Thomas Rogers

Thomas Rogers
Location
Brooklyn, New York, USA
Birthday
December 07
Title
Deputy Editor
Company
Open Salon
Bio
I'm an associate editor at Salon. I live in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, where I spend far too much time tripping on subway steps.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 18, 2009 1:56PM

A German brothel's surprising recession strategy

Rate: 22 Flag

From today's Spiegel, a somewhat shocking news item as a German (uncreatively-named) brothel tries a new strategy to attract clients:

The city's "Pussy Club" has made headlines in the local press by giving clients unlimited access to all its ladies for €70, which includes an all-you-can-eat-and-drink offer, in a bid to weather Germany's worst economic slump since World War II . . .

"Seventy euros, that includes everything -- ladies, drinks and food," a member of staff contacted by phone told SPIEGEL ONLINE, confirming media reports. The offer runs during off-peak times. On weekdays it applies between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. On weekends, it's extended by an hour until five p.m.

The story points to the fact that, as the global economic downturn intensifies, it's putting industries that were formerly deemed "recession-proof" under more and more pressure. Gambling is one such industry, and sex is another. In December, the NY Times ran an article focusing on the decline in sex business that pointed out that Artemis, Berlin's biggest brothel, had noticed a 20% decrease in revenue in 2008 for the same period in 2007 -- and that the famous Mustang Ranch in Nevada had laid off 30% of its staff. Larry Flynt, more famously, has recently asked for a porn bailout.

But the downturn -- and this item in particular -- also raises questions about the well-being of the sex workers themselves (I can't imagine that they're happy about being offered as part of a 70 Euro all-you-can-eat buffet).

In a post about sex work during Argentina's market downturn, the Economist noted that:

The most interesting part is that the market is counter cyclical. In bad times more (and more attractive) women enter the market, but they have a higher reservation wage, so they charge more. Less attractive and even cheaper prostitutes may still be available, but for a variety of very good reasons, the customer will not desire the cheapest option, suggesting prostitution services can be classified as a Giffen good.

A Giffen Good, by the way, is something that people consume more of as price rises (counter to the law of demand).

This means that as the global recession deepens, more and more women will be entering the sex trade -- from a variety of backgrounds, and with a variety of prices. (A more recent Economist post notes an increased "elasticity" in the price of New York sex workers and an uptick on the number of escorts claiming to have been previously employed in the "financial services industry").

Unfortunately, as women from different backgrounds stream into the industry, this is bad news for those that are already on its margins ("the cheapest option" as the Economist put it). They will likely be pushed further down and out -- putting them at greater risk for abuse and making them easier to take advantage of by clients and pimps.

A push to legalize and regulate prostitution, however, could potentially help keep those women out of harm's way. As the Times noted, in the Czech Republic hotel owners are bemoaning the loss of sex tourism, and hoping sex work will be legalized for financial reasons. (Germany only recently made them legal). And though San Francisco's recent attempt to decriminalize sex work failed, if there's an influx of women from other professions where greater rights and respectability are the norm, perhaps they'll take initiative, and create a grassroots movement here in the US. Maybe the time has finally come for an American sex workers' union?

Your tags:

Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Imagine the service we could get from AIG with all the money we tossed into that black hole.

There's a line from Dog Day Afternoon: "Kiss me....."

Rated.
The rights of sex workers ought to be recognized. I realize that cops love nothing more than to bust prosties. But they can probably find some kind of actual crime with a victim to protect society from.
Baffled by the buffet. It makes me think of that sex-and-food episode of "Seinfeld" -- which was funny, but also fairly gross, to be honest. George Costanza naked and a Pastrami sandwich. I need a Tums.
puts a new accent on 'happy hour.'

the price might go up as a result of the consumer profile changing. poorer men stop going as they lose jobs or fear doing so, creating a rich mans service.
i only regret that i can't offer more support to the poor, struggling sex industry. but i remain thankful that peeling the ol' carrot is still within my budget.
I tried for years to get prostitution decriminalized, to no avail.

If Mustang is "laying off" workers, could say more about the brothel owners than the lack of business. Look where the last owner is, on the run from prison in Brazil, the coward.

Been there done that, and it just isn't going to happen.
Wow, I've heard of dessert being free, but this is a bit much.
Actually, the movement might get some support from the frustrated right if there were sex worker's union.

You may remember something I posted long ago called Wisdom from a Hooker. I made friends with a legal prostitute in Nevada. She was a happy businesswoman, till the bad economy closed the place; could have used union support:
http://open.salon.com/blog/lea_lane/2008/09/20/wisdom_from_a_hooker
As a Libertarian, I don't believe in victimless crimes. As long as you have two consenting adults the gov should mind it's own beeswax. In other countries legalization leads to safer sex, health checkups, tax revenue, etc. We need to get over our puritanical streak and enter the 21st century. Screw Disneyland, I'm going to Germany. Just kidding.
I wonder if the rampant loss of health insurance could be a factor. It would seem to me that perscription viagra or cialis would be necessary to make an all you can eat buffet worthwhile.
I'm not sure what the "all you can eat" refers to to...........

but the larger issue is making a clean. safe environment for sex workers.......the ones who offer an outlet for people who suffer from any one of a number of maladies ranging from under-appreciation at home, to problems with social skills. It has never been exclusively about sex (though it seems the actual point most of the time). I understand the need to make adjustments for the times, and I have sympathy for the ones who will benefit least from these adjustments.....I advocate international legalization of the "sex trade." I know this opinion is not popular, but i feel it would solve many problems if sex-workers could work in a system over-seen by regulations that could guarantee safety, and fairness.
This is going to be the perfect place if Card Check passes. Heck, if I was the owner of brothel in NV I wouldn't agree to a contract just to see what the government would do when they have to decide the issue.

Great fun.
Oh God.. I read that first excerpt as "all you can eat ladies." I think I need to go to bed.
Do they really mean "all you can EAT?"
Ah, brings back fond memories of my loss of my virginity at Nevada's Moonlight Ranch. I was just 18, scared to death, and the whole thing was over in 5 minutes. The cost - 5 bucks! Now that I'm entering my dotage, I'm hearing about cheap flights to Europe...
Just last week, I noticed that the ads for escorts had increased in the Atlanta area. And my first thought was these were women who had lost thier jobs and were desperate for income.

I don't think these women understand what they are entering. I'm concerned for them.
unfortunately you may be right that the entrance of formerly "normally employed" women in prostitution might provide the push needed to increase visibility and concern for the plight of sex workers.

historically when people in a group that is considered "morally relevant" (ie worthy of moral concern) come to inhabit the world of society's detritus against their will they can raise consciousness about the plight of people who have been living there all along. it's a sad logic but one that may end up useful for those organizing for justice for oppressed groups (sex workers in this instance). just look at the times' recent coverage of the newly unemployed and poor (mostly centered around the "zomg turns out it's hard to be poor and many people who are poor aren't just 'lazy'!" narrative) to see this dynamic in action.
It is true that the low end girls will be for the worse with the sagging economy. Supply and demand theory stipulates that when supply increases and demand holds steady then competition will force some to supply at a lower cost (to spur demand). In other words the low end girls will have to have more clients to make the same buck.

Prostitution to supply drug money has always been a desperate game. Greater competition in the form of better looking (and maybe classier) women will surely leave the bottom end disproportionately affected. The truly down and out sometimes commit suicide to escape the self-imposed hell (and sometimes not so self-imposed). It already happens - it will only happen in greater numbers now.
Sex work is illegal? apparently someone forgot to tip off the hoards of hoes (i'm sorry) ..what I meant to say was someone forgot to tell the numerous erotic massage technicians advertising on craigslist in the erotic services section that the whole sex for money thing was not on the right side of the law. Well why the hell aren't those skanks on the real house hoes of orange county on the most wanted list ? A 40k rollex , a new harley, 35k diamond bracelet hmm they are doing more than housework for that..