Diffuse minus Specular

Specular

Specular
Bio
CGI geek. Occasional writer of fiction. Secret fan of stuffed monkeys. Ex-rock-and-roll star turned mop boy at Celine Dione's Vegas showroom.

MY RECENT POSTS

Specular's Links

Salon.com
AUGUST 8, 2009 9:49PM

Things I don't understand

Rate: 7 Flag

[Rant alert: this post is pure rant and has no redeeming substance]

  • American Cheese. I don't mean that I don't understand how American cheese came to exist. Without taking the effort to look it up, I assume it was developed during a war, when milk was expensive. Or something like that. But what is completely beyond my comprehension is why anyone would eat it, let alone why any restaurant—a place that is trying to lure you in based on the irresistible yumminess of it's product—would serve it. American cheese seems as if somebody who hated cheese set about a way to sabotage cheese consumption by creating something so resolutely bland that the entire concept of cheese would be destroyed. And yet it and it's vile cousin Veleeta persist. Why? If there is one thing that should unify Americans of all political parties, religious affiliations and sexual orientations, it should be the absolute FAIL of American cheese as an edible substance.

 

So, by Things I don't understand, I don't mean things I either lack the education or mental capacity to understand. There are plenty of things I don't understand that I'm content to not understand. How computers work, for example. I understand programming, more or less, but how a huge collection of binary switches work together to allow me to do anything remains absolutely baffling to me. Sure, I could study for years and figure it out, but right now: no clue. And don't ask me to explain the finer points of Chinese calligraphy. 

 

  •  "Everything happens for a reason." Has there ever been a more commonly held sentiment that is more obviously untrue, given even a tiny amount of thought? Unless the speaker means, "everything follows the rules of the universe," the statement is bunk. It's a statement that is usually used about a specific person's circumstance. It implies that the entire universe has been constructed in such a way that that circumstance was inevitable—and created for the purpose of that person benefiting from it. For it to be true, something would have to engineer a universe centered on that specific person. All the horrible things that happen to other people would have to happen for the benefit of that one person. Millions of people killed by Hitler? That happened for a reason. All the people killed in Katrina? That happened for a reason. The guy who was paralyzed when he was electrocuted in a freak accident? That happened for a reason. Much more likely, nothing happens for a reason. At some point, the universe just happened (see below). It had a bunch of fundamental rules that determined everything that happened after that point. And that's the entirety of the reason anything and everything happens. You and everybody you've ever known are just as much of an after thought as the hair that washes down the drain after a shower.

  • Does God exist? It's not that I find that question hard to understand, I just don't understand why people aren't more baffled and intrigued by the question, "why is there existence?" Once you posit existence, anything is possible. But why would there be a big bang or whatever created existence? Any explanation has to posit existence before existence. Unless I'm not smart enough to figure it out. Which is definitely a possibility. This is the kind of question that used to give me headaches and cause me sleepless nights as a child. It fundamentally challenges the rationality of anything. Yet nobody seems to care.

  • Movies based on toys. I have to admit that Pirates of the Caribbean proved to be fairly charming. And the concept of a movie based on a theme park ride is just as abysmal as one based on a toy. But come on, aren't there hundreds of good books writers and producers could rip off to make a movie without having to resort to toys? Or is the fundamental problem that we've reached a point in our cinema culture where plot and character have become so secondary to boom-boom  that scripts are largely irrelevant.

  • My team when used in reference to a team one doesn't play on. More specifically, the idea that a team owned entirely by some corporate enterprise or wealthy family that doesn't include you is "your team." It isn't. In fact, what you are is not a fan, but a patsy. The more you hold the belief that this team that doesn't care about you at all is yours, the more likely they are to reach into your wallet and take your money, with your blessing, to ensure they stay wealthy. If you have a sufficiently strong connection to the concept that the owner's team is your team, you will facilitate the owner reaching into your neighbor's pocket and taking his money as well, as you vote to have you and your neighbor pay the owners basic business costs.

  • Why I'm ranting about any of this. Okay. I'm know the answer to this question. I just don't want to accept it.

 

Author tags:

american cheese

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Very nice! I can't explain any of those things either, but I'll add American beer, of the pale lager variety: light yellow in color, mildly hopped in flavor, best drunk at a temperature low enough to numb the taste buds. Pour me another!
Or worse, light American lager. Take watery beer and add more water. At a certain point, aren't you just drinking eau de beer?

However, Rob, I'm counting on you to be able to at least think about the "why is there existence" question :) You're the one guy I'd suspect might also have encountered some sleepless mights pondering such things.
I confess that I've never thought about that specific question. I have thought about two that might be related, though: "What is the nature of meaning?" and "Where might meaning in life come from?" (Theists have an easy answer for the latter, but I think they'd have to punt on where their Creator derives meaning.) For both questions I'm not so much concerned with "the" answer, but rather how we can get at some answer in a reasonable way. Questions about meaning aren't necessarily the same as questions about why, but for what it's worth... Hmm. I'll have to think (tonight, awake in bed, tossing and turning).
Sometimes it's more peaceful not to try to understand. I don't understand road rage. Unless you're a doctor on the way to save a life. Most people with road rage aren't. lol
"American Cheese." OMG! :D

Its great on a grilled cheese sandwich, LOL I love this post! I find that if I reflect on certain things too much (like the universe) I end up mind fucking myself and end up ruining my day, :) I remember when I was little, I would sit in the hallway and stare at the wall and think about what was beyond the solar system: those were really scary, yet fun times.
Please, please LadyMiko, try cheddar or gruyere. So much better than --I can't even say it.
Wonderful post. These are the thoughts that I would have on my best friend's porch until 3am when I was in high school. Those were the days when the only cheese I had was American so I hated cheese. Then I had gruyere for the first time, WOW. That reminds me, what was the delicious cheese you brought to the Chicago OS Meet Up? Yum.
That was probably bucheron. Mmmm...
I believe your problem is not that you aren't smart enough, as you suggest, but that you are too smart, a dangerous thing in today's America. Let's start with Velveeta. Of course it's bad, but its makers are smart enough to keep it the way it was fifty years ago, rather than changing it into a health food. Thus it is the same stuff I ate as a child on those meatless Friday's at my Catholic grade school. The one thing Irma Menoni could handle flawlessly was grilled cheese for 300. So, yes, despite improving my diet over the last ten years, I still toss a slice on my morning eggs. It makes me happy. And isn't happiness good for the heart? So, there, I've offset the bad part for my heart with a good part, so it's a wash, plus I'm happy.

I'll leave it to others smarter than I to answer the other topics you raise. But I believe the same principal applies. In small, strategically placed doses, ignorance is good for you!
Velveeta is what the cockroaches will be eating after the nuclear winter. As for the rest of your questions:

The human brain is wired to find patterns, including cause and effect. We don't do well with chaos or the unexplained when they hit close to home. "Everything has a reason" is an attempt to impose a feeling of control on a random event. We may not understand "why," but we can understand an event being part of a pattern.

God?/existence?/"Any explanation has to posit existence before existence." In order -- I don't know; I don't know; and I can't say, but let me toss this in and see if it makes any sense. Because we all studied Einstein intensely, we all know that Time is a dimension much like the familiar three spacial dimensions. Can't seem to go back in Time, so it isn't like you can walk back and forth or go up and down. But that's beside the point. At the Big Bang, all of our Universe's dimensions were created. Seemingly our laws of physics immediately came into play (any physicists out there, feel free to correct me). "Time," as we understand it, was created during the Big Bang. Hence any reference to what came before the Big Bang makes no sense. There was no "before" because Time didn't exist. It's painfully counter-intuitive. Bugs the shit out of me.

Movies based on toys: there's a built-in market. Kids who play with the toys will want to see the movie. The producers are counting on those kids shredding their parents' nerves until taken to see the movie. It's the flip side of the same coin that gave us toys based on movie characters (which is how George Lucas made his real money).

My team: Humans are tribal. Generally we "root, root, root for the home team." In the case of Chicago, you don't find many avid Cubs fans who were born on the South Side. That particular brand of Cubs fan usually gets the crap beaten out of him at an early age.

This droning length of b.s. was brought to you by me staying up too late.
Okay, I've thought about the "why" question a bit, and I've remembered some of what I've read in the philosophy of science literature, and I think the question needs to be fleshed out a bit. There's a story I vaguely recall, possibly about Newton, but also possibly about Kepler (and also possibly entirely apocryphal), in which one of these prominent scientists publishes a piece of work in which he explains why the planets move along the paths they do. Some of his contemporaries are excited about this, thinking they're going to read insights into the workings of the universe, why things are as they are... but they're disappointed to find that it's just Kepler's laws of motion. They complain, "We thought you were going to tell us why---and these equations aren't it." The scientist responds, "That's all you get. In fact, that's all you can get." (If you know this story, and I've gotten it wrong, sorry about that.)

When we ask a question like "Why did that building fall down?" we might be satisfied with answers like "The foundations were unsound," or "There was an earthquake," or "A bomber did it." But we should notice that these are just links in a causal chain; we might then ask, "Why were the foundations unsound?" or "Why are there earthquakes?" or "Why did the bomber do it?" And we might continue, like two-year-olds, indefinitely. Eventually we reach a point where we have to say, "That's just the way things are."

When you say, I just don't understand why people aren't more baffled and intrigued by the question, "why is there existence?" I think that one answer might be that people are baffled and intrigued by it, but eventually come treat it as being unanswerable, because if you were going to try to explain why, it's not at all clear what would count as a good explanation. If every other why question bottoms out in "That's the way things are," then we might expect the same thing to apply to "Why is there existence?" That might seem unsatisfying, but I think it might be all we have.

(I should note that I'm not a philosopher, as you know, and I recognize my limitations in philosophy more acutely than most, having seriously tried to do it---without much success---at times. :-)
Stim, you're exactly right on there being no time before the big bang (assuming that the big bang theory is correct on that point). Time, however, flows isn't a one way drift. At least according to one of my old classmates who keeps up on physics, the last five years or so have radically altered the way scientists think about reality. They've begun to understand time a bit better. The consequence is that free will is probably an illusion. It can only exist when what happens can't be known before it happens, i.e., time flows in one direction. If time flows forwards and backwards, there is essentially no "after" for decisions to implement themselves in.

But as far as the "why is there existence," the lack of time outside of the universe doesn't explain why there is anything at all. Everything else appears to be rigidly driven by physical laws, but existence is outside of that. Which is the exception that calls into question the rational understanding we have of the world. At least for me.

Rob, you're right that most people just give up on these kinds of questions as unanswerable. But the question of the existence of God (as a large concept) is also unanswerable, yet countless books have been published on the subject. Obviously, a large part of this is that culturally, theists and atheists are debating a topic that remains central to our understanding of morality and even to our politics. Existence is undebatable. But if you examine the arguments over God, the theist arguments are generally full of holes (because they take as a given that their version of God exists, rather than an indifferent über-figure that might exist), while the atheists get too caught up in the details of the theist's arguments (e.g., the brilliant but perpetually flawed Christopher Hitchens whose real agenda seems less an exploration of whether God exists than taking the piss out of people he dislikes).
Hmmm . . .sharp cheddar on sourdough . . .yummy!
That's a winner, LadyM. Try it with quality tomato bisque. Mmmmm..
Oh, what I wouldn't give for a grilled cheese at the moment- or a french onion soup bread bowl (want to go to Panera? I would actually leave the house for that today)
I agree with you- nothing happens for a reason. It's very little that you have control over. It's why I'm so hooked on video games- god to have some fucking control is so nice. Life is way too random.
But you don't have any control over video games, either: that's just an illusion :p
I click a button, and the pixels go where I will- that is control enough for me :D
That assumes that you have a choice in clicking the button. That's the illusion.
There are a couple of books I want to read (and understand: which given how rusty my math skills are, may take some work). Once I have (sometime this fall), I'll probably post a entry or two on free will. But first, I'll probably try to engage Rob in a discussion on the meaning of meaning or the meaning of life
if button clicking to move pixels around is the sum of my responsibility for a few hours a day- I am a happy girl- & if that is pandering to my innate ocd, agoraphobia, or other biological hiccups- who the fuck cares :) It's good to take happiness where you find it, especially when it hurts no one and costs nothing (well, 'cept the burning of coal- thanks much for making me feel guilty about my computer and air condition habits :p~~)

I'd also be interested to hear Rob ponder on the meaning of meaning ;) although I have to agree with what he's said so far, which I understand to be: "scientists will never know, because it is something we can't test" but hey, if he's willing to dip into metaphysics ;) I will watch you two chat
oh, and I have an audible copy of Sophie's World, want me to bring you a copy on Thurs? Can't talk about it, cause I haven't listened yet- been too busy stuffing my brain full of Faefever and Hyperion :/ classy, and well educated I is