My Life as I See It

Meanderings of a Twisted Mind

Kathy Henry

Kathy Henry
Location
Chicago, Illinois, US
Birthday
November 20
Title
Thinker
Bio
I am a woman. I am an African-American. Belonging to two minorities has shaped my viewpoint on life in more ways than I can count. It is not easy being a woman in a inherently sexist society. Add skin color to the equation and you have me. This is my world and my viewpoint. You do not have to agree with my thoughts but in the end, you will respect me.

Kathy Henry's Links

New list
No links in this category.
Editor’s Pick
NOVEMBER 29, 2011 11:12AM

Working for Pennies – The Harsh Realities of Being a Welfare

Rate: 24 Flag

One of the biggest misconceptions in American culture is that welfare recipients are living large at the taxpayer’s expense, receiving thousands of dollars per month while driving Cadillacs and other expensive cars.  This myth is so not true and how do I know? Because for the past two months, I have been on welfare and let me be the one to tell you: being on public assistance sucks. welfare reform is bad

August 3, 2011 will be a day in infamy I will never forget because it was on that date that I received my last unemployment check and officially became one of the 99ers, a term for unemployed people in the United States, who have exhausted all of their unemployment benefits, including all unemployment extensions. After applying for over two thousand jobs, I found myself in the position of having to apply for Public Aid or be faced with disconnection notices and phone calls from bill collectors who cannot speak English. If someone had asked me five years ago would I be in this position, back on welfare,  I would have laughed because I went back to school and received a Bachelor’s degree and people who have degrees are supposed to be protected from economic turmoil.  I graduated five years ago from Roosevelt University with a Bachelor’s degree in Sociology and a 3.6 grade point average and I am proud of myself for that accomplishment. I know that some folks turn their noses up at people who pursue a liberal arts degree but I learned valuable critical thinking skills, how to analyze and solve problems in a creative manner, and most importantly about social stratification and inequality and I have no regrets.  I also have over ten years of transferable experience in the administrative/clerical field and an ability to work with all types, fools and all.  However, even with all those wonderful qualities, I cannot find a job to save my life. 

welfare tanf 

When I made the decision to apply for welfare, I tried to keep positive about my situation. Millions of Americans are suffering from either being unemployed or underemployed so at least I was not alone in my troubles. But I cannot lie: Feelings of self-loathing and inadequacy run through my veins on a daily basis and a rage is building in me.  A rage against a society that tells individuals that a college degree is the path to a economic prosperity, but does not disclose how centuries of social inequality have kept and will continue to keep the best and brightest out of the workforce. A rage against rich, clueless politicians who believe people that receive unemployment and welfare benefits are sitting on their butts swigging alcohol and smoking dope.  A rage against myself for waiting so long to get my life together and having to deal with the consequences of perhaps being considered passé in the workforce.

I was a teenage mother who did not get my GED until I was twenty-six and my Bachelor’s degree until I was thirty-five. The entire time before both these changes took place, I was told by society that if I educated myself, I would get myself and my children out of poverty. Guess what? It did not work because I am back on welfare receiving $318 dollars per month.   I did everything society told me to do and I am in the same position I was in nine years ago when I made the decision to attend college and that is a shame.

If I did not have children and bills to pay, there is no way in hell I would have gotten back on the system.  But when you are a mother, one has to make sacrifices, so I swallowed my pride and applied for cash benefits. By signing the Personal Responsibility contract in return for public assistance, a welfare recipient in essence signs her rights to being an adult away. Recipients must work for their cash and going to school is not an option.

Yes, welfare recipients must WORK for their cash benefits. I know that people believe in the myth of women laying up on welfare, eating bon-bons and spitting out a baby every year but that is a load of malarkey. On August 22, 1996 in the Rose Garden of the White House, President William Jefferson Clinton signed into law the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, better known as welfare reform, dismantling the sixty-one year program of federally guaranteed cash assistance to needy families or what is known as welfare.  Welfare recipients have five years to receive cash assistance and after that, it is a wrap. The debate surrounding welfare reform was dominated by white male politicians and journalists and focused predominately on minority women and their families living in poverty because minority women are the only ones in America who received Public Aid (sarcasm). Although President Clinton had the right idea, he and others did not take into account what would happen if the economy collapsed and finding a job would be the equivalency of hitting the lottery.

It burns my soul that I am back on the dole, working for $318 per month which is equal to $79.50 per week at six hours per day after everything I went through to better myself.  If I refuse to go to any of the job sites my caseworker sends me to, I will be sanctioned, meaning that my monthly benefits will be cut in half to $159. So the next time, a hardworking tax payer complains about welfare recipients and how they are living good, eating lobster and shit, think about me, the college educated single mother who took care of her children, saw two of them graduate from high school, one from college, only to find herself and youngest child still poverty-stricken and broke as hell.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
There's gonna be an upwelling of rage when all the people in your (leaky) boat get together. The Occupy movement was just a peaceful first blip which The Powers That Be think they've squelched. But people gotta LIVE.
compassion must have been one of the things held back in human road to evolution.
compassion must have been one of the things held back in human road to evolution.
I have no doubt that there are those who will castigate you for "poor choices". As if making some poor choices was a good enough reason to treat a person as if they were subhuman, dooming them to never-ending poverty. As if every one of us hasn't made some "p0or choices" in our lives. Thanks for the reality check.
So sorry this happened to you. It goes to show that people can do many of the right things and still get the short end of the stick. I hope this economy improves soon.
Brutal and very real. I wish you well and I commend you for taking care of your kids. It is a tough world. I am on the edge too but my mother helps me sometimes for which I pay with my soul. sigh.
I think most of us are a few paychecks away from where you are. I don't know what it will take for the economy to turn around and more jobs to be created...but I hope that you find one soon.
Thank you for sharing your story, Kathy. The more real human faces that can be put to these stories, the less weight the nasty and largely untrue generalizations will carry!
R
Oh, Kathy. Your rage is palpable and contagious. I'm clenching my teeth for you. I am so sorry this is happening to you and to so many others.
Your life story of getting a GED, and a liberal arts degree sounds familiar...mostly, because that is exactly what I did.

My oldest daughter graduated with honors, went to college on a scholarship, married her high school sweetheart, and bought a brick house in a nice neighborhood with a fenced in yard for her little dog.

My youngest soared a little higher, perhaps too close to the sun, and now she has me worried. She may go off to college on scholarship soon, but she is also pregnant.

I feel that we are living in reduced circumstances, also. I understand the resentment you may feel about the promises of an education. People like you and me...we will never have the same kind of lives that traditional students had. There was a point when I was working on my BA, when I realized that no matter how valuable my degree would be- it would never "change my life" to the degree that I would be "just like everyone else" who went to college right after high school. I realized I would never have some of the opportunities that a traditional (normal) life would have offered me, and now my daughter may face some of the same challenges.

My BA is in English, and when the economy headed south, I decided to make myself more marketable by going back to school (on a Teach Grant) so that I could become a teacher. Substitute teaching is a lot of work for the pay...but it is flexible and it helped me get where I wanted to go. Background checks are time consuming. Still, a teacher's life includes giving back to the community and a way to pay off student loans.

I guess my point is...you need not give up- after coming this far. You may be one of the 99% (which means that you are not one of the 1% that make up the wealthiest of our nation). Being part of the 99% means that you are working class... not unemployed.

It is obvious by the strength that you have shown, that you are a force to be reckoned with, not a disappointment. Do what you have to do, but don't let the things you are hearing on the news, and your current state of welfare- resign you to giving up on a better life you are going to have down the road... a better life that you deserve.
@Natutica: I have not given up but I am so pissed off!!! I owe everyone including the college I attended so until I get some money to pay them off, I am in purgatory. All I want is a decent paying job in which I can save some money, take my daughter out of the public school system (which sucks big time), and live in a decent neighborhood where I do not have to worry about dodging bullets. Nothing special or fantastic just normal. I am currently in the process of publishing a book of bloggings I have written in the last year and hopefully, I can make some money from that.
Kathy you are so courageous thanks for sharing and congrats on you editors pick best of luck in finding that job soon
I have a BA in psychology and English, and those degrees go nowhere. I went back to school to get certification to counsel addicted people, and then budget cuts got rid of most of those jobs.

I'm also a 99er, and my spouse has 20 weeks of unemployment left. Then we'll be in a real mess because we have no kids so don't qualify for "welfare."

I'm scrabbling for SSI now, and that looks like it will fall through. We get buy on food stamps and charity.

You are NOT alone in your position or your emotions about it.
Fantastic Post!

My favorite part is: "I know that some folks turn their noses up at people who pursue a liberal arts degree but I learned valuable critical thinking skills, how to analyze and solve problems in a creative manner, and most importantly about social stratification and inequality and I have no regrets." That's right, you shouldn't have any regrets. You educated yourself, and that's something to be damn proud of. Good luck with getting your finances back on track. And thanks for sharing.
Oh, Kathy. You and I have a lot in common. I didn't go back to college until I was 30 and a single mom, and didn't get my bachelor's degrees (dual degrees) until I was 35. Now I'm paying the price, too, because employers automatically assume I'm ready to retire. I'm no where near retirement! The average American can't afford to retire, maybe not ever. I've always been a late bloomer, but I think that's a good thing. ... We both have a lot of great life experience, and I don't care what anybody says, perspective is important.

Do you ever get the feeling that employers don't "trust" that you can "really" do the job? And you have to prove yourself over and over and over again? Sigh. It gets old.

But you have to get up every day and act like everything is swell. I really hope something comes through for you soon. I think it's time we stop telling everyone that a college degree is the "key to success." It's not. Look at all of the folks who skipped college and are making loads of money working as stock brokers, condo sales people, mortgage brokers, bank managers, and similar jobs.

Despite your situation, though, remember to cherish the fact that you put yourself through college and excelled as a student. That, in and of itself, is important. Education, as a good in and of itself, is important, even if it does not guarantee financial stability.

Hang in there!
Pissed off is the appropriate response in this situation Kathy; it means there's a part of you that has not drunk the kool aid that says unemployment is a personal rather than a structural issue. The "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" amounts to the kind of compulsory labour policies that were common in most colonial regimes and which were largely criticized and dismantled in the early part of the 20th century. And the arguments were the same: since "the natives" were lazy, it was justifiable to compel them to work. Hold your head high, do what you need to do and I pray that you and the millions of others in your situation will find avenues to a living wage soon.
Clinton's welfare changes worked pretty well --- in a booming economy. The people on welfare and driving Cadillacs have undeclared income which is probably highly variable and highly illegal.

But, yeah, I get your rage. I'd like to go back to work, but the economy sucks.
I'd say 35 was still plenty young to get a degree. Not everyone has parents who can pay for them to go to college. It is an advantage to have a degree when things are up and running. Lots of jobs don't care what your degree is, just that you have it. But there just aren't jobs now. As bad as things are now, I'm guessing you will be hired more quickly when things pick up than someone with only high school.

Maybe you'll write more and give more detail about the jobs that you do for ~$80 a week. We have an enormous unemployment problem, and the welfare system is undercutting the job market by forcing people to work at slave wages? How convenient for somebody. I want to know who gets your work at such a discount. That really pisses me off.
Kathy - I am curious also what you are required to do for the
$318 as well. I know you want a job that utilizes your education, but can't you do whatever it is that the program has you doing and get paid more than $318 a month. If you are working for 6 hours a day that is ~ 120 hour s a month. Which is less than $1.50 /hr.

I guess I don't know enough about the program but this seems confusing to me.
Have you looked at the possibility of picking up some online freelance projects for pay, for example through elance.com? I've been significantly underwhelmed by the pay rates offered on Elance for typical writing or administrative admin work but they do usually pay more than $2 per hour, so if you can line up enough projects you *might* be able to use them to replace or supplement the $159 a month from your mandatory welfare work.
I don't know if that's something that could work for you - I've done 3 or 4 projects on Elance, so I'm not exactly an expert. I just liked the way their payment system was set up - it seems like fairly reasonable system to guarantee payment for work done.
Anyway, just a thought. I am very sorry that your current situation sucks so badly and I hope that a real job will come your way soon. And I'll definitely remember your enlightening description of our sad welfare system.
Are you telling me that the state and/or federal government are actually paying you below minimum wage? WTF? How can those two concepts exist in the same world. It's either our minimum wage, or it's not.

I'd be pissed off too! Hey girl, I took a job teaching in China because I got layed off in Phoenix, and one month after I left 3500 more got layed off and I would never have gotten a job there.

My child is grown, so I could up root. It says something when Americans are the new immigrants....
@Joseph Cole: Several corporations in Chicago, both for profit and non for profit use welfare recipients like temporary workers except these companies do not have to pay them. I am currently working at a non for profit as a receptionist. Some women are working at banks (trifling!), janitorial services, Walgreens, etc. It is a fucking disgrace and that is why companies are not hiring: They can use the shit out of their current employees and get some broke single mothers to work for free.
FINALLY someone whose on welfare tells the real side of the story. People don't want to be on welfare but sometimes ypeople don't have much of a choice, and no we don't sit on our asses eating Bon-Bons because we have children to raise and we do have morals unlike the negative stereo-types the media depicts welfare recipients as. I hope things get better for you and your family. I know the hell people on welfare go thru from personal experience and our faith in God is the only thing that keeps my family strong. I am definitely posting your story on my Facebook page. Take care.
"The people on welfare and driving Cadillacs have undeclared income which is probably highly variable and highly illegal."

Did you read the damn article? What person with other income and a Cadillac would be willing to work 30 hours a week for $300/month?

Will you please get over the welfare queen myth?
Thanks for this--more than enlightening, and also disturbing. It's no wonder our elected legislators don't feel compelled to take any real action on unemployment if they have an army of unpaid and unacknowledged free workers. That's outrageous. And just so you know, when I think of "welfare recipients living large at taxpayers expense", I think of corporations like Walmart and the banks that were too big to fail, and so on.
Oh, God. Our system is so broken. I am so sorry you are going through this hell. I wish you the very best. I can't imagine what you're going through since I have a job, but I feel for you.
Thank you for having the courage to raise your voice against a system that feeds off those it was created to help. Please do not loathe yourself for doing what you have to do to survive...and for your children to survive. My heart goes out to you in your struggle but please know that when I hear and talk about welfare, I am thinking of women and families like you who are getting crushed by a broken system and who need help - never, never the "Welfare Queen." I wish you luck with your book...let us know when it's available!