When Your Spirit Whispers

Pay Attention! _ Write It Down!
FEBRUARY 9, 2011 2:51PM

Persians Are Not The Same As Arabs!

Rate: 21 Flag

  Arash the archer

 Arash statue in Iran

If you read my blogs regularly, you know that I love to keep small souvenirs from different periods of my life. If someone were to find my box of grocery receipts, hand written notes, theater tickets and such, they most likely would put them directly into a recycle bin. The popular idiom: “one man’s garbage is another man’s treasure” would be the perfect way to introduce my next story.

Throughout my life I have been characterized as a hopeless romantic, a label I wear proudly in spite of the pain it sometimes brings. Once I have opened my heart to someone they remain there for the rest of my life. What is curious, is how I can be walking down the hallway of my apartment and forget where I’m going, or why, before I reach my destination. But one or two pieces of paper from my box of keepsakes can bring back a story from decades ago in remarkable detail.    

In May of 1977, I single handily organized a demonstration at the White House to ask President Carter to include “Gay Rights” at home in his global call for human rights. The demonstration was called “Save Our Children From Anita Bryant.” I was a recent refugee from Anita Bryant’s homophobic state of Florida. At the time I worked in a small bookstore at Dupont Circle on Connecticut Avenue. During my campaign to promote the White House demonstration, I met a “Persian” man named Arash.  

Newsweek 77
My White House Demonstration featured in centerfold of June 6, 1977 Newsweek

Arash, an Iranian scientist specializing in cancer research, was working on a two year project in DC. I thought he was the most exotic man I had ever met. He had piercing brown eyes and jet black hair that covered his entire body. His facial hair was as soft and shinny as the hair on top of his head. The first adjective I would choose to describe his appearance might be pretty or beautiful, and yet he reeked of masculinity! As we walked down Connecticut Avenue together, all heads would turn, both male and female, to steal one more glance at this extraordinarily handsome young man.

As I look back now, I can see the possibility that Arash was attracted to me because he thought I was also exotic. I had long wavy blond hair, sideburns and a Fu Manchu mustache. He was generous in his praise for my courage and convictions as an openly Gay man, something that was not only impossible, but dangerous in Iran.

I was 28 years old when I met Arash. It’s a time of transition when boys are curious to find their place in the world of adult males. I found Arash’s stories of growing up in the Middle East both fascinating and challenging. His sense of masculinity turned everything I believed up-side-down. He was not allowed to even entertain the idea of being open about his physical attraction to men, but somehow he was able to grow up without the barrier to intimacy I had obtained growing up in America. Because of my short relationship with him before he returned to Iran, I was left with an understanding of what real fear tastes like. It was probably also the first time I understood the true meaning of brotherhood!

Arash was adamant about one thing. He was Persian NOT Arab! He was named after a Persian folk hero, an archer. He took his name so seriously he had taken up archery as a hobby. For me it was a perfect image that supported the dichotomy of his physical beauty and his powerful sense of masculinity. While I found all of this new information about Eastern culture and history fascinating, I was unable to ignore the Roman counterpart of Arash who had pierced my heart with his arrow!

Exactly three days after my successful demonstration at the White House, the movie Star Wars opened. Arash invited me to join him at the Uptown Theater on Connecticut Avenue the following Saturday for the matinee. Even though we arrived one hour before show time, the line already made its way completely around the block. I was so proud to walk to the end of the line with this beautiful man at my side. It seemed everyone I knew in DC was already waiting in line.

StarWars

In November of the same year, when the Shah of Iran attended a State Dinner at the White House, my thoughts turned to Arash who was preparing to return to Iran in January of 1978. At this time I was very naive about the politics of Iran. Arash had educated me about the mythology of his culture, but never mentioned current politics. His ability to study and work in the US were directly related to the close relationship between our two governments.

After Arash returned to Iran, my attention was focused on every article that appeared in the Washington Post about politics in Iran. The entire year was a chronicle of the deterioration of the Shah’s power. This was the same year I began to develop a close working relationship with many people involved in the Democratic National Committee. Nearly one year after the Shah had attended the State Dinner at the White House I noticed a small card with the Presidential Seal in a wastebasket. I was curious why someone would throw away such a keepsake. It was an invitation for a member of Carter’s cabinet to the state dinner for the Shah. Of course now, I could assume many things about why the cabinet member would choose to throw the invitation away at that particular point in time. But at the time it was just another keepsake to remind me of my beautiful Arash! So I tucked it into my pocket and put it into my box of memories where it has remained until now.

Shah


The entire year 1979 was filled with anxiety and fear for what had happened to my friend Arash. Each time I read about public executions of homosexuals, I would wonder if Arash had been among them. And if he had, I would think to myself, was it something I had done or said that allowed him to let down his guard and be found out?

So I find my feelings about the Egyptian protests to be directly linked to Arash. I stand with the people in Tahrir Square. I share their calls for an end to oppression and corruption. I believe they truly want liberty! And when people point to Iran in fear, and call for the continuation of the status quo to assuage that fear, I hear Arash’s words, “Persians are not the same as Arabs!”

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Stupid corruption!! END IT NOW!!!

:)

Rated.
Persians are not Arabs indeed, although, there are some structural similarities in Egypt now and Iran then that are flashing red at U.S. policymakers.
Persian, Arab - they're all The Other.
Thank you so much for sharing this story of your friend Arash, SpiritMan SF. I hope he is well. And I hope you keep being a hopeless romantic... :)
What a romantic story. When I think of Persians I think of Rumi, and the Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam; of swooning, brilliant, mystical genius, from mathematicians to poets. When I think of Iran I conjure oppression of anything outside a very, very narrow paternalistic definition of "normal", and complete religious and spiritual oppression. What a pity.
In this we are alike: "Once I have opened my heart to someone they remain there for the rest of my life." I used to be a debater in high school speech. We carried huge evidence boxes around with us to be able to back up our arguments. My heart is a huge evidence box filled with things that bring up threads of memories and thoughts of those people whose lives are forever a part of me. Great post. And yes, Persians are not Arabs.
My father served in Iran during World War II and his war stories fascinated me so much that I developed a lifelong obsession with the country and its people. Thirty years later, I joined a Persian Sufi Order, to which I remain affiliated. Persians are wonderful people, except for the crazy ones.
i too had some friends with people from iran when i was a student at the university of new mexico and played in the soccer team, the center forward was ali sheva......(sorry i don' t fully recall the family name); ours was a soccer team friendship which went a bit further due to the the fact that we were both foreigners, one persian and one italian; i also remember fondly dinners we had at his house where his wife prepared wonderful dishes mostly based on rice (one dinner in particular with rice and cherries, wonderful!), lamb, eggplant and other basic ingredients

amazingly, but i presume normally in a 1968ish university world, we had parties where most of the foreign students (with a few enlightened americans) hailed from south africa (the great jamal, a white from durban most loved by our african friends), ivory coast, somalia, morocco, uganda etc., and myself, a swede (quite aloof) and a norwegian, as well as our iranian friends

i still have some pictures of those days, in one i wear an arabic garb, head gear included, while dancing to some arabic music; it all seems a bit passè now but then it was just that way....all foreigners together for the love of the beautiful game and the feeling of togetherness in a foreign, but friendly, country

as a final note, in my last year at the university, i was the only white player in the african team (don't remember why the honor, maybe they just needed the 11th player) , in the university final we met an all white german named team, we won with the score of 1-0 and i kicked the winning goal....i will never forget the joy, the hugs and the kisses from my team mates.....btw, the coach was ali
Sometimes the world we live in is without borders and we all belong to the same family!
This is fascinating...thank you for sharing this beautifully written story.
r
a fascinating and well-written story. i really enjoy reading things like this about other people's experiences with cultures and histories and, of course, individuals like arash. thanks for this.
We share something in common. I too collect things like that, and like you they all have memories attached. Thanks for sharing this story!
If Persians are the same Arabs, Germans are the same as the French. I empathize with your concern for Arash.
Beautiful..thanks for sharing.
Excellent article. Persians are not Arabs and they are not all Muslims either. If only we could do away with the identity politics.
Interesting. Have you read Tariq Ali's "Clash of Fundamentalisms"? You might find it interesting--it spans the territory between the historical and the mythical in the region.
rated
I tutored a middle-aged Persian woman at a community college for a few years. She had been here for some time, but her English was almost unintelligible to me when I first met her. She frequently called me a word that sounded like "Mommy-John," which she said meant "Teacher."

She had been an accountant in Iran but came to the U.S. and was earning her degree in accounting so she could return to the work she liked so much. She lived at the Californian hotel and barely scraped by from month to month, but her spirit was full of gratitude even when she cried over the separation from her children and husband.

SpiritMan (you handsome man with your warm and loving writing), you wrote, "Sometimes the world we live in is without borders and we all belong to the same family!"

If I might make a suggestion, we are indeed all one worldwide family; we just don't all know or understand it yet. While I was ruminating on what you said, it reminded me of the Alabama Governor Robert Bentley, who recently said--on Martin Luther King, Jr. day of all days:

"There may be some people here today who do not have living within them the Holy Spirit," Bentley said shortly after taking the oath of office, according to the Birmingham News. ''But if you have been adopted in God's family like I have, and like you have if you're a Christian and if you're saved, and the Holy Spirit lives within you just like the Holy Spirit lives within me, then you know what that makes? It makes you and me brothers. And it makes you and me brother and sister."

''Now I will have to say that, if we don't have the same daddy, we're not brothers and sisters," he continued. "So anybody here today who has not accepted Jesus Christ as their savior, I'm telling you, you're not my brother and you're not my sister, and I want to be your brother."

We are already his brothers and sisters, but he refuses to recognize it. And that's very, very disturbing in a representative of the people and every other person we meet.

Only love will save us.
Very interesting. I suppose Arabs and Persians get mixed up (add Turks and anything remotely Islamic) because we can't look beyond that first outstanding feature of 'the other'.
I wish we could, but we can't.
I too am a 'petit document' hoarder, but my partner is always forcing me to throw stuff out.

The battle continues!
You seem to have all kinds of interesting experiences. I keep things that remind me of events, too, but sometimes I forget what the event was. Then suddenly I remember. Whatever happened to Arash?
"Whatever happened to Arash?"

That may be a question I will never know the answer.
Good story! DC is awesome and a great place to study the world and other cultures by way of folks you meet there. I discovered Serbian culture by bumping into a girl at a Kosovo War protest on the mall and it turned into an awesome 1 week fling. Its great that love, multiculturalism, learning and the desire for human freedom can be so inextricably intertwined in a city like DC.


We need to ensure that the city has more stories like ours, and less about war and funerals in Arlington for vets coming home from the same. r
well I had begun thinking you would for once and all explain WHY Persians are not Arabs and then I would take up the onerous task of educating my American friends why Asian is not a Pina :) and then was disappointed - anyways at least one American knows the difference.

By the way Persians are considered to be one of the most beautiful races in the world in our part of the world and Persian wives were coveted in the Mughal harems. And the Persian poetry is beautiful and full of references to Saki, the word Saki meaning a boy lover. Shd interest you if you are gay yourself.
Rolling: point taken.

But the point of my post was to respond to those who believe the revolution in Egypt means the same outcome as the 1979 revolution in Iran.
o. ok. sorry I missed the point. we often look for what we want to see I guess :)