When Your Spirit Whispers

Pay Attention! _ Write It Down!
OCTOBER 17, 2010 10:22AM

An Open Letter To Councilman Joel Burns _ Fort Worth, Texas

Rate: 19 Flag

Dear Councilman Burns,

I am a 62 year old gay man who now resides in San Francisco, California. I am writing to thank you for your courageous heartfelt appeal on behalf of gay teens and others who may contemplate suicide because of bullying. I was so moved by your personal story, I wept the first five times I watched it. But then, I had to watch it again, because the parallels to my own life were so unbelievable. Each viewing brought more clarity to my own life and struggle. I understand that your purpose in making this video was very focused and deliberate. From watching your delivery, I am also moved by the unintended affect on yourself in a very positive healing way.

But the effects of your selfless act of courage are so much bigger than what you had originally intended. You have put your finger on a problem that involves the reputation and the integrity of Fort Worth, the state of Texas and the entire nation. You have opened a dialog about what it means to be Christian in America and the responsibility that we all bear in supporting the concept of freedom of religion. You have also opened the possibility for all of us to understand that the concept and execution of bullying goes far beyond the school campus, including work places, religious institutions, the internet and every other aspect of our everyday lives. Yes, it affects those in their teens more than those of us who have become older and wiser with thicker skins. But the hatred and ignorance that drives it affects everyone of every age! I would like to share my personal transformation, with much deserved gratitude to you.

My sister’s family moved to Fort Worth in 1971. Since then it has been a second home for me. When I moved to San Francisco with my partner Rob in December, 1981, Fort Worth was the stop on the way to our new home. When Rob died in 1995, it was the place I ran to in order to heal and put my life back together. When my niece Cyndi, from Fort Worth, died from lung cancer in 2000, I was there at her bedside. Whenever I spoke to others of my second home, Fort Worth, I was always quick to point out that Cow Town USA was a very cultured place with world class museums, music and entertainment. During the nearly forty years of personal interactions and relationships with residents of Fort Worth, I experienced first hand, the true meaning of Southern Hospitality.

But because of my extensive international travel and my other life in San Francisco, it was impossible to ignore the other side of my second home. In 1972, in Sansom Park, I was roughed up by two police officers, beaten over the head with a flashlight by one of them and spent the night in jail, for no other reason than because I was gay. This was just a few years after my own experience in High School when bullying also brought me very close to contemplating suicide. So over the four decades of relationship with Fort Worth, I have been forced to live two lives there. One life openly with my close friends and family and another life in public, where I always looked over my shoulder. So when I read of the police raid on a gay bar in Fort Worth in the summer of 2009, I shrugged my shoulders, thinking “absolutely nothing has changed.”

But now you, my dear man, have given me hope! The first time I watched your video, I shared your belief that perhaps you might suffer political ramifications for your selfless act. But then, at the end of your presentation people stood to applaud! In that single moment the ridiculous contradiction between my personal relationships and my life in public became more apparent, begging me to stand with you in calling for an end to the insanity.

Fort Worth is also known for being part of the Bible Belt. The positive side of this was what I experienced as Southern Hospitality. The negative side was what I would characterize as institutionalized bullying. Your call to compassion is also a call for all Christians who believe in the example of the life of Christ’s compassion, to rise up and denounce those who twist religion into the insane concept of a God who condones hatred, while denouncing some forms of love. By your own example, you have also called on us to conduct this dialog without calling each other names. I’m putting my bets on a familiar bumper sticker slogan often seen in Texas. “What would Jesus do?”

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
He (and you) are brave and good. That's a lot, btw. R.
Very important to keep addressing this again and again, and dig for all the insidious ways people bully. I hope he continues to speak out, instead of only the one time. It is about him, but it is about us all. R
This was my status on Face Book yesterday:I have a major crush on Joel Burns...right now...I don't care if he is gay and would not reciprocate- He is sexy and brave.

Attraction transcends orientation and this man is attractive!!! This is not to sound trite...sometimes we just have to get past sex.There are a lot of women who feels he embodies the perfect ideal of manly-ness right now.
This is a wonderful letter. I hope that you will send it on so that he knows just how much his effort is being appreciated. When I read this I thought about writing their city council and tell in them just how lucky they are to have Joel on there serving the people and how fortunate they are to have the opportunity to change negatives in their community through his courage to speak out. I hope that it is not just one night of applauding and moving on. I hope it is a very conscious effort to make change within their governing bodies, their police force, their fire department and all the other entities which make up their government and public service. May this be a tipping point for Ft. Worth and the surrounding communities and areas. When we embrace people instead of attack them, we find ourselves in a better place, with a stronger sense of community and safety for everyone. We waste so much energy hating when we could be building. Discrimination in our country is wrong, it is not what we are truly about, no matter what hateful group including so called religious spreech.
If this can happen in Texas...it can happen anywhere. Beautiful. I am so moved by this story!
Yeah, I was particularly touched to see the audience and other councillors rise to their feet and applaud. There was a middle-aged woman near the front who was just sitting there, and I thought I was getting Disapproval Vibes from her...but she was just arranging herself so she could get up on her feet and clap.

Anti-gayness, tho virilent, is increasingly a minority position, I think. And the more public people who come out, the faster the societal change.

I just fear that the economic situation, which really shows no signs of changing soon, nor perhaps ever returning to the heady days of American prosperity, will make straight (and white, and whatever) people sour and angry, and they'll look for scapegoats... It's easier to be 'tolerant' and generous and live-and-let-live when times are good... Two waves colliding here...
Beautifully stated. Thank you for sharing this. We both were moved to write about this and that is a good thing. Rated
It is so hard to be a young person - straight or gay - but especially gay. I have a gay daughter. I love her unconditionally. Her sexuality is part and parcel of who she is. How can a parent deny any part of their beloved children? I don't get it ... and I don't see how anyone can call themselves 'Christian' and be such bigots at the same time. Our poor kids have a hard enough time just being kids. At least at home they should be free to express themselves and be confident that they will still be loved, will still be safe ... that their parents will stick up for them - help them fight against hatred and cruelty - and remove them from danger if that is what it takes. Kids learn this hatred & bigotry from their parents ... they don't come into the world with those feelings. Sigh ... good for you and good for Joel and all the others who spread the word that being gay is all right and that it really does get better. But there is still way too much hate in the world ... against anyone who is perceived as 'different' . . . different color, different sex, different physicality, etc. We all need to fight the good fight.
I was moved to tears watching Mr. Burns speech. I am so glad he spoke out and am amazed at how brave he is, especially living in the Bible Belt. I think it is unacceptable to use religion to condemn others who are different, that is not very God-like or loving! R
Excellent.

It's to be hoped that this might start awareness of and a trend against bullying of any kind. Children are the most angelic and cruelest beings, open to all avenues, needing direction for surviving in society. Our current system of giving that direction (*any* school of any sort) very much encourages herd mentality - which encourages rebuffing 'differences' of any kind.

I'm not sure what will be the most effective method of creating a change - but this has got to be a good start.


Rated for another voice.
People like you and Joel remind us all of the importance of compassion. Keep telling your stories because they make us all brave.
A moving piece, well-told. When I first saw this video last week I was left wondering if I really knew or understood Americans. When they stand at the end -- and look close, even those few sitting are applauding -- I felt such pride and happiness with our capacity for good. And how human truth, plainly told, befuddles the hate in us, makes us one, if but for a few minutes. The private prejudices of religion and tradition are stopped short by the tragedy of no-hope death. Of 13 year olds. Even now, still, with ordinary citizens.

All we need is a hundred more of him, telling personal truths, with those young faces, projected large on the wall.
Face facts. We fail because we fail to support the people who step forward to enunciate what we think but do not speak ourselves. When someone like Joel Burns steps forward as he has done, it becomes incumbent on those of us who agree with him to provide tangible support. I don't care if it's only a buck, enough bucks will provide the support Joel Burns needs to stay in office and grow there.

Make no mistake, Joel Burns has made himself a target for the reactionary elements in our society who want to stuff the genies back into their bottles, who want to stifle anyone who expresses views that diverge from theirs.

Just as we have, to an amazing extent, abandoned a progressive president because he wasn't progressive enough, but there's another case that causes even more discomfort.

Remember Cindy Sheehan? The Gold Star mother who became the foremost anti-war activist to speak out against our wars in Iraq and Afghanistan?

Cindy Sheehan was a throwback to the antiwar organizers who opposed the war in Vietnam, the Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin of this generation.

A generation ago, or maybe it's two generations now, Hoffman, Rubin and their c0horts organized millions of people into demonstrations, marches, and other actions designed to bring the war to an end. I know this, because I was one of the organizers of those demonstrations...and yet I did nothing to support her.

We have come so far down the wrong path that legitimate challenges to authority cannot get the bare minimum amount of support necessary to promote legitimate debate, and challenge illegitimate authority.

I am embarrassed to admit that I didn't support Cindy Sheehan, but my reason was simple: I knew from my own experience that demonstrations only strengthen the resolve of the war mongers to monger their wars more.

I believe that the anti-war movement during the Vietnam period actually extended the length of the war because the Nixon administration was terrified of being perceived as caving in to the demands of the people.

This has been the case for decades now. The people, when they voice their disapproval of public policy, encourage the public policy with which they disagree.

This is a hard truth....but that doesn't mean we should not support Joel Burns and his cohort as they speak out, not because our support will help them materially but because, when we look back on these times, we will know that we did what we could.
I knew you were special from your first post on OS...thanks for this one...and smarkychaser makes a point..this man proves that REAL men sometimes cry, they tell the truth, even when it hurts, and they aren't afraid to admit they've been frightened or threatened or confused...Doesn't get sexier than that for a lot of us women-- whomever he loves back! R with celebration of who you are as a man and a blogger...thanks again
There are so many good points shared in the comments here. I see so much support and goodwill. If we keep talking and supporting youth things are bound to change for the better. I can only imagine the impact of hearing these stories for a kid who is afraid and hurting.
Yes, Yes, Yes!!! Heartfelt thanks!!!
Thank you so much for posting Joel Burns' talk and your letter. You are both wonderful.
Excellent letter. I hope he receives it and takes it to heart. I sort of understand what you mean about the double life. I hid my opinions as a "communist, socialist" for years from my local friends. The hiding is basically over though!
Touching, real, vulnerable.
What a powerful video! It brought me to tears. And thank God for the response he received, as he so deserved. Thank you also for all your personal sharing in this regard. It is so important!!! Parents, please love your children for who they are, not who you want them to be. They are perfect as is. Thanks again for your work and the work of Joel Burns. You are both brave courageous men.