The Human Rights Warrior

Jennifer Prestholdt

Jennifer Prestholdt
Location
Minneapolis, Minnesota,
Birthday
February 25
Bio
Human rights lawyer, wife, and mother of three. (Not necessarily in that order.) I write about my experiences in fighting for human rights and how I am trying to bring those lessons home to my kids. Join our journey at www.humanrightswarrior.com, Humanrightswarrior on facebook and @JPrestholdt on Twitter. All material on this blog is © Jennifer Prestholdt, 2011, 2012

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 27, 2012 12:54PM

Justice Delayed Is Justice Denied for Cambodians

Rate: 13 Flag

 Skulls of Khmer Rouge victims.

Skulls of Khmer Rouge Victims ( Image source)

Monoram Hang was just 9 years old in April 1975 when Khmer Rouge soldiers forced his family from their home in Phnom Penh. His mother, weak from giving birth two days earlier, fell to her knees and begged for permission to wait for her husband to return from work so their family could leave together. The soldiers kicked her to the ground and ordered them out at gunpoint, forcing them to join the swollen river of people leaving Cambodia’s capital. As Hang related, “At that time we walk, we don’t know where we are going, we don’t know where we end up. We just walk and walk. . . . And Khmer Rouge soldiers behind us and shoot from behind and force us to go.”

Hang was lucky to survive; as many as two million Cambodians died in the “killing fields” of the Khmer Rouge regime. He found refuge in the United States, one of nearly 10,000 Cambodians now living in Minnesota—the country’s sixth-largest home to Cambodians. Like Hang, most witnessed genocide and endured forced migration and labor camps under the Khmer Rouge.

 1990: Minnesota Puts the Khmer Rouge on Trial

In 1990, Hang and other survivors testified at a mock trial of the Khmer Rouge leadership that was held at the State Capitol in St. Paul. The Advocates for Human Rights organized the mock trial with Minnesota’s Cambodian community to give voice to the victims of Khmer Rouge atrocities. The panel of public officials serving as judges at the mock trial found the Khmer Rouge leaders guilty of genocide. The entire Minnesota Congressional Delegation issued a statement formally recognizing members of Minnesota’s Cambodian community for their testimony and joined “the appeal to establish an international inquiry into crimes of genocide perpetrated by the Khmer Rouge between 1975–79. Well-established principles of international law require accountability and punishment for those responsible for genocide, the Khmer Rouge being no exception.”

The mock trial was such a positive experience for the Cambodian community that The Advocates then created the Khmer Oral History Project, enlisting volunteer attorneys to interview Hang and other members of Minnesota’s Cambodian community about their experiences under the Khmer Rouge, their life in refugee camps, and their immigration to the United States. Transcripts and video recordings of those interviews are available through the Minnesota Historical Society.

 2012: Actual Justice Remains Elusive

Yet more than two decades after The Advocates put the Khmer Rouge on trial in Minnesota and Minnesota lawmakers called for accountability, one—and only one—Khmer Rouge leader has actually been brought to justice. In 2010, a hybrid United Nations-Cambodian tribunal, the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC), found Kaing Guek Eav responsible for the deaths of more than 14,000 people at the notorious S-21 prison and convicted him of crimes against humanity, murder, and torture. An ECCC appeals court last month increased his sentence to life imprisonment.

For survivors like Hang, justice delayed may be justice denied. Thirty-five years after the Khmer Rouge took power, only three additional leaders, all in their eighties, are answering charges in an ECCC “mini-trial.” Additional mini-trials against the same elderly defendants will follow—if their health holds out. Proceedings against a fourth defendant have been stayed as she battles age-related dementia.

 Cambodian Government Interference Perpetuates a Culture of Impunity

A recent dispute between UN and Cambodian authorities threatens to bring the ECCC’s slow progress to a grinding halt. The Cambodian government, which is bidding for a rotating seat on the UN Security Council for 2013–2014, has made plain that it opposes any additional charges against other defendants. International co-investigating judge Siegfried Blunk resigned last October, complaining of government interference.

According to the painstakingly negotiated UN/Cambodian agreement establishing the ECCC, Cambodia’s Supreme Council of the Magistracy was obligated to appoint reserve judge Laurent Kasper-Ansermet to replace Blunk. Kasper-Ansermet took his post in December, paying no heed to government efforts to obstruct justice and launching investigations against new defendants. In January, however, the Supreme Council rejected his appointment, and Kasper-Ansermet’s Cambodian co-investigating judge has constantly contested his authority to investigate cases. UN Special Expert to the ECCC, David Scheffer, has emphasized to Cambodians on the court that Kasper-Ansermet has full authority to serve as the international investigating judge.

Last week, frustrated with the recalcitrance of his Cambodian colleague and the resulting “dysfunctional situation within the ECCC,” Kasper-Ansermet tendered his resignation. He did so in view of “the victims’ right to have investigations conducted in a proper manner.” The UN has voiced “serious concern” at the developments prompting Kasper-Ansermet’s departure.

 Hang and other victims of the Khmer Rouge have waited too long for justice. For their sake, it is time to ensure that the work of the ECCC goes forward to hold the perpetrators of horrific crimes against humanity accountable. United States lawmakers should join California Representative Ed Royce in calling for more trials and an end to the Cambodian government’s culture of impunity.

Further, the United States, which has contributed more than $6.7 million to the ECCC, should demand that the Cambodian government cease its interference in the proceedings. Unless the meddling ends, Cambodia has no place at the table on the Security Council.

This commentary was written with Amy Bergquist and originally published as an op-ed in MinnPost.   Justice delayed may be justice denied for Minnesota Cambodians.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for sharing this, Jennifer. That pain seems to reverberate down the generations...what a good idea to have the mock trial, bringing it out in the open and allowing some healing, even as most of the perpetrators are dying out.

(I believe Minnesota also has the largest Hmong population in the US. My son once showed me this Youtube video...how some young Hmong (whose families fought the Secret War for the CIA in Laos) are dealing with that past: Hmong Dedication C-Walk (unedited)

I wish we would remember these wounds that don't heal for generations, next time we go thinking of starting up another war.
Excellent post Jen... keep doing what you do so well. Nothing but awe and admiration.
clay ball - Yes, the impact of conflict lasts for generations. And we do have the largest Hmong community here in MN, along with the largest Somali community and many other large refugee communities. Thanks for sharing the video - I look forward to watching it. Thanks very much for your comment!

Thanks much, jmac! I know I have some work to do reading your prolific writing over the past week or so. Sorry! It's been busy. But now I have something to look forward to.
I admit, with so much to think about in this world I haven't thought about Cambodia in so long. It's good to be reminded. It's awful to think that by delaying these horrible criminals can live out their lives to maturity with impunity.

There is a bright side though: I was just reading another thread by zanelle engaged in an Internet conversation with a paranoid survivalist; the Cambodians who lived through the atrocities of the Khmer Rouge have probably survived a situation worse than the worst scenarios these fearful right wingers can imagine. Somehow people still recover and move on even after the most tragic horrors unfold. That is something amazing about people.

Still, one wishes for there to be consequences for committing such heinous crimes.
Why aren't these crimes prosecuted in Cambodian courts or an international court? Here's why the Cambodian government is interfering: The case is prosecuted by an American court. They see it as United States imposing on their sovereignty. Sure there's corruption, as there is corruption anywhere, but there should be an international entity to impartially prosecute cases like this.
Hi Jeff J! Thanks for your comment. Yes, the resiliency of humans is amazing and inspiring. Witnessing that is part of what keeps me going in this line of work.

MaxV - thanks very much for reading and commenting. The ECCC is an entirely unique international justice mechanism - a domestic Cambodian court with Cambodian legal procedure but with both Cambodian and international lawyers and judges who enforce Cambodian and international laws. The international community, including the US, provides financial support through the UN.

There have been several recent international criminal justice mechanisms (including tribunals for the Former Yugoslavia, Rwanda, Sierra Leone). Each has been different, but all have been extremely expensive. I completely agree with you that there needs to be impartial prosecutions. As the International Criminal Court has just issued its first verdict (they found Thomas Lubango guilty of the war crime of using child soldiers in the Democratic Republic of Congo), many are hopeful that the ICC will fill that role.
Thank you so much for writing and posting this, Jennifer. I have many friends who survived the horrors of the Khmer Rouge and more. There was so much hope that finally, albeit slowly, justice would be served and now another set-back. I have been to Cambodia twice and love that country and its people like nowhere else. They deserve better.
Thanks, Firechick! Justice has been slow in coming to a country where more than 2 million people were killed. I should also mention that members of the Cambodian diaspora in the U.S., frustrated with the setbacks at the ECCC, asked us to write this op-ed to help raise awareness.
Thank you for this important and informative post. I hadn't realized that justice was so slow in coming, if it comes at all, to the perpetrators of the killing fields. It seems ironic how full our U.S. prisons are of people on minor drug charges and etc. and people like this can't get tried until they're too old to even withstand a day in court.
Thanks for reading and commenting, ManhattanWhiteGirl. Yes, there are many ironies in the pursuit of justice and accountability.
Seems like kind of a no-brainer, doesn't it? Thanks for reading and commenting, baltimore aureole!
Great post again Jennifer!!!!
Jennifer,i think the world needs lawyers like you.That are first humane humans and than their degree.Nothing else to do but admire you,your work and wish Justice to be right and come..Rated with best regards.
STATHI STATHI - that's just about the nicest thing anyone has ever said about me! Thank you and best regards to you, too!

And, of course, thanks to you as well, Nicole!
Thanks for bringing this to us, Jennifer. It's sad, and terrible, but not nearly enough people know about this.
Thanks for your comment, Neha! Yes, we humans have a short attention span for tragedy. Sometimes we need to be reminded. Thank you for reading!