romance with work (even slipping in a nooner with Abe in her office), Joan has ceased to find the silver lining in polishing Sterling.  The match that breaks the not-Camels back comes when Roger confesses his concealment of the Lucky Strike-out. Calling her from the NYC hotel where he’s hiding out (while pretending to be in North Carolina trying to get the client back), he reveals his cowardice and draws her anger at failing to even try to save the business.  Oblivious to her reaction, he begs her to join him at the hotel and comfort him, but his failure to try to woo the client is repaid by losing any hope of doing so with Joan.

Showing up at her apartment later, he’s genuinely mystified as to why she didn’t obey his summons to play reassuring Mommy. So adept at language when it suits him, Roger is utterly obtuse when it comes to parsing his own motivations or the feelings of others. Arguing that Joan always comes back to him “because we belong together,” he insists that she comply once again because “I need you right now” and counters her weary observation, “Because I’m a port in a storm” with a clueless “No, because I feel like shit and you care about me,” not understanding he’s just proved her point. 

Tantalizing us with a further hint that she did not go through with the abortion, Joan warns, “I’m not a solution to your problems; I’m another problem.”  But it takes the three-times-is-the charm repetition of “I can’t do this any more” before he finally believes her, and his reaction says it all: Rather than bemoaning losing the love of his life, he merely regrets not knowing the mugging was the last time they’d have sex. But what can you expect from a guy who thinks that the highest compliment he can pay a woman is telling her that she’s the greatest piece of ass he’s ever had?  Here’s hoping Joan has truly kissed off Roger for the last time.

Stumbling home to trophy wife Jane in double defeat, Roger’s presented with the hollow victory he deserves, the first copies of the book he’s spent the past year writing rather than tending to the business of keeping his clients happy. (Those who can’t do, write.) Like the cold breath that Stan told Peggy to blow in his face, the title “Sterling’s Gold” mocks Roger even as a clueless Jane tells him how proud she is. After inscribing a book with the insipid, “To my loving wife,” at her insistence, he slumps down and reluctantly accepts her embrace on the marital couch. 

You made me wait for you while you worked. I’m not waiting anymore. ~ Faye to Don

Back at Chez Draper, Don falls into the exact same posture with Faye, who’s just thrown him a lifeline in the form of a possible death knell to her own career, should word of her unethical indiscretion leak out (any bets on whether it will?).  While Roger appears utterly unconnected to Jane, Don seems silently remorseful at Faye’s sacrifice, perhaps wondering what he’s done by cavalierly moving on to Megan. Reluctantly inviting Faye to stay while warning her he’ll probably just fall asleep on her, he buries his head in her hair with either real affection or need.  As both men sit on their (for once) sexless couches with their mates, Roger seems lost, but we’re left wondering whether Don will fall asleep emotionally on Faye, becoming unconscious again after his recent attempts to wake up.  “Miracles, I guess, still happen now and then,” music hopefully croons as the credits roll, “Step into my heart.”

We have dog food experience. ~ Don at the funeral

I got him. ~ Pete

But hearts are what these men seem to have buried in their drive to succeed, even using the funeral of a rival mad man to troll for accounts they can harvest like organs from his dead corporate body.  The eulogies that the guests offer up for the dear departed point up the hollowness of the businessman’s life, telling tales of months spent away from home while reassuring the grieving wife and daughter that the baubles he made sure to buy them showed that they were his real treasures.  In the same vein, Pete’s father-in-law shoos him from the hospital by saying he was at a ball game when Trudy was born and Pete should likewise “relax and go about your business,” while the women get on with this minor matter of bringing new life into the world. Pete’s informed of his daughter’s birth and wife’s recovery by a secretary and while obviously touched, doesn’t question the imperative that he go to a funeral and drum up business rather than rushing to be with his family. Like several other characters in this episode, Pete’s being wooed, possibly by the least attractive suitor of all, the slimy Ted Chaough.  Pete’s father-in-law Tom pressures him to accept Chaough’s advances, terming SCDP a “folly” and saying Pete needs to grow up now that he’s a father. Despite this hard sell as well as Chaough’s tempting offer to put his name on the building (as he’s always wanted), Pete’s sure that Chaough’s just trying to get revenge on Don for the Honda fiasco and so resists the courtship – for now. 

I’m not at that point yet. ~ Don  

Recovering the Clio that Don has hurled across his office when Glo-Coat devalues it by telling him they’re abandoning the sinking ship SCDP, Megan explains that “I thought in the end you wouldn’t want to throw it away.” 

“You’re wrong,” Don responds gloomily. What he might throw away – his success or his personal life or both – remains an abiding question of the series, one that has broadened to encompass the other characters.  Each is struggling with the dividing line of work and life, trying to determine what will truly make them happy, and only the dark horse Peggy seems to be pulling ahead in the race, declaring “I’m not worried,” even as the agency teeters on the brink of collapse. Rather than ruining her career as she feared, Abe’s proved himself a good guy, and she takes the risk of accepting his humble implied apology (“I’m learning”) and letting him into her heart. Having earlier told Don that nothing seems as compelling as what she does in the office, she seems to have found something that is, embracing that “meaningful life” that women have when their work is done, including finding meaning in having done that work well.

Tellingly, while Don tries to monitor his drinking, enlisting Megan to help him yet still ending up as he tells Faye, “one over” (but not won over?), Peggy tells Stan that “I can’t do this drunk” before delivering her crucial presentation. Soberly facing her fears in both romance and work, she succeeds and literally has the last laugh, even at her own foibles, rather than lying and hiding in fear, a route that seems to be leading the men who follow it to destruction.

 

Only so much we can pretend like we’re doing.~ Don

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Great post. It's good to check in on Monday morning! I'm finally coming around on the subject of Roger and Joan -- good riddance. And I agree with you about Peggy. I always had the feeling she was going to wind up running things.
Terrific commentary, Nelle.
Was I the only one who expected Roger to finally sack up for once , fly to Raleigh and wow the Board? Right up until the phone call with Joan - I was sure she would tell him to go. Perhaps the rumours that John Slattery is tired of acting are true, though that would be such a loss, because he is the best on the show. Jon Hamm seemed especially monochromatic. Robert Morse shone. Maybe Bert Cooper will be the saviour?
Will Weiner pull out the rabbit, or completely reboot for season five?
I still say that Peggy can do SO much better than Abe.
You pegged Meaghan exactingly, though I thought the Clio scene showed how much she really does understand Don.
Wouldn't Don have issues with Faye catching a scent of Meaghan?
This episode seems to have sealed Roger's demise, I think. Bert's comment to him sums it all up - "Lee Garner Jr. never took you seriously because you never took yourself seriously." He was always vapid, but now he's truly pathetic.
Great post Nelle.

Weiner is not a credited writer for this episode, and it shows. While it is good, it is not great, at least in terms of multiple layers of subtleness and symbolism. It is pretty straightforward writing. That is probably appropriate, now that we are in the home stretch. the first nine episodes were devoted to studying the characters' response to the bombshells at the end of the previous season. So, I suppose the past two episodes and the next two episodes will be bombshells.

It is still August and the pacing is quickening to a real time mode. So it seems unlikely that the season will end with the blackout, which ocurred in early November.

The season does seem to be reflecting both 1965 and 2009 (even a reference to British Petroleum). The executives at SCDP have driven their company into the ground through incompetence, unscrupulousness and a sense of entitlement. I would have titled this episode, "Men Behaving Badly". (And to think that you ladies assert that the women characters are shown in a poor light.)

here are a coule of curiosities about Joan and Roger. First of all, Joan is not wearing her wedding ring. Second, when roger accepts that Joan will never go to bed with him, romantic string music played in the background. This show never plays background music, except at the end of an episode. what is up with that?

So, how does this train wreck play out? I just don't see Weiner writing a a trite ending where someone saves the day. The only exception to that would be Bert Cooper using his old new York ties to pull one out of the hat and justify his existence. It would also allow him to assert his character as the only adult in the room, while all the boys are behaving badly.
Joan's wedding ring was stolen by the mugger two episodes ago.

What's the tip that we're still in August? Fewer than 30 days have passed since Lee Garner broke the news about Lucky Strike, but that occurred around Aug. 11 or 12 (the Beatles concert was on Sunday, Aug. 15).

I'm not at all sure what to make of Megan, whose actions seemed to come out of nowhere this week.
Great line, Nelle, about polishing the Sterling. Love this blog, and the comments.
Thank you Nelle, once more, for your hard work, attention to detail and the "Monday Morning- MM Post-Game" Report, I couldn't live without it.
One point that I was curious about, was when Don is pushing Faye to self-destruct by saying "I would do it for you" (meaning that he would share trade secrets to help her). Now, really! Would he ever make himself that vulnerable professionally to help HER?
Holy Moly, is she rising for a fall. As to Megan being the "next Mrs. Draper." Sure looks like that's where it's going, but I bet Don does a save at the last minute, sees through her and carries on. I too still think Joan is pregnant, and that through these series of crises, Roger slowly but surely, and against all odds, begins to grow.
Hope springs eternal.
Not only was your post great as always, but loved your cigarette puns (I can't help it, I've always been a sucker for clever puns).

The sex notwithstanding, until this episode, I felt that Roger and Joan had a real friendship and some mutual respect. When he did his " we belong together . . .because you care about me and make me feel better" speech, I actually yelled at the TV, giving my cat quite a fright. At this moment, it doesn't look as if Roger can do anything to redeem himself, making me wonder if the rumors Brian has heard about Slattery's being tired of acting are true. If Roger is going to remain a character, Weiner's got his writing work cut out for him. And Tennessee, I was so busy trying to soothe my cat's frayed nerves that I completely missed the romantic music in Joan and Roger's good-bye scene.

I loved seeing Peggy come in to work in a pink haze after her night with Abe -- yes, Brian, she can do better, but he's the best she's done so far. At first, the SCDP situation can't cut through her erotic fog, but then when she realizes the gravity of the situation, she characteristically puts her nose (perhaps somewhat lipstick smeared) to the grindstone and lands Playtex gloves.

And what is it with Pete and Don? Why, with what he knows about Don and the way Don treats him both last episode and this one, is Pete so loyal? It's easy to say that Pete,who never had his father's approval, is looking for an approving daddy, but Don isn't old enough, and of anyone at SCDP, Pete knows that Don might not be good father material. I also missed Don saying to Pete, at the funeral, "We've got dog food experience." I did hear Pete say, "I've got him." I either need to turn the volume up or get my hearing checked.

I like the idea of Bert Cooper coming to SCDP's rescue, and I'm hoping for two bang-up final episodes.

I'm still not sure how to view Megan; I'm still half willing to believe that she's a free spirit and not that manipulative, kind of like Ms. Farrell. But last night's events do make that seem less likely.

When Faye, who must love Don, to have compromised her principals for him, showed up at his flat after his office tryst with Megan, put her arms around him, I heard Betty saying to her therapist, "Sometimes he comes home smelling of perfume, sometimes something worse."

It's worth noting, I think, that in Don and Betty's relationship, Betty was more or less a child. Don never expected mothering from her, yet he allows (asks) both Faye and Megan to mother him by helping him limit his drinking. And he feels at least some remorse about what's gone on with Megan when Faye turns up at his flat. He never seemed to feel any remorse about his adulteries when he was with Betty.
Joan giving Roger the kiss-off was deeply sad.

If Megan's angling to be the new Mrs. Don does that make Faye Don's Joan?
I am NOT reading your post today . . . because I'll get the episode on-demand tonight. But I'll be back.
Nice wordplay in your piece, Nelle. We have a less than jolly Roger looking like a burned out butt fading to white in a railway station stand up ashtray while the call goes out to hop on the future train. Our cadaverous cad teeters on the brink of moral destruction (does that Meggin have an OS bio or what?) while his savior swoons in lush life violin infused rhapsody giving the viewing wretches something to look forward to, and girls do just wanna have fun.
I finally lost it with Mr. Draper. The other men have always been weak. Roger for example has always been immature, so all of his complexities were not as challenging. But Don was always written as a complex man, and for that reason, compelling. But he's become more insufferable than interesting lately, and last night, he became a certified asshole. I understand we don't analyse characters from one's contemporary point of view, but there are universal characterizations that transcend time - and although he is supposed to mirror the flawed pre-60's Western man struggling with the confusion of the cultural changes underway, he cannot stop being a human being. Perhaps because there has been a kind of 'Shakespearean' color to his characterization, I expect this show to rise above easy generalizations. Don cannot just be a cold, egotistic child. I need to keep seeing glimpses of the redemptive in the man. I would hate to see his character lose that ambiguity. I remember how Tony Soprano never lost it, even at the end, when he took LSD (?) and thought he "got it", and we knew he didn't. You still felt for the guy. I was with him all the way even after he killed his own nephew - even hours after its 'aborted' ending, you were still trying to remember if there were hints of some kind of redemption. Two more episodes then. We'll see...
Mad Men is certainly irreducible to any simplistic set of ideas, but it is striking how often the writers show us instances of the uncomfortable alliance between the personal and the professional.

Weiner himself has stated that he started the project being interested in ideas of identity, and the kinds of identities he’s consistently displayed are those that are transforming themselves as a result of professional endeavors. Work grants a confidence and a measure of equality, as it does for Peggy, showing that it has the power to raise the social status of those who had been left out of previous power arrangements. Yet there is also a debasement that arises from the split loyalties that separation of work and life entails, nicely exemplified by the fact that respect for births and deaths are essentially sacrificed on the altar of business. Abe’s comment a few episodes back about America’s religion being business is certainly confirmed here, and it is that absolute loyalty to profits over people that will be so angrily challenged in the coming youth revolt.

The most compelling aspect of Mad Men, the decision to set the story in the ‘60s, cleverly reminds America just how much its identity has changed, and its focus on advertising is an elegant way of exploring the kinds of activities which essentially reshaped the American character. The point of advertising is to “create want”, to liberate desires, to forge emotional bonds between products and people such that people come to view themselves differently. The immediate goal is money, personal gain, but the end result is a radical transformation of how we see ourselves.

There are many hints that the kind of work Don does is in part responsible for creating the liberated identities that shook the system down to its hands and knees. And this seems to be the most potent idea of the series: the way in which capitalism allows for a kind of fluid identity, one always in transformation in ways the mavericks of industry never could have presaged. Don and Peggy are the central characters of the show because they best exemplify the notion that one can reconstruct identity with the help of the business world.

This reformulation of identity is not seen as good or bad; it just is. Certainly Peggy’s ascent is cause for joy to all women, but we mustn’t forget that she paid with her first born for the privilege of upending the boy’s private club. Similarly, Don is clearly an alpha master of the universe type, having come from the lowliest of possible circumstances, and we have to admire how he became what he desired. Yet to achieve that goal he abandoned his original family, and has created schism in his current one.

Furthermore, business tends to create motivations with no respect for morality or life. The birth and funeral scenes drive that point home, and more subtly, we are consistently reminded that SCDP’s existence is mostly due to convincing America to smoke. Harking back to the very first episode, Don and co. are able to push cigarettes by telling people, “wherever you are, whatever you’re doing, you are OK”. But are they OK? Are they really?

So what is the kind of identity that’s being invented one piece of copy at a time? Mad Men strongly suggests that it is an empowered identity, but one defunct in emotional health, defunct in its ability to recognize what is truly valuable in life and hold fast to it. Certain characters navigate these waters better than others, (Peggy seems especially well balanced at the moment), but I think in the end all characters will regretfully pay a significant price for having sought empowerment.

An ancient piece of wisdom holds that a master in the art of living makes no distinction between work and play - he is always doing both. American culture never truly embraced this ideal; indeed it’s hard to think of other times and places in history in which there was such a thorough separation of professional and personal lives. What does it mean to have a set of work goals for most of the day, and then come home where another set of priorities await? Do people become what they do? What will be the effect on our most cherished relationships when we split our loyalties and often grant the larger share to the set of impersonal relations we call work?

Impossible to predict exactly, but things will inevitably get emotionally messy. One thing however is beyond dispute: what Mad Men depicts is very serious business.
A possible redemptive moment for Roger: When he alluded to Lee Gardner's concern re: television not taking cigarette ads in the future-though Cig ads were banned in the UK on Aug 1, 1965, it would take till Jan 1971 for the ban to take effect in the US.
I wonder if SCDP DOES become more political (and left-leaning and selective with what clients it serves) as the lead characters evolve? Lane is involved with a black woman, Peggy with a Jewish leftie, and who knows what or who is on the docket for Don?
Great analysis, as always, Nelle. For me, the most moving part of the episode was Don and Pete sitting uncomfortably at the funeral, listening to the tales of how the dead ad exec neglected his daughter, when Pete hasn't even seen his new daughter yet, and Don is remote and estranged from Sally who needs him desperately.

I think the storyline is building toward a Roger Sterling suicide. He's just not strong enough to handle all of it. I think Joan is distancing herself from Roger so that when her pregnancy becomes obvious, no one will connect the two of them as lovers. I also thought, as you did, that Joan's comment, "I'm another problem" indicated that there was an ongoing problem - her pregnancy.

I also thought, as did the previous poster, that Faye would smell Megan on Don. I kept wanting him to tell her he needed to wash up.
Nelle, I started to count my fav observations here, but there are just waaaay too many. Ok - Top Fav: "Joan has ceased to find the silver lining in polishing Sterling", but I could go on... thanks again for an astute review, full of bon mots and wonderful turns of phrase.
Oh! I forgot to mention that it looks like the question about Faye's background has been answered. Definitely Jewish (she made reference to Don's punim, yiddish for 'face' I think), which means he's 0 for 2 with the Jewish ladies. Oy vey, such a shame.
Steven, Peg is looking stronger and stronger all the time. I like the well-rounded person she's becoming. And yeah, I'm way ready for the Roger and Joan show to be over. Like Joan, I can't do it anymore!

Susan, thanks!

Brian, thanks! I was shocked that Roger hadn't said anything to anyone but once that fact came out, I knew he wouldn't do anything. After all, if he did, it would come out that he'd sat on the news for weeks. So he had to go all-in on his lie that it was a surprise to him as it was to everyone else. I hadn't heard that about Slattery - -would be a shame if so, and I'd be surprised if he'd blow off Roger, which is a great character to play. As for the smell, yes, that occurred to me, too, as it did to several other commenters!

Jeanette, I thought about including that quote, because like you, it seemed to sum Roger up perfectly -- at least careerwise.

Tennessee, I find the writing this season to be far less complex overall. It's a high bar, though, that the show set the first 3 seasons. The BP anecdote stuck out at me, too, and I don't think that's a good thing, when they wink at our present day time (or it has that effect, due to current events). But you have sharper ears than I do -- I missed that romantic music despite watching the ep twice in a row!

Crunchy, I think Megan's been in stealth mode but my take is that she's been biding her time, being careful and laying groundwork -- e.g., the nice way she handled Sally in the office. And now she's sprung into action.

Lorrie, thanks!

Shelley, Good point that Don would almost certainly not risk his career for Faye! (Why do I suddenly hear Bogart in Casablanca saying, "I stick out my neck for no man"??) And you have an interesting idea that SCDP could carve out a niche as a more "lefty" agency and fill a gap. I hadn't thought of that.

Adele, Roger reached a height of loathesomeness in this episode. You have to give the show credit - -they cut out his cutesy-poo side so that rather than laughing at him, you could feel genuinely angry at the small person that he is. (He seemed like a spoiled child to me...which of course is what he was.) I don't think Pete's being loyal to Don at this point -- I think he's being loyal to an agency he helped start and is a partner of (albeit an unnamed one). I think his FIL suggesting he get a "real" job (in effect) only stiffened his spine to make it work, to make it something of his own vs. just working for another agency as an exec. And realistically, he could look forward to being a full named partner as Roger and Bert retire. As noted above to Brian, I also thought about how Don smelled, and even thought Faye was about to say something at one point to that effect. And yes, Don's definitely expecting more mothering than he ever did from Betty - kind of an interesting change. As for Megan, I thought she put her cards on the table this week -- at least to the viewers, who aren't lust-blind like Don.

David, that's an interesting idea, but I can't see Faye ever agreeing to be someone's mistress!

Damon, ha! and thanks.

Kalayaan, I found your comparison of Don and Tony very interesting (especially as a huge fan of The Sopranos). I agree that Don's character, while fascinating and more relatable than Tony, suffers from less consistency in how he's written. I think part of that is deliberate -- he's supposed to be slippery and not what he seems and also shifting and changing -- but sometimes it feels like a lack of continuity or forethought. I also appreciate TV or movies that take the risk of portraying characters that aren't likable (even Tony was notably so, despite being a homicidal sociopath!) but agree that you can only push the audience's patience on that so far. I think Don's coming to an edge, or at least I hope so, as the season winds up.

Ryan, lots of good insights as always! I will comment just on the cigarettes, which I also find fascinating as a throughline for the series. I remember the opening of the series very well, with Don in a restaurant/bar smoking, thinking up Lucky Strike ads and talking to the waiter about his cigs. I remember my own childhood as being enveloped by cigarette smoke - it was literally the air we breathed. I think as a metaphor for the series (as well as a realistic depiction of American commerce), it's brilliant.

Jill, I found the funeral scene moving, too, as Pete and Don's expressions said so much. As for Roger, I had a fleeting thought he'd die, too -- not suicide but a stress-induced heart attack. Remember we saw him pop a nitroglycerin tab for his heart after his talk with Lee Jr hearing the bad news. The guy has early death written all over him! As for the scent on Don - per note to Brian above, several of us had the exact same thought!

Gabby, I chuckled when Faye used the word "punim" and thought, "OK, well, that settles that question." Although people who grow up in NYC do learn and use various Yiddish expressions. But I think we're supposed to believe she's an assimilated Jew, including with a familial name change some time back.
Hey Nelle. Great review and the puns and allusions just flowed seamlessly in this week's post. I especially liked "what’s a cigarette matter when you’ve met your match?".

Interesting to get a woman's take on the Megan-Don scene. At first it seemed too soap opera-ish but in the end I guess they pulled it off. And in Don's position I probably would have succumbed too.

His pressuring of Faye to tip him off about potential clients seemed about right as well. It would have seemed moralistic had he not done so, especially in a crisis.

Glad to see more blossoming from Peggy and Pete continues from strength to strength. As for Roger, mid-life crisis or what? I thought he'd muster up something but now he's just a shell, an empty suit. Everybody's on him about losing his only client, he knows very well he's mishandled it, Joan rejects him and he must be counting the time till his wife sees through him. I'm still expecting a bounceback but it's long odds now.

I thought that Faye might have picked up some scent on Don back at his apartment. Did he wash up off-camera?

Maybe Heinz will save SCDP's bacon if Don can give them a good shake. But maybe's it's time for Honda to reappear. Only two more to go and you know that SCDP can't go under.
I'm still hoping for the Japanese/Honda to come to the rescue but we'll see what the writers have in store. 2 episodes left? Nelle, what are we supposed to do without you? (Any chance you'll watch and blog about "In Treatment"? I know it's not the same as Mad Men or Sopranos, but it's fun to talk about.)

I like Abe for Peggy; at least he's edgy and ethnic in a pseudo-1960's leftist sort of way. His temporary loss of Peggy seems to have given him a little more substance.
As always, I appreciate your intelligent take. rated
Good post but the advertising business, at least the accounts end of it is whoredom at it's finest. And these guys are starting up an agency, racing the big guns and they've got to be on point at all times. Even if they're not with this agency. THAT"S the nature of it. You're in it to win it.

So a baby born without a dad present, a funeral where everyone is watching the big clients for signals (and don't think it's just the sterling coopers who were looking for loose ends), where friends ask other friends to give them a line on a potential lead for business and ethics be damned. It happens. And not only that... it happens all the time. I was thinking last night exactly how she could have told him about Heinz without saying the name or saying anything that was unethical while still giving him the info.

The business is super lucrative, superfast and super cut throat. it was then, it is now. Read From Those Wonderful Folks Who Gave You Pearl Harbor by Jerry Della Famina because it's obvious the writers on Mad Men have. The business is unlike ANY other. You fall in love with it and once you love it, you're ruined for any thing else.

What makes this show unique is how it shows the VERY qualities that make it seductive: it is an entirely amoral, greedy, obsessive, misogynist, exciting, creative and myopic business answering only to itself. The show isn't about any one or any couple or even about people. It's about Don the metaphor for the business: beautiful, creative, a liar, charming and only truly alive when he's nailing a concept, an account or a woman.
Foolish Money and others, thanks for reminding us about the true nature of sales in the professional services industries. As someone who is in business development in a service industriy, I can assure you that the business ethics of SCDP are pretty good. From a purely business standpoint, my only complaint about the ruthless approach to sales is that it is twenty months late.

It is good to remember that Pete (at the behest of Trudy) was busily in the process of stealing clients from Sterling Cooper in an anticipated job change, when he parlayed that into a partnership at SCDP. This is exactly how one becomes a partner in the professional services industry.

As for Faye, her real career risk is others learning that she is sleeping with Don. Once that becomes public information, all other firms will assume that she is channeling clients to Don - whether she does or not. Her only two escape routes are dumping Don ASAP or coming to work at SCDP (their first woman partner?).

let us remember that sales is Roger's responsibility. Others (besides Pete, ken and others) are simply helping him. If Roger (with or without the help of Bert) does not deliver the answer, he is toast and will no longer be head of of Accounts, assumong there is a SCDP. Can Miss Trudy (sorry, southern style affection) help Pete pull off this coup, much like he steamrolled fis FIL earlier in the season?

Leaving Roger a subordinate to Pete would be great fodder for next season. Pushing Bert and Roger and Bert out of operations and exclusively onto the board (investors only) would also be a great premise for drama next season.

The wild card for this crisis (besides Bert) is Lane. Presumably, he has a long list of contacts that he can explore while in Great Britain. he obviously comes from money. So can he parlay a pending divorce, a life of priviledge and some contacts into a primary role at SCDP?

Pure speculation can be so much fun.
where do I think this is going?

roger has a fatal heart attack. he's going to call for joanie at the end. or he'll commit suicide. his one account is gone. he's miserable, gets no respect, doesn't love his wife or his life. perhaps he'll leave joanie a chunk of change in his will.

is joan pregnant?
I don't think so. she's not stupid. the "problem" she mention is herself as a complication. they're both complications to each other. he'd be a lousy father. she's a working woman and she needed an abortion and she had one. she's no pie in the sky romantic.

don. I see don with neither megan or faye. they're a comfort, like the hookers he used early on. he's healing slowing and I think coming through a number of crisis pretty well...the loss of a marriage, a new business, loss of his home...any one of those things could precipitate a drinking problem. he's dealing with it.

what I find interesting is even in this day and age, I'm reading many here who can't seem to accept that even back then, there were women who could fuck like a man - want him and be satisfied to get a piece of him and god knows there were PLENTY of women who fucked their way up. sometimes that was the only way.

straight up she told him she's ambitious. says she wants to be like peggy. and since everyone assumes peggy slept w don for her job, megans just doing the same thing. AND being a good secretary, showing him she's working on her professional flaws, making sure she does what he asks, keeping tabs on his drink count, checking to be sure he gets enough food and rest. secretaries back then were admin assistants. they were also mothers.

I'm loving peggy. she's the new wave of advertising. she's learning how to sell herself and her concepts and to have some fun. I like the new boyfriend but I don't see him in her future. she's a woman moving up the ladder pretty rapidly.

particularly now that they're going to doing endless pitches,there will be endless all nighters advertising is known for, holing up for weeks, sometimes months, wooing a client, creating for them. and if it's multiple clients, god help him. she's going to be tense, pressured, focused.

I think he's too romantic. maybe she is too...but I dont' think so. she's an irish pragmatist, having already learned, her friends are more reliable than her loved ones. and in this business friends are really what it's about.
ah Tennessee, I was thinking the same thing about Faye. I don't think they'll make her a partner because she doens't bring accounts, but they'll definitely make her exclusively theirs. Don will see to that.
gah!
I completely forgot joan is married. okay..changes everything. she's pregnant for sure. monkey prediction.
We all like to identify with this character or that, love them, hate them or something in between.

I wonder when we may realize that this show is not about redemption or development (for most of them, anyway), but about portraying the era for what it was, and using these characters as the conduit for this portrayal.

That said, my votes: Roger dead by end of season; Joan is pregnant; Don won't marry Faye or Megan; Peggy might hang with Abe for a while; Stan continues to be the new comic relief!
Hi, this is my first time to contribute a comment but have been enthusiastically following Nelle's wonderful summary/analyses and all the insightful commentaries that follow. Thank you all!

When watching this episode, something occurred to me that I haven't seen commented on: the way that Stan looked at Peggy at the end of the Playtex presentation, after she knew that she had done the whole thing with lipstick on her teeth. I interpreted it as his childish revenge on her for pushing him away. After all, his unwelcome smackeroo in their office is what put the lipstick in the wrong place and he could have told her about it before she went it, but didn't. He enjoyed what he assumed was her humiliation, and in an era when women still wore hats and gloves to church, such things as lipstick or spinach marring a smile in public were enough to send a typical young woman into agonies of mortification. And knowing that fact gave (and still gives) men power over women who let them exercise it. Though the moment was fleeting and seemingly inconsequential, it succinctly struck a nerve while drawing a satisfying distinction between early Peggy and maturing Peggy.

Xevvsmom
You take a very literal read of the show at times, but your commentary is fun to read nonetheless. I'm torn between the soapiness of recent eps, and the next for something to happen. Meanwhile, more pitches!
My take on Mad Men pajama references:
http://open.salon.com/blog/jamampoline/2010/10/08/mad_men_-_a_pajama_slideshow