Stellaa's Blog

Flickers

Stellaa

Stellaa
Location
Santa Rosa, California, USA
Birthday
August 21
Title
Flaneuse
Bio
I blog. I am not a writer by trade nor do I strive to be one. I love blogging. Ideas, flickers, and in no time, you have a body of work. Blogging is like a yoga practice for the brain.

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 26, 2009 12:29PM

Iran: Considering Death Penalty For Bloggers

Rate: 31 Flag

Ok, I get mad at some bloggers, but the Parliament of Iran is seriously considering applying death penalty to those who under Quranic law, "spread mischief via the internet".  

First, I am opposed to all death penalty.  I find it to be an anachronistic vindictive tradition that has no place in modern times.  Second, this raises my issue with religions that impose legal frameworks from hundreds of years ago to now.  

Watch this clip from Al Jazeera and see what the logic is.  They cannot control bloggers, so the fear of death penalty will be used to dissuade from blogging against the government.  

Now of course these patriarchal fools, the supreme leaders of hypocrisy, will use that to make an example of someone and start a public theater. The law is not passed yet, but it is seriously being considered.  

So, what may under laws suggested in a book written 800 AD, "causing mischief against the leaders", now a days, we call free speech and a duty of the citizen.  I hope I live to see these guys come tumbling down.  I enjoyed watching the Shah fall, but then these guys took over, maybe I will see them fall.  

C'mon Iranian bloggers, give them some mischief.   

 

 
A matter of clarification.  I am no speaking against Islam, if it stays as a religion.  I have the same sentiment against all religions.  Especially the ones that come with legal systems that mandate punishments and rules from thousands of years ago and a bunch of guys holding on to the reigns of power in a changing world.  Let go fellas.  
 
drupal stats

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
[huge sigh]

For all its flaws, I love this country and now that it's pulling itself back from the brink of its own Western brand of religious tyranny, I'm all the more grateful that I can sit here at a keyboard, write something I believe, and let the world see it without fear of repercussion.

Iran may not be on the Axis of Evil, but...well, you know my feelings about all ancient religions that have been anachronistically hauled into modern times, I suspect.

Thumbs.
VR: Patriarchal anachronism is thinly veiled as religion in many places, I am glad we kicked our version in the groin.
Thanks, Stellaa, for posting on this. I understand that they do have a blogger in prison at this time.
It is small wonder that they fear the internet because it is truly democratic and free. So right, it is not God's laws but men's interpretations which are evil.
They already have the death penalty for homosexuals and women who are raped [hang the former, stone the latter]. Don't think they are gonna join the 21st century any time soon. Rated.
So many comments to make, don't know where to start.
Great topic.
If you blog you get flogged? This doesn't surprise me, after all free speech is a big enemy of tyranny and oppression. I have noted on my stats thingie that my post on masturbation/oral sex has received quite a few visitors from Iran. I won't be vacationing there this year!
"New blog" see, I don't think you will get it. Your attacks are against all the people, bombing them, killing them, verging on irrational. That is the right wing take.

I am against the regimes in those countries. Like the Saudis propped by us and the Iranians propped by their own insanity.
Stellaa- the voice of sanity
Stellaa, the Shah of Iran fell precisely because he went past threats and started shooting people in the streets. Once people lost the fear for their lives, because their lives could be forfeit for nothing anyway, they revolted.
The mulahs, if they impose publicly the same actions as the Shah, will see the same fate (and not a moment too soon)>
I agree! But let's keep in mind why Iran is the way it is today...because the CIA and the American government INTERFERED with Iran's political system!! The USA is mainly responsible for Iran now being a theocracy.

The CIA infiltrated Iran in the 1950s and overthrew the DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED PRESIDENT OF IRAN SO AS TO INSTALL THE SHAH!! The Shah was corrupt, arrogant, and spent his nation's revenues on AMERICAN military hardware: planes, weapons, tanks, helicopters, etc. while the people starved and had no health or education services.

Considering the corruption in this country and the fact that selling weapons is our biggest industry, we de-stabilized another nation so that the weapons' industry could reap huge profits. Therefore, intense hatred of the USA was created in a public more and more responsive to its Muslim leaders.....and the rest is history, as they say.

I attended graduate school in the 1970s with a number of Iranians (my alma mater, G. Peabody College, now of Vanderbilt University, is one of the most prestigious graduate schools in the world with a huge international student population!) What I didn't know at the time, but soon found out, was that the American government allowed the Shah's secret police, the Savak to spy on Iranians in this country. So, there were actually Savak agents on Peabody's campus spying on Iranian graduate students while I was there!! Some of my fellow students from Iran were actually the Shah's agents!!!!!

What a country!! Sowing discord and hatred and death so as to sell weapons!! And what's the American reponse now? Attack Iran!!!
Reminds me of an old Broadway musical "Shenandoah" (I saw it when I was a kid). There was one song that always stuck with me:

Freedom ain't a state like Maine or Virginia
Freedom ain't across some county line
Freedom is a flame that burns within ya
Freedom's in the state of mind
Freedom, freedom,
Freedom, freedom
Freedom is a flame that burns within ya
Freedom's in the state of mind

Freedom ain't a boat that's leaving without ya
Freedom ain't a place ya float to find
Freedom's in the how ya think about ya
Freedom's in the state of mind

Freedom, freedom,
Freedom, freedom
Freedom's in the how ya think about ya
Freedom's in the state of mind

You can't get to freedom by riding on a train
The only way to freedom is right on through your brain

Freedom is a notion sweeping the nation
Freedom is the right of all mankind
Freedom is a body's imagination
Freedom is a state of mind

Freedom, freedom
Freedom, freedom
Freedom is a full-time occupation
Freedom's in the state of mind

Freedom, freedom
Freedom, freedom
Freedom is a notion sweeping the nation
Freedom is a body's imagination
Freedom is a full-time occupation
Freedom's in the state of mind


Gotta love freedom. :-D

Thumbed.
To Soap Box Amy

Iran's problems with the world are not just about the nasty things the US did to Iran in the 50s or even the 70s. The Shah was toppled 30 years ago; 30 years after the US NUKED Japan - twice - the Japanese were selling Hondas to the US. It's time the Iranian mullahs mellowed out on their anti-American attitudes.

But they won't, because they're drinking the same kool-aid that so much of the radical Moslem world is drinking. It isn't the CIA's actions over 50 years ago in Iran that caused the Taliban, or the Moslem terror in the Phillipines, Thailand, Gaza, Egypt, Europe, India, Pakistan...

Your focusing on the US as the cause of anti-US hatred in Iran, while ignoring all that goes on in the rest of the world is quite provincial.
Jonathan, yours is exactly the kind of comment that I knew would be attracted to this post. This is not about your view of "Moslem" terror.

Amy, Iran is complex. That is why I had an initial hesitation on posting this because it brings out the anti islamic and the myopic anti Iran hordes.
In the final analysis, all governments (even the ayatollahs') govern with the consent of the governed and cannot govern without it. The government of Iran will not change until the Iranian people want it to. They changed governments forcibly when the Shah got to be too much and they could do it again.

The Iranian government recognizes the blogs as the Ayatollah Khomeini tapes of the new era, that's why they're so worried.

Bombing cities does not make the people want to change the government, nor do blockades. Information and persuasion are slow but sure.
Death to bloggers? Man, I am SO toast, Certified Bad Attitudinalist that I am.
____
"So, what may under laws suggested in a book written 800 AD, "causing mischief against the leaders", now a days, we call free speech and a duty of the citizen.
____

In our 4th Amendment, the "papers" part ("...secure in their persons, papers, houses, and effects...") owed directly to Colonial hatred of the Crown's "Seditious Libel" prosecutorial tradition.
Stella, please reread my comment. I was replying to Amy's comment, *not* your article.
Also, while my comment is critical of radical Moslem terror groups, and the Iranian government which supports them, it is in no way "anti islamic," unless you consider those groups and the Iranian government the entire face of Islam. (Do you?)
As Christopher Hitchens writes, “Almost every historic battle for free expression, from Socrates to Galileo, has begun as a struggle over what is and is not ‘blasphemy’”.

Superstition, a.k.a. “religion”, serves no good societal purpose, especially in an overcrowded world. It’s not like our own nation is not constantly fighting off such asinine superstitious beliefs:

Consider this quote from a recent article regarding Kentucky state law and the Dept. of Homeland Security:

Under state law, God is Kentucky's first line of defense against terrorism.

The 2006 law organizing the state Office of Homeland Security lists its initial duty as "stressing the dependence on Almighty God as being vital to the security of the Commonwealth."

Specifically, Homeland Security is ordered to publicize God's benevolent protection in its reports, and it must post a plaque at the entrance to the state Emergency Operations Center with an 88-word statement that begins, "The safety and security of the Commonwealth cannot be achieved apart from reliance upon Almighty God."

"This is recognition that government alone cannot guarantee the perfect safety of the people of Kentucky," Riner said. "Government itself, apart from God, cannot close the security gap. The job is too big for government."


And then there is this from the UNITED NATIONS - “Islamic countries Monday won United Nations backing for an anti-blasphemy measure Canada and other Western critics say risks being used to limit freedom of speech.”

Enlightened human beings, which does not necessarily exclude all religious people, had better wake the hell up about religion, regardless of the nation or the brand.
Stellaa, this is not the same as the proposal of the death penalty, however, recent news indicates that some western governments are considering checking out what we put on the internet. see the link:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/scienceandtechnology/technology/facebook/5046447/Facebook-could-be-monitored-by-the-government.html

It is under the basis of fear of terrorism etc, but advocates of civil liberties are asking if there is other intentions in monitoring what you and I put on the internet.
first off, lets get it straight, you DIDNT WATCH THE SHAH FALL...you werent even born idiot..
sick as shit of "American" Jews propagandizing against the middle eastern peoples...
Fairy tales are as seductive to grown ups as they are to their offspring.

Why? The themes that mimic our everyday lives but go a step further and tie up the loose ends and give the good guys (us) a happy ending.
Iran has got to be one of the worst ruled countries on the planet. Mossadeg was the last good leader they had, but BP couldnt have him nationlizing oil.
Hossein Derakhshan, aka. Hoder, aka "The Father of the Iranian Blogging Revolution," aka the Blogfather, rots in a prison in Tehran. I very much encourage anyone who sees this and is on Facebook to join this group advocating his release.
Well done, Stella. Thanks for drawing attention to this.
Well, Obama could send them a video. Oh....never mind.
Does their list of potential candidates include any bloggers from Salon?
Geez, this got heavy real fast. Sans the death penalty stuff, I was gonna send 'em a list of some OS bloggers, but now... what the hell, I'll just have our local Ayatollah off them off my favorites list.

WOOF
I have to second Verbal. With all the nonsense that goes on in politics and in the news, we still live in the greatest country. Radicals will always go to the extreme. It's how they feed their power.
Ali Khamenei, I know as grand Ayatollah everything in Iran runs or stops on your word, but do understand, you are OLD, the "Islamic" revolution of Iran is OLD, the generation that is rising to the top of the ranks in Iran is is YOUNG. Wield threats around, they are the gesticulations of old men who no longer breath with a kind of vitality that any really care about anymore...what can you do..mafeesh haga! When Iran's come around, I am hoping with all hopes, that Mr. Mahmoud al-din-e-jad, will be changing his name to Mr. Mahmoud al-I-need-a-job. Salam. Khoda hafez.
It's a good thing Obama sent a video instead of blogging to the mullahs. He might have gotten himself into trouble.
Did you people really believe that everything in Iran runs or stops on Ali Khamenei's word? Ha! A little gullible maybe? People are gonna go about their doings. Dire warnings come and dire warnings go, just as do the winters snow..
Hear, hear! Go, Stellaa!
if they have a hall of fame at langley, 1st prize is surely awarded to the bright spark who suggested: " let's shoot mossadegh, support a right wing dictatorship, and see how it turns out..."
Is this about my FAIL2FOOS II: The Musical post? I mean, come on people can't ya take a joke?
Omar, I hear you, I hope they give him hell, and they will. The old guys took it to the ridiculous extreme and they will fall. They will pick some random victims, but they cannot stop it.

Lets see, a video or starting a war like in Iraq? I choose the video.

Pablo, I will check it out.
Should provide some perspective to the OS whingers but i doubt if it will.

Rated
Malesh! Let go and let god or whatever..don't hold your head so tightly Stellaa the universe will land on its back end as it ought to. Loosen up. I have it on good authority that the average Iranian teenager is up to more "mischief" than the any mobile mullah patrol is probably humanly or inhumanly capable of keeping up with..so just kick back and have a coffee.
Padraing...thanks.

Omar Efendi, like they say in Egypt, "salimah".
Yalla masalama..out with the old in with the new, who needs old mullahs to strangle ones's views..ay?
"first off, lets get it straight, you DIDNT WATCH THE SHAH FALL...you werent even born idiot..
sick as shit of "American" Jews propagandizing against the middle eastern peoples..."

There's one in every crowd, right? I know Stellaa is more than capable of defending herself, but I just want to make a point. If you look back at earlier posts you would see that Stellaa passionately defended the rights of the Palestinian people during the Gaza invasion. I really don't think you want to enter unarmed into a battle of wits with her, however fun it might be to watch her run rings around you.
Natalie, thanks, did not even know he or it was speaking to me.
Did not bother with "it".
Omar Effendi:

I do not doubt that:

"I have it on good authority that the average Iranian teenager is up to more "mischief" than the any mobile mullah patrol is probably humanly or inhumanly capable of keeping up with.."

but what you fail to say is that this observation is only about boys, young women would not dare to do these things. A pity that this teenage love play can only be carried out on one side.
i haven't read the comments here yet so this may be redundant; death for blogging? come on!

"I am not speaking against Islam, if it stays as a religion. I have the same sentiment against all religions. Especially the ones that come with legal systems that mandate punishments and rules from thousands of years ago and a bunch of guys holding on to the reigns of power in a changing world. Let go fellas."

amen stellaa. let's hope people over there will grow as sick of their repessive regime as we did of ours here.
Ablonde,

Always Americans view Muslimahs, that is to say Muslim women as such neutralized and powerless people. Do you not know that in most Middle Eastern families that the real power is exerted by the matriarch and not the "man of the house." Get off your act, it's as old as Ali's. If you haven't any real world experiences please don't pontificate like one of the pious ones..we have enough of them already.
Take my mother for example. My father may have worn a sultan's crown, but it crumbled to dust, if ever there crossed my mother's face, a disapproving frown. Mooshikila? Getting the hang of it? It's a different culture..
And my mother god rest her soul was no wilting flower!
Omar - but only inside the house, right? There's the rub. I happen to know Muslim and Middle East culture, and you won't convince me that it's just "different". Sorry. What's true is that the cartoon depth understanding of many Americans is unhelpful, as it makes people needlessly defensive.

Iran has tons upon tons of bloggers. This will not end well for the mullahs if they pursue it.

newblog - welcome first. Second, both the USSR and Apartheid South Africa crumbled without any direct military assault upon them.
"There's one in every crowd, right? I know Stellaa is more than capable of defending herself, but I just want to make a point. If you look back at earlier posts you would see that Stellaa passionately defended the rights of the Palestinian people during the Gaza invasion. I really don't think you want to enter unarmed into a battle of wits with her, however fun it might be to watch her run rings around you."
(Natalie B)

"Natalie, thanks, did not even know he or it was speaking to me.
Did not bother with "it"." (Stellaa)

Stellaa and Natalie, it is worth noting that the offending comments came from one who has not yet been able to write a blog of there own, and the comments written by this same source have all been negative and vindictive towards other bloggers. That kind of gives an indication of the qualityof where the comment came from. Any one with little ability can seek to destroy, but it takes some one of some worth to build and bring something positive into life.

Stellaa, well done for a noble response.
Inside-outside..what are you saying? And what is this with rubbing..you're not a wild gypsy who's going to give me the rub are you? My mother never felt compelled to go about Cairo covered in an abbaya type dress (in Iran they have something similar called chador) and she came and went about her business and the business of our family unhindered. So many Americans make much melodrama of Middle Eastern women. In some respects and in some societies there is severity, in others, it is a different matter, but still you use such broad strokes to paint a so simplified picture.
Call me majnoon...but I feel you look at us and see a TV cartoon.
New blog, Jon is not Kelvin. He is a great person and blogger.

On the women of the middle east, gads...that is another topic. Omar Effendi has some truths. In some neighborhoods the women are the Sheh's...the bosses of the neighborhood, at least in Egypt. Each country is different. But still, women that are not covered up Omar are treated like sharmutahs and taunted. Go figure.

We have moved away from the topic. Why can we not discuss this one issue, freedom of speech in Iran and applying the antiquated legal structure from a century old religious system on to modern times.
New Blog, why am I here? Well ask the Greeks how they feel about half Greeks.
new blog, you said it. I don't agree with you. Now we are done with that thought I hope for the day.
Yes, the open minded Greeks....!!!!
aiwa..ifta..open the mind.
It sounds like the strategy is to have a law that is so vague that no one would ever know what was punishable and what wasn't, and a court could construe the meaning of the law any way they wanted. I guess that's what happens in a country without due process.
Mishima, very true. The very definition of tyranny. Keep them in order through fear.
I hadn't heard about this. Chilling.

Free speech is my favorite right. I think everything else flows from it. Take it away, and every other freedom is imperiled, because you can't speak up to defend them. So I revere that old saying about how "I might disagree with what you say but I'll defend to the death your right to say it."
At least in America:
" YOU ARE FREE, TO DO AS WE TELL YOU! YOU ARE FREE, TO DO AS WE TELL YOU! GO BACK TO BED, AMERICA, YOUR GOVERNMENT HAS FIGURED IT ALL OUT. YOU ARE FREE, TO DO AS WE TELL YOU!"
-the late great Bill Hicks
Mother of god, what century is this? Rigoddamndiculous. I can't help but wonder how the HELL they would enforce this. It would tie them up bureaucratically.
Best country on earth!!!

Highest percentage number of citizens behind bars.
Somewhere near 30th best in most health care categories.
An unprecedented 44 countries militarily intervened in since WWII - Grenada, anyone?
#1 arms merchant to the world.
Recaptured Nathan's hot dog eating championship (usa, usa, usa).

My voluntary expatriate life has had me live in eleven different countries, and there is no doubt that american hardly comes close to being best by most metrics of civilization.

new brog's got it right - we just need to employ more 5,000 bombs. There are ~ 1.6 billion Muslims in the world. Incinerating them shouldn't be much of a problem for a military that has bungled most of the adventures its embarked upon since WWII.(and before)

"Best country on the earth," the feeble cry of xenophobes or those incapable of wading through the pap that is supposedly an informed populace.