JULY 26, 2010 1:35PM

No One Wants Her

Rate: 31 Flag

Sometimes people don’t understand my sister so I try to do the talking when we’re out shopping or eating at a restaurant.  I make eye contact with whoever is helping us and hope they can read my expression. This is what I’m trying to say: “I know she’s weird, but I’m not. Really. Just help us, make it fast, and we’ll be on our way.”

            I do this because my sister wants to talk to everyone she meets even though they may not want to talk to her. She doesn’t seem to pick up on body cues or facial expressions. She’s always been talkative and very friendly. But it’s different now. I don’t think she sees herself as others do, sitting like a tiny bird in a wheelchair.  Plus, there’s this: since her stroke, she talks with a kind of cartoon-like Chinese accent. Sometimes it sounds Middle Eastern.

            I don’t understand my sister, either, but in a different way. None of us do, my other sister who is a year older than this sister, an older brother, and a younger brother. What we don’t understand is how we got to this place with her. The physical and mental part we get. It’s the other we don’t understand: why none of us will take responsibility for her.

             “Hi-di-ho,” I hear her say through the receiver. It’s 7 in the morning and the phone has woken me. “I know it’s early, early,” she continues. I can hear a morning news show blaring in the background. She’s got the phone on speaker. That’s the only way she can talk. Her left arm and hand don’t work. Her arm hangs from her shoulder, an uncooperative appendage that has lost any resemblance to its original form. She pauses to light a cigarette with her right hand. She’s been up for hours and just wants someone to talk to. She can’t get showered and dressed on her own. The muscles in her left leg, like her left arm, have atrophied and even if her brain had been able to send it the right signals it now wouldn’t be able to hold her. She uses a tripod cane to walk. Even then she battles the laws of gravity, tripping over things that seem to appear out of nowhere.  Sometimes she can’t get back up and she’s stuck, like a turtle on its back. She wears a call button around her neck for an emergency response company.

            She tells me she’s hungry but doesn’t want cold cereal or toast, something she could fix unassisted. Her home health aide comes at 8. I ask her what she’s been up to, although I know the answer.      

            “Doin’ doin’, “she says.

            My sister was an executive secretary for the manager of a major department store. She was married, divorced many years ago, and has a son who lives across the country.           

            She was 55 when she had the big stroke. The earlier stroke or strokes came, the doctors tell us, during surgery for a brain aneurysm. It’s hard to describe the way my sister was before the surgery. Afterwards it was as if any good parts of her disappeared. Only the bad ones remained, and they got amped up. Even the doctors asked us what she had been like before. “Before what,” we asked.  

            It’s been that way with my sister for as long as I can remember. She was the quintessential middle child, always in trouble, stubborn to the point of destruction, and the only one who didn’t know to duck or hide. She was the party girl who never knew when to stop.

            So she’s faced with the steady accumulation of bad decisions and brain chemicals gone awry. She’s a disabled, broke, drug addict nearing 60. And none of us want to take care of her. We love her but we don’t like her.

            It wasn’t supposed to be like this. I always imagined the big extended family my father presided over continuing for generations even after our parents’ deaths.  I guess I knew it wouldn’t happen. There were signs of a break-down long ago but somehow I thought it would change, my sister would change.   

            I don’t know how to end this story. I’d like to be able to say somehow everything was magically fixed, but I’ve never been much for fairy-tales.

            I take each day as it comes, or as my sister says, “doin’, doin’.”

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Sad, poignant and so well told.
Stephanie Tames: 'We love her but we don't like her' is a strong and vitally informative part to this post. Thanks.
Joan
ume
Real life+real people+real families
thanks,
s
This is wonderfully written. So honest and true and sad. I thank you for writing it. You did it so beautifully.
I was wondering when you'd get to her, Steph. Well told. The ending, it's perfect.
It is brave of you to write out loud what so many of us feel inside.
And you wrote it so well.
Lezlie
Happy endings are rare in real life. Usually we get endings we can deal with, if we are lucky. You tell your sister's story in a truthful, no-holds-barred honesty that is a treat to read. Oh and btw....welcome to OS and I hope your readership grows and with writing like this, I am sure it will.
Doin doin. Doin some fine writing here. And your humanity and good humor shine thru the heartbreak.
Welcome Stephanie. Wonderful writing on a heartfelt "real life" issue.
We love her but we don’t like herSo many here can relate.
Very well done. We, too, have a family member something like this. My mother's brother was the victim of assault & battery about 17 years ago, and he's never been the same. Severe brain injury, and like your sister, the best parts of him are gone. It's a tough road, but we're "doin' doin'" too. One day at a time. Welcome to OS...I'm glad I found this!
Ver touching and sad, told tenderly. Gabby Abby pointed me here. Glad to have found your page (and your website) ~R~
Maddie, Gabby, Bonnie, L, Torman, Matt, trilogy -- thanks. I've learned that the truth hurts, too.
Lisa, sometimes I wonder how much of it was it her genes and how much can be attributed to trauma -- she cracked her head open three times in the same spot before she was 13.
FusunA - I'm glad you listened to Gabby!
I really hear you, my dad has been unlikeable for the half century I've known him. He's 87 and he's in bad shape so I've spent the last 7 years helping with him, who am I kidding, my whole life when I live near. Neither my mom or I really want to but like you we do it. My daughter and I think he's a sociopath, no idea how he got to be how he's always been. Either way, he's family and we're stuck with him and we love him, someone has to love him in spite of who he is.
Stephanie,
Like Joan said, so well told. Yes, where does that big extended family we think will be there, go? It must have been tough to write that title.
Stephanie, welcome to Open Salon. I am another one that Abby sent here...
I always wanted a big family, with lots of brothers and sisters. I romanticized siblings (even though my own late twin brother was troubled). One of the things I've learned since coming to OS is to let go of that -- so many siblings are stuggling with just what you've described. The horrifying realization that they don't really like the people they are responsible for. Talk about a trap.
Excellent post, Stephanie. There's a difficult/troubled person in my family also, so I was nodding along as I read.
as gabby said, the end was perfect.

this was real....and sad.
I understand, my friend, I understand. R
Good opening draws the reader in, and then you gradually reveal more and more layers to the story, giving us several surprises along the way. Excellent writing. I can see how those 7 AM phone calls would be a bit tough. Hoping you and your sibs find a solution.

And welcome to OS!
Oh boy. At least she doesn't act nasty to the waiters. That is the single most shameful thing for me when I'm out with someone. I enjoyed this.
Stephanie,

What courage it took to write this post and express feelings and thoughts that most people hide even from themselves. Although my mother never had a stroke (which would have, at least, been an excuse for her behavior), she left my sister and I with something much stronger than dislike in our hearts for her. She lived to be 96 -- that's a long time to fight a battle between obligation and real caring. All I can say to you is it's okay not to like your sister. You are entitled to your feelings. You came by them honestly and fairly. As for caring for her, I wish I had an answer for you. Best I can say is follow your heart and remember that your health is as important as her health. Don't let obligation take its toll on you.
R
" I take each day as it comes, or as my sister says, “doin’, doin’.”"

And that's the only way you can do it!! Great piece. Highly rated and Tink Picked!!!
I have a brother who reminds me of your sister without the strokes. i love him, but he is very difficult to like. Well written. I get it.
l'Heure Blue, Donna, Bellwether Vance, Scarlett, Catherine, mgihmn, Renatta, SunnieGirl, AtHome Pilgrim, LC Neal, Caroline, Michael, tinkerertink69 -- did I forget anyone, sorry: thanks for your kind words. So many of you have walked the walk. A storm knocked out phone and internet so I've been sans OS for a day. I have a lot of catching up to do.
~s
Very tough stuff. Bittersweet and tragic that she stroked and has been left this way. You are so kind to attempt to understand and find empathy for her. Not easy. Yet you recognize her both as the former self and now the new version of your sister. I can only imagine what this would be like. I have 4 sisters and can feel the angst in my gut to think of such a thing, were it to ever happen to one of us. Thank you for this sharing, difficult it must be.
Thanks for this. Clean, calm, true. I have a mother who is ill now with self-inflicted behavior -- after surviving five kinds of cancer. I was happy to rush to her side for her mastectomy and a brain tumor. Not anymore. Families can kill you with their needs and their selfishness, and yet...they are our families. It's tough.