I wandered down tonight to the Occupy Atlanta tonight to see for myself my city's version of the national protests. I was expecting a lot of things- tension, controversy, chanting, and possibly a drum circle surrounded by several half-dressed pseudo-hippies.
It was a shattering disappointment. They couldn't even scrounge up the hippies. There were about twenty tents, but the crowd was underwhelming to say the least. The homeless and mentally ill were a prominent presence...actually, from the moment I stepped off the MARTA at Five Points Station, the homeless and mentally ill were a prominent presence. One more strike against Atlanta in my mind.
And Atlanta has it's strikes. It's poorly managed, corrupt and covered up in panhandlers, lowlifes, and creeps. Significant parts of our downtown looks like something out of a Mad Max movie. All that was missing tonight was a post-apocalyptic tank wandering around with a gang of hooligans hanging off the gun barrel. But I digress....a bit. The protest was sparsely attended, overshadowed by the mentally ill/drunk people hanging around and jumping up in front of the cameras, didn't seem to have anyone coherent within reach of a mic, and was dominated by glory-hogs hanging around shouting ambiguous slogans like "Power to the People." Serious, someone shouted that. Randomly. Nothing was happening.
I'd use the term 'pathetic' to describe the whole experience. Also 'disappointing.'
I'm not sure if I'm more disappointed in Atlanta for not having a cogent
program to deal with the mentally ill homeless population or in the protest for such a miserable showing for what I consider an historic, national movement. Really Atlanta? This is the best you could do?
I want to bitch-slap the city. I really do.
There was a media presence. Channels Five and Two were there, filming live shots and taking comments. Someone offered me some free-form poetry on the protest...I don't think he was with the media, or even the event. The ironic gentleman who posed for this photo- and he did take the time to pose- proceeded to wander over to a tree and hump it. I'm not kidding.
There were some interesting signs posted around the park. I'll try to include some on this post. But most of the experience was dominated by the impression that Mayor Kasim Reed knew exactly what he was doing when he decided to let the protestors stay and get media coverage. Footage of this will seriously undermine the national protests. "Sure, stay in the park til Monday....talk to the press...protest all you want...<snicker>...it's not like you're serious."
I've spoken with a friend who is involved in the Occupy Wall Street protests, and it sounds like it's going better up there. They're trying to form a message of some kind. It's something at least. Better than Atlanta, which seems like the only over-arching message is "Cool! A camera! Look serious."
I know the common complaint is that these protests don't have a coherent message. As though that means that the criminal negligence of bankers and traders doesn't really matter- since we can't name it, there must be no 'real' injustice, just a bunch of whiners.
What really matters is that the people who's pensions/benefits/jobs/lives were wiped out by the last few years are so overwhelmed with the injustices of the system that we couldn't come up with just ONE message. The rigging of the system is too great.
Our problem is no that we have no place to start our protests- our problem as a [formerly-middle] class is that there are so many abuses by the people with money and power that we don't know where to start. That's the problem. Not the lack of a message...the large pile of them. Oh, we've got a message, alright. That's why this protest spread to over 60 cities (and counting) with virtually no central organization. (Yes, Fox News, I'm sure you think the unions are behind it all. Now go put your safety helmet back on.) Occupy Wall Street has tapped a deep vein, as I'm sure many Americans realize. We've got a point to direct a lot of our pent up energy after years of knowing- KNOWING- that people are buying their way out of justice, that they system is off, that corporations, as Jon Stewart so accurately put it on The Daily Show, may be considered people by the law...but they are not Americans.
I've watched the majority of my family suffer these last few years. We are lucky that we can scrap by, although several family members lost most of their material possessions and their homes to foreclosure. I went to the Occupy Atlanta ready to join a movement that might channel my anger and resentment at the pack of lies handed down from people who want to be called 'job creators.' I didn't see anything I wanted to join. Shame on you Atlanta, for such a disappointing show.
Here are some of the more poignant signs from tonight in Atlanta:






Salon.com
Comments
too bad though, as so many I know in Atlanta are hurting.
I could see every one of them being too proud to let anyone know how they feel by protesting, they might be seen on the news!
http://open.salon.com/blog/barzin/2011/10/12/my_disappointing_jaunt_through_occupy_la
The reason this "movement" isn't getting off the ground is because their is no compassion for others. Statements such as, "It's poorly managed, corrupt and covered up in panhandlers, lowlifes, and creeps." goes to show the depth of care and concern for fellow man the self proclaimed 99% really possess.
--sinclair louis
"One withstands the invasion of armies; one does not withstand the invasion of ideas."
--victor hugo
occupy wall street, my speech to the masses
"you go to war with the war you have, not the war you want"
--Donald Rumsfield
"I wouldnt want to join any group that would allow me to be a member"
--groucho marx
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"
--sinclair louis
"One withstands the invasion of armies; one does not withstand the invasion of ideas."
--victor hugo
occupy wall street, my speech to the masses
I know you are disappointed, and I am, but at the very least there were protesters. Mentally ill and homeless have a HUGE need in America. Equity. Parity.
I have bi-polar I and I hate to be clumped with mentally ill label. People are harsh about illnesses that are untreated and measure anothers' value based on appearances.
I have care. I have a job. I think most people are like me. Job is number one- especially in this economy, and I'm not going to do ANYTHING to lose it- like appear on TV with less stable folks.
Um. Rated.
Grady Hospital's psyche ward is right down the street from Woodruff Park. The park also intersects Georgia State's urban campus. It is a very complex mixture of society. There are huge disparities between the power elites and the poor. The people of Atlanta really do care about social and economic parity, but like one commenter has noted, many of those who care live and work far away from Woodruff Park.