Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 19, 2009 10:03AM

Favorite Movie: Satyajit Ray's "Distant Thunder"

Rate: 11 Flag

Ashani Sanket, 1973
[Distant Thunder.  Color, In Bengali with subtitles. 101 minutes.]

Babita

                                                               When it came to movies, Satyajit Ray was the God of Small Things, but a god he was.

If you are familiar at all with Indian film, it is probably by way of  overwrought Bollywood dance, drama and music spectaculars. But Ray is not of Bollywood. He made his films in Calcutta 1500 miles and a world away. With Ray, the drama is in a look, the dance is in the curves of a cupped hand resembling a lotus, the music is in the melody of monsoon rains and the dissonance of a distant thunder.

Distant Thunder is set in 1943 in what was then undivided Bengal  still under the British Raj (see map below). There is a war on somewhere, the people of the village don't rightly know where.  The monsoons have been abundant, the rice crop plentiful,  there is a sense of simple joy in the air.

lotus

The movie begins with an unforgettable montage that is pure, liquid poetry compressing the above  into the first  few minutes. The images of the rains, the undulating fields of grain, the lowering skies , a shot of airplanes flying in formation which the uncomprehending villagers regard with wonder (one comparing it  with the flight of cranes) and of village women frolicking in the water is the work of a master at the height of his lyrical powers. (The only clip on YouTube is of this sequence. The quality is rather poor, but it does convey the essence. The haunting background music, composed by Ray, is not your usual Bollywood fare either. It was based on the folk music of Bengal, especially the minstrel tradition of the Bauls.)

bengal

Into this idyl comes our protagonist, Ganga, with his young bride, Ananga.  They have come from the capital city of Calcutta, where things are not so idyllic, where food shortages have already started to occur, severe rationing has been imposed as the British sequester available stocks for the War effort and the grain merchants (Indians) have started to hoard anticipating higher profits.

Ganga is an educated Brahmin, of the highest, priestly caste. He is a man with a clever, not particularly venal, plan. He intends to teach school, perform various priestly functions (the village lacks both), including that of apothecary (he has brought along a basic store of pills from Calcutta as well as a book on hygiene). He expects that both as compensation and  Brahmin Sewa (literally, service rendered to the priest) he will earn enough, especially food, amid the seeming bounty all around,  to make a life for the young couple.

mealtime
And at first things go very well. He is a good school teacher.  A neighboring village calls on him to recite prayers to ward off the evil spirits responsible for the outbreak of cholera there. He does so, while advising them to boil their water for drinking and cleaning cooking utensils. When the epidemic is quelled, the villagers send him off laden with rice and fruit and other goodies.

But after the harvest, when the grains have been sold to the merchants and middlemen, the food shortages hit the village as well.  People are reduced to begging for food. And here is where Ray's mastery is in full flow: instead of  shots of starving chidren and rotting corpses (there are none), he drills to the core of  a disintegrating society in a few strokes.

Ganga tries to shoo away a starving beggar who has come to his door for food -- a significant violation of the priestly code, Brahmin Sewa is supposed to work both ways. His wife forgoes her own meal to feed the old man. She has to take to manual labor in the fields, a violation of caste and societal norms, and is reduced to foraging for food in the woods.  For a few handfuls of rice for her family, a married woman has sex with a man whose face  has been horribly disfigured in a fire. Almost imperceptibly, fire images and a sere landscape replaces the wet lushness of the movie's beginning.

And then there is an old woman lying in the middle of a a dry, dusty road. None of the villagers will even go near her because she is of an Untouchable caste. Ganga, the Brahmin, touches her, feels for her pulse. She is dead. He carries her to the river bank, builds a funeral pyre, performs the final rites and lights the flame.

The movie ends as we learn Ananga is pregnant, and with the ineffable image, burnt in my memory since I first saw it 35 years ago, of the entire screen filled with the silhouettes of hundreds of people streaming out of the village, then frozen in a still shot imprinted with the only overt message of the entire movie: 

 "OVER FIVE MILLION DIED OF STARVATION AND EPIDEMICS IN BENGAL IN WHAT HAS COME TO BE KNOWN AS THE MAN-MADE FAMINE OF 1943."

                                              ____________________

Satyajit Ray died in 1992 at the age of 71. If Americans remember him at all, it is for his  speech from his deathbed accepting the Oscar for Lifetime Achievement in 1992. 

He was a deeply humanistic and humanitarian film-maker.  Distant Thunder  is a true work of art from a master at peak form in all aspects of his craft. The cinematography, the music and of course, Ray's always subtle story-telling.

We never see the war (the Japanese were in Burma by 1944, not that far from Bengal),  just the one image of the planes flying in formation.  We see exactly one dead body in the whole movie. And while society  in microcosm is shown imploding because of unseen, unstoppable external forces,  Ray also gives us hope through Ganga and Ananga of the possibility of the human spirit prevailing over circumstances.  The same Ganga who would not share his food with a beggar redeems himself performing the funeral for the untouchable woman. And his wife, Ananga (Babita, a Bangladeshi actress, is positively incandescent in this role, like so many of Ray's female leads), who is the moral center of the movie (once again, like so many of Ray's heroines), is steps ahead of her husband in accepting and adapting to the world changing around her with sacrifice, caring, love and shared responsibility. Truly one of my all-time favorite movies.

Photo credits: SatyajitRay.org

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Wow...this movie seems to have made a great impression on you and from the narration I can see why...I wonder where it is possible to see all these old gem of movies these days
I am impressed by your description, and I too wonder where we might be able to get a copy to watch.
Dips, about a half dozen of Ray's movies, including the Apu trilogy, Shatranj ki Khilari "Chess Players", etc. are available on DVD from various sources in the States, including Netflix.

"Distant Thunder" is available on tape, but not on Netflix. I have a an old copy, obtained in India, but the quality is rather bad.

Many of the archival prints and negatives of the Ray movies, stored in non-optimum conditions in hot, humid Calcutta have apparently deteriorated badly.

www.SatyajitRay.org has a lot of info.
Thank you, Susanne. As I said to Dips, copies of the movie are very hard to come by in the States. While writing this piece, I came across something called "Share Torrent," a peer-to-peer network advertising the availability of this movie, but it might be a scam and I'm too scared of viruses and such to give that sort of thing a try.
Thank you for filling me in. I get Netflix, so I will look for others there.
Beautiful writing about a beautiful movie. I am disappointed that we can't see it, now that we have discovered it through you.
http://www.1worldfilms.com/India/distantthunder.htm

Here's a link to the "1 world festival of foreign films".... It has the VHS version. I can't attest to the validity of the site...
Thank you, denese, and thank you for the link. Yes, the VHS version does seem to be available, but the print quality, at least on the one I have, is not that good.
Wonderfully written. And what a great tribute to one of the greats.

WOOF
Superb description of what sounds like a superb movie. I'm looking forward to seeing it - thanks.
:) thanks for the warm welcome.
I was in school when I watched it for the first time and had been horrified and scared. Today, while seeing it thru your eyes, came to appreciate the poetry and the sublime in human attempt to live on despite the odds.
Indeed, Satyajit Ray is probably unknown by the world out there, for whom Indian movies ressemble more American musicals than the extremely thought out and directed Ray's movies. Amongst my personal favorites: Apu's Trilogy and Le Salon de Musique (don't know what it is called in English, saw it when I was a teen in France).
Thank you, Sanjuro, Rolling, Sarah.

Sarah, Le Salon de Musique was called "Jalshaghar" in Bengali and released as "The Music Room" in English. Actually, the French captures the meaning of the title better because while a music room may be for private practice etc., the Jalsaghar was indeed a salon for public performances for/by selected guests of the host, who would be of the landed gentry class.

Jalsaghar is one of my favorites too (all of Ray are my favorites, like Sarah said of Renoir and others on her post). The then dean of Bengali actors, Chhabi Biswas, played the lead and the music was composed not by Ray or Ravi Shankar, a frequent collaborator, but by another famous Indian classical musician, Ustad Vilayat Khan.
My favourite even now is Kanchenjungha and Parash Pathar. I can watch them over and over again and Shakhaproshakha where he had used raag Kedar in a curious way, wdn't you say?
Thank you for this wonderful writeup. I have most of Ray's movies in my collection and have been a fan since my teens. It was hard coming up with one favorite among all movies watched in one's lifetime. While coming up with a favorite of my own I found myself going back through my own movie watching life story and living it all again.
I first saw Satyajit Ray's films in Seattle in about 1974. The interest in his films was such that the showing of them became the basis of the Seattle International Film Festival (SIFF). It screens films during May of each year and is now the largest film festival in the US. We clearly owe an enormous cultural debt to Ray for more than just his films! Thanks for this reminder of a great man.
Thank you. Not enough Americans know about Ray. Subcontinental Indian culture is only now competing with the Japanese for influence over here, although Emerson derived a lot of his own philosphy from Hindu. Driven by an entirely different core culture, Indian world views still have more in common with ours than Japan's austere, philosophy-driven aesethetic, does. Both must be taken very seriously.
Thank you all for your comments.

Rolling, those two and Charulata and Teen Kanya and Kapurush/Mahapurush and Debi and Aranyer Deen Ratri and the kiddie films and ... ending with Agantuk.... all great!

Rama, your post about watching outdoor movies was great and selection of Ray's "Pather Panchali", of course, unassailable. I especially liked the way you tied in Ray's humanism to your own life and values.

Hazel, yes, the 70's were sort of the heydey for foreign "art" films, weren't they? I watched so many of these movies in those days at the University Film Society which showed "foreign films" and budding cinéastes drank them in.

Winona, "let a thousand flowers bloom" as someone neither Indian nor Japanese once said :-).
Thanks for this. I have read Pather Panchali and seen Ray's adaptation of it on screen. Another gem of Ray's genius.
About finding Indian movies... try your local Indian grocery. Most in my area also rent movies.
What a compelling review. The stills are fantastic.
I'm a big fan of Ray's, thanks for posting this. I have never found any of his films in the foreign language section of movie rental stores, guess I'll join Netflix.
Thank you all for your comments.

I found a source advertising the DVD version of "Ashani Sanket/Distant Thunder": www.calcuttaweb.com. $12.95, but don't know how good or reliable. They also advertise "Nalen Gurer Sandesh" from Bhimnag, but only for shipping in Kolkata, not abroad :-(.