I watched an entire episode of The O’Reilly Factor for the first time last week. It was an eye opening experience for me, not so much because of what I saw and heard, but rather because of the reactions I noted by observing two of his loyal fans – my parents.
I was visiting with my parents in the Bay Area. This was the first time in many years that I had stayed at their home. When I lived in the Bay Area, naturally, I’d only stop by their house to visit. And, after I moved away, I would always stay in a hotel when visiting. But this time due to financial concerns related to my work (as in "lack of"), I accepted their invitation to stay at their house.
My parents are in their 80s. They both retired from long middle-class working careers. My dad worked in a factory for one company from the time he left the Navy after WW II until he retired at age 65. My mother worked in public school administration for the same amount of time. Even though they encouraged, and helped pay for, all four of their sons to graduate college, neither of them had an education beyond high school.
I have always considered my parents to be apolitical. They never talk politics, and the only thing recently that they seem concerned about is their fear of losing some (or all) of their Social Security or Medicare benefits.
However, I learned by living with them for several days that they have a strong affinity for watching the Fox Cable Network - in particular The O’Reilly Factor.
Under any other circumstances I would have moved out immediately. But, loving my parents as I do, and having learned a long time ago that it is not wise for a Rockford child to argue with his parents, I decided to try to gain an understanding of what makes an O’Reilly fan an O’Reilly Fan.
The O’Reilly Factor, it seems, is the only non-sports or entertainment TV show that my parents watch. My mother spends most of the day watching soap operas, and my dad likes to watch sports (especially baseball). In the evening, they both watch old episodes of Lawrence Welk, Bonanza and Golden Girls.
Until Bill O' comes on.
One night I sat down with my mother and watched an entire episode of The O’Reilly Factor – from start to finish (In the past, I’d only seen YouTube excerpts from his show). Based on this experience, I think I see the genius of the Roger Ailes propagandist approach to brainwashing the elderly.
At one point O’Reilly winked at the camera and said something like, “and, I’m just looking out for you.” My mother said, “See son. How can you not trust that kind-looking man with a twinkle in his eye when he says his only concern is to help you?” Later in the program O’Reilly talked about a group of “pinheads,” a term he apparently uses to describe any (and all) liberal intellectuals. My mother then began to berate one of O’Reilly’s favorite “pinheads,” Al Gore, based on things she had heard on his show in the past. “Don’t you agree that Al Gore is just a smarty pants who likes to talk down to us regular folks?” she said.
At that point, my head was about to explode.
I came to realize that The O’Reilly Factor is nothing more than cleverly disguised hippie-bashing. The Ailes’ formula is to get into the “comfort zone” of Fox elderly viewers. He lets them know that, “You can trust us to understand and take care of your needs.” And, at the same time, “We will let you know about the evil, fast-talking, slippery-tongued intellectuals who are out to take everything away from you.”
Genius?
Maybe not – But it works!


Salon.com
Comments
1. Nice people like your folks, who are, and should be, worried about where the policies of the right wing of America have taken us.
2. The "tri-tip" hat wearers- these are the, er, eccentrics who have ALWAYS been part of politics, as anyone, which is practically no American, who has been active in grassroots politics knows well. Think not US Flag t-shirts, but rather, full regalia to the point of red white and blue coat and tails, high hats, etc, basically the "Uncle Sam" haberdashers.
3. The HATERS: the core audience which is causing every problem in the country today by clinging to hate of anyone who isn't from thar nek o' da woods, these are the core of the Tea Party, the John Birch Society, and, yes, (oh, and it is the same folks- they've always had their night time get ups) THE KLAN. Most likely your parents were Democrats before 64-68 (educated guess, of course could be wrong) and so may not realize that actual, true Conservatives refer to this horrid group of racist, and truly credulous and imbecilic, haters as, as the Great Buckley himself often said while slamming the door in their face, THE VULGARIANS- these racist haters, basically brownshirts, are, with Ailes' perverse assistance and propaganda expertise, EXPLOITING GOOD PEOPLE LIKE YOUR PARENTS FOR THE KOCH BROTHERS AND THE KKK!!! using 400 years of racism against Blacks, Asians and Latinos.
ps, I am not young, nor do I hate white culture for no good reason, so, I am not embarrassed to say I watch Welk re-runs too ... too bad Ed Sullivan isn't on retro TV ... bet your folks would watch it and I would too!
You sit there and watch your parents and I sit here and watch you.........
If there is any difference in the level of brainwashing that has got y’all, I can’t find it. Yeah, it’s on different subjects but it’s all brainwashing. I strongly suspect it’s got me too. Strongly.
ʘ‿ʘ
.
Yup. My parents were Democrats until the late '60s.
How'd you know?
most americans have better sense than to turn all their money over to a 'financial advisor,' on his promise to 'look after you,' but that is precisely what they do in politics.
Fear and Unbalanced is what Ailes' purveys.
It sounds as if Bill plugs into your mother's need to feel respected, and that BOR's you-and-me-against-the-world chatter speaks to their need to belong.
So, I'm sitting here wondering how we can plug into those same needs. I cannot help but think that the fact we actually on your mother's side should help.
Contrast that with left wing, or even slightly left of center media. There are problems and shame on you if you're not doing something to ameliorate them. Guess which one resonates.
No, what stopped me completely was your brief aside about not knowing your parents' politics, until now, simply because they "never talked about it." I was dumbstruck by how different my own upbringing was (not to mention, the two Freudian psychologists who committed it).
I can't remember ever not knowing where they stood on something... whether issue or person... or t.v show or flavor of ice cream, for that matter. They had strong opinions on virtually everything, the kind that didn't lend themselves to debate because that would mean acknowledging the possibility they were wrong.
One of the harsher realizations, watching my mother ripen into her 90's (though, in all honesty, it's more like withering) is that the die-hard liberal who raised me ended up as closed-minded and prejudiced as the people who once moved her to join the March on Washington.
She doesn't watch FOX. I think her loyalty to NBC may well be one of the few things she hasn't discarded over the years. But what frightens me is to think that, if she did, it might be because of, not despite, its political perspective. I pray age never effects me the same way.
If it does, would someone please turn my proverbial lights out... and make sure to shut off my TV?
My best guess is that you could start by chipping away at their trust in Bill O’Reilly. You could start by being honest about what you're trying to do. "Mom, I feel bad that he's managed to convince you of some of his stories," and give her an example or two of when BOR has been caught in a whopper. Point out to her ways in which BOR’s stories are in line with his corporate sponsors’ financial interests, and help her see the logic of his lying—he’s not lying because he’s evil; he’s doing the job he’s being paid to do.
You could also ask them to return the favor of watching a show. "Dad, I watched BOR with you, and I'd like you to watch something with me next time I visit." Then rent "An Inconvenient Truth," but before you sit down with them to watch it, ask them to tell you what they expect about it, having listened to BOR. Then show them the movie, and ask them what they think of Al Gore now, and whether they think BOR was straight with them.
Do none of this with any sort of "I-know-better-than-you" attitude. Every step of the way make sure your verbal and nonverbal messages are consistent with those of one friend helping another wade through the torrent of messages that come through that cable.
Maybe you live too far away to try, but as I said on my blog about this topic, people like you and me have to figure out this deprogramming gig. Only relentless person-to-person, eyeball-to-eyeball effort will recapture the hearts and minds of friends and families.
Actually, I did manage to get my parents to watch a Keith Olbermann episode. My mother thought he was “a handsome but very intense man.” I plan to continue with my deprogramming efforts (with my brothers’ help) when I visit with them at Thanksgiving.
You are very fortunate to have been brought up in a family that “inspires” open discussions on issues of the day. I was not. My mother always felt that her children (at any age) were to be left out of “adult” issues, meaning anything to do with politics, economics or religion.
Fortunately for my daughters, this has proven to be a source of “How not to raise children” for my wife and me. Our dinner table is literally a “family forum” every night. Everyone is encouraged to discuss “anything and everything” regardless of how sensitive the issue may be.
Thank you for your very interesting comment.
rated
I also find it sad that people cannot be more 'middle of the road' in their approach to what they watch. And being that I'm in a city that's heavily Democrat, I don't mind if someone sees me checking out Fox on the Internet.
You might be the one that needs the calming effects of a martini. I suggest dry.
Take care and, wow, lighten up.
I used to go to a gym here in town on a regular basis. Whenever I’d be on the treadmill, all I’d see on the flat screen TVs in front of me would be the mind-numbing, idiotic chatter of Fox TV. I knew the owner of the gym, and I asked him if he could at least change the channel to a sports network or anything besides the mindless propaganda of Fox News. He said he liked the programming and if I didn’t like it I should leave.
So I did.
Don’t get upset, Barbara, because some of us realize the garbage that is being forced down our throats by Murdoch, Ailes et al. You can watch it if you like.
I won’t
As an example, my parents were both fearful for my life during the Wisconsin protests; I am a teacher and joined others at the Capitol for those days in February. I know it's because they saw the "show" that FOX was giving them, portraying us as "violent union thugs" sometimes. Nothing could have been further from the truth. (And I did ask them when they had EVER seen a palm tree in Wisconsin.)
I respect their right to choose their programming in their own home (they raised me to respect the points of view of others) but I do make sure that NPR is on in my car, and I conveniently leave The Nation on the coffee table when I leave.
Great post.
Obviously leaving the gym is of a different order.
Although, personally, I think it shows how narrow the Left can be that people, nice people like you, won't expose themselves to the other side. I think it good for us to read, watch, and debate with the other side.
I'm not comparing it TO the man, but saying we are not talking about something on that level here. Sorry if that is not clear in some way.
Good luck.
The Capitol rally must have been a great experience.
“I conveniently leave The Nation on the coffee table when I leave.” – Perfect!
There will be no remedy for this as long as free and unbiased non-corporate journalism is so scarce (especially on TV) in this country. The only trustworthy source of filmed news coverage is Amy Goodman's Democracy Now, and sadly, their audience is minuscule.
At the end of the day, it always comes down to the fact that we no longer have “unbiased non-corporate journalism.” If we could fix that, we could fix many things that are wrong with our society today.
Thanks for your comment.
And to call Fox News "somewhat conservative" is woefully inaccurate. It is propaganda, pure and simple.
And a more general observation directed to anyone who happens to read: I don't absolve the other networks of lapdog journalism, by any means, but Fox News is the most blatantly deceitful. All corporate news sources are guilty of sins of omission and complicity; Fox News has regularly been found to disseminate outright falsehoods. Factual newscasts can be found in only one place that I'm aware of, and it's not PBS, sadly, for they suppress what is against the plutocracy's best interests, as well, or at least they don't report it until a few years after when it is too little, too late. No, I refer to Amy Goodman's Democracy Now. She is a true patriot, and if her audience were only greater, democracy might be more than the sham to which it has devolved, in the US.
Love reading the Nation.
This was all too familiar. My favorite comment from my mom recently was "Why won't the government let us buy Mr. Edison's bulbs?"
Me: "Mom, have you been watching Fox News?"