Things I learned along the way

or things I learned because I had to

sueinaz

sueinaz
Location
Arizona,
Birthday
February 26
Bio
Your average inconsistent X'er I used to care very much about being a good Republican, but I don't know what that means anymore. I now focus my energies on writing about growing up, the politics of Animal Welfare. I volunteer. I organize fund raisers. I do my best to raise awareness about cruelty, gay penguins, stupid people who keep wild animals as pets and showing funny cat videos. I also write extensively about my family who would probably laugh about this blog, then choke me (but not hard enough for it to be a felony). You can also find me at: http://catsandpolitics.blogspot.com/

MY RECENT POSTS

Sueinaz's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 25, 2010 10:38AM

A monkey peed on my head : Defending Zoos and Aquariums

Rate: 11 Flag

I'll be honest, I never really cared about hoof stock until I saw a teeny brown 3 day old Arabian Oryx shivering on the ground and realized he was one of 1500 on the entire planet. That little animal taught me more about being an environmentalist than any lecture I ever attended.  I stood about 6 feet from him and helped a a few photographers snap his photo. I did this while I volunteered, at my zoo. 

 That being said, I want to take a moment to defend Sea World.

1. At the circus animals do tricks and people pay money to see wild animals do funny things.  At accredited zoos and aquariums, people pay money to see animals in habitats suitable for healthy living: play, breeding as well as viewing.

2. I admire Sea World's breeding program, and think they deserve a lot of credit for this work.  Look at this gorgeous otter pups and tell me Sea World isn't doing good in the world:

 

 I have mixed feelings about animal shows: on one hand if they help the public care about endangered animals they are actually doing good in the world. However if those animals are lacking suitable habitats, then I have a problem with it.

2.  Wild animals are always wild. It doesn't matter if they were hand-raised by a pack of loving nuns who treated that orca/mandrill/orangutan like a baby. They will always be wild. People who do  conservation work with living beings always recognize that the animal they care for and possibly have raised has no qualms about ripping their flesh off. I would wager to bet, the trainer was aware of the danger every moment working with the whale.

3.   Hazard is a fundamental part of working with wild animals.  I know someone who was bit by a python. Her reaction "I was moving him and I guess he just felt unsafe." Did she blame the python? Hell no. It's a python's job to bite when it's scared.Actually when I think about it, everyone I know who works directly with wild animals has a few bumps, scars and stories to tell.  For example, a monkey peed on my head. 

 4. Conservation Ecology is about ensuring the survival of species. That is all. These organizations, in the US, tend to participate in something called the "Species Survival Plan" or SSP. This plan helps ensure the genetic diversity of endangered animals and helps explain why zoos trade animals of breeding age.

5. There is an international organization called the IUNC that will help explain this better than I can:

The IUCN Species Programme working with the IUCN Species Survival Commission (SSC) has for more than four decades been assessing the conservation status of species, subspecies, varieties, and even selected subpopulations on a global scale in order to highlight taxa threatened with extinction, and therefore promote their conservation. Although today we are operating in a very different political, economic, social and ecological world from that when the first IUCN Red Data Book was produced, the IUCN Species Programme, working with the Species Survival Commission and many partners, remains firmly committed to providing the world with the most objective, scientifically-based information on the current status of globally threatened biodiversity. The plants and animals assessed for the IUCN Red List are the bearers of genetic diversity and the building blocks of ecosystems, and information on their conservation status and distribution provides the foundation for making informed decisions about conserving biodiversity from local to global levels. 

6. You can learn more about endangered animals at: http://www.iucnredlist.org/ 

What happened at Sea World was tragic, but I hope this doesn't color people's perceptions of Zoos and Aquariums. Really, they are here for the best of purposes:   educating the public about biodiversity through conservation ecology. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I agree. For the record, I've been bitten, kicked, pooped on, spit on, by a nice variety of God's creatures.
PS Just noticed tomorrow is your birthday - Happy Birthday in advance :)
Most important -- Happy Birthday! So nice of you to celebrate with us.

God, I love animals and I'm torn about the whole zoo/circus aspect of raising and protecting the many species. I know how valuable and needed they are but I still wonder about the well being of the animals. Wouldn't it be nice if we could find a way to save animals for future generations by leaving them in their natural habitats. But, then along comes man and the whole plan gets derailed.
R
It's a complicated issue. Thanks for addressing it. For the record, I agree that SeaWorld has done a lot of good things. A line was crossed yesterday; the question is, primarily, who crossed it? This wasn't an animal in a show; it was an orca who'd been taken to SeaWorld and put in restrictive circumstances because of its past.
I can't really say it better than luluand phoebe. I have been involved with the local zoo and it's Big Zoo Lesson in which third graders spend a week of intense work at the zoo. They (the zoo) curate, protect and love species that would otherwise disappear from the earth. I do not see Sea World (or circuses, or rodeos) in this light. I certainly don't blame the animal, and I really don't blame the trainer...if there's blame, I would place it on businesses that encourage these potentially lethal combinations that are cruel to the animals involved for the sole purpose of making money.
In his novel LIFE OF PI, Yann Martel gives a fantastic defense of zoos. Modern zoos fill animals needs much more humanely (or animal-ly?) than was done before. But there definitely are lines put up by both animal and human that must not be crossed. Maybe we understand their signals less than they ours.
Orcas are highly intelligent, social animals who travel more than 70 miles a day, and live in tightly bonded matriarchal pods. The only thing we should learn from seeing whales and dolphins in aquariums is that they don't belong there.
What Donna said, again.
I'll say it again, Sea World has a tremendous breeding program. I think the work they have done with small aquatic mammals is impressive. The large ones are the issue: they need space and they certainly don't need to do tricks...
The issue of what to do with marine parks in general and killer whale exhibition shows in particular is really separate from what should happen, or perhaps what should have happened, to Tillikum, the orca in question in this case. Having been involved in an incident in Victoria, British Columbia, should he have then been released into the wild? Where should he have gone, and what should have become of him. He was used in a breeding program at SeaWorld. Was this humane? Everyone needs to back up a couple of steps and ask what should have become of this particular animal when he left British Columbia.

All of these discussions need some balance.
I've seen plenty of people injured by domesticated animals. The first rule is always be aware of your environment. The second is when an animal isn't acting normal be on guard.
I too agree with Donna's comment - which is a tough realization to come to considering the joy that dolphin shows used to give me as a kid. I'm also wondering about the PR ramifications for cetaceans, especially since Japan, Norway and other countries are stepping up their whaling programs.
Hello, dear ladies and gentlemen, http://www.coolforsale.com Buy now proposed a. A rare opportunity, what are you waiting for? Quickly move your mouse bar. commodity is credit guarantee, you can rest assured of purchase, coolforsale will provide service for you all, welcome to 1. sport shoes : Jordan ,Nike, adidas, Puma, Gucci, LV, UGG , etc. including women shoes and kids shoes.
2. T-Shirts : BBC T-Shirts, Bape T-Shirts, Armani T-Shirts, Polo T-Shirts,etc.
3. Hoodies : Bape hoody, hoody, AFF hoody, GGG hoody, ED hoody ,etc.
4. Jeans : Levis jeans , Gucci jeans, jeans,
Bape jeans , DG jeans ,etc. NHL Jersey Woman $ 40NFL Jersey $35 NBA Jersey $ 34MLB Jersey $ 35 Jordan Six Ring_m $36 Air Yeezy_m $ 45 T-Shirt_m $ 25Jacket_m $ 36,Hoody_m $ 50 Manicure Set $20
Free to pay freight, For details, please consult : http://www.coolforsale.com
I'm a former zoo employee and I agree. When I was child, zoos were animal prisons (keeping big cats in tiny cages, for instance, which was horribly cruel). They have really evolved, though, since then, and I have not been to a zoo, as an adult, that failed to create environments conducive to the animals' health and happiness. Modern zoos do enormous good for the cause of wildlife conservation.
Thank you for this important perspective. Like others, and typically for me, I'm conflicted and ambivalent. But I'm glad there's an eloquent defense of conservation-minded animals-in-captivity programs.

fyi: there's a documentary up for this year's Academy Awards called THE COVE; I heard the makers of it talk on NPR today. Apparently, they did some sneaky work to get some footage of regular dolphin captures and kills off a coast of Japan. I bet there's renewed interest in this after the Sea World incident, and I'd actually like to see it before the Oscars.
Perhaps you'd feel differently about orcas and those cute little shows if YOU had to live in a bathtub, do tricks for food, and swim around in your own watered-down feces and urine...

Zoos are what they are. Sea World orca circus tricks are something completely different.
Jesus, I just checked back after many hours away and you only got 10 ratings. You must have really pissed people off to post such an emotional, blood-pressure-rising issue and miss hitting a vein.......

I think that the concensus here is that the "Killer" Whale was justifiably pissed off.
You make a compelling argument regarding conservation. Other than this one valid exception, the case for keeping animals in captivity for our entertainment and edification does not hold water. We share the planet with many other species, but have been rather selfish and self centered in our actions. We destroy habitats in the name of progress or for financial gain. We hunt for sport. As king of the hill, we are not very beneficent sovereigns.
How rude of me……..I do wish you a sincere Happy Birthday
I agree, too. Thanks for showing us the otter pups. R. So cute.
As a keeper of fresh water aquarium fish I sometimes feel that may be my pets would be better off back in their natural state. But the majority of the fish, especially tropical fish are bred specifically for aquarists and some species bear little resemblance to the original fish from for example a South American river.
http://www.fresh-water-aquariums-guide.com/fresh-water-aquarium-fish/
What I forgot to say above was that folk who keep Fresh Water Aquarium Fish really benefit from them . In fact it is known that many folk have become healthier and actually lowered their blood pressure due to the relaxing environment that home aquariums produce not to mention the feel good factor of looking after and caring for live animals.