DECEMBER 15, 2008 8:48AM

Public Hanging in America

Rate: 25 Flag
Rainey Bethea Hanging

At precisely 5:21 a.m., 20 thousand men, women and children parted like the Red Sea to let the young man pass by.

Flanked by deputies and followed by a Catholic priest, Rainey Bethea passed through the crowd. He stopped at the base of the platform to pull on clean new socks.

Slowly, the 22 year old climbed the 13 steps and stepped out onto the large X. Pausing for a moment, he turned east and gazed at the sunrise. Silent, he declined to speak any last words.

A long black hood was pulled over his head and a heavy hemp noose, oiled so it would tighten faster, was slipped over his head. As the deputy leaned into the lever, the trap door fell eight feet.

The young man barely swayed when his neck broke. His cheek dropped to rest on his shoulder. Fourteen minutes later, he was pronounced dead.

Vendors continued to hawk food and beverages to the hungry crowd.

Wielding pen as sword and club, angry journalists turned their wrath on the town, painting the horror of an event that needed no embellishment. One wire service dispatch read:

"CHEERING, BOOING, EATING AND JOKING, 20,000 PERSONS WITNESSED THE PUBLIC EXECUTION OF RAINEY BETHEA, 22, FRIGHTENED NEGRO BOY, AT OWENSBORO, KY., YESTERDAY. IN CALLOUS, CARNIVAL SPIRIT, THE MOB CHARGED THE GALLOWS AFTER THE TRAP WAS SPRUNG, TORE THE EXECUTIONER'S HOOD FROM THE CORPSE, CHIPPING THE GALLOWS FOR SOUVENIRS.”

Mocking the sheriff for allowing the execution, yet declining to pull the lever himself, journalists cried out for an end to public hangings.

The issue was not Bethea’s innocence or guilt. The issue was the subhuman behavior and mob festivity that surrounded his death. Due to public outcry, hangings were immediately outlawed in the state of Kentucky. Other states hurried to follow suit.

Perry T. Ryan, a former Kentucky prosecutor, documented the hanging in a book entitled "The Last Public Execution in America."

Mr. Ryan, I beg to differ.

Enter, the Internet. The gold rush lives again and public hangings are again becoming commonplace. Except, now it is the frenzied mob wielding pen and voice as sword, club and noose.

"F***ing do it. Get on with it, get it round your neck."

Only after Kevin Whitrick, depressed, recently divorced father of twins, hung limply in front of his webcam were the voices subdued.

14 year old Megan Taylor Meier, found hanging in her closet. Cyber bullying. 13 year old Hannah Bond, found hanging from her bunk bed. Cyber cult.

And in November, 2008, Abraham Biggs, a 19 year old black boy egged on by chat members swallowed pills and laid down in front of his webcam. Only when police and EMT broke down the door, checked his pulse and quickly covered the webcam did chatters hurry to log off and erase their browser history.

Welcome to the Internet, where there are few rules and compassion cowers in the corner while freedom of speech reins supreme.

In a frenzy of forum posts, blog comments and electronic whispers, the bodies leaning on the lever are often invisible, the swing of the trapdoor silent and unseen.

Sticks and stones can break my bones, but words can never hurt me?

On the fringes of the crowd, vendors continue to hawk their wares.

Rest in peace
Abraham Biggs - Rest in Peace

=======================

Note: Normally I come here to take a break, post random thoughts and read/comment on blogs. This is an example of my serious writing. If you like the writing style, let me know. If you prefer fluff, say that, too. lol. Thanks!

Author tags:

perspective, opinion

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Aaron, thanks for commenting. I think the saddest part, to me, is that so many people are so focused on their right to 'freedom of speech' that they don't stop to think how their words may affect the person they are saying them to. Anonymity isn't always a good thing. It often makes people callous.

In the case of Abraham Biggs, when police broke down the door, people in the chat were saying "OMFG, it's for real...." That strikes me as horribly sad.
We have the incredible ability to exhibit the best and the worst of human behavior. The internet just makes it happen louder and faster.
HIghly rated and very well written.
Beautifully written boomer. A chilling subject. Important to discuss. I will never understand people who find joy or entertainment in the pain of others. Never. I find the internet a real mixed bag of blessings and curses.
Rated
Your subject content is horrifying, but the way that you present it is skillful. I appreciate how you began with the public lynching of a black man, horrifying in its own right, then onto the modern day hangings broadcast over the internet, resulting from cyber-bullying. People should be outraged that this is happening. It presents yet another reason why bullying, cyber or otherwise, should never be tolerated. It can have dangerous results.

By the way, write what you want. Your writing is of such high caliber that anything you write will be worth reading.
Cartouche, thank you. Coming from you, that last sentence means a lot.

Gracielou, you can take my comment to Cartouche and just repeat. Your writing always moves me.

Lisa, thank you. You are one of the kindest, gracious and humbling people I've ever met.
RB, well stated, and the analogy is apt. For those teetering on the brink in lonely isolation, the push from tormenters never met face to face can certainly be a death sentence. And it's easy for the cruel and unempathetic to forget the humanity of the one on the other side of that electronic connection, with terrible consequences. Bullying and tormenting have always been with us, but perhaps it's easier to do it when you aren't in the victim's actual presence. Those merely observing can't realize the seriousness of the matter until it is too late. They become unintentional witnesses to a lynching.
Way ta go, Boomer.

Treating a subject like this in an essay you wanted to be judged on writing style is top drawer, Boomer. And you pulled it off like a champ.

I agree with everyone who has posted so far...but especially with Gracielou & Lisa.

Amazing how easy it is to talk about the beauty of a piece when the piece deals with such an ugly subject. As I said, you pulled it off.

Congratulations.
I like the serious writing and fluff.
Procopius.... so true, what you said about people teetering on the brink. So sad and so true.

Frank... thank you. I am so humbled. I love your writing, which makes your comment that much more meaningful.

Dorinda... thank you for everything I don't need to say because you already know.
Rated for quality of the writing.
Horrified, but not surprised. From the day of the first public killing, people have cheered and jeered. Your writing is terrific, I'd like to see you take on the concept of why people do so. And I'd be willing to read a much longer piece than this if you did.
Tim.... what an intriguing invitation. I have firmly planted your suggested topic between my ears. The words I have no control over. They just bleed out of my fingers when they're dang well ready. But I will write on it when it's ready. Count on it. And thanks for the thumb. :)
If you are so fragile that idiots on the internet could goad you into killing yourself, you probably weren't long for the world anyway.
BBE, when you are that fragile, it is often a temporary condition.

People become suicidal when their stress level exceeds their ability to cope. Another human being can push you to take your life... or take your hand and lead you to the help you need. Especially with kids, whose frontal lobes aren't yet developed and often lack critical coping skills. They are teetering. A push - either way - is often all it takes. Which way will someone push ... that's the real question.
Your piece was very good, it offered me a look into the viciousness of the people involved in the stories and the compassion of some of the OS posters. I suspect that most of the morons online, egging these people onto their deaths still wipe their butts with mommy and daddies TP and haven't a clue about what life, much less death is all about. It's a damn movie to them. What the hell do they care?

Someday death is going to come into their life, maybe somebody near and dear to them will be, "fragile".. pushed over the edge by some creep then and only then will they understand and maybe they will wish for a little compassion, (and not get it) their own selves.

Thanks for the post.
Wow. Perfect analogy. Excellent writing. I'm embarrassed to be human sometimes.
Ric... you're so right about "mommy and daddies TP" - at least most of the time. There are a few documented incidents where the tormentors and/or encouragers are adults, but often they are kids that have somehow not yet learned compassion.

Seattle... thank you. I know exactly what you mean!
This was am important topic, sensitively handled.

What I love about this place is that we feel safe enough to try out all finds of things and find our way. I say explore all facets of your writing and you will find more about yourself from within than from any of us.

Will keep reading you, RB. Thanks for this.
That sticks and stones saying - who is that attributed to, I wonder. Someone who doesn't read a lot, I'd wager. Because words don't just hurt - words can kill. Words can incite others to kill. Words create belief, words substitute for belief. There is nothing more powerful than words - words can destroy much much faster than fists, and more effectively and permanently too. The person who can harness words can harness the world.
Btw I really like the analogy you draw here. I agree w/ Procopius' comments. High tech makes it too easy to communicate without the feeling of personal responsibility that often, wisely,stays words on our lips when dealing face-to-face.
Lea... thank you very much. You're right, as usual, too.

Sandra... it was a childhood chant where I grew up. One I never agreed with. Words often cut deeper than anything else. I loved that point Procopius made, too, about the face to face connection. It's so true, and to me that's what makes cyber bullying even sadder. Many of these folks would not act the same way if they were in the boy's room looking in his eyes.
Although New to the Internet, suicide is not new by any means. In another time, a twelve year old boy hanged himself in his father's barn. He was a straight a student who offered no hints whatsoever of his intentions. This was about a mile from where I grew up and long before there was an internet.
A woman stands on the edge of a bridge in rush hour traffic. The traffic snarl she causes prompts the travelers to exit their cars and encourage her to jump so they can get home before their dinners get cold. The world can be a cold heartless place.
I'm in no way making lite of the latest internet suicide craze. It's very disturbing to me, I only want to point out that it is not a new phenomena.
Thanks for this post Boomer.
This is such an informative and moving piece, that it reinforces my desire to get information from other places than the mainstream media, which spent, what, 30 seconds, or 100 words on these stories?

I wish that parents would begin to pay attention to their kids experiences on the internet, and in school, but it's a wistful wish.

The internet is definitely a new world of "mean streets", where the worst of monsters and predators operate freely, with no identity, and in secret. The last public hanging demonstrated that even "decent" people can easily become a mob of hateful, unthinking monsters. But those people were at least present, and identifiable as individuals.

Unsupervised internet exposure has become the equivalent of dropping one's children off in the seedy part of any major city, and expecting them to fend for themselves every night.

Thanks for a well done expose of this problem.
Michael... ture that suicide is not new by any means. My aunt hanged herself long before anyone even heard of computers. The really tragic part is when someone is in that fragile place and total strangers push them over the edge with taunts for sport ... and then say "OMG, it was real?"

zumalicious... thank you for the kind compliments. Love that phrase...mean street. A lot of the Internet is mean street.
ture = true. (adds 'edit comment' feature to wish list)
R.B., by all means, WRITE MORE! Socially relevant things like this are what make us a better society. The internet is both the best and worst thing ever invented. Like most things, it has it's yin/yang. The bullying and such goes on everywhere, but now it's much more easily accessed by EVERYONE, 24/7 and Continents apart even. That's again, both good and bad.

Great post
(rated)
Greg.... yin and yang... that's it in a nutshell, really. Thanks for the kind words and the thumb action. :)
Technology often outstrips intelligence. One of the reasons I limit my kids' access to the internet, and I try to keep track of where they're going and what they're doing. For the older one, I think that simply reminding him of simple common sense measures is sufficient - he is old enough now to understand how to deal with people both good and bad.
This was a most disturbing piece, RB. Disturbing because it shines a light on a side of technology that no-one really wants to look at. Still, a very coherent and cogent piece of work.

Thumbed.
Thanks, Bill... for some people, I think the technology they have at their fingertips exceeds the intelligence they have to use it with, and the compassion they bring to it. Mostly, it can be overlooked. Sometimes, it costs lives and that's when it's tragic. I appreciate you taking the time to comment... (P.S. sounds like you're a great dad, too)
I love this side of you ranting. What a well written and compelling piece. Heart wrenching. And, I love how you tied in the public lynchings to some of the more horrific happenings in the Internet world. You do a great service by writing about this and I would suggest you submit this piece for submission to some magazines. Your point is powerful and legitimate.

The Internet is here to stay. I can only speak of the untold suffering the Internet is causing parents and spouses. You could write a book about the subject. Thanks for an astute and timely post.
Mary, thank you. Gosh, I don't even know what to say. Here I am over at Randy's lamenting that you need more cover time and you are here, commenting on this piece.

All things "Internet" is a topic close to my heart. I make my living working via the Internet. If not for it, I would be in the boat that many chronically ill people are, unable to provide for themselves. That's the good part of the Internet. As is OS. Friends and getting to know people we'd never know any other way.

A young girl that is near and dear to my heart was 'beat up' so the video could be posted on YouTube. I have family members that have suffered cyber bullying and cyber stalking. Those are the bad parts.

But I digress. Thank you. Your comments mean a lot to me. :)
RB, sorry to be so late to comment. Well written and about as chilling a comment on emotional distance as I've seen.
John... thanks for popping in and thanks for the kind words. Emotional distance - that's it in a nutshell. Anonymity allows people to have it.
Got me right there in the gut, Ms. Boomer. Thank you for reviving and displaying such necessary history. It needs to be told.
Thank you, Penrose. Mob cruelty disturbs me. Anonymity makes it so much easier.