Editor’s Pick
MAY 8, 2011 12:16AM

Secular Prayers

Rate: 10 Flag

When it became clear, a couple of years ago, that we were moving to our current Southern city for the foreseeable future, I was a little concerned. We had a two and a half year old daughter and a brand new son, and needed urgently to make sure that their early lives and education were provided for appropriately in this new place. So I spent my daughter's dwindling nap-times calling pre-schools in our new area, trying to find one that suited her learning needs and our family.

Soon, I developed a script from which I dutifully read off questions to whoever at the pre-school picked up the phone. There were, of course, questions about nap-times and snack policies, pre-reading activities and outdoor playground facilities. Like any parent, I wanted to know about staffing and teacher-student ratios. Yet quickly, all these question became secondary to the one that eliminated one reputedly excellent place after another. "Is this a secular program?" I would ask. It seemed, to me, to be a simple question. And yet, the answers I got proved that I was about to get in over my head.

Almost invariably, except for church-sponsored Mother's Day Out programs, the answer to my question would be "yes."  "Great" I would think yet again, puffing with a new gust of hope, right before being deflated with "we say grace at mealtimes, of course, but we rarely go to chapel" or "the children do read Bible stories, of course, and we do encourage them to meditate on the sacrifice of Jesus and their Salvation!" While I do not have any objection to these activities in private pre-schools, it confused me that they could be thought of as secular. We finally did find a wonderful preschool which appeared to be entirely religiously unaffiliated, only to find my daughter chanting Grace at the school Thanksgiving feast.

I am agnostic, and have been content with this belief system for as long as I can remember. It is not, as some of my new neighbors assume, that I am anti-religious. It's just that I had never encountered any reason to be interested in one, one way or the other, until our latest moves. Like peanut butter, another acquired American taste, it seemed to be working really well for most people, causing allergies in some, and be of zero use to me, lacking any reference in my cultural or personal history.

Growing up in the last years of the USSR did not prepare me for understanding religion on the American scale. What I knew about religion I gathered from historical novels, visits to museums, and pithy catchphrases. I had been told in school that Marx had called religion "the opium of the people," but at 11, had only a very vague sense of what opium might be. I had attempted, and failed, to read Dostoyevsky's "The Grand Inquisitor," but came away only with a murky sort of sense of adult angst that need not have concerned me. I knew about religion in the same way that I knew about mangoes -- I could classify them as a delicious fruit, but had never tasted, smelled, seen, or touched one. If they were real, they had so far had no implications in my life.

A move to an immigrant enclave in the Northeast did little to clear up my muddled understanding of religion. Even after spending two years in a tiny yeshiva I could not imagine that the girls who swayed in prayer around me every morning understood or meant the words literally. I excelled in the study of religious books, because they were either interesting stories or convoluted and involved legal arguments, all of which I enjoyed immensely. Unreasonable though it sounds, it truly never occurred to me that the serious rabbis and wigged married ladies who taught us these things could possibly mean any of it as anything other than cultural anthropology.

And so here we were, completely unequipped to deal with our neighbors' and new friends' assumptions about religion, morality, and us. Afer the pre-school challenges, I was faced with honing appropriate responses to the well-meaning questions of whether we had found ourselves a "church home" and which summer Bible camp my children would be attending. Strangers in the supermarket ask me whether I am saved. People offer to pray for me for everything from hayfever to a death in the family. They ask for my prayers in return. It is a culture I am still learning to navigate, and one in which I feel confused and off-balance almost all of the time.

The friends I have made so far have been kind and gracious, though my churchlessness seems to confuse and trouble them. We seem to have agreed tacitly that we will talk only about those topics that concern us mutually, like our children, our homes, our dinners, our weekend plans... This is clearly a kindness on their part, a concession I appreciate on the one hand and chafe against on the other. I have grown very fond of these women -- I wish we could share a depth of relationship that is simply not possible. I am sure I shock them daily. I know they shock me.

As my daughter rises to kindergarten and goes to our wonderful local elementary school, my concerns only multiply. Less sheltered and away from her tiny and ultimately accommodating pre-school, will she be ostracized? Mocked? Will she feel left out? Will she know what other kids mean when they make assumptions about beliefs they think are shared by everyone? How do I reconcile my desperate wish for her happiness and inclusion with my strong belief that we have as much right to our absence of belief as others have to the presence of theirs?

If I prayed, this is probably something that I would pray about. And so I think of my constant rehashing of these thoughts as a sort of secular prayer. I must be one of those people who helps themselves. I will learn to listen better. I will try not to judge. I will seek to understandthe need for belief. And in return, I will hope and ask for the understanding to raise our children as wel see fit, until such time as they can decide for themselves. And then it will be time for another secular prayer.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
A very interesting post, and it hits close to home for me for many reasons.
It would impossible to simplify any of these wonders you have, and it does depend on where in the South you are, it's not just one way in the Southern states, although it can seem like it to an outsider...Christianity is the big club everyone wants to know if you're a member of in the South, that can also be true, but I also have many liberal, non-religious friends in the South as well. They are there.
My one Southern educational anecdote I've never forgotten is when my oldest son was in middle school and the teacher assigned "Who would you vote for?" essays, leading up to the Bush/Kerry election in 2004.
Each essay was put up in the school hall for everyone to read!!
Every single child wrote they would vote for Republican George Bush, except my son who wrote his essay on the reasons why America has a secret ballot for voting and why it is so important...as he put it to me, "I was so pegged by that one...I got called Stupid Liberal the rest of the year."
So you do have reasons for concern looking ahead...
Just Thinking, I really appreciate your anecdote. I am slowly growing a collection of my own. On the one hand, I have found people more open and more ready to do kindness than I have in other communities. On the other, I have encountered exclusion and mutually negative assumptions that I am afraid will become apparent and painful to my children soon. There is good and bad there, but I am less prepared for both here than in most places.
I would think that coming from the USSR where religion is basically "outlawed" in many ways, you would want your own children to have the choice to grow up within a religion where they actually got to have God in their lives. That's one reason so many people immigrate to America, to worship freely.
Oh dear --- probably best that you never settled in Utah, then. Mormons - lovely people, questionable theology - and definitly very exclusive about 'belonging.'
I have dealt with this but in the Midwest. It's as if by refusing to adhere to a religion and/or church that I don't believe in, folks can only be open up to a certain point. It is alienating for sure.

It's difficult and tiring work but you might want to consider setting your child(ren) and yourself up with additional social activities outside the local school environment so that when the times comes your children have another outlet.

As I tell immigrant friends (who didn't grow up here as I did) welcome to america.
Deborah -- you are right. The outlawing of religion in the USSR was ugly and egregious. In fact, my parents went to synagogue as a form of protest, and, if memory serves, may have gotten arrested. That is unconscionable, and I would not perpetrate that on anyone. I would also not prevent my children from worshipping if that was something they came to and realized they needed. However, the concept is foreign to me personally, and I do not choose to raise my children as part of a religious community. The challenge with which I am faced is how to walk the line of respecting the right of my friends to raise their children in their religion, while also making sure that my beliefs are not denigrated or used to hurt my children.
The Southern kindness...and willingness to chat for 20 minutes to total strangers...completely disconcerted my Northern husband for the first year we lived there....two years later, he was chatting away to anyone he met himself!
...so look out... : )
Best wishes to you --
A suggestion, since you are taking advice. By and large, Montessori schools eschew overt religious observances so you might want to investigate that option. Of course, the chances are that there might not be a Montessori school in your area. In the meantime, religion is the Molotov Cocktail of America society....so be careful how you handle it. The problem, you see, is that you may be agnostic, but you are still Jewish as far as the Christian world is concerned...and the Christians want to save you from both agnosticism and Judaism.
Thanks for the suggestion, sagemerlin. We have actually looked at Montessori, and liked some. The problem is that they require a five day a week commitment from the earliest preschool level. Since I am at home these days, it doesn't work well for us. But I appreciate the thought, and will continue looking.
I lived in the Southwest for a total of 12 years (7 years in Oklahoma and 5 years in Texas). I grew up in Turkey in a religious family. So, even for a person who understands the religious sentimentality the experience of the Southern Baptist zeal was overwhelming. They are very good people and they have been good friends.
Good luck to you, takingadvice. I haven't lived in the south, but I have definitely experienced this kind of thing. In college, I had a particularly zealous group of dorm mates who regularly held prayer meetings. At the time, I wasn't sure what I believed so I tagged along with a friend now and then. I think they marked me out as the "seeking college student" and I got the full onslaught of conversion for about six months. I still remember a kid I barely knew sitting down across from me at breakfast (breakfast! before coffee!) and saying, "How's your walk with God?" I wish I'd had a pithy comment to come back with.

I don't know what to say other than you will find friends. For the sake of having a church to go to, you might try the Unitarian Universalists. It's a wonderful community of people who aren't necessarily sure what they believe, but they like to get together on Sunday mornings and sing songs. If nothing else, you'll find other agnostics and atheists like yourself, marooned in the South.

Good luck.
When I moved to England, I was shocked to learn that religion is a part of the national curriculum and that there are government supported (ie free) church schools. To be a boy scout leader, you had to believe in God (and then they wondered why they had such a hard time recruiting leaders. It definitely was an issue in the leader class I attended).

I remember a pre-school assembly where my son had his hands folded in prayer, while the Lord's prayer was recited. He was in that school for 2 years without a single bit rubbing off. My daughter swallowed the whole thing, but then, she was already at the age for the national curriculum to come in and she liked the bible stories. However, when we left England, her religion left her, too. You need parental support and practice.

The funny thing is, the Brits constantly expressed amazement at the extent to which religion is a part of American life, but everyone in any school that followed the national curriculum (99%) got classes in religion, and unless you were in a Catholic school or one of the very rare Jewish schools, it was all Church of England. With perhaps the occasional comment that Islam and Judaism were different but acceptable.

People of faith often find it hard to conceive of people without it. Since they look to their church for guidance on morals and ethics, they sometimes assumed people who have no religion have no morals, but I suspect "non-practicing Jew" is an acceptable answer to what religion you are.

It certainly works in the Northeast, where I recommend you move. Boston has a thriving Russian community. I think Richmond, Maine does, too. When I lived in Pittsburgh, years ago, Squirrel Hill was full of signs, Zdes govoryat po-Russki.

What's funny is that here in Moscow, religion is returning. Putin and Medvedev make a point of showing up at Easter services and all restaurants have a Lenten menu for Veliky Post. Lip service is always paid to the traditional religions, Christianity, Judaism, Islam and perhaps Buddism.

I do think knowing bible stories is an important part of Western culture. You can tell, for example, the story of Joseph and his coat, or Noah and the whale as interesting fairy tales without an emphasis on the religious meaning.
Man, I knew the South was religious but I hadn't realized it had that pervasive a grip on the culture. Thanks for an enlightening and well-composed post TA.
Wonderful post. Thank you. I have wondered about religion all my life and just did a post on people who put crosses in their front yards. I did homeschool in the Alaskan wilderness with my two girls for a few years. I was appalled that there were so many religious home school students. My kids grew up just fine and are independent thinkers. Their father became a born again Christian after our divorce and that was and is pretty traumatic. But America has freedom of religion and I hope we can keep it. FREEDOM. The Christians think this is there country but it is not. It is mine and I am an agnostic. As my girls got older I got a set of workbooks that taught about all religions and when they got older still we went to different churches together on exploration trips. The Unitarians were the best, the Quakers were wonderful, Buddhism isnt a religion but a way of life we studied and we even went to a Baptist Church. I am so sad to hear of the riots in Egypt between the Right Wing Muslims and the Christians. I hope we never come to that here. Find a community that is not so very Christian to raise your kids in if you possibly can as Right Wing Christians are very scary and powerful in this country right now. Good luck and I hope you keep blogging here. You have a great voice.
Coming back at you, there's an extreme importance to the five-day schedule in Montessori education....my ex was a Montessori teacher-trainer, so I got the Montessori treatment 24/7 for many years; that was part of our problem. We had a Montessori relationship which doesn't work well between adults. Nevertheless, it is unsurpassed for raising adept, aware children....but it works best when you start them off early and well. If you need an in, let me know and I will see if I can arrange to drop her name as a calling card. She was well known in that world. PS: She is now the head mistress of a Jewish Day School in Cambridge, MA.
It's hard to imagine how many if any of them can do much thinking for themselves if they all feel they have to conform to the appropriate religion that involves worshiping and trusting a God that doesn't communicate and allows so many conflicting and irrational versions of his divine truth to be forced on so many people.
We need your support and trust!!! Dear friends, please temporarily stop your footsteps To our website Walk

around A look at Maybe you'll find happiness in your sight shopping heaven and earth You'll find our price is

more suitable for you.
Welcome to our website ( http://www.styshops.com/ )
Thanks to the support!