Dr. Susanne Freeborn

Dr. Susanne Freeborn
Location
Bellingham, Washington, USA
Birthday
November 06
Company
Depends on the hour
Bio
...................................................... BANNER BY RIC TRESA

JANUARY 24, 2009 8:05AM

Toad Lake Logging: Is 80% enough for them?

Rate: 23 Flag

The pictures here are often not of the best quality because they were taken under difficult, overcast skies, and as fog was just lifting.  They are meant to chronicle what happens when logging comes to the land next door here in Washington State.

The family who did this have a little old granny who lives in the farm house in the large cleared fields at the bottom of the first picture.   She and her husband used to graze cattle on both the little meadow near my house and in the large fields.  He would cut a tree once in a while to pay his taxes, but just a selected tree or two, never a wholesale logging operation.   Then he died.  Cue the lawyers, the trust and the relatives.  The family, save the little granny, who is quite a good hugger, don't live here on the mountain, they live in town.  I'm sure that they will make plenty of money from what they have done.  As if that is all that matters.

Toad Lake on Squalicum Mountain

This is Toad Lake on Squalicum Mountain.  We are outside the city limits of Bellingham, Washington.  If you look carefully, you can see a tiny meadow at what would be 7:00 if the lake were a clock.  I live just to the left of the meadow, about 100 yards from the bottom of the lake.  This picture was taken about seven or eight months ago by my neighbor from a small airplane.

The Meadow Now  

This is what the meadow looks like now, after a few weeks of a logging operation.  All of  the forest below the lake is owned by the family trust that now, through its lawyer, manages that property.  With a permit, the laws in Washington State allow for them to log 80% of the logs, and they got pretty close to doing so. 

 Our House in September 2008

As you can see, the forest was dense behind our house this past September when Dan was staining the decks and the fascia boards.  I loved it just like this.

Trees Gone Heart Broken

These are the trees left just behind my house.  The wire fence is the property line.  We will be putting up a fence now to screen the view of the deforestation they have left behind. 

 Logging 4  

 This is a view of what is left after they cut down so many trees.  The next view is what it looked like this Spring when we planted a Dogwood in what was our shade garden.  We aren't sure that our investment in shade plants will do well here anymore.  It's not exactly dappled light anymore, is it!

Dogwood 

 

Another view

Here's another view of what they cut down.

Log piles  

Here are some of the log piles they built while hauling logs from down the mountain up to the staging area they made of the former meadow.  Did I mention that cattle grazed on this little meadow for decades?  That's why there was a barbed wire fence, to keep them safe and contained.  I watched the tracks on this logging equipment grind up a beautiful group of ferns that I had watched grow for the past four years.  Just ground them into the ground leaving giant gouges as it turned to grab the trees and haul them out where they were delimbed and turned into logs.

Logging truck 

This logging truck has returned and hauled out more than twenty loads as large as this and runs by our yard each time it does so.  It's caused me to be a good bit gloomy lately.

Abandoned limbs  

This is the detritus in its earliest state after a logging operation.  I am sure detritus is not the word that the loggers would use, but this is dead organic matter mixed with the humus that has been dredged up by their heavy equipment and it will take one hell of a long time for it to compost unattended.  I am watching to see what they will do with this material. 

I really don't know what they will do, I have never been this close before, but it concerns me that they may have made a lot of kindling that they are now going to leave laying about.  I am thinking this 80% permit was the Washington State legislature's answer to the ban on clear cutting.  Great, it really looks so healthy to rape the land in this way.  This is what property rights can buy you in the US.  You can do whatever the hell you want and the consequences are meaningless under the law. 

Bye Bye Now 

From Walt Whitman's Leaves of Grass

Along the northern coast,

Just back from the rock-bound shore, and the caves,

In the saline air from the sea, in the Mendocino country,

With the surge for bass and accompaniment low and hoarse,

With crackling blows of axes, sounding musically, driven by strong arms,

Riven deep by the sharp tongues of the axes—there in the Redwood forest dense,

I heard the mighty tree its death-chant chanting.

 

The choppers heard not—the camp shanties echoed not;

The quick-ear’d teamsters, and chain and jack-screw men, heard not,

As the wood-spirits came from their haunts of a thousand years, to join the refrain;

But in my soul I plainly heard.

 

Murmuring out of its myriad leaves,

Down from its lofty top, rising two hundred feet high,

 

Out of its stalwart trunk and limbs—out of its foot-thick bark,

That chant of the seasons and time—chant, not of the past only, but the future.

Hit CountersRank Noodle

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
That's very sad, Susanne. I'm sorry to hear (and see) this happen.
Thanks Rob. We will find some kind of solution that masks what has happened and adds value to our property, but one thing is for sure, this is not change we can believe in!
This is heartbreaking Susanne. there have to be changes in our society's demand for paper and wood products that can have substitute materials. I'm so sorry to see this affect your family and neighbors. I hope there can be a push to grow faster, renewable materials in the US, such as hemp. It can be made into paper, cloth, and other useful products. It also provides a fuel source.

There are many other material substitutes......too many to mention..
I have been pretty heartbroken and have been having a little trouble keeping my sense of humor, though I have been looking hard inside for what is left of it. I am awfully glad that Dan and I are good with designing and gardening and will be able to make lemonade out of this somehow.

Thanks for your concern. I do appreciate my friends here so much.
I am so sorry for this--- so very sad. . .
Well it seems we have agreement for my depression. Sometimes it isn't a chemical imbalance, as so oft discussed. Depression can come from depressing circumstances, like the souls of the old trees wandering around the mountain without their trunks, their limbs fallen on the soil and their roots wondering what is left to feed. That's why I thought of that portion of Leaves of Grass, it reflects the feeling of this experience.
Heartbreaking, Susanne. I am the Lorax, I speak for the trees. Trees are living spirits and deserve our respect. By doing this, those people are bringing the wrath of the Earth upon them. Gaia is not pleased.

I know this sounds strange but the native Americans worshiped the trees and we should, too. I am so sorry this happened to you, to your view. I hope you pursue legal action as to the loss of your view and plants.

I love your house, BTW.
Thanks for coming by Lauren. I am not sure exactly what we will do. We came here to relax, fighting is not exactly what we had in mind.
It seems there is an awful lot of logging being done up around Bellingham lately. There must be good money in it, is all I can think. What a real shame this is, just a shame.
Love Walt...

This is the changing landscape of our beautiful world. It's becoming a Concrete Jungle. I wish I had the money to buy up green land. I would have it in my will that if anyone ever sold any part of it they would lose it and would have to preserve it...

It's such a sad thing to see...

(rated)
Great post
Greg
Thanks again UK and Greg. It's good to know that others have witnessed this too.
this is the american way. aren't you proud to be part of such a society?
Suzanne--thank you for sharing your story. I am sure the view will be better when you get your landscaping skills out there. Plant some fast-growing pines to get back your shade.

We are thankful we bought up the land around us (79 acres of mostly oak-hickory forest) years ago because the neighbors have clear cut on both sides of us. On one side they put it in a mobile home within 30 feet of our property.

We put a conservation easement on the land a few years ago to protect it forever from clear cutting or development. There were tax credits for doing this but our main motive was to save the land for wildlife. I don't know if Washington has such a program. I believe Obama even has plans to do more so landowners will have an incentive to conserve forests and farm land.

Actually, for those of you interested, you can buy up land in Virginia and get the conservation easement too.
This is flat out obscene. I remember driving up 101 in Oregon
seeing the clear cutting just beyond the line of trees left along
the highway to shield the view. Now that 20% left over might
become a bone of contention. I hope not. Best of luck to you.
I'm sorry for your loss.
Susanne,
I am saddened by these photographs. The land remembers. The trees actually do cry out to their fellow tress ("W" waves).
Looks like they did not give you a good 20% for a screen which they are required (at least in Oregon). The danger in leaving these few douglas fir trees is that the root system is so shallow. They depend upon each other to stand and, in a high wind, are helpless without their fellows.
Do you have anyone who is a logger who might look at it for you? I know you are not up to a fight but having the forest service look at it might be good.
So sorry...
I am absolutely appalled at what happened!!! I am NOT happy at all! I know there's nothing you can do but still you have my sympathy. Your beautiful garden and yard with the wonderful trees in the background, never the same.

And you wonder why I sometimes have a low opinion of most people on the planet.
I live in BC so I've seen a lot of this kind of atrocity against nature in some of the most beautiful places in the world (my opinion). What was once living, ethereal, historic, and even magical is now a dead place, stripped of life, beauty and soul. It makes me feel sick inside, which is why it took me so long to click on this.
Most of my neighbors here are pretty generous and kind people. Logging is still an important industry here, but this little slice of our neighborhood is not much compared to what is done further away from the City of Bellingham.

Thanks for your comments and your kind concern.
Well, as you know Emma, we can see a great deal of BC on a clear day, without even crossing the border. I am certain that BC looks similar to Washington, some beauty, then some OMIGOD!, then some more beauty. It makes me wonder if folks are just blind sometimes. Thanks for coming by.
Yes, fly over BC and the rape of the land is stunning. Many don't realize it because they see only the perimeter along the roads etc. but between the clear-cut logging -- no government here has ever seen a logging company it didn't love, even to the point of exporting raw logs -- and the storms we've been having in recent years, a lot of trees are gone. I live in what was once an incredibly wooded part of the city but in the 5 years I've been here, the trees cut down to accommodate hideous McMansions, to prevent damage to houses -- even if said trees are nowhere near -- and just for $$$$ is heartbreaking. The wildlife also suffers. It always kills me when people cut down every living thing and plant non-idigenous shrubs etc -- feng shui is alive and well here -- then bitch that there are no birds. They just don't get it.
A lot of clear cutting here in Oregon, too. It's simply devastating. The forests are just dying, between greed, global warming and invasive species.
Thanks for coming by Cat. I thought more folks would be interested in this, even if it doesn't involve sex, drugs or infidelity. Perhaps that is at the heart of why this goes on and on...
Can't imagine what it feels like to have this next door. Beautiful rendering of a tragic story.
I had the opposite happen next door to me in Northern PA. In the eleventh hour I was able to block 10 acres from being cleared thanks to the state and Delaware Highland Conservancy providing the money to help me buy it and put a land easement on it blocking a developer from building 40 homes and postage stamp size properties.

Sorry to hear your horrible story. The only way to prevent this sort of thing seems to be buying property around you and having notice of what is about to happen. Attending town meetings is one possible way to catch wind of some people's intentions.
Sometimes that is possible, but this family does not want to part with its land. Thanks for coming by Bob.

Thanks Jimmy, it was hard to write. I still am going to add the law that provides for this in as an addendum at the end, and hopefully, I can research the history of that law as well.
You break my heart.
I remember the Bellingham of my youth... my parents live off Connelly, where there was nothing but trees all the way up to Padden. Now, it's nothing but houses and more houses.... someday, there'll be no more trees on Sehome Hill! What is happening there?
Ugh, you probably had connections to this family before too and now how could you help from not cursing them in your sleep. I hear similiar stories from friends but not like yours where you weren't approached first the buy the land. In their cases they often called the owners buff and never thought it would happen to them. I am going to send this post to others I know would appreciate your story. There's alot more I want to share but right now that's not bringing back the trees...ugh, people.
sciencechick, I had a similar experience going home to the place where I grew up. Someone had scalped the hills into unnatural shapes, the road to my grandparents home was gone, and there were strawberries growing in this weird landscape. It was like landing on mars. And I was there to show my husband where I grew up, but it was gone. Same thing with my best friend's family home in town. It had been taken down and a big condo development went on for blocks and blocks.

There is still a lot to love up here in Whatcom County though. Thanks for dropping by.
Thanks Bob, that was the point, sharing it to remove some of the distance between the issue and the reader.
Susanne

There is a large need for lumber products. I know I can't live with out TP. While lots of people want what the land gives us they really want NIMBY.

On the other side of the coin. Clear cutting is not a bad as you think. The problem is after you do it you have to do certain things to restore the land. The land will return and be better than it was before it was cut. The problem is you and I will not live long enough to see it. After it is reclaimed there will actually be more timber there than before it was cut.

What you need to do is quickly check with the state to see what they are required to do to reclaim the land. When you find out hold their feet to the fire.

While the resources are here for us to use there is a right and wrong way to do it.
By writing what I have here I didn't mean to imply that I don't know what to do legally. I am a law school graduate and perfectly capable of researching the law. I even took a course in land use at the time, but it was focused on California land use.

We already have a copy of the permit to do this logging and the laws that are applicable. I am waiting to see if they will do what they are supposed to do. They are still hauling out wood, though the job is nearly done.

I am reading the laws, rules, requirements now and have already stopped the crew from burning unattended fires on the property. I will do the best I can without being overly combative. I have to live here and I don't want to lose track of the fact that I moved here for a quieter, more peaceful life. If my neighbors interfere with my quiet enjoyment of my home, I will do my best to get their cooperation in a neighborly way.
Susannne,
Like someone else said, I haven't opened this until now because I was afraid of what I would see. People, ugh!
On the brighter side, your lot and home look pretty enchanting from what I can tell. Maybe some more picks after the loggers leave?
Oh no, that's so awful.

Most of the forest around here (Memphis) is scrubby pioneer forest, not anything worth holding on to in the grand ecological sense, but it always wrecks me when I drive by what used to be a lovely woods and is now a vast pile of red mud with a sign saying, "Zoned commercial, available."
Well at least I am lucky that they cannot build more than one house per ten acres under the zoning for the land which was logged. And since I am a gardener, I am glad I don't have that red clay!
When I was on the road, I spent a lot of time traveling some gorgeous, tree-filled areas. However, when I was driving through OR, and WA, I saw SO MUCH logging ... acre upon acre of "no-longer forest". And I cried. Seeing your photos, of trees lying like so many dead bodies, makes me tear up.
AnniThyme, you must have heard the same death chant chanting that Whitman heard. I know I did. I am no longer curled into a ball over this, but sorrow is my companion.

Thanks for coming by to bear witness.
Susanne,
Came by for seconds.
I wish you luck on your effort to force them to keep promises.
How about a large stand of bamboo to sheild you from this eyessore that was once a forest?
Hopefully, this spring will bring you a lot of foxgloves and mushrooms. The land does heal but at its own pace which is not ours.
Our area was clear cut for railroad ties back in the early 20th century. What grew back is so unhealthy, densely packed, and competing for light. We have had to "fire wise" the land around the house - and I have tried only to take out the sick ones. Last year the pines started snapping much like during your ice storms, only from drought and disease. As much as possible, we've tried to use the resource but it burns hot and stinky and makes a poor fence post.

Small consolation, I know, but with five times our annual rainfall the destruction around you will be overgrown with plant life in relatively short order. For us, you drive cross country just once and the ruts stay for years.

Your place is gorgeous. Happy birthday to Dan. Have a great celebration.
Susanne, I feel ashamed as I read this. What else can we do to f**k up this earth? I'm feeling so angry now,so I can only imagine the RAGE that you must feel! I can't debate the veracity of the info about whether the logging actions actually bettering the earth, and although you won't be there to see the improvement, you are certainly witnessing the pillaging of our beloved Earth! Very powerful post! RATED/junk1
Susanne,

I glad to hear your a lawyer. You know how the system works and how to get around in it. For most that could be a bigger issue that getting them to do what they need to do.

As you know, I don't agree with lots of items that are posted on OS. We have to use what is on the earth. We have to build shelter and grow food. Also, while I hate the NIMBY people, it has to be in somebodies back yard. While there may not be a good way to do it, there are worse ways of doing it.

I know that doesn't make it any easier for you. You still have to put up with all the stuff that goes along with it. I just glad you can deal with it. I grew up around the coal fields of WV where they did a lot of strip mining. Before they were forced to reclaim the land the mess was beyond belief. Leaving the land destroyed is also not in my belief system.

Do they have to file a plan on how they are going to reclaim the land before logging can begin? What are they going to do with the land after they are finished. My landlord just clear cut some of his land. He is turning it into needed pasture for his dairy herd.

Let us know please.
This is an abomination. This kind of large-scale change can wreck a local ecosystem. We're upset down here by all the trees that were lost in the wind storms last week--and that was, as they say, an act of God, and not something that someone did on purpose. Shame on that family.
This can't continue indefinitely. There must be some anger in you over this occurrence. I experienced something similar when I lived in Oregon. I also worked on a tree planting crew at one time replanting the clear-cut areas like this one you show us. I was always amazed at the sheer destructive ability of our species.
I missed this post when it came out originally, lost in the feed I guess. And my heart is broken by it. What is to be done? What is to be done?
I am so sorry to see this happen. My brother lives in Oregon and I know from him just how widespread this is there. I wish we could make "living sustainably" an actual way of life instead of just a "fringe movement". This cannot go on indefinitely. Sadly, I think there are some who won't be happy until the world has 20 billion people and is entirely paved over.
I appreciate your coming by to see. I don't live on a street where there is a lot of through traffic, so it feels pretty lonely this loss.
Hi Neighbor,
Yes, it really is too bad that family had to log the trees. Mom and
Dad’s wishes were to remain on the property always and not go into a
nursing home. We are trying to grant those wishes but, unfortunately,
the cost of home care is very high. As children with families and
responsibilities of our own we are unable to contribute financially to
Mom’s care, therefore, we needed to find means to support Mom. We
could of sold the property to developers who would of put houses or
apartments on the land and ruining the view and amenities for many
people.
I know you don’t know me but I thought I’d give you some thoughts
of how
I feel about Toad Lake. When I was young we could walk clear to the
head of the lake and back to get our cows. There was only a path around
the lake. Trees were everywhere along with bear, deer, coyotes as well
as the normal wildlife (rabbits, skunk, squirrels). The lake was full of
catfish and frogs (hence Toad Lake). The frogs where so loud we could
hear them to our house it was like heaven living there. We (my brothers
and sisters) use to enjoy trekking to the big rock on the west side of
the lake where Dad, our uncle and their friends craved the names when
they were young children.
Then the developers came and took out tons of trees, put in roads all
over, then houses right next to our fence line. Now that was really
sad. No more fun swimming in the lake on our side with no one to bother
us. The developers didn’t clear their junk out of the lake but
instead pushed it to our side of the lake to rot; unsightly as well as
not good for the lake. They poisoned the lake to kill all the frogs and
catfish off so that it would turn the green to call it Emerald Lake and
planted trout. We never had trouble with the wild animals bothering our
farm animals but once people moved close dogs came wondering. The dogs
killed several chickens, chewed on a cow so bad she had to be put down
and killed calves. Very disturbing for Mom to lose her chickens. She
often kept a rifle handy.
Yes, it was a very sad day when the developers came and started to
change our way of life as we knew it as children. With people moving in
and the killing of the frogs and fish chased off the bears and deer.
There are still a few deer around but not like it use to be.
We use to have such a quiet heaven there but now we hear cars going by
and people talking like it’s in the other room. Yes, it’s still
nice and peaceful but it was a sad day when people started moving in
next to us.
Times change no matter how much we wish to remain the same. It is hard
for us kids to go home and see the changes but we still have all of the
memories of the fun we had growing up in the country.
Mom and Dad had the foresight to keep the property in the family for
many years to come so there children, grandchildren, great grandchildren
and beyond can enjoy it. We may have to harvest timber to keep the cost
of upkeep down but development will not happen anytime soon. Hope fully
Thanks for writing. I still think the mess the loggers left next to my house is unconcionable and that who ever set that contract up could have hired better, more responsible people.

Your family could have asked around to see if anyone would buy some of the land that wouldn't develop it. The property has a zoning that prevents it from being developed in the same way that the land next to the lake was developed. It is zoned rural, which means there can only be one home per ten acres of land. If someone had asked us, we might have tried to find a way to buy the land next to us to protect it. But no one thought to ask anyone that I know.

I'm with you, you can't make me call it Emerald Lake. It's Toad Lake as far as our family is concerned.

We see frogs now and again. And at certain times, it still gets pretty loud.

We moved here because it reminded me of where I grew up. It was in California, but it was out in the country. It still feels like that up here to some degree, but sometimes I hear the little race cars from the go cart raceway echoing up the mountain. I don't know how that sound can travel so far.